C and J Designer Homes Pty Ltd v Robey

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

C & J DESIGNER HOMES PTY LTD v ROBEY & ORS [2007] FMCA 79
COPYRIGHT – Architectural drawings – domestic dwelling – builder’s indemnity claim against owner.
Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic)
Copyright Act 1968 (Cth)
Beck v Montana Construction Pty Ltd (1963) 80 WN(NSW) 1578
Toll FGCT Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 52
Maggbury v Hafaele (2001) 210 CLR 181
Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd v Gordian Runoff Ltd (formerly GIO Insurance Ltd) & Ors [2006] NSW SC 223 (BC 200602856)
BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Shire of Hastings (1977) 180 CLR 266
Commonwealth Bank v Amadio (1983) 151 CLR 447
Wigan v Edwards & Anor (1973) 1 ALR 497
Applicant: C & J DESIGNER HOMES PTY LTD (ABN 43 005 236 144)
First Respondents: CHRISTOPHER JOHN ROBEY AND VALERIE DAWN ROBEY
Second Respondent: B & G COLE PTY LTD
(ACN 006 536 536)
Cross-Claimants: CHRISTOPHER JOHN ROBEY AND VALERIE DAWN ROBEY
Cross-Respondents: B & G COLE PTY LTD
(ACN 006 536 536)
File number: MLG1015 of 2005
Judgment of: McInnis  FM
Hearing dates: 29 August 2006 and 30 August 2006
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 30 January 2007

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the First Respondents: Mr S. Minahan
Solicitors for the First Respondents: David Stagg Tonkin & Company
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr E.J.C. Heerey
Solicitors for the Second Respondent: Bolden Lawyers

ORDERS BY CONSENT

  1. The First Respondents (“the Owners”) indemnify the Second Respondent (“the Builder”) in respect of the damages incurred by the Builder by reason of the claim brought by the Applicant including:

    (a)The amount paid in settlement by the Builder to the Applicant namely $1,500.00; and

    (b)The amount in settlement for costs paid by the Builder to the Applicant namely $9,737.66.

  2. The Owners pay the Builder’s costs of and incidental to the Cross-Claim proceedings and the substantive proceedings on an indemnity basis being agreed in the total sum of $64,762.35.

  3. The damages pursuant to paragraph 1 and costs pursuant to paragraph 2 of these Orders be paid by the Owners to the Builder as follows:

    (a)The amount of $38,000.00 within thirty (30) days of the date of these Orders; and

    (b)The balance of $38,000.00 within sixty (60) days of the date of these Orders.

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
MELBOURNE

MLG1015 of 2005

C & J DESIGNER HOMES PTY LTD (ABN 43 005 236 144)

Applicant

And

CHRISTOPHER JOHN ROBEY AND VALERIE DAWN ROBEY

First Respondents

B & G COLE PTY LTD (ACN 006 536 536)

Second Respondent

B & G COLE PTY LTD (ACN 006 536 536)

Cross-Claimant

CHRISTOPHER JOHN ROBEY AND VALERIE DAWN ROBEY

Cross-Respondents

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The issue before the Court is a Cross-Claim for contribution and indemnity by B & G Cole Pty Ltd (the Builder) against Mr and Mrs Robey (the Owners).

  2. The Builder and the Owners have resolved the claim made in these proceedings by the Applicant.  The proceedings were settled without an admission of liability and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C and J Designer Homes Pty Ltd v Robey and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FMCA 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of C and J Designer Homes Pty Ltd v Robey, the Applicant, a company specialising in home design, initiated proceedings against the Respondents to establish whether they had infringed the Applicant’s copyright. The matter proceeded to the consideration of the Respondents’ cross-claim, which sought indemnity from the Applicant under a contractual indemnity clause. The primary legal issue before the court was whether expert evidence on copyright infringement was relevant and admissible in the context of the cross-claim. The Applicant argued that the settlement of the copyright infringement claim should preclude the need for such evidence, while the Respondents contended that evidence on the infringement was necessary to address the indemnity dispute.

The court considered the implications of the settlement on the admissibility of expert evidence. It determined that the settlement and the resulting consent orders effectively resolved the Applicant’s cause of action for copyright infringement, thereby concluding any hypothetical consideration of whether other parties had infringed the Applicant’s copyright. The court found that the principles of res judicata applied, rendering the copyright infringement issue irrelevant to the present indemnity dispute. The court reasoned that the task before it was to resolve the narrow issue of whether the current proceeding fell within the indemnity provided by clause 15.0 of the contract, rather than re-litigating the copyright infringement matter.

The court ruled that expert evidence regarding copyright infringement was not necessary for the determination of the indemnity dispute. It held that the settlement between the parties had resolved the copyright infringement claims, and thus, any opinion evidence related to such infringement was irrelevant. Consequently, the court focused on the contractual indemnity provision and determined the scope of indemnity available under the contract without considering the merits of the copyright infringement claims.

The final orders of the court were that expert evidence on copyright infringement was deemed irrelevant and inadmissible in the context of the cross-claim. The court directed the parties to proceed with the determination of the indemnity dispute based on the terms of the contract, without revisiting the settled copyright infringement claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Is expert evidence as to the infringement of the Applicant’s copyright relevant and/or admissible when considering the Cross-claim? The Builder referred to the Owners Defence at paragraph 8 which reflects statements made by Mrs Cole’s affidavit sworn 17 February 2006 (Exhibit 1R2) referring to legal opinions and conclusions relevant to the elements of copyright infringement. It was submitted that once it is accepted that the first limb of clause 15.0 has been fulfilled and that the present application brought by the Applicant and settled between the parties which falls within the term “any claim for copyright infringement” then it is irrelevant and unnecessary for the Court to determine whether the Respondents infringed the Applicant’s copyright. It is argued that it would be embarrassing to demand a determination by the Court in the absence of the Applicant given the determination must depend firstly upon matters which only the Applicant can prove, particularly that copyright subsists in the Applicant’s plans and that the Applicant is the owner of the copyright and has standing to bring the action pursuant to the relevant provisions of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). Without the Applicant proving copyright and standing, it was submitted, that it is a waste of the Court’s time and resources to engage in a hypothetical consideration of whether other parties have infringed such copyright. It was submitted that it is in the nature of compromise claims that many issues remain undetermined which could have been determined either way. In this application it is noted that it may have been open to the Court to decide that the owners had infringed the Applicant’s copyright by making the ‘cut and paste plan’ or by authorising the Builder to design and build a house incorporating a substantial part of the Applicant’s plans. In the alternative it may have been open to the Court to determine to the contrary by finding that the part copy was not “substantial”. Ultimately it was submitted the settlement puts and end to these enquiries and the Applicant’s cause of action for copyright infringement has merged in the consent orders made amongst the parties on 26 May 2006 pursuant to the principles of res judicata. The statements therefore made by either the owners or the Builders which relate to the copyright infringement are therefore irrelevant to the present indemnity dispute before the Court. The task of the Court it was submitted was to deal with the narrow issue of whether and how the present proceeding falls within the indemnity provided by clause 15.0 of the contract. It was submitted that issues of copyright infringement against the Builder will always remain unresolved due to the settlement. As I understand it the Owners submitted that opinion evidence was necessary to establish any alleged copyright infringement and that any settlement was without prejudice to the rights of the Owners in dealing with the alleged infringement. Detailed reference was made to statements made as set out in the affidavit material together with the correspondence between the parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.