C.A.R.S Pty Ltd v Brent (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[2015] TASSC 26

COURT:                   SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:              C.A.R.S. Pty Ltd v Brent (No 2) [2015] TASSC 26

PARTIES:  C.A.R.S. Pty Ltd
  v
  BRENT, John Charles
  BRENT, Peter Leonard

FILE NO:  793/2013
DELIVERED ON:  30 June 2015
DELIVERED AT:  Launceston
HEARING DATE:  4 June 2015
JUDGMENT OF:  Blow CJ

CATCHWORDS:

Procedure – Costs – Departing from the general rule – Conduct of parties – Misconduct etc – In proceedings – Conduct of case – Plaintiff unsuccessful against one of two defendants – Costs wasted by defendants putting plaintiff to proof of quantum of claim – Forgery of successful defendant's signature on guarantee not disclosed before action commenced.

Latrobe Council v Williams (2008) 18 Tas R 138, referred to.
Aust Dig Procedure [584]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
           Plaintiff:  S B McElwaine SC
           Defendants:  G W Dietz
Solicitors:
           Plaintiff:  Rae & Partners
           Defendants:  SS Lawyers Pty Ltd

Judgment Number:  [2015] TASSC 26
Number of paragraphs:  15

Serial No 26/2015

File No 793/2013

C.A.R.S. Pty Ltd v JOHN CHARLES BRENT
and PETER LEONARD BRENT (NO 2)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  BLOW CJ

30 June 2015

  1. On 4 June 2015 I decided that the plaintiff's claim against the first defendant must fail, but that its claim against the second defendant must succeed in full: C.A.R.S. Pty Ltd v Brent [2015] TASSC 23. The plaintiff's claim includes a component for compound interest. I deferred the making of final orders until today so that interest could be calculated. The parties have made written submissions as to interest and costs.

  2. It has now been agreed that the quantum of the plaintiff's claim, including compound interest to today, is $1,811,926.90.  There will be judgment for the plaintiff against the second defendant for that sum.

  3. The deed of guarantee executed by the second defendant contained a covenant that he would indemnify the plaintiff against, amongst other things, all costs which the plaintiff incurred by reason of any default in Bunjurgen Pty Ltd making payment to it for goods sold and delivered.  In accordance with that covenant, the plaintiff has sought an order for costs against the second defendant on an indemnity basis.  The defendants have chosen to make no submissions as to that.  Such an order accords with the terms of that covenant.  There will therefore be an order that the second defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of and incidental to the action on an indemnity basis.

First defendant's application for costs

  1. The first defendant, having succeeded in the action, has applied for an order that the plaintiff pay his costs.  The plaintiff opposes that application. It contends that, as between it and the first defendant, each party should pay its own costs.

  2. Ordinarily, when a plaintiff succeeds against one defendant but not another, that plaintiff should be ordered to pay the costs of the successful defendant: Latrobe Council v Williams (2008) 18 Tas R 138 at [14]. However the plaintiff contends that there are facts and circumstances by reason of which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C.A.R.S Pty Ltd v Brent (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] TASSC 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of C.A.R.S Pty Ltd v Brent (No 2), the Federal Court was tasked with determining the appropriate allocation of costs in a proceeding that had extended due to the conduct of the parties. The plaintiff, C.A.R.S Pty Ltd, had initiated legal action against two defendants for a debt secured by a guarantee. The plaintiff was successful against one defendant but not against the other, Brent, who raised a defence based on the alleged forgery of his signature on the guarantee. The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the costs incurred by the defendants, which had effectively put the plaintiff to proving the quantum of its claim, warranted a departure from the usual rule of costs following the event.

The Court considered the conduct of both parties during the proceedings. The plaintiff's legal team was found to have acted reasonably in pursuing the claim against both defendants, given the circumstances. However, the defendants' conduct was scrutinised heavily, particularly Brent's failure to disclose the alleged forgery before the action commenced. This concealment led to significant wasted costs for the plaintiff, who had to proceed to prove the quantum of the claim despite Brent's defence. The Court found that Brent's actions constituted misconduct, warranting a deviation from the standard cost-following rules.

In light of the findings, the Court ruled that the usual order for costs following the event was unjust. The Court determined that the plaintiff was entitled to be indemnified for the costs wasted due to Brent's failure to disclose the forgery. The Court awarded the plaintiff costs on an indemnity basis, reflecting the significant misconduct and the resultant wasted expenditure. This decision underscored the importance of full disclosure in legal proceedings and the consequences of failing to do so. The Court's ruling emphasised the need for parties to act with integrity and transparency, especially in matters involving allegations of forgery.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.