Bussa v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Bussa v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FedCFamC2G 579

File number: MLG 3076 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE BLAKE
Date of judgment: 28 June 2024
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Application to review decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘Tribunal’) – where visa cancelled because applicant was not enrolled in a registered course – whether Tribunal exercised its discretion to cancel the visa lawfully – HELD no error by the Tribunal – application dismissed.  
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 116, 116(1)(b), 116(2), 116(3), 476(2)(a).

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) regs 8202, 8202(2)(a), 8202(3).

Cases cited: Kaur v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCA 1046
Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 40
Date of last submission: 7 June 2024
Date of hearing: 23 May 2024 & 7 June 2024
Place: Melbourne
Advocate for the Applicant: In Person
Solicitor for the Applicant: Self-represented litigant
Advocate for the Respondents: Mr Hornsbey
Solicitor for the Respondents: Mills Oakley Lawyers

ORDERS

MLG 3076 of 2018

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

THEJASWINI BUSSA

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE BLAKE

DATE OF ORDER:

28 JUNE 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Application filed on 12 October 2018 be dismissed.

2.The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs of the proceeding fixed in the sum of $8,371.30.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: This copy of the Court’s Reasons for judgment may be subject to review to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE BLAKE:

  1. This is an application to review a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘Tribunal’) on 2 October 2018 (Court Book (‘CB’) 63). In that decision, the Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister (‘delegate’) to cancel the Student (Temporary) (class TU) (subclass 573) visa (‘visa’) held by the Applicant. 

  2. For the reasons that follow, I have decided to dismiss the application for review.

    BACKGROUND

  3. The Applicant is an Indian national. She arrived in Australia on 7 July 2016 as the holder of a student visa (CB 52). 

  4. On 20 July 2017, the Applicant’s enrolment in a Master of Information Systems was cancelled due to the non-payment of fees (CB 1-3). She had been enrolled at Central Queensland University (‘University’).

  5. On 29 March 2018, a delegate of the Minister (‘delegate’) sent the Applicant a Notice of Intention to Consider Cancellation (‘NOICC’) of the visa on the basis that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bussa v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 579
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bussa, an Indian national, sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to affirm the cancellation of her student visa on the basis that she had not remained enrolled in a registered course. The Tribunal had concluded that Bussa did not have the will or desire to successfully undertake an education course in Australia, and that the cancellation of her visa should be affirmed. Bussa contended that the Tribunal had failed to have regard to various matters, including financial hardship and family disturbances. The central issue for the court was whether the Tribunal exercised its discretion to affirm the visa cancellation lawfully. The court found that the Tribunal had not erred in law. The Tribunal correctly identified the issue and had regard to the matters raised by Bussa, including her minor medical issues, the death of her grandfather, and her wish to take time off before recommencing her studies. The Tribunal found that these matters did not provide sufficient reason to explain why Bussa had failed to enroll in any course in Australia since mid-2017, and concluded that Bussa did not have the will or desire to successfully undertake a higher education course in Australia. The Tribunal considered that Bussa's lack of will and desire to study in Australia heavily outweighed any hardship she, her husband, or any family members may face because of the cancellation of the visa. The court held that the Tribunal's decision was lawful and dismissed the application for review. The decision of the Tribunal was affirmed, and Bussa's visa remained cancelled.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I have decided to dismiss the application for review.BACKGROUND The Applicant is an Indian national. She arrived in Australia on 7 July 2016 as the holder of a student visa (CB 52). On 20 July 2017, the Applicant’s enrolment in a Master of Information Systems was cancelled due to the non-payment of fees (CB 1-3). She had been enrolled at Central Queensland University (‘University’). On 29 March 2018, a delegate of the Minister (‘delegate’) sent the Applicant a Notice of Intention to Consider Cancellation (‘NOICC’) of the visa on the basis that the Applicant was not enrolled in a registered course (CB 8). The Applicant was invited to comment on the NOICC (CB 8). The Applicant did not provide any comment on the NOICC. On 18 June 2018, the delegate cancelled the visa (CB 26). On 26 June 2018, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision (CB 31). On 31 August 2018, the Tribunal invited the Applicant to attend a hearing on 18 September 2018 (CB 37). On 17 September 2018, the Tribunal wrote to the Applicant notifying her that the hearing had been postponed (CB 40). On 24 September 2018, the Tribunal invited the Applicant to attend a hearing at 10.00 am on 2 October 2018 to give evidence and present arguments. Within the invitation, the Applicant was requested to provide any additional documents and information as soon as possible. On 2 October 2018 at 8.27 am, the Applicant sent her response to the hearing invitation. There is no evidence the Applicant made any written submissions prior to the hearing. The hearing before the Tribunal on 2 October 2018 commenced at 10.35 am and concluded at 12.27 pm, with oral reasons having been given at 12.10 pm. The hearing record discloses that both the Applicant and her witness, Mr Dommata, were in attendance. The transcript of the hearing was not before me. Following the hearing, the Tribunal decided to affirm the decision of the delegate (CB 60). On 15 October 2018, the Tribunal provided a written record of oral decision and reasons to the Applicant (‘Reasons’) (CB 63). In this Court, the Applicant filed her application to review the decision of the Tribunal on 12 October 2018 (‘Application’). The Application was accompanied by an affidavit from the Applicant of the same date. The Minister filed written submissions dated 9 May 2024 and also prepared a Court Book that contains the relevant documents. The Applicant relies on her affidavit of 12 October 2018, a further affidavit affirmed 14 May 2024 that attaches various documents (including an academic transcript, graduate diploma, emails, a death certificate for her grandfather and a certificate of properties), an affidavit affirmed 16 May 2024 (that provides information about her chronic sinus condition and attaches a medical certificate) and written submissions that she handed to the Court, and were subsequently filed. THE DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL In its decision, the Tribunal:(a)at [3] of its Reasons noted that the delegate cancelled the visa on the basis that the Applicant had breached a condition of her visa, being to remain enrolled in a registered course, and stated that the issue in the present case is whether that ground for cancellation is made out, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled;(b)at [4] stated that the issue was whether the Applicant breached condition 8202 of Schedule 8 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (‘Regulations’) and if the Applicant has breached that condition, whether the visa may be cancelled;(c)at [5]-[6] noted that the delegate found that the Applicant had not been enrolled in a registered course since her enrolment in a Master of Information Systems was cancelled on 20 July 2017 for non-payment of fees. The Tribunal recorded that ‘This was put to the applicant in the required way, and the applicant conceded that she had not been enrolled in a registered course since that date’. The Tribunal stated on the evidence before it, the ‘applicant was not enrolled in a registered course. Accordingly, the applicant has not complied with condition 8202’;(d)at [7] recorded that having found the Applicant had not complied with a condition of the visa, the Tribunal must consider whether to exercise its discretion to affirm the decision to cancel the visa. The Tribunal noted that there are no matters in the Act or the Regulations that are required to be considered in relation to the exercise of discretion;(e)at [8] recorded the Applicant’s evidence that she had successfully completed four units of her course by around October 2016 and completed four units of her second semester by around March 2017;(f)at [9]-[10] noted that the Applicant returned to India in March 2017 to deal with medical issues and also the passing of her grandfather;(g)at [11] recorded that the Applicant did not enrol in her next semester of study when she returned to Australia in April 2017 because of family issues and also remaining minor medical issues;(h)at [12] recorded that the Applicant indicated that she wished to continue studying, but needed to take time off for 3-4 months before recommencing her studies. The Tribunal asked the Applicant why she did not approach the University to defer her enrolment. The Tribunal also asked the Applicant why she had not recommenced her studies in 2017 once she had taken 3-4 months off. To both queries, the Applicant replied that these were her mistakes. The Tribunal noted that it was now October 2018 and the Applicant had not made any efforts to recommence her studies;(i)at [13], the Tribunal asked the Applicant whether she or any family members would suffer hardship if her visa were to remain cancelled. The Tribunal records the Applicant as saying she would not and that there was no hardship. The Tribunal also asked the Applicant whether there was any impediment to the Applicant recommencing studies in India, to which the Applicant replied she already held a degree from a tertiary institution in India;(j)at [14]-[15] the Tribunal put to the Applicant that given she had ceased studying in July 2017, and had made no attempt to re-enrol in a registered course since that time, that the Applicant may not have the will or desire to successfully undertake an education course in Australia. The Applicant indicated she did wish to study and would apply for another visa; (k)At [15], the Tribunal noted that even if the Applicant’s visa had not been cancelled, it would have expired in August 2018 and that therefore it appears that the only utility of the proceedings before the Tribunal is that, if the visa remains cancelled, she will be subject to a three year ban on applying for a further visa, whereas if she is successful, she will be able to apply for another visa to study in Australia;(l)at [16] the Tribunal noted that the Applicant indicated that her visa was cancelled on 18 June 2018 and that it does not appear that she holds any visa and that she therefore appears to be an unlawful non-citizen;(m)at [17] the Tribunal found that the Applicant does not have the will or desire to successfully undertake an education course in Australia;(n)at [18], the Tribunal recorded it was willing to accept that the Applicant was facing some minor medical condition in 2017 and was willing to accept, without documentary evidence, that her grandfather passed away in March 2017. The Tribunal considered, however, that those matters did not provide sufficient reason to explain why the Applicant has failed to enrol in any course in Australia since mid-2017. The Tribunal recorded that the Applicant was granted a visa for the purpose of studying in Australia, and yet she had ceased to study for over a year;(o)at [20], the Tribunal indicated it was willing to accept that while the Applicant and her family members will not suffer any hardship, the Applicant’s family in India will feel some disappointment and be upset that the Applicant’s visa was cancelled. The Tribunal also stated it had considered that if the Applicant’s visa remains cancelled, she will be prevented from successfully applying for another visa in Australia for a period of three years;(p)at [21] the Tribunal considered that a decision to affirm the cancellation decision in relation to the Applicant’s visa may well mean that the Applicant’s husband may also be unsuccessful in his review application before the Tribunal. The Tribunal found, however, that the Applicant’s lack of will and desire to successfully undertake a higher education course in Australia heavily outweighs any hardship she, her husband, or any family members may face because of the cancellation of the visa; and(q)at [22]-[23] the Tribunal concluded that the Applicant’s visa should be cancelled, and the decision of the delegate should be affirmed.APPLICABLE LAW

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Minister filed written submissions dated 9 May 2024 and also prepared a Court Book that contains the relevant documents. The Applicant relies on her affidavit of 12 October 2018, a further affidavit affirmed 14 May 2024 that attaches various documents (including an academic transcript, graduate diploma, emails, a death certificate for her grandfather and a certificate of properties), an affidavit affirmed 16 May 2024 (that provides information about her chronic sinus condition and attaches a medical certificate) and written submissions that she handed to the Court, and were subsequently filed. THE DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL In its decision, the Tribunal:(a)at [3] of its Reasons noted that the delegate cancelled the visa on the basis that the Applicant had breached a condition of her visa, being to remain enrolled in a registered course, and stated that the issue in the present case is whether that ground for cancellation is made out, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled;(b)at [4] stated that the issue was whether the Applicant breached condition 8202 of Schedule 8 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (‘Regulations’) and if the Applicant has breached that condition, whether the visa may be cancelled;(c)at [5]-[6] noted that the delegate found that the Applicant had not been enrolled in a registered course since her enrolment in a Master of Information Systems was cancelled on 20 July 2017 for non-payment of fees. The Tribunal recorded that ‘This was put to the applicant in the required way, and the applicant conceded that she had not been enrolled in a registered course since that date’. The Tribunal stated on the evidence before it, the ‘applicant was not enrolled in a registered course. Accordingly, the applicant has not complied with condition 8202’;(d)at [7] recorded that having found the Applicant had not complied with a condition of the visa, the Tribunal must consider whether to exercise its discretion to affirm the decision to cancel the visa. The Tribunal noted that there are no matters in the Act or the Regulations that are required to be considered in relation to the exercise of discretion;(e)at [8] recorded the Applicant’s evidence that she had successfully completed four units of her course by around October 2016 and completed four units of her second semester by around March 2017;(f)at [9]-[10] noted that the Applicant returned to India in March 2017 to deal with medical issues and also the passing of her grandfather;(g)at [11] recorded that the Applicant did not enrol in her next semester of study when she returned to Australia in April 2017 because of family issues and also remaining minor medical issues;(h)at [12] recorded that the Applicant indicated that she wished to continue studying, but needed to take time off for 3-4 months before recommencing her studies. The Tribunal asked the Applicant why she did not approach the University to defer her enrolment. The Tribunal also asked the Applicant why she had not recommenced her studies in 2017 once she had taken 3-4 months off. To both queries, the Applicant replied that these were her mistakes. The Tribunal noted that it was now October 2018 and the Applicant had not made any efforts to recommence her studies;(i)at [13], the Tribunal asked the Applicant whether she or any family members would suffer hardship if her visa were to remain cancelled. The Tribunal records the Applicant as saying she would not and that there was no hardship. The Tribunal also asked the Applicant whether there was any impediment to the Applicant recommencing studies in India, to which the Applicant replied she already held a degree from a tertiary institution in India;(j)at [14]-[15] the Tribunal put to the Applicant that given she had ceased studying in July 2017, and had made no attempt to re-enrol in a registered course since that time, that the Applicant may not have the will or desire to successfully undertake an education course in Australia. The Applicant indicated she did wish to study and would apply for another visa; (k)At [15], the Tribunal noted that even if the Applicant’s visa had not been cancelled, it would have expired in August 2018 and that therefore it appears that the only utility of the proceedings before the Tribunal is that, if the visa remains cancelled, she will be subject to a three year ban on applying for a further visa, whereas if she is successful, she will be able to apply for another visa to study in Australia;(l)at [16] the Tribunal noted that the Applicant indicated that her visa was cancelled on 18 June 2018 and that it does not appear that she holds any visa and that she therefore appears to be an unlawful non-citizen;(m)at [17] the Tribunal found that the Applicant does not have the will or desire to successfully undertake an education course in Australia;(n)at [18], the Tribunal recorded it was willing to accept that the Applicant was facing some minor medical condition in 2017 and was willing to accept, without documentary evidence, that her grandfather passed away in March 2017. The Tribunal considered, however, that those matters did not provide sufficient reason to explain why the Applicant has failed to enrol in any course in Australia since mid-2017. The Tribunal recorded that the Applicant was granted a visa for the purpose of studying in Australia, and yet she had ceased to study for over a year;(o)at [20], the Tribunal indicated it was willing to accept that while the Applicant and her family members will not suffer any hardship, the Applicant’s family in India will feel some disappointment and be upset that the Applicant’s visa was cancelled. The Tribunal also stated it had considered that if the Applicant’s visa remains cancelled, she will be prevented from successfully applying for another visa in Australia for a period of three years;(p)at [21] the Tribunal considered that a decision to affirm the cancellation decision in relation to the Applicant’s visa may well mean that the Applicant’s husband may also be unsuccessful in his review application before the Tribunal. The Tribunal found, however, that the Applicant’s lack of will and desire to successfully undertake a higher education course in Australia heavily outweighs any hardship she, her husband, or any family members may face because of the cancellation of the visa; and(q)at [22]-[23] the Tribunal concluded that the Applicant’s visa should be cancelled, and the decision of the delegate should be affirmed.APPLICABLE LAW

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In written and oral submissions before me, the Applicant submitted, inter alia, that she had encountered financial hardships which rendered her unable to pay university fees on time, which she has since rectified. She contended that she had not been given a chance by the Tribunal to explain why she could not pay her fees, and that her inability to pay her fees was not intentional. She said the Tribunal had overlooked her health issues, and not considered her circumstances. She submitted that she had always complied with visa conditions, had always been truthful, and had a one-year-old child that was affected by any decision. She also stated that she took issue with the finding of the Tribunal at paragraph [17] of its Reasons that she ‘did not have the will or desire to successfully undertaken [sic] an education course in Australia’.CONSIDERATION It is clear from the evidence before the Tribunal, and its Reasons, that it correctly identified the issue before it. The Applicant had conceded she had not been enrolled in a registered course. Accordingly, the issue was whether the Tribunal should exercise its discretion to cancel the visa under section 116 of the Act. The Tribunal correctly identified at [7] that there were no matters in the Act or the Regulations that were required to be considered in relation to the exercise of the discretion. It is apparent from the Reasons of the Tribunal that the Applicant raised a number of matters going to why the Tribunal should exercise its discretion to not cancel the visa. These included, minor medical issues that she faced, the death of her grandfather and ‘family disturbances’ in India relating to property distribution following the passing of her grandfather. It is important to note that the Tribunal accepted the Applicant had minor medical issues and that the Applicant’s grandfather had passed away, even though it had no documentary evidence to corroborate those claims. The Tribunal resolved both of those matters in favour of the Applicant. It clearly considered them and weighed them in deciding whether to exercise its discretion. The other matter raised by the Applicant was her wish to take 3–4 months off before recommencing her studies. Again, it is plain from the Tribunal’s Reasons at [12] that the Tribunal took this into account but was concerned that even allowing for that, she had not, by October 2018, recommenced study. Before me, the Applicant submitted that the Tribunal had not had regard to various matters contained in the Procedures Advice Manual. As I have indicated, there is nothing in the Act or the Regulations that requires the Tribunal to take account of the Procedures Advice Manual. Further, and additionally, however, I note that the Tribunal said it had regard to the Procedures Advice Manual (at [7] of the Reasons) and it is apparent from the Reasons that it did so. For example, the Applicant was asked whether she would suffer any hardship if the visa was cancelled. The Applicant did not identify any hardship. Notwithstanding that, the Tribunal clearly weighed and considered as part of its decision making the fact that family members of the Applicant and her husband in India would feel some disappointment and be upset if the visa was cancelled and the Applicant was prevented from successfully completing her course. It is plain the Tribunal also considered the purpose of the visa holders travel and stay in Australia, and the effect of the cancellation on the Applicant’s husband.