C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd v Rock Tool Refurbishment Solutions Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

C.M.E. Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd v Rock Tool Refurbishment Solutions Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] FCA 632  

File number: SAD 43 of 2020
Judgment of: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 3 June 2022
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — Interlocutory application by applicant/cross-respondent for orders requiring first respondent/cross-applicant to produce documents and things and for orders for discovery and inspection — where first respondent brings cross-claim for non-infringement declaration under ss 125 and 126 of Patents Act 1990 (Cth) in relation to grinding machine it intends to use, offer for sale and sell (RTRS Grinding Machine) — where document identifying features of RTRS Grinding Machine (Full Written Particulars) and “Additional Particulars” provided to applicant by first respondent — where applicant’s expert mechanical engineer has deposed information provided insufficient for him to consider whether RTRS Grinding Machine possesses any claim of any of applicant’s patents — where applicant seeks sample and/or inspection of RTRS Grinding Machine and production of related documents — whether material sought by applicant relevant on first respondent’s cross-claim for non-infringement declaration — consideration of requirement in s 126(1)(a)(ii) of Patents Act that Court must not make non-infringement declaration unless applicant for declaration has given patentee full written particulars of act done or proposed to be done — application dismissed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — Interlocutory application by first and second respondents for summary judgment on four parts of proceeding — where applicant has filed and served evidence-in-chief — where applicant brings claim of infringement of its Patent 1 against respondents on basis that by installing their replacement parts on applicant’s device (CME Grinding Machine), CME Grinding Machine ceases to exist and new grinding machine created which embodies integers of various claims of Patent 1 — where applicant’s expert mechanical engineer has deposed each of integers in Claim 1 of Patent 1 present in CME Grinding Machine but also that he has been unable to measure or otherwise gauge feature the subject of integer 1.8 in Claim 1 and is not able to confirm presence of other related claim — lay evidence advanced by applicant as to presence of integer 1.8 in Claim 1 — whether applicant’s evidence in relation to claim of infringement of Patent 1 insufficient — where applicant’s Further Amended Statement of claim (FASOC) contains allegations relating to non-party (Ausharp) — whether allegations relating to Ausharp irrelevant — where applicant brings claims in conversion and detinue in relation to software (CME Software) incorporated on media (microprocessor) embedded in CME Grinding Machine — where applicant alleges that before its assets and business were acquired by first respondent and/or second respondent in September 2019, Ausharp purchased one or more CME Grinding Machines subject to Terms and Conditions including non-transferrable licence to use CME Software — where applicant alleges that upon acquiring assets and business of Ausharp, respondents did not acquire any licence to use or legal title to CME Software and applicant became entitled to immediate return of microprocessor — whether applicant’s evidence must…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd v Rock Tool Refurbishm... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 632
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd and Rock Tool Refurbishment Solutions Pty Ltd involves two interlocutory applications in the Federal Court. The first application, by C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd, concerns orders for the production of documents, discovery, and inspection. The second application, by Rock Tool Refurbishment Solutions Pty Ltd, seeks summary judgment on parts of the proceeding. The dispute revolves around claims of patent infringement, non-infringement declarations, conversion, detinue, and inducement to breach contract.

The court had to determine whether the material sought by C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd was relevant to Rock Tool Refurbishment Solutions Pty Ltd's cross-claim for a non-infringement declaration. It was also required to decide whether C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd's evidence was sufficient to establish a prima facie case in relation to its claims, and if it had a reasonable prospect of success in prosecuting the proceeding. The court examined the sufficiency of the information provided to C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd regarding the RTRS Grinding Machine and assessed whether the allegations related to non-party Ausharp were relevant. The court also considered whether C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd had established a proprietary or possessory interest in the CME Software.

The court found that Rock Tool Refurbishment Solutions Pty Ltd had provided C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd with sufficient written particulars of the RTRS Grinding Machine for the purposes of a non-infringement declaration under section 126 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). The court concluded that the information provided was adequate for C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd's expert to form an opinion on whether the RTRS Grinding Machine possessed any claim of any of C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd's patents. The court also found that C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd's evidence was insufficient to establish a prima facie case in relation to its claims of infringement, conversion, detinue, and inducement to breach contract. Consequently, the court dismissed both interlocutory applications.

The court ordered that C.M.E Blasting & Mining Equipment Ltd's Interlocutory application dated 3 June 2021 and the first and second respondents' Interlocutory application filed on 15 June 2021 be dismissed. The dismissal of these applications means that the parties must continue with the litigation as originally planned, without the benefit of the orders sought in the interlocutory applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s Interlocutory application dated 3 June 2021 be dismissed.

2. The first and second respondents’ Interlocutory application filed on 15 June 2021 be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am not satisfied that CME has no reasonable prospect of success with respect to its claim for inducement to breach a contract.Conclusions The applicant’s Interlocutory application dated 3 June 2021 is dismissed. The first and second respondents’ Interlocutory application filed on 15 June 2021 is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The conditions which must be satisfied before a non-infringement declaration can be made under s 125 are set out in s 126 of the Act which is in the following terms:126 Proceedings for non-infringement declarations(1)A prescribed court must not make a non-infringement declaration unless:(a) the applicant for the declaration:(i)has asked the patentee in writing for a written admission that the doing of the act has not infringed, or would not infringe, the patent; and(ii)has given the patentee full written particulars of the act done, or proposed to be done; and(iii)has undertaken to pay a reasonable sum for the patentee’s expenses in obtaining advice about whether the act has infringed or would infringe the claim; and(b) the patentee has refused or failed to make the admission.(2) The court may make orders as to costs as the court thinks fit. The dispute in this case centres on whether the patentee has been provided with full written particulars within s 126(1)(a)(ii) with respect to a grinding machine which RTRS contends does not infringe any of CME’s seven patents. The course of events with respect to the particulars which RTRS has provided to CME is as follows. On 18 January 2021, RTRS’s solicitors wrote to CME’s solicitors annexing a document titled as follows: ANNEXURE AThe RTRS Grinding Machine That document identified four features of the RTRS Grinding Machine as follows:(a)a tilting table arranged to hold drill bits being ground;(b)a supporting structure for the grinding head; and(c)a grinding head; and(d)a control cabinet.Thereafter, the document set out the details of each of these four features. The letter itself contained a number of statements about the features of the RTRS Grinding Machine and concerning the absence of features identified by reference to claims in CME’s various patents. These statements were subsequently incorporated into the earlier document which was then titled as follows:Full Written ParticularsThe RTRS Grinding MachineExpert Evidence Mr William Samuel Hunter is a consulting engineer with over 30 years’ experience in developing and designing commercial and industrial products and he has been engaged by RTRS. He has affirmed two affidavits, one on 26 April 2021 and a second on 21 June 2021. Those affidavits are relied on by RTRS in support of its application for a non-infringement declaration. In his first affidavit, Mr Hunter expresses the opinion that the Full Written Particulars for the RTRS Grinding Machine contains sufficient information for him to give his opinion as to whether each feature of the independent claims of each of the patents is present in the RTRS Grinding Machine. He sets out in tabular form his opinion as to whether the RTRS Grinding Machine possesses each feature of the independent claims of the seven CME patents which are the subject of RTRS’s claim for a non-infringement declaration. He answers that question in the negative: not every feature of the independent claims of the seven CME patents is present in the RTRS Grinding Machine.