BURTON v POLICE
[2000] SASC 174
Magistrates Appeal: Criminal
MULLIGHAN J This is an appeal against sentences imposed by a learned Magistrate sitting in the Magistrates Court at Elizabeth on 23rd March 2000 for various offences which sentences together amounted to a total head sentence of three years and three months with a non-parole period of two years to commence on 16th January 2000.
The offences occurred over a period of ten months. I mention them and the dates upon which they were committed: being unlawfully on premises, driving without a licence, driving a motor vehicle with headlamps and a rear lamp not alight, and failure to truly answer questions (6th December 1998), breaking, entering and committing an offence (18th February 1999), driving a motor vehicle whilst disqualified from holding or obtaining a licence to drive a motor vehicle (“drive disqualified”) and driving an unregistered motor vehicle (“drive unregistered”) (1st May 1999), drive disqualified (2nd July 1999), drive disqualified, drive unregistered, driving an uninsured motor vehicle (“drive uninsured”) (15th September1999), unlawful possession, drive disqualified, drive unregistered, drive uninsured (23rd September 1999), drive disqualified, drive unregistered, drive uninsured and driving a motor vehicle contrary to a defect notice and removing a defect notice (29th September 1999).
He pleaded guilty to all but the offences committed on 23rd September 1999 before another Magistrate on 12th January 2000 who remanded the appellant to 10th March 2000 and ordered a pre-sentence report and a psychiatric report. On 10th March 2000 the appellant also pleaded guilty to the offences committed on 23rd September 1999.
The appellant is aged 21 years. He has a long record of prior offending commencing in 1992 when a child. His past offences include larceny, throwing a missile to cause injury or damage, using offensive language, building breaking and felony, resist police, illegal interference with a motor vehicle, possessing a controlled substance, being unlawfully on premises, driving without a licence, driving unregistered, being in breach of a bond, giving a false name and address, receiving, loitering, possessing equipment to administer a nominated substance and common assault. All of these offences were committed whilst the appellant was a child and were dealt with in the Youth Court, as it is now known. On occasions he was discharged without penalty, with or without conviction, but on many occasions he was convicted and fines were imposed or he was required to enter into bonds. When aged 16 years he was again convicted of building breaking and felony and the antecedent report shows that he was sentenced to imprisonment for five months which, I assume, was not imprisonment but detention. At about the same time he was convicted of receiving and found to be in breach of a bond. The record shows that he was sentenced to imprisonment for two months which, I also assume, was detention. On 17th June 1996 he was convicted of a drink driving offence and driving without a licence and fined. He attained the age of 18 years on 23rd…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Burton v Police No. Scgrg-00-341 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 174
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the sentences imposed by the Magistrate were manifestly excessive and whether the Magistrate erred in applying sentencing standards. The court was also required to consider whether the Magistrate had made factual errors regarding the appellant's criminal history and whether the sentences for driving while disqualified were excessive.
The court found that the Magistrate had not correctly applied sentencing standards for the offence of breaking, entering, and committing an offence, and had made factual errors about the appellant's criminal history. The court determined that the sentence of two years was manifestly excessive. Furthermore, the sentences for the offences of driving while disqualified were deemed manifestly excessive, violating the principle of totality. The court also noted an error in not backdating the sentence and non-parole period to the date the appellant was arrested for the driving offences.
The court allowed the appeal, setting aside the convictions for the driving while disqualified offences and the sentences for those offences. The case was remitted to the Magistrates Court for rehearing. The information alleging the offence of breaking, entering, and committing an offence was also remitted to the Magistrates Court for the purpose of imposing sentence.
Background
Background to the litigation
This is an appeal against sentences imposed by a learned Magistrate sitting in the Magistrates Court at Elizabeth on 23rd March 2000. The appellant pleaded guilty to all charges except the offences committed on 23rd September 1999, which were also pleaded guilty to on 10th March 2000. The appeal was heard by Muliggan J in the Supreme Court of South Australia.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the sentence imposed for the offence of breaking, entering and committing an offence was manifestly excessive.
2. Whether the sentences for the offences of driving while disqualified were manifestly excessive.
3. Whether the sentence and non-parole period should have been backdated to the date the appellant was arrested and refused bail on the charges of driving while disqualified.
Held
1. The sentence imposed for the offence of breaking, entering and committing an offence was manifestly excessive.
2. The sentences for the offences of driving while disqualified were manifestly excessive.
3. The sentence and non-parole period should have been backdated to the date the appellant was arrested and refused bail on the charges of driving while disqualified.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MULLIGHAN J
The appeal was heard by Mulligan J, who found that the sentence imposed for the offence of breaking, entering and committing an offence was manifestly excessive. The learned Magistrate had not correctly applied the sentencing standards established by King CJ in The Queen v Halse (1985) 38 SASR 594, which suggested a sentence in the region of twelve to eighteen months for a single offence committed by a previously imprisoned offender where there has been a plea of guilty and the value of property taken is small. The court concluded that the sentence of two years was manifestly excessive, and it declined to fix a new sentence or to express further opinion on the matter.
The court also found the sentences for the offences of driving while disqualified to be manifestly excessive. The court noted that a total sentence of twelve months for these offences offended the totality principle, as the appellant was a young man and such a heavy sentence required intervention. The court considered that the learned Magistrate, the police prosecutor, and the appellant's counsel were not aware of the new prosecution policy, which would have provided an opportunity for the appellant to have the charges withdrawn and be dealt with regarding outstanding fines under the new regime.
Lastly, the court found that the sentence and non-parole period should have been backdated to the date the appellant was arrested and refused bail on the charges of driving while disqualified. Mulligan J noted that the appellant was in custody on remand with respect to the drive disqualified charges and the sentence should have been backdated to 13th December 1999, in accordance with the decision in Tong v Police (1998) 198 LSJS 398. Mulligan J allowed the appeal, set aside the convictions on the charges of driving while disqualified and the sentences for those offences and for the offence of breaking, entering and committing an offence, and remitted the complaints to the Magistrates Court for rehearing.