Burton v Referee, Small Claims Tribunal, Gympie

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

No.788 of 1994

Brisbane

Before the Hon. Mr Justice Mackenzie

[Burton v. Referee, Small Claims Tribunal, Gympie]

BETWEEN:
  DOUGLAS JEFFREY BURTON
  Applicant

AND:
  REFEREE, SMALL CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, GYMPIE
  First Respondent

AND:
  GYMPIE BUILDING COMPANY PTY LTD
  Second Respondent

CATCHWORDS:  JUDICIAL REVIEW - natural justice - procedural fairness - decision of SCT in respect of award for building works - whether breach of hearing rule - right of tribunal to regulate proceedings - party not allowed to put case in precise order or detail party wishes - whether bias evident from degree of reduction of applicant’s claim and acceptance of respondent’s estimate over applicant’s - whether order was fair and equitable in the circumstances:  Referee enquired about the monetary difference in assessing the claim on a cost or value basis, estimate given by respondent only which was not mechanically applied to achieve the sum awarded.

Counsel:Applicant appeared on his own behalf.

Ms J.E. Sligo for the first respondent.
Second respondent appeared by its Managing Director Mr P.J. Lohse.

Solicitors:Applicant appeared on his own behalf.

Crown Solicitor for the first respondent.  
Second respondent appeared by its Managing Director.

Hearing date:          4 December 1997

JUDGMENT - MACKENZIE J.

Judgment delivered 10 December 1997

The applicant has applied for review of a decision of the Small Claims Tribunal, Gympie on 24 October 1994 in which he was awarded $100 in respect of his claim and $57 costs against the respondent company which had built a lavatory for him at business premises in Gympie. The contract was completed in late 1987 but the claim was not instituted until 11 September 1994. The application for review was filed on 17 November 1994 but remained quiescent, following dismissal by Fryberg J of an application under s.48 of the Judicial Review Act on 6 January 1995, until September 1997, apparently because the applicant was preoccupied with other things including sale of the premises as an adjunct to which the lavatory had been constructed.  The applicant volunteered that the sale of the premises had recently occurred, and said that the lavatory had not been repaired prior to the sale. 

The applicant argued the matter in person.  The respondent Gympie Building Company was represented by its managing director Mr Lohse.  The Referee indicated through a solicitor from the Crown Law Office that he would abide the order of the court and leave was given to the legal representative to withdraw on that basis with the right being reserved to make submissions as to costs.  Because of these factors some latitude was extended to the parties in the way submissions were presented. 

The invoice as presented to the applicant included an item “to construct D/Toilet Block as quoted”.  The quotation referred to constructing a “double toilet block 3 metres x 2 metres with concrete floor 100 millimetres thick and coved concrete upstands under partitions, walls to be sheeted with 4.5 millimetre thick hardiflex”.  A substantial issue before the Referee was the meaning…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burton v Referee, Small Claims Tribunal, Gympie and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QSC 226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Douglas Jeffrey Burton, sought judicial review of a decision made by the Small Claims Tribunal, Gympie, in which he was awarded $100 for his claim against Gympie Building Company Pty Ltd, with an additional $57 in costs. The claim related to the construction of a lavatory at the applicant’s business premises in Gympie, which was completed in late 1987. The applicant filed the claim on 11 September 1994 and the tribunal’s decision was made on 24 October 1994. Burton argued that the tribunal breached natural justice and procedural fairness by limiting his opportunity to present his case, showing bias in favour of the respondent, and basing the decision on proven damages evidence. He further argued that the tribunal erred in law by making an award on a cost basis instead of a value basis and that there was an error of fact in the difference in price between the two construction methods.

The court examined whether the applicant was denied procedural fairness by the tribunal’s regulation of proceedings and whether there was evidence of bias. It was noted that the right to put one’s case and the right of a tribunal to regulate proceedings coexist. The court held that the tribunal did not improperly inhibit the applicant’s right to present his case, as it had given him the opportunity to put the essence of his case sufficiently. The court found no evidence of ostensible partisanship, personal prejudice, or pre-judgment on the part of the tribunal. The referee’s decision to accept the respondent’s estimate over the applicant’s submission did not suggest bias, as it is common for evidence or submissions of one party to be accepted over the other without suggesting bias. The court also found that the referee did not mechanically apply the respondent’s estimate to the award made and had considered the matter on the basis of a fair and equitable order.

The court dismissed the application for judicial review, holding that the referee had not breached natural justice or procedural fairness, shown bias, or erred in law or fact. The referee’s decision to award $100 for the claim and $57 in costs was considered fair and equitable in the circumstances. The court also noted that the referee had enquired about the difference in costs between the two methods of construction, which may have been a baseline for determining a fair and equitable order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.