Bushcliff Pty Ltd v Redland Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

Brisbane  No 7235 of 1996

Before the Hon. Justice White

[Bushcliff Pty Ltd v. Redland Shire Council]

BETWEEN:

BUSHCLIFF PTY LTD
  (ACN 058 736 879)
  Applicant

AND:

REDLAND SHIRE COUNCIL
  Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WHITE J

Judgment delivered 31/08/1996
  Reasons for Judgment delivered 23/09/1996

CATCHWORDS: INTERLOCUTORY INJUNCTION - Judicial Review Act - Local Government determination to put amended strategic plan on public display - decision - serious question - natural justice - improper purpose.

Counsel:Mr M Hinson for the applicant

Mr W Cochrane for the respondent

Solicitors:Corrs Chambers Westgarth for the applicant

King & Company for the respondent

Hearing Date:   31 August 1996

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

Brisbane  No 7235 of 1996

[Bushcliff Pty Ltd v. Redland Shire Council]

BETWEEN:

BUSHCLIFF PTY LTD
  (ACN 058 736 879)
  Applicant

AND:

REDLAND SHIRE COUNCIL
  Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WHITE J

Judgment delivered 31/08/1996
  Reasons for Judgment delivered 23/09/1996

Bushcliff Pty Ltd has brought an application for judicial review of a decision by the Redland Shire Council ("the Council") to put on public display amendments to the Planning Scheme for the Shire which depict, inter alia a change in the designation of certain Council land adjacent to land owned by Bushcliff.  Bushcliff sought an urgent injunction on Saturday, 31 August 1996 to restrain the Council from placing the new draft Strategic Plan on public display on Monday, 2 September 1996 showing the subject land with a changed designation from that which appeared previously.  I refused to grant the injunction giving brief reasons and now give fuller reasons.
           By a contract bearing date 24 February 1994 Bushcliff purchased certain land from Lensworth Properties Pty Ltd exercising power of sale as mortgagee.  The registered proprietor of the land was Glenkoo Holdings Pty Ltd.  That land at Wellington Point was rezoned into the Comprehensive Development and Residential A zone to enable a canal residential subdivision to be developed in 1992 ("the development land").  A Development Agreement ("the Deed") was entered into between Glenkoo and the Council in respect of the development.  The development is described as the Wellington Harbour Canal Estate.  So far as is relevant to this application the Council agreed to transfer to Glenkoo certain Council land adjoining part of the Glenkoo land and zoned Rural Non-Urban and Unzoned to be incorporated in the residential allotment canal subdivision and be rezoned into the development zone.  No monetary compensation was contemplated by the agreement but Glenkoo was to carry out development works which have been estimated to be valued at $1.4 million.  The State Department of the Environment gave approval for canals in the development which approval has been extended from time to time, is current and has been extended to Bushcliff.  At the time when Glenkoo's mortgagee sold the land to Bushcliff the Council land had not been transferred to Glenkoo.  The contract between the mortgagee and Bushcliff provided that Bushcliff would enter into a deed of novation of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bushcliff Pty Ltd v Redland Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] QSC 169
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bushcliff Pty Ltd has sought judicial review of a decision by the Redland Shire Council ("the Council") to amend its draft Strategic Plan to change the designation of certain Council land from "marine oriented development" to "open space." Bushcliff purchased land in Wellington Point from Lensworth Properties Pty Ltd in February 1994. Glenkoo Holdings Pty Ltd was the registered proprietor of the land. The land was rezoned into the Comprehensive Development and Residential A zone to enable a canal residential subdivision to be developed in 1992 ("the development land"). Glenkoo entered into a Development Agreement with the Council to develop the land. The Council agreed to transfer to Glenkoo certain land adjoining part of the Glenkoo land and zoned Rural Non-Urban and Unzoned to be incorporated in the residential allotment canal subdivision and be rezoned into the development zone. Glenkoo was to carry out development works valued at $1.4 million. The State Department of the Environment gave approval for canals in the development which approval has been extended from time to time, is current and has been extended to Bushcliff. At the time when Glenkoo's mortgagee sold the land to Bushcliff the Council land had not been transferred to Glenkoo. Bushcliff engaged in extensive discussions with the Council and other authorities in respect of the development conditions and necessary approvals to proceed with the development. On 6 August 1996 a draft Strategic Plan was presented to the Environment Planning and Development Committee of the Council. The Committee recommended that the draft Strategic Plan be adopted by the Council for the purpose of statutory public exhibition. On 20 August 1996 the Council considered the Wellington Harbour Canal Estate. The Council reaffirmed its decision of 22 November 1995 to retain the Council land and resolved that it no longer favoured the establishment of a residential canal estate in the area using Council owned land. Bushcliff has two grounds for review. The first, that the Council failed to accord it natural justice in that it did not "properly advise" Bushcliff of its intention to change the designation of the land from "marine oriented development" to "open space" and afford Bushcliff an opportunity to be heard in relation to the making of the decision. Bushcliff further complains that the decision to place the draft Strategic Plan on public display showing the changed designation was an improper exercise of its power in that it failed adequately to consider the dispute and negotiations existing between Bushcliff and the Council, the validity of the Deed, and the Council's obligations with respect to the land. Bushcliff contends that the Council exercised the power of redesignating the land for a purpose other than a proper purpose. In my view those interests would attract the principles of natural justice. The statutory scheme enables submissions to be made by members of the public including Bushcliff and to have those submissions considered before the proposal is placed before the Governor-in- Council to amend the planning scheme. Bushcliff submits that that is insufficient given the damage which it asserts may be done to it if the preferred designation of the Council for the Council land goes to public display. If that is accepted and there was an obligation upon the Council to hear Bushcliff then Bushcliff faces some difficulties. It has already conferred with and made submissions to the Council's officers in respect of its entitlement to the Council land. The Council meeting, as the minutes reveal, had a detailed presentation of Bushcliff's arguments in favour of the Deed including a precis of counsel's opinion on the legal issues. I am not persuaded that the ground based on natural justice has any substance. Bushcliff has submitted that by redesignating the Council land the Council has in effect pre-empted the outcome of the dispute over the Deed and has thus utilised its planning powers for an improper purpose. The redesignation of the land was based on proper planning principles and the Council had a public duty to carry out those planning principles. There is no direct evidence of an improper purpose on the part of the Council in redesignating the land. The Council officer's recommendation to the Council that from a planning perspective additional material had not been presented which could give rise to a change of recommendation to that which led to the original planning approval might be regarded as evidence from which the inference of ulterior motive might be drawn. The material as it presently stands does not persuade me that it is likely to be resolved in favour of Bushcliff but I am of the view that there is a serious question to be tried about this matter. The orders made were: 1. Refuse the application for injunction. 2. Adjourn the further hearing of the application for judicial review to a date to be fixed. 3. Costs were reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bushcliff Pty Ltd purchased land from Lensworth Properties Pty Ltd in 1994, which was part of a larger development plan known as the Wellington Harbour Canal Estate. This development involved a canal residential subdivision and required the rezoning of certain land owned by the Redland Shire Council ("the Council"). The original agreement, known as the Deed, between Glenkoo Holdings Pty Ltd and the Council stipulated that certain Council land would be transferred and rezoned to support the development. However, at the time of Bushcliff's purchase, this land had not been transferred. The contract between the mortgagee and Bushcliff included a provision for a deed of novation of the Deed with the Council, which was not executed. Bushcliff engaged in discussions with the Council about the development conditions and necessary approvals. In November 1995, the Council received legal advice indicating it was not obligated by the Deed to exchange lands. Subsequently, the Council decided not to exchange the land, considering it not beneficial to the community. In August 1996, the Council presented a draft Strategic Plan for public exhibition, which included a redesignation of the Council land from "marine oriented development" to "open space", affecting Bushcliff's development plans.

Bushcliff applied for an urgent interlocutory injunction to restrain the Council from placing the new draft Strategic Plan on public display, which depicted the subject land with a changed designation. The application was heard on 31 August 1996. The court refused to grant the injunction, providing reasons for the decision on 23 September 1996. The matter was set for further hearing on the application for judicial review, with costs reserved.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Council's decision to redesignate the land and place it on public display constitutes a reviewable decision.
2. Whether the Council failed to accord Bushcliff natural justice by not properly advising it of its intention to change the designation of the land and afford Bushcliff an opportunity to be heard.
3. Whether the Council exercised its power for an improper purpose by redesignating the land without adequately considering the dispute and negotiations with Bushcliff, the validity of the Deed, and the Council's obligations with respect to the land.

Held
1. The court held that the Council's decision to redesignate the land and place it on public display constitutes a reviewable decision under the Judicial Review Act.
2. The court held that the Council did not fail to accord Bushcliff natural justice by not properly advising it of its intention to change the designation of the land and afford Bushcliff an opportunity to be heard.
3. The court held that there is a serious question to be tried whether the Council exercised its power for an improper purpose by redesignating the land without adequately considering the dispute and negotiations with Bushcliff, the validity of the Deed, and the Council's obligations with respect to the land. However, the balance of convenience did not favour granting an injunction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the procedure for amending a planning scheme under the Local Government (Planning and Environment) Act 1990, concluding that the Council's decision to redesignate the land and put it on public display was a reviewable decision. The court rejected Bushcliff's argument that it was denied natural justice, noting that the statutory scheme allowed for public submissions and consideration before the proposal was placed before the Governor-in-Council. The court found that the Council's decision to redesignate the land as open space was based on proper planning principles and there was no direct evidence of an improper purpose. However, the court recognised that there was a serious question to be tried whether the Council had adequately considered the dispute and negotiations with Bushcliff, the validity of the Deed, and the Council's obligations with respect to the land. The court determined that while the balance of convenience did not favour an injunction, Bushcliff could make submissions to the Council and seek to influence others who support its position. The court's decision recognised the importance of proper planning principles and the need for public participation in the planning process, while also considering the potential impact on private parties with interests in the land.