Bussenschutt v QBE

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MERIT REVIEWER
CITATION: Bussenschutt v QBE [2022] NSWPICMR 13
CLAIMANT: Malcom Bussenschutt
INSURER: QBE
MERIT REVIEWER: Katherine Ruschen
DATE OF DECISION: 24 February 2022
CATCHWORDS: 

MOTOR ACCIDENTS- Merit review; dispute about payment of statutory benefits under section 3.24 and/or 3.26 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act); meaning of treatment and care; jurisdiction; schedule 2, clause 1(j) of the MAI Act; whether services provided by the claimant to dependents before the accident; whether thresholds in section 3.26 of the MAI Act met; whether services are for others or for the claimant; Held – the reviewable decision is affirmed. 

DETERMINATIONS MADE: 

The reviewable decision is about whether statutory benefits are payable under section 3.26 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act) and the amount of statutory benefits so payable, and is therefore a merit review matter under Schedule 2(1)(j) of the MAI Act.

1.     The reviewable decision is:

affirmed.

Issued under section 7.13(4) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017

BACKGROUND

  1. There is a dispute between Malcom Bussenschutt (the claimant) and the insurer about whether statutory benefits are payable under section 3.26 of Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act) and the amount of statutory benefits so payable.

  2. On 4 February 2021 the claimant made a claim for payment of domestic services based on recommendations for paid commercial domestic services made by
    Ms Warner, occupational therapist in a report dated 31 January 2021.

  3. On 22 February 2021 the insurer declined the claim for payment of domestic services.

  1. The claimant requested an internal review of the 22 February 2021 decision.

  2. On 8 March 2021 the insurer issued their internal review decision in which the decision to decline the claim for payment of domestic services was affirmed.

  3. The claimant has applied for a merit review of the 8 March 2021 internal review decision.

SUBMISSIONS

  1. The application for a merit review requests a merit review as to “whether the domestic assistance recommended by Ms Warner in her report dated 31 January 2021 is reasonable and necessary”.

  2. In response, the insurer submitted the Personal Injury Commission (the Commission) does not have jurisdiction to determine a dispute of the type framed by the claimant because:

    (a) the dispute framed is not a merit review matter within schedule 2(1) of the MAI Act, no issue having been raised about costs;

    (b) further, the dispute framed is not a medical assessment matter as it is not caught by schedule 2(2)(b) of the MAI Act which confines itself to what has been provided, not what might in future be needed;

    (c) in addition, section 3.25 of the MAI Act effectively provides that no statutory benefits are payable in connection with the provision of gratuitous attendant care services, and

    (d) in summary, the section 3.25 prohibition and the fact the claimant’s application does not make a claim for payment or reimbursement for any assistance or care allegedly needed and provided to date as a consequence of the subject accident,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bussenschutt v QBE and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPICMR 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The claimant, who suffered an injury in a motor accident, has applied for a merit review of the insurer's decision to decline payment of domestic services. The insurer had already declined the claim through an internal review and the claimant sought to challenge this decision by applying for a review by the Personal Injury Commission (PIC). The insurer argued that the PIC lacked jurisdiction to hear the application for merit review. The insurer contended that the dispute was not a matter of merit review, as no issue had been raised about costs, nor was it a medical assessment matter as it did not relate to what had been provided. The insurer also argued that section 3.25 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act) effectively provided that no statutory benefits are payable in connection with the provision of gratuitous attendant care services. The claimant, on the other hand, argued that the PIC had jurisdiction to hear the matter under schedule 2(1)(j) of the MAI Act, which states that merit review matters include "whether statutory benefits are payable under section 3.26 (statutory benefits for loss of capacity to provide gratuitous domestic services), and the amount of statutory benefits so payable".

The PIC considered the arguments of both parties and found that the insurer's position was correct. The PIC held that the dispute was not a matter of merit review as no issue had been raised about costs, nor was it a medical assessment matter as it did not relate to what had been provided. The PIC also held that section 3.25 of the MAI Act effectively provided that no statutory benefits are payable in connection with the provision of gratuitous attendant care services. The PIC found that the claimant's application did not make a claim for payment or reimbursement for any assistance or care allegedly needed and provided to date as a consequence of the subject accident, and therefore there was no scope to argue that any part of schedule 2 confers jurisdiction on the PIC to deal with the application.

The PIC affirmed the insurer's decision to decline payment of domestic services and dismissed the claimant's application for a merit review. The PIC held that the dispute was not a matter of merit review, as no issue had been raised about costs, nor was it a medical assessment matter as it did not relate to what had been provided. The PIC also held that section 3.25 of the MAI Act effectively provided that no statutory benefits are payable in connection with the provision of gratuitous attendant care services. The PIC found that the claimant's application did not make a claim for payment or reimbursement for any assistance or care allegedly needed and provided to date as a consequence of the subject accident, and therefore there was no scope to argue that any part of schedule 2 confers jurisdiction on the PIC to deal with the application. The claimant's application for a merit review was dismissed and the insurer's decision to decline payment of domestic services was affirmed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The claimant requested an internal review of the 22 February 2021 decision. On 8 March 2021 the insurer issued their internal review decision in which the decision to decline the claim for payment of domestic services was affirmed. The claimant has applied for a merit review of the 8 March 2021 internal review decision. The application for a merit review requests a merit review as to “whether the domestic assistance recommended by Ms Warner in her report dated 31 January 2021 is reasonable and necessary”. In response, the insurer submitted the Personal Injury Commission (the Commission) does not have jurisdiction to determine a dispute of the type framed by the claimant because: (a) the dispute framed is not a merit review matter within schedule 2(1) of the MAI Act, no issue having been raised about costs;(b) further, the dispute framed is not a medical assessment matter as it is not caught by schedule 2(2)(b) of the MAI Act which confines itself to what has been provided, not what might in future be needed;(c) in addition, section 3.25 of the MAI Act effectively provides that no statutory benefits are payable in connection with the provision of gratuitous attendant care services, and(d) in summary, the section 3.25 prohibition and the fact the claimant’s application does not make a claim for payment or reimbursement for any assistance or care allegedly needed and provided to date as a consequence of the subject accident, means there is no scope to argue that any part of schedule 2 confers jurisdiction on the Commission to deal with the application. The Commission wrote to the claimant requesting clarification of the nature of the merit review, including identification of the subclause under schedule 2(1) relied upon by the claimant to make a merit review application. The claimant responded by stating he relies on schedule 2(1)(j) which states merit review matters include "whether statutory benefits are payable under section 3.26 (statutory benefits for loss of capacity to provide gratuitous domestic services), and the amount of statutory benefits so payable". The claimant provided the following submissions in support of an application for a merit review under schedule 2(1)(j):“The claim made by the claimant clearly articulated the cost of the care in the letter dated 4 February 2021 as follows: -4 hours per week for bulk preparation of meals that can be frozen for future reheating, a thorough vacuum and mop, cleaning of the bathroom, changing of bed linen; and spring-cleaning activities as they arise. -2 hours per week for mowing, heavy gardening and sweeping and cleaning of outdoor areas and yard maintenance activities; -Fortnightly washing and polishing of his vehicle. -Recommendations -12.1.1. Introduction of 4 hours weekly commercial domestic assistance @ $54.45 per hour. (Source: Australian Home Care Services ph: 1300 303 770). -12.1.2. Introduction of 2 hours weekly commercial mowing, gardening, yard and pool maintenance activities @ $50.00 per hour. (Source: Jim’s Mowing). -12.1.3. Introduction of fortnightly car washing/polishing at a professional car wash @ $35.00 per wash. (Source: Snap Car Wash).The insurer is taking a very narrow approach to the wording contained within the legislation to submit that this is only in respect of what has been provided. If the dispute was in respect of a Neurosurgeon recommending a spinal fusion and this was disputed, this is the very clause that would be relied upon to refer the matter to the PIC for determination and there would be no issue. There is no difference here where there has been domestic assistance (care) recommended by an Occupational Therapist, this has been denied by the insurer and the claimant is seeking referral to the PIC to determine the dispute.”