BUTT & OWNERS CORPORATION UNITS PLAN NO 1725 (Units Title)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

BUTT & OWNERS CORPORATION UNITS PLAN NO 1725

(Units Title) [2013] ACAT 17

UT 12/27

Catchwords:             UNITS TITLE – meaning of “quorum” in section 89 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011: whether proxies may be counted for a quorum – a unit’s share of sinking fund contribution - intended operation of section 89 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 – inconsistency between clear wording of the provision and the examples: “usurpation of the legislative function under the thin disguise of interpretation” is not appropriate

List of legislation:     Legislation Act 2001, ss. 132, 139, and 141

Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011, ss. 72, 83, 86 and 89, and Schedule 3

List of cases:             Bermingham v Corrective Services Commission of New South Wales (1988) 15 NSWLR 292

Magor and St Mellons RDC v Newport Corp [1952] AC 189

R v Young (1999) 46 NSWLR 681

Tribunal:                  Ms Mary-Therese Daniel, Member

Date of Orders:  21 March 2013
Date of Reasons for Decision:         21 March 2013

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          UT 12/027

BETWEEN:

MICHAEL EDWARD BUTT

Applicant

AND:

THE OWNERS CORPORATION UNITS PLAN NO 1725

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Ms Mary-Therese Daniel

DATE:  21 March 2013

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The resolution of 18 July 2012 approving the sinking fund contribution for the owners corporation units plan 1725 for the 12 month period commencing 1 May 2012 is set aside.

………………………………..

Ms Mary-Therese Daniel

Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. These proceedings were instituted by Mr Michael Butt (applicant) filing an application on 7 November 2012 under the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (Act) against the Owners Corporation Units Plan 1725 (owners corporation). 

  2. The applicant seeks that the Tribunal set aside a resolution made by the owners corporation approving a specified sinking fund contribution, on the grounds that the resolution was not in compliance with the requirements of the Act.

Facts

  1. The relevant facts were agreed as follows.

  2. The applicant and his wife jointly own one of the 34 units in Units Plan 1725. 

  3. On 24 May 2012, the annual general meeting (AGM) of the owners corporation was held.  There were 18 units personally represented (what appears to be a typographical error in the minutes has Lot 24 being represented twice) and in addition there were three proxies held.  The Minutes record another 3 units as having provided absentee votes, although the Minutes record these under the heading for proxies. 

  4. The Minutes record that a quorum was declared present and the meeting proceeded as scheduled.  The Minutes then record:

    MOTION 6:  Ordinary Resolution.  It was resolved that the sinking fund forecast report as compiled by QIA Group Pty Ltd, as circulated, be adopted.  CARRIED

    MOTION 13:  Ordinary Resolution.   It was resolved that the proposed sinking fund expenditure of $5,000.00 be adopted.  Also, that the corporation determine a contribution of $12,517.00 for the twelve month period, commencing on 1 May 2012, and to be contributed in accordance…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BUTT & OWNERS CORPORATION UNITS PLAN NO 1725 (Units Title) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ACAT 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Court was an application by Butt, a unit owner, against the Owners Corporation of Units Plan No 1725. The dispute centred on the validity of a resolution passed at an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) of the owners corporation on 18 July 2012, which approved a resolution to levy sinking fund contributions. The issue at hand was whether the resolution was properly passed, given the presence or absence of a quorum at the meeting. Specifically, the question was whether proxies should be counted in determining whether a quorum was present at the meeting, as defined under section 3.9(1) of Schedule 3 to the Act.

The Court was tasked with interpreting the statutory requirement for a quorum at a general meeting of an owners corporation. The relevant provision, section 3.9(1)(a), stipulated that a motion could only be considered if there was present a quorum made up by people entitled to vote on the motion in relation to not less than half the total number of units. The Court needed to determine what constituted a "person entitled to vote" for the purposes of this provision, specifically whether it included proxies. The Court considered the wording of the provision and the broader context of the Act, including the absence of any specific exclusion of proxies from the definition of "person entitled to vote."

The Court concluded that the correct interpretation of section 3.9(1)(a) was that proxies could count towards the quorum. This interpretation was supported by the language of the provision and a consideration of the Act as a whole. The Court found that there was indeed a quorum present at the EGM of 18 July 2012, as proxies were properly included in the count. Consequently, the resolution approving the sinking fund contributions was valid, and the owners corporation was entitled to set aside this resolution and reconsider the issue.

ORDERS:
The resolution of 18 July 2012 approving the sinking fund contribution for the owners corporation units plan 1725 for the 12 month period commencing 1 May 2012 is set aside.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The resolution of 18 July 2012 approving the sinking fund contribution for the owners corporation units plan 1725 for the 12 month period commencing 1 May 2012 is set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The position at common law is that proxies do not count for the purposes of a quorum. Authority for counting proxies towards the quorum must be found in either the rules or the relevant statute. In the current case, section 3.9(1) of Schedule 3 to the Act sets out the requirements for a quorum at a general meeting of an owners corporation with 3 or more members, as follows:3.9Quorum at a general meeting—owners corporation with 3 or more members(UTA s 99)(1)A motion may be considered at a general meeting of an owners corporation with 3 or more members only if there is present—(a)a quorum (a standard quorum) made up by people entitled to vote (on the motion) in relation to not less than ½ the total number of units; or(b)a quorum (a reduced quorum) made up under subsection (2).(2)If a standard quorum is not present within ½ an hour after the motion arises for consideration, a reduced quorum for the motion and any subsequent motion considered at the meeting is made up by 2 or more people present at the meeting who are entitled to vote on the motion.(3)If a reduced quorum is not present ½ an hour after the motion arises for consideration, the meeting is adjourned to the same day in the next week at the same place and time.(4)If a reduced quorum is present for the consideration of any motion and the motion is voted on, section 3.10 (Notice of reduced quorum decisions and adjournments) applies to the decision on the motion. The question is, in interpreting paragraph 3.9(1)(a) does one count the number of people present (ie. ignoring ownership of more than one unit and proxies), or the number of entitlements to vote that are physically present (ie. multiple ownership counts, but proxies do not), or the number of entitlements to vote that are held by people that are present (ie. including proxies)? The use of the words ‘in relation to’ would best lend itself to the third interpretation. That this is the correct approach is supported by a consideration of the Act as a whole. Paragraph 3.31(4) of the Act specifically provides in relation to absentee votes that such votes do not count “for the purposes of making up a quorum”. If the same approach was intended to be taken in relation to proxies, similar legislative provision would have been made. I am satisfied that the correct interpretation of paragraph 3.9(1)(a) is that proxies may count towards the quorum. It follows that there was a quorum at the EGM of 18 July 2012 and it was open to the owners corporation to proceed, as it did, to set aside the resolution to approve Motion 13 and reconsider the issue of the sinking fund contributions. Part 5 of the Act deals with matters of financial management of owners corporations, and Division 5.2 in particular covers administrative, special purpose and sinking funds. Section 89 of the Act deals with how an owners corporation may levy sinking fund contributions from members:89Sinking fund—contributions(UTA s 64 (1), (2) and (3)) (1) An owners corporation for a units plan may determine a contribution (a sinking fund contribution) required from its members for the corporation’s sinking fund. (2) The sinking fund contribution payable for each unit for a financial year is—(a)the proportional share for the unit of the total sinking fund amount for the financial year; or(b)a proportion of the total sinking fund amount worked out using a method set out in an unopposed resolution.NoteTotal sinking fund amount, for a financial year, means the total of expected sinking fund expenditure for the year set out in the sinking fund plan (see s 82). Expected sinking fund expenditure means expenditure for the purposes mentioned in s 83 (1) that the owners corporation reasonably expects will be necessary to maintain in good condition the common property and any other property it holds (see s 83). (3) A resolution under subsection (2) (b) may provide that only stated unit owners, or unit owners in a stated class, are required to pay a sinking fund contribution. (4) A resolution under subsection (2) (b) may only be—(a)amended by unopposed resolution; or(b)revoked by special resolution.