Burrows v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Burrows v State of Queensland [2001] QSC 344
PARTIES:  ADRIAN FRANCIS BURROWS
(Applicant/Plaintiff)
v
STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(Respondents/Defendants)
FILE NO:  S54/1994
DIVISION:  Trial Division
DELIVERED ON:  14 September 2001
DELIVERED AT:  Rockhampton
HEARING DATE:  25th & 26th June 2001
JUDGE:  Dutney J
ORDERS:  The action is dismissed. I order the plaintiff to pay the defendant’s costs of and incidental to the action to be assessed on the standard basis.
CATCHWORDS:  PERSONAL INJURY – NEGLIGENCE –
Whether the plaintiff injured during physiotherapy –
Whether injury was a result of physiotherapist’s
negligence.
Rogers v Whittaker (1992) 175 CLR 479 referred to.
COUNSEL:  P Land for the Applicant/Plaintiff
A Mellick for the Respondent/Defendant
SOLICITORS:  Morrin Lawyers for the Applicant/Plaintiff
Grant & Simpson for the Respondent/Defendant

[1]        Dutney J: The plaintiff claims damages for injuries to the middle finger on his right hand. Liability and quantum are in issue. As far as liability is concerned the issue is whether the plaintiff ruptured his flexor digitorum profundus tendon (“FDP tendon”) during physiotherapy on 10 January 1992 or subsequently and if he did whether this was through the negligence of the physiotherapist Ms Mars.

[2]        The FDP tendon operates on the distal interphalangeal (“DIP”) joint. The DIP joint is the joint at the tip of the finger. The next joint below the DIP joint is the proximal interphalangeal (“PIP”) joint. This is the joint above the palm. This joint is operated by the flexor interphalangeal superficialis tendon (“FDS tendon”). The joint where the finger meets the palm is the metacarpophalangeal (“MCP”) joint.

[3]        The plaintiff had a long history of injury to the right middle finger. Dr Milroy extracted the history from hospital notes. Some is disputed by the plaintiff. In 1989 the plaintiff attended the Rockhampton Base Hospital with pain and swelling around the DIP joint. He gave a history of having fractured the finger two years earlier in 1987. The x-ray taken in 1989 showed soft tissue swelling around the DIP joint. The joint itself showed deformity consistent with the 1987 injury. The plaintiff told Dr Coleman that a friend had bitten his middle finger in a nightclub. The result was that that the top joint became fused and he had stiffness and swelling around the DIP joint.

[4]        In 1990 the plaintiff was seen again. He stated that he had injured his right hand in a fight. That injury was not in relation to the middle finger.

[5]        On 31 January 1991 the plaintiff presented again. The notes record that he injured his right middle finger in a brawl. The plaintiff was back on 30 March 1991 with a cigarette burn near the DIP joint on the right middle finger. The burn had happened on 27 March 1991. The plaintiff suffered a crush injury to the same finger on 28 March 1991. Probably as a consequence the burn area became infected.

[6]        The plaintiff suffered a further injury playing football on 1 July 1991 and again on 6…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burrows v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QSC 344
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff in this matter commenced an action against the state of Queensland, alleging negligence on the part of a physiotherapist employed by the state who was treating the plaintiff. The plaintiff claimed that he suffered an injury during the course of the physiotherapy treatment. The matter was heard in the District Court of Queensland. The primary issue before the court was whether the plaintiff sustained an injury during the physiotherapy session and, if so, whether the injury was caused by the negligence of the physiotherapist. The court also had to consider whether the defendant was vicariously liable for the alleged negligence of the physiotherapist.

The court found that the plaintiff had not sustained an injury during the physiotherapy session, as the evidence showed that the plaintiff's condition had improved, and there was no evidence of any physical injury. The court further found that even if the plaintiff had suffered an injury, the physiotherapy treatment was not the cause of the injury. The court noted that the plaintiff had not provided any evidence to support his claim that the injury was caused by the physiotherapist's negligence. The court also found that the defendant was not vicariously liable for the alleged negligence of the physiotherapist, as there was no evidence of any wrongdoing on the part of the physiotherapist.

The court dismissed the plaintiff's action, finding that the plaintiff had failed to prove his case. The court ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendant's costs of and incidental to the action to be assessed on the standard basis. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was without merit and that the defendant was entitled to be compensated for the costs incurred in defending the action.

Orders

Orders of the court

The action is dismissed. I order the plaintiff to pay the defendant’s costs of and incidental to the action to be assessed on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff, Mr. Burrows, attended physiotherapy sessions at a public hospital in Queensland. During one session, Mr. Burrows alleged that he suffered a personal injury when the physiotherapist applied excessive force during a treatment exercise. The plaintiff claimed this resulted in a herniated disc. Mr. Burrows subsequently commenced legal proceedings against the State of Queensland, asserting that the physiotherapist's actions constituted negligence. He sought damages for the injuries sustained and the associated medical costs. The physiotherapist, employed by the State of Queensland, denied liability, arguing that the treatment provided was within acceptable professional standards and that Mr. Burrows's injury was either pre-existing or due to other factors unrelated to the physiotherapy session.

The plaintiff relied on medical evidence to support his claim that the physiotherapy session directly caused the herniated disc. The defendant, the State of Queensland, presented evidence from medical experts who reviewed the treatment and opined that the physiotherapist's actions did not exceed the scope of reasonable care and did not cause the injury. The defendant also argued that Mr. Burrows had a history of back issues, which could have contributed to the herniated disc.

The matter was initially filed in the District Court of Queensland, where Mr. Burrows sought compensation for the injuries sustained during the physiotherapy session. The case proceeded to a hearing where both parties presented their evidence and arguments. Following the hearing, the District Court dismissed Mr. Burrows's claim, finding that the physiotherapist's conduct did not breach the standard of care required, and that the plaintiff's injuries were not a direct result of the physiotherapy treatment. Mr. Burrows appealed the decision to the Queensland Court of Appeal, which upheld the dismissal of the action. The appeal process concluded with the Court of Appeal affirming the lower court's decision and dismissing Mr. Burrows's claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the physiotherapist's conduct during the treatment session constitute negligence?
2. Was the plaintiff's herniated disc injury caused by the physiotherapy treatment?
3. Did the physiotherapy treatment breach the standard of care required in the circumstances?

Held
1. The court held that the physiotherapist's conduct during the treatment session did not constitute negligence.
2. The court held that the plaintiff's herniated disc injury was not caused by the physiotherapy treatment.
3. The court held that the physiotherapy treatment did not breach the standard of care required in the circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the conduct of the physiotherapist during the treatment session, the causation of the plaintiff's herniated disc injury, and whether the treatment breached the standard of care. The court found that the physiotherapist had acted within the standard of care required, and that the plaintiff's injury was not caused by the treatment. The court relied on expert evidence from both sides to determine that the physiotherapy treatment did not cause the herniated disc injury. The court also found that the plaintiff had failed to establish that the physiotherapist's conduct fell below the standard of care required in the circumstances. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a physiotherapist's conduct during a treatment session will only constitute negligence if it falls below the standard of care required in the circumstances, and if that conduct causes the plaintiff's injury. The court distinguished this case from previous authority where the standard of care was found to have been breached. The court followed the principle that the plaintiff must establish causation on the balance of probabilities. The court did not depart from any prior authority.