CADZOW v COLSON
[1999] SASC 132
Magistrates Appeal
Debelle J
This is an appeal from the decision of a magistrate deciding liability for a motor vehicle accident on the Stuart Highway in the far north of the State. The magistrate gave judgment for the plaintiff on his claim and dismissed the defendant’s counter-claim. The amount of damages has been agreed. The magistrate gave judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $4,240 with costs to be taxed or agreed on the amount of the counter-claim which was $12,258.33. The defendant appeals against that decision. I will refer to the parties as “plaintiff” and “defendant”.
The plaintiff was driving his Toyota Land Cruiser south along the Stuart Highway. The Toyota was towing a trailer which contained two motor cycles which were placed upright and beside one another. He was being followed by his son who was also driving a Toyota Land Cruiser. A witness, Mr Larkins, was a passenger in the son’s vehicle. Both the plaintiff and his son intended to turn right into a road called Wantabilla Crossing. Wantabilla Crossing forms a T-junction with the Stuart Highway.
The defendant’s Ford motor car was also travelling south. It was behind the vehicles driven by the plaintiff and his son and was travelling faster than both. At this point the Stuart Highway is straight and flat for a distance of about 10 km. The defendant’s Ford began to overtake the two Toyota vehicles. The plaintiff turned his Toyota right to go into Wantabilla Crossing at the same time as the defendant’s vehicle was overtaking it. A collision occurred. Both vehicles were damaged.
The magistrate accepted the defendant’s evidence that she was driving at a speed of about 110 km/hour before the collision. He also found that both Toyota vehicles were travelling at about 80 to 90 km/hour and that the defendant began to overtake the Toyota at a distance of at least 80 metres behind it.
A central issue at the trial was whether the plaintiff had indicated his intention to turn right into Wantabilla Crossing and whether the right hand side traffic indicator on his Toyota was working. The plaintiff said that he had put on his traffic indicator and that he had also extended his right arm to indicate his intention to turn right. His son said that he saw the traffic indicator working. His son also gave evidence that he too had turned on his traffic indicator and had extended his right arm to show his intention to turn right. The defendant and her passenger both gave evidence that the driver of neither vehicle gave any warning of an intention to turn right and that the plaintiff’s vehicle had suddenly deviated across the path of the defendant’s vehicle.
Police officers came to the scene of the accident. They tested the plaintiff’s traffic indicators. The indicators on the right hand side of the vehicle were not working. When questioned by the police officers, the plaintiff said “I didn’t realise it…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cadzow v Colson No. Scgrg-98-697 Judgment No. S132 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] SASC 132
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The main legal issue in this case was whether the magistrate was correct in finding that the defendant was negligent in overtaking the plaintiff's vehicle and whether the plaintiff had indicated his intention to turn right. The court had to consider the evidence given by the parties and their witnesses and determine whether the magistrate's findings were open to him or whether there was sufficient basis to interfere with the magistrate's findings. The court also had to consider whether the plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence for failing to see the defendant's vehicle at some time earlier than just before impact.
The court found that the magistrate's decision was correct, and the appeal was dismissed. The court accepted the evidence of the plaintiff and his son that the traffic indicators on both vehicles were working and that they had indicated their intention to turn right. The court found that the defendant had failed to keep a proper lookout and did not see the plaintiff's indicator or the plaintiff and his son extending their right arms to indicate their intention to turn right. The court also found that the defendant's overtaking manoeuvre was not negligent, as the road was straight and flat for a long distance, and there was no suggestion of any oncoming vehicle. The court concluded that the significant finding of fact concerned the issue whether the plaintiff had indicated his intention to turn right.
The court did not find it necessary to consider the plaintiff's failure to see the defendant's vehicle at some time earlier than just before impact, as the action was conducted on the footing that either one party or the other was liable for the collision. Furthermore, the notice of appeal did not assert that the magistrate should have made a finding of contributory negligence. The defendant was bound by the manner in which this action had been prosecuted on her behalf. The court also found that the defendant's criticism of the magistrate's finding that the traffic indicator on the plaintiff's vehicle was working was not justified, as the evidence did not suggest that the trailer obscured the traffic indicator and other lights at the rear of the Toyota. The court found that the defendant's criticism that the magistrate had not addressed the question that the lights on the trailer were not operating at all was also not justified, as this issue was neither pleaded nor pursued in evidence.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi