C v Road Transport Authority (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

C v ROAD TRANSPORT AUTHORITY
(Administrative Review) [2016] ACAT 46

AT 6/2016

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – reviewable decision – driver’s licence – whether applicant meets all 4 criteria under ‘Medical Standards for Licensing - Psychiatric Conditions’ in order to hold a driver’s licence – medical evidence about psychiatric and cognitive issues  confirm the grounds for cancelling the applicant’s licence

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, s9

Road Transport (General) Act 1999 s 95

Subordinate

Legislation:Road Transport (Driver Licensing) Regulation 2000 ss 15, 87

Road Transport (General) Regulation 2000 ss 11, sch 1, part 1.4

List of Papers/Texts

Cited:Medical Standards for Licensing – Psychiatric Conditions’, Part 7.3, Austroad

Tribunal:                   Senior Member L Beacroft                 

Date of Orders:  18 May 2016

Date of Reasons for Decision:         18 May 2016

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL  AT 6/2016

BETWEEN:

C

Applicant

AND:

ROAD TRANSPORT AUTHORITY

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:              Ms L. Beacroft – Senior Member

DATE:  18 May 2016

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

  1. That any evidence given at the hearing, or the documents filed with the tribunal in relation to the application, will be de-identified for the public record by the exclusion of the name of the applicant.

  2. That no person shall publish the name or address of the applicant and he is to be referred to as “C”.

  3. The reviewable decision of 19 November 2015 is confirmed.

………………………………..

Senior Member L Beacroft

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. The applicant, identified in these reasons as C, held an ACT driver’s licence which was cancelled by the Road Transport Authority (the respondent), and he sought a review to regain his driver’s licence.

  2. He then applied to the Tribunal for review of the decision made by the respondent on 19 November 2015 which confirmed the cancellation of his licence (‘the reviewable decision’).

Assessment and Objection

  1. The original decision by the respondent to cancel the applicant’s licence indefinitely, dated 5 August 2015, was based on medical evidence, being the most current Fitness to Drive Medical Clinic Report (FTDMC Report) dated 27 July 2015, signed by Dr Parekh.

  2. The FTDMC Report considered various material provided by the applicant including a letter from a mental health nurse, dated 14 July 2015, letters from a psychiatrist, dated 14 July 2015 and 18 September 2014, and letters from a medical practitioner at a mental health service the applicant attends, dated 20 May 2015 and 1 May 2015. The preparation of the report involved telephone conversations with the applicant’s then treating doctors and mental health clinicians. The FTDMC Report relied on a clinical examination of the applicant on 25 September 2014 where (among other assessments) the applicant was administered the Addenbrooke’s Cognitive Examination ACE-III Australian Version A (2012) test (ACE test). The FTDMC Report concluded that the applicant did not meet the requirements to hold any driver’s licence, as measured against the ‘Medical Standards for Licensing - Psychiatric Conditions’.[1]

    [1]  Respondent’s Submissions dated 18 April 2016, Attachment D, FTDMC Report dated 27 July 2015,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C v Road Transport Authority (Administrative Review) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACAT 46
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this administrative review case, the applicant, referred to as C, contested the decision of the Road Transport Authority to cancel their driver's licence. The dispute centred on whether C met the criteria set out in the 'Medical Standards for Licensing - Psychiatric Conditions'. The applicant's licence was cancelled based on medical evidence that indicated C did not meet these standards due to psychiatric and cognitive issues.

The central legal issue for the court was to determine if the Road Transport Authority's decision to cancel C's driver's licence was justified based on the required medical standards. Specifically, the court needed to assess whether the evidence provided by the authority adequately supported the conclusion that C did not meet the medical criteria for holding a driver's licence.

The court reviewed the statutory provisions governing the authority's power to vary, suspend, or cancel a driver's licence. It found that the decision to cancel C's licence was supported by medical evidence confirming that C did not meet the required medical standards. The court held that the evidence was sufficient to conclude that C did not comply with the medical criteria for holding a driver's licence, thus upholding the authority's decision.

The Tribunal confirmed the reviewable decision and made orders to protect C's identity. The orders included de-identifying any evidence or documents for the public record and prohibiting the publication of C's name or address.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Orders that:

1. That any evidence given at the hearing, or the documents filed with the tribunal in relation to the application, will be de-identified for the public record by the exclusion of the name of the applicant.

2. That no person shall publish the name or address of the applicant and he is to be referred to as “C”.

3. The reviewable decision of 19 November 2015 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Internally reviewable decisions—Act, s 90, def internally reviewable decisionA decision mentioned in schedule 1, column 3 under a provision mentioned in column 2 in relation to the decision is prescribed. Meaning of required medical standards(1)For this regulation, the required medical standards, in relation to a person, are the medical standards set out in the publication Assessing Fitness to Drive, as amended from time to time, published by Austroads, that apply to the person.(2)The Legislation Act, section 47 (6) does not apply to the required medical standards.Note The commercial standards mentioned in the required medical standards apply in relation to the accreditation of a driving instructor and of a heavy vehicle driver assessor (see s 104 (2)). When authority may vary, suspend or cancel driver licences(1)The road transport authority may vary, suspend or cancel a person’s driver licence on its own initiative under section 88 (Procedures for variation, suspension or cancellation of driver licences) if the authority is satisfied on reasonable grounds that—(a)the person is not eligible to apply for, or be issued with, a class or kind of driver licence held by the person; or(b)the person does not have sufficient driving ability or knowledge of safe driving practices or road law to hold a driver licence or a driver licence of the class or kind applied for; or(c)the person is not a suitable person to hold a driver licence or a driver licence of the class or kind held by the person; or(d)the person does not comply with the required medical standards; or(e)the person’s ability to drive safely is impaired by—(i)an illness, injury or incapacity suffered by the person; or (ii)the effects on the person of treatment (including the taking of a drug) for an illness, injury or incapacity suffered by the person; or (f)the person has not complied with any requirements of a law of any jurisdiction relating to the assessment, treatment, supervision or education of drivers convicted or found guilty of offences involving alcohol or drugs that apply to the person; or(g)the person has been convicted or found guilty in another jurisdiction, an external territory or a foreign country of an offence because of which the licensing authority of the other jurisdiction, external territory or foreign country could have varied, suspended or cancelled the person’s licence if it had issued the licence; or(h)the licence was issued or renewed in error; or(i)the licence is incorrect in any material respect; or(j)the person has failed to comply with a condition to which the licence is subject; or(k)the person has not complied with a requirement made by the authority in relation to the licence or a requirement of the Act relating to the licence; or(l)the photograph contained in the licence is no longer a true likeness of the person; or(m)if the licence was issued endorsed with ‘Valid without photo’—the person has unreasonably refused to go to a place designated by the authority to have a photograph taken or provide a photograph that is suitable for use on a driver licence; or(n)the person has failed to comply with a request under section 88B (2); or(o)the person has failed to return the person’s public vehicle driver authority card to the authority as required under section 64B (2).NoteSee s 15 for the meaning of required medical standards.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established