Business Finance Pty Ltd v Casula Projects Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Business Finance Pty Ltd v Casula Projects Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] NSWSC 1608
Hearing dates: On the papers; final submission 8 November 2022
Date of orders: 24 November 2022
Decision date: 24 November 2022
Jurisdiction:Equity - Expedition List
Before: Parker J
Decision:

See [42]

Catchwords:

COSTS – equitable remedies – mortgage wrongfully discharged – plaintiff obtains order to defendant to re-register new mortgage in the same form – plaintiff unsuccessful on some quantum issues – no judgment for mortgage debt necessary – quantum issues not “clearly dominant or severable” – costs of proceedings awarded to plaintiff

COSTS – indemnity costs – contractual entitlement to costs – mortgage wrongfully discharged – order to defendant to re-register new mortgage in the same form – costs of obtaining order not costs incurred under original mortgage – indemnity costs claim not pleaded – costs awarded on ordinary basis

Legislation Cited:

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r 42.25

Cases Cited:

Akierman Holdings Pty Limited v Akerman (No 3); In the matter of Akierman Holdings Pty Limited (No 2) [2021] NSWSC 869

Business Finance Pty Ltd v Casula Projects Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 1156

Dimos v Willetts (2000) 2 VR 170

Kyabram Property Investments Pty Limited v Murray [2005] NSWCA 87

Overton Investments Pty Ltd v Cuzeno RVM Pty Ltd [2003] NSWCA 27

Southern Oil Refining Pty Ltd v Hydrodec Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] NSWSC 336

Trentelman v The Owners - Strata Plan 76700 (No 3); The Owners - Strata Plan 76700 v Trentelman (No 3) [2021] NSWSC 578

Category:Costs
Parties: Business Finance Pty Limited (Receiver and Manager appointed) (First Plaintiff)
Marcus William Ayres in his capacity as Receiver and Manager of Business Finance Pty Limited (Receiver and Manager appointed) (Second Plaintiff)
Casula Projects Pty Limited (Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
S Ipp/A Girgis (Plaintiffs)
D Barlin (Defendant)

Solicitors:
Corrs Chambers Westgarth (Plaintiffs)
Pointon Partners Lawyers (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2021/60376
Publication restriction: Nil

Judgment

  1. The trial in this matter took place over five days between 22 and 29 August. At the end of the argument on 29 August, I delivered ex tempore reasons. The proceedings were adjourned to allow the parties to agree on orders giving effect to my judgment. Following further argument, those orders were made on 14 September. Those orders disposed of the proceedings, except the question of costs, which the parties agreed should be dealt with on the papers. That question is the subject of this judgment.

  2. On 14 September I issued a formal judgment which had been revised from the transcript of 29 August and also included the final orders made on that date: Business Finance Pty Ltd v Casula Projects Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 1156. This judgment assumes familiarity with that one, the paragraphs of which are referred to in this judgment as “J1”.

Background, procedural history and decision

  1. The first plaintiff (“BF”) formerly held a registered mortgage over a townhouse owned by the defendant (“CPPL”) at Surfers…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Business Finance Pty Ltd v Casula Projects Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 1608
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Business Finance Pty Ltd v Casula Projects Pty Ltd (No 2), the plaintiff sought to recover costs from the defendant after a successful application for an order requiring the defendant to re-register a new mortgage in the same form as one that had been wrongfully discharged. The court was asked to consider whether the plaintiff was entitled to indemnity costs for the proceedings, given their contractual right to recover costs, and whether the costs incurred in obtaining the order to re-register the new mortgage should be considered as costs incurred under the original mortgage. The court found that while the plaintiff was entitled to an order to re-register the mortgage, they were not entitled to indemnity costs because the costs were not incurred under the original mortgage, and indemnity costs were not pleaded. The court awarded costs on an ordinary basis.

The legal issues before the court included whether the plaintiff was entitled to indemnity costs for the proceedings and whether the costs of obtaining the order to re-register the new mortgage should be considered as costs incurred under the original mortgage. The court had to determine if the quantum issues were "clearly dominant or severable" from the main issue of the wrongful discharge of the mortgage, and if a separate judgment for the mortgage debt was necessary. The court also needed to consider the contractual entitlement to costs and whether indemnity costs could be claimed.

The court found that the plaintiff was entitled to an order to re-register the new mortgage but was not entitled to indemnity costs because the costs were not incurred under the original mortgage, and indemnity costs were not pleaded. The court held that the quantum issues were not "clearly dominant or severable" from the main issue of the wrongful discharge of the mortgage, and a separate judgment for the mortgage debt was not necessary. The court awarded costs on an ordinary basis, as the contractual entitlement to costs did not automatically entitle the plaintiff to indemnity costs. The court concluded that the costs of obtaining the order to re-register the new mortgage were not costs incurred under the original mortgage and that indemnity costs were not pleaded.

The final orders of the court included an order for the defendant to re-register the new mortgage in the same form as the one that had been wrongfully discharged, and an order that the plaintiff was entitled to costs of the proceedings on an ordinary basis. The court did not award indemnity costs as the plaintiff had not pleaded indemnity costs and the costs were not incurred under the original mortgage. The court did not make a separate judgment for the mortgage debt as the quantum issues were not "clearly dominant or severable" from the main issue of the wrongful discharge of the mortgage.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case revolves around a dispute concerning a mortgage and its wrongful discharge. Business Finance Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) had a mortgage registered over certain properties owned by Casula Projects Pty Ltd (the defendant). The mortgage was wrongfully discharged by the defendant, leading the plaintiff to seek an order for the re-registration of a new mortgage in the same form. The plaintiff was successful in obtaining this order but faced challenges in determining the quantum of costs. The case did not require a judgment for the mortgage debt, and the quantum issues were not deemed clearly dominant or severable.

The plaintiff argued that the costs incurred in obtaining the order for re-registration of the mortgage were not costs incurred under the original mortgage, thus the contractual entitlement to costs did not apply. The defendant argued against the indemnity costs claim, stating that it was not pleaded. The court had to determine the appropriate basis for awarding costs of the proceedings.

The matter came before the court following an unsuccessful application by the plaintiff to have the costs of the proceedings awarded on an indemnity basis. The plaintiff had previously obtained an order for the re-registration of a new mortgage in the same form as the wrongfully discharged one. The court was required to decide on the appropriate basis for awarding the costs of the proceedings, considering the unsuccessful quantum issues faced by the plaintiff.

The court had to assess the contractual entitlement to costs under the original mortgage and whether the indemnity costs claim was valid. The plaintiff's claim for indemnity costs was based on the argument that the costs incurred were not those incurred under the original mortgage, while the defendant argued that the indemnity costs claim was not pleaded. The case involved determining the appropriate basis for awarding costs in light of these arguments.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the costs of the proceedings should be awarded to the plaintiff on an indemnity basis.
2. Whether the contractual entitlement to costs applies to the costs incurred in obtaining the order for re-registration of the mortgage.
3. Whether the indemnity costs claim was properly pleaded and should be considered by the court.

Held
1. The court awarded the costs of the proceedings to the plaintiff on an indemnity basis. The plaintiff was successful in obtaining an order compelling the defendant to re-register a new mortgage in the same form as the original, wrongfully discharged mortgage. The plaintiff's unsuccessful arguments on some quantum issues did not render the quantum issues "clearly dominant or severable" from the successful claims.
2. The contractual entitlement to costs did not apply to the costs incurred in obtaining the order for re-registration of the mortgage. The court determined that the costs of obtaining the order for re-registration were not costs incurred under the original mortgage but were instead costs related to the equitable remedy of compelling the defendant to re-register the new mortgage.
3. The indemnity costs claim was not properly pleaded and, therefore, should not be considered by the court. The court found that the indemnity costs claim was not adequately pleaded and, as a result, the plaintiff was not entitled to indemnity costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's decision to award costs on an indemnity basis was based on the plaintiff's overall success in obtaining the primary relief sought, which was the re-registration of the mortgage. The court considered that while the plaintiff was not successful on all quantum issues, these issues were not "clearly dominant or severable" from the successful claims, and therefore, the costs should be awarded to the plaintiff. The court's reasoning in awarding indemnity costs was grounded in the principle that a successful party should be compensated for the full extent of their costs when the other party has acted vexatiously, abusively, or otherwise unreasonably. However, the court held that the contractual entitlement to costs did not extend to the costs incurred in obtaining the order for re-registration, as these costs were related to the equitable remedy and not the original mortgage. The court further found that the indemnity costs claim was not properly pleaded, as it was not clear from the pleadings that the plaintiff was seeking indemnity costs. Consequently, the court did not consider the indemnity costs claim and awarded costs on the ordinary basis. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a successful party in an equitable action may be awarded indemnity costs if the opposing party has acted vexatiously or unreasonably, provided that the claim for indemnity costs is properly pleaded. However, the entitlement to costs under a contractual clause does not extend to costs incurred in obtaining equitable remedies such as an order for re-registration of a mortgage.