Cakmakkaya and TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Cakmakkaya and TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2017] AATA 695 (18 May 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2015/3376

Re:Erol Cakmakkaya

APPLICANT

TNT Australia Pty LtdAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member J F Toohey

Date:18 May 2017

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review

...............................[sgd].........................................

Senior Member J F Toohey

CATCHWORDS

Compensation – lower back injury – liability accepted – multiple injuries – degenerative condition – whether effects of injury ceased – whether respondent presently liable to compensate applicant – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 16, 19, 62, 64

CASES

Abrahams v Comcare [2006] FCA 1829

Szabo and Comcare [2011] AATA 114

Szabo v Comcare [2012] FCA 28

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member J F Toohey

18 May 2017

  1. Mr Erol Cakmakkaya was working for the respondent on 7 March 2014 when he sustained an injury to his lower back while pushing a 60 kilogram pallet.  He lodged a claim for compensation for “lower back strain/sprain”. On 24 March 2015, the respondent accepted liability under the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) to compensate him for his injury.

  2. On 11 May 2015, the respondent determined that it had no present liability to compensate Mr Cakmakkaya under ss 16 or 19 of the SRC Act. On 6 July 2015, the respondent affirmed that determination. 

  3. Mr Cakmakkaya seeks review of the respondent’s determination.  He maintains that the effects of his injury have continued.

    Preliminary question

  4. On 26 July 2016, the Tribunal heard argument as to whether it had jurisdiction to consider a “nature and conditions claim” as well as one for a “frank injury”.  For reasons given orally, the Tribunal determined it had jurisdiction to consider both.  For completeness, written reasons reflecting those given orally follow.

    The “cease effects” determination

  5. On 11 May 2015, the respondent determined it had no present liability to compensate Mr Cakmakkaya under ss 16 or 19 of the SRC Act. The respondent relied on a report of Professor Fredrick Ehrlich dated 7 May 2015 in which he said:

    This man’s present back problems should not be attributed to injury. He has had back pain for many years and whilst there have been injuries they were essentially of the trivial nature, representing little more than a strain.

    Mr Cakmakkaya’s condition should not be attributed to injury. It is of constitutional origin and would produce symptoms regardless of his employment.

    Whatever strain may have occurred in the past can reasonably be assumed to have resolved within a few weeks.

  6. Up to this point, the claim had been expressed in terms consistent with a “frank injury”. It had been accepted on that basis, and the “cease effects” determination and the medical report on which it was based were in respect of a “frank injury”.  Nothing up to this point suggested a “nature and conditions” claim.

    Request for reconsideration

  7. By letter dated 3 June 2015, Mr Cakmakkaya, through his solicitor, requested reconsideration of the determination dated 11 May…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cakmakkaya and TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 695
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Cakmakkaya against a decision by TNT Australia Pty Ltd to deny ongoing compensation for a lower back injury. The dispute centred on whether the effects of the work-related injury on 7 March 2014 had ceased, or if the respondent remained liable to compensate the applicant for his ongoing symptoms, which were attributed by the respondent to a pre-existing degenerative condition.

The court was required to determine the nature of Mr Cakmakkaya's claim and the extent of TNT Australia Pty Ltd's liability. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the applicant's condition constituted a "frank injury" with temporary effects, or a "nature and conditions" injury, or an aggravation of a pre-existing degenerative condition, as argued in the alternative by the applicant. The central legal issue was whether the effects of the work-related incident had resolved, or if the employment had contributed to or aggravated a long-standing degenerative condition in a manner that rendered the employer liable for ongoing compensation.

The court reasoned that the initial claim and acceptance of liability were based on a "frank injury." However, a subsequent request for reconsideration framed the claim as either a "nature and conditions" injury or, in the alternative, an aggravation of a pre-existing degenerative condition. The delegate, in affirming the original determination, rejected the "nature and conditions" claim, finding that while the degenerative disease may have been temporarily aggravated by work incidents, these effects were reasonably assumed to have resolved within a short period. The court found that the delegate's decision, when read in context, was a rejection of the "nature and conditions" claim, and that the Tribunal had the power to review this decision.

The court affirmed the reviewable decision, finding that the delegate had correctly rejected the "nature and conditions" claim and that the evidence supported the conclusion that any aggravation of Mr Cakmakkaya's pre-existing degenerative condition was temporary and had resolved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Cakmakkaya, an employee of TNT Australia Pty Ltd, sustained an injury to his lower back at work on 7 March 2014. He had a history of degenerative changes in his lumbar spine and had experienced multiple incidents of back pain and problems at work over the years. Following the incident, an MRI on 4 April 2014 showed multilevel focal spinal canal stenosis, disc bulging, congenitally short pedicles, prominent posterior epidural fat, and evidence of ligamentum flavum hypertrophy. An x-ray on 25 March 2015 revealed degenerative changes with a scoliosis apex to the left at L3. On 23 April 2015, Dr Bryan Hsu, a spine surgeon, diagnosed discogenic back pain and disc herniation caused by the work activity. Mr Cakmakkaya was also having physiotherapy with Mr Aldrin Ocsing, who reported significant reduction in pain and improved range of lumbar flexion.

The matter came before the court for review of a decision made under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act). The original determination, dated 11 May 2015, found that the effects of Mr Cakmakkaya's work-related injury had ceased by that date. Mr Cakmakkaya sought reconsideration of this determination, submitting that his condition was caused by the nature and conditions of his employment, and was an aggravation of a pre-existing condition. The delegate affirmed the original determination in a decision dated 6 July 2015, leading to this review by the court.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent contends that any symptoms Mr Cakmakkaya experienced as at, and since, 11 May 2015, are not related to the injury on 7 March 2014, but to the “significant pathology” in his lumbar spine which is constitutional in origin. The respondent contends that the effects of the work-caused exacerbation of his constitutional and degenerative conditions which occurred on 7 March 2014 were short-lived and had no lasting effect on his lumbar spine.Medical evidence It is common ground that Mr Cakmakkaya has long-standing degenerative changes in his lumbar spine. An MRI on 4 April 2014 showed “multilevel focal spinal canal stenosis contributed to by disc bulging, congenitally short pedicles and prominent posterior epidural fat [and] evidence of ligamentum flavum hypertrophy”.Dr Pierides On 22 October 2014, Mr Cakmakkaya saw Dr Lew Pierides, occupational physician, for assessment. Dr Pierides reported that his back strain had “improved significantly” and he should continue with an upgraded return to work. He thought Mr Cakmakkaya would be capable of pre-injury duties “in 5 weeks’ time”. He did not think there was any aggravation of pre-existing condition.Functional Capacity Assessment On 11 December 2014, Mr Nicholas Karam, an exercise physiologist, undertook a Functional Capacity Evaluation. He reported that Mr Cakmakkaya had the “functional capacity to complete his pre-injury hours”, he could complete tasks within his pre-injury duties “up to the identified weights” and, to minimise the chance of further or aggravation, he should continue with a prescribed exercise program.X-ray and MRI An x-ray of Mr Cakmakkaya’s lumbo-sacral spine on 25 March 2015 showed “degenerative changes … with a scoliosis apex to the left at L3”. A multi-positional MRI on 26 March 2015 found “markedly congenitally narrowed canal +++” and “canal stenoses, being of up to tight severity at the level of L3/4 with diffuse disc osteophyte, further mild canal stenoses with multilevel osteophytes throughout”.Dr Hsu On 23 April 2015, Mr Cakmakkaya saw Dr Bryan Hsu, spine surgeon who noted the findings of the MRI. He took a history from Mr Cakmakkaya that he had been experiencing lower back pain for approximately 12 months after a work-related injury; his symptoms had been improving but he had experienced an exacerbation of symptoms approximately six weeks earlier. On 28 September 2015, Dr Hsu reported that he diagnosed discogenic back pain and disc herniation caused by the activity that he did at work. Dr Hsu was alone in making this diagnosis.Physiotherapy Around this time, Mr Cakmakkaya was having physiotherapy with Mr Aldrin Ocsing who wrote a report on 23 April 2015. Mr Ocsing reported that his pain had “reduced significantly” over the previous two weeks and was now “intermittent throughout the week”; he had a better range of lumbar flexion and could return to some light duties with the lifting restriction and regular breaks every 30 minutes; he should continue with physiotherapy and hydrotherapy which had relieved his pain “greatly”.Professor Ehrlich

Decision

Reasons for decision

There can be no doubt that the request for consideration put the claim in the alternative: primarily that it was a “nature and conditions” claim but, in the alternative, that it was an aggravation of a pre-existing condition. On a fair reading, it “amplified”, or better explained and justified, Mr Cakmakkaya’s claim. The reviewable decision In the reviewable decision dated 6 July 2015, the delegate set out the history of Mr Cakmakkaya’s claim, including his earlier injuries, and reproduced, almost entirely, the letter from his representative seeking reconsideration. The delegate stated that she had “reviewed the totality of the available evidence, together with the reconsideration submission”. Affirming the original determination, she stated:22In support of the reconsideration request the claimant’s legal representatives put forth reasons which I note:a.There is no evidence put forth that supports the contention that the determination made on 11 May 2015 was incorrect.b. [Accepting the opinion of Professor Ehrlich]c.There is no evidence to support that the claimant’s condition was caused by his work with TNT. The evidence does support that the claimant’s disc degeneration and spondylotic disease have been temporarily aggravated by incidents at work however these could reasonably be assumed to have resolved within a short period of time. The meaning of the statement at 22(c) that “There is no evidence to support that the claimant’s condition was caused by his work with TNT” is not immediately clear. It could be read to deny any relationship between a “frank injury” and Mr Cakmakkaya’s employment. Read in context, however, I understand it to mean there is no evidence to support a “nature and conditions” claim. Read with the sentence that follows, in which it is accepted that his disease was “temporary aggravated by incidents at work”, I am satisfied that the delegate was rejecting a “nature and conditions” claim. By s 64 of the SRC Act, the Tribunal has the power to review a reviewable decision made under s 62. I am satisfied that the Tribunal has that power in this case. This case may be distinguished from Szabo and Comcare [2011] AATA 114 (and see Szabo v Comcare [2012] FCA 28) in which Mr Szabo’s claims “may have appeared” to be worded as “nature and conditions” claims but “there was no appropriate determination by Comcare, and no reviewable decision relating to nature and conditions of work against which Mr Szabo could appeal to this Tribunal”. The purpose of giving notice is relevant. The Full Court in Szabo observed at [33] that those purposes:… include enabling [the respondent] to determine whether the claim should be met. In construing a notice of injury or notice of claim, consideration of the purpose of giving notice of injury and of enabling the decision maker to have a fair opportunity to investigate the claim properly are paramount (see Abrahams v Comcare [2006] FCA 1829; (2006) 93 ALD 147 at [18]).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Up to this point, the claim had been expressed in terms consistent with a “frank injury”. It had been accepted on that basis, and the “cease effects” determination and the medical report on which it was based were in respect of a “frank injury”. Nothing up to this point suggested a “nature and conditions” claim.Request for reconsideration By letter dated 3 June 2015, Mr Cakmakkaya, through his solicitor, requested reconsideration of the determination dated 11 May 2015. The letter disputed Professor Ehrlich’s opinion. It stated that Mr Cakmakkaya had suffered injuries to his back at work “in approximately 2006 and then again 2008 and then again in 2011, 2013 and ultimately on 7 March 2014”. It continued: It is submitted that Erol has suffered an injury over an extended period of time that the injury is one of a “nature and conditions” injury.This is supported by the fact that Erol has been working in physically demanding employment which included the requirement to lift and move freight over many years.Errol has had a number of instances of back pain and problems at work over the years which have been documented.Ultimately, that repetitive injury which occurred over many years reached its endpoint with the injury which occurred on 7 March 2014.…It is submitted that in this matter Erol has suffered from the nature and conditions injury over many years, with the damage to Errol’s back being done progressively over time, with that time commencing in 2005 and finishing on 7 March 2014.…… In the alternative to the injury being caused by the nature and conditions of employment, it is submitted that Erol’s condition is one in which the degenerative disease in Erol’s back has been rendered symptomatic by his employment and aggravated by employment.As such Erol’s injury is alternatively an aggravation of an ailment being a disease pursuant to Section 5B of the Act. There can be no doubt that the request for consideration put the claim in the alternative: primarily that it was a “nature and conditions” claim but, in the alternative, that it was an aggravation of a pre-existing condition. On a fair reading, it “amplified”, or better explained and justified, Mr Cakmakkaya’s claim. The reviewable decision In the reviewable decision dated 6 July 2015, the delegate set out the history of Mr Cakmakkaya’s claim, including his earlier injuries, and reproduced, almost entirely, the letter from his representative seeking reconsideration. The delegate stated that she had “reviewed the totality of the available evidence, together with the reconsideration submission”. Affirming the original determination, she stated:22In support of the reconsideration request the claimant’s legal representatives put forth reasons which I note:a.There is no evidence put forth that supports the contention that the determination made on 11 May 2015 was incorrect.b. [Accepting the opinion of Professor Ehrlich]c.There is no evidence to support that the claimant’s condition was caused by his work with TNT. The evidence does support that the claimant’s disc degeneration and spondylotic disease have been temporarily aggravated by incidents at work however these could reasonably be assumed to have resolved within a short period of time.