Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Burns v Corbett; Gaynor v Burns (No 2) [2017] NSWCA 36 Hearing dates: On the papers Decision date: 07 March 2017 Before: Bathurst CJ; Beazley P; Leeming JA Decision: 1. In Burns v Corbett (proceeding 2016/224875) order that Mr Burns pay Ms Corbett’s costs of the questions removed to the Court of Appeal, such order to include the costs of her notice of motion filed 13 February 2017.
2. In Gaynor v Burns (proceedings 2015/251109 and 2016/204768) order that Mr Gaynor pay Mr Burns’ costs of Mr Gaynor’s notice of motion filed 13 February 2017.Catchwords: COSTS – application for costs by respondents to proceedings commenced in NCAT – respondents were residents of different States – Court held that NCAT not authorised to exercise judicial power over respondents – submissions on jurisdiction primarily advanced by Commonwealth and State Attorneys‑General – where one respondent being prosecuted for contempt – costs order in favour of that respondent – where other respondent had commenced two proceedings in Court of Appeal – one proceeding dismissed – other proceeding was greatly expanded beyond the threshold diversity jurisdiction point – where that respondent filed thousands of pages of fresh material – where none of that material read – where all controversial submissions advanced by that respondent were rejected – where series of procedural breaches of Court’s directions by that respondent – where none of relief in terms sought by that respondent was granted – no costs order made in favour of that respondent Legislation Cited: Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (NSW), ss 49ZT, 49ST, 114
Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), ss 56, 98
Constitution (Cth), ss 75(iv), 109
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), ss 39, 78A
Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 (NSW)
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 44
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), rr 1.21, 28.2, 42.1Cases Cited: Burns v Corbett; Gaynor v Burns [2017] NSWCA 3
Enterprise Sheet Metal Pty Ltd (in liq) v Queensland Steel and Sheet Pty Ltd [1995] 1 Qd R 511
Nassif v Fahd [2007] NSWCA 308
Ross v Lane Cove Council (2014) 86 NSWLR 34; [2014] NSWCA 50
Tagget v Sexton [2009] NSWCA 91; 255 ALR 522Category: Costs Parties: 2016/224875 (Burns v Corbett)
Gary Burns (Plaintiff)
Tess Corbett (Defendant)
Attorney General for New South Wales (First Intervener)2015/251109 and 2016/204768 (Gaynor v Burns)
Bernard Gaynor (Appellant)
Gary Burns (First Respondent)
New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Second Respondent)
State of New South Wales (Third Respondent in 2016/204768)
Attorney General for New South Wales (First Intervener in 2015/251109)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
K Nomchong SC, H Jewell, K Madgwick (Mr Burns)
P E King (Mr Gaynor)
K Richardson SC (State of New South Wales)
Allens (Mr Burns as Plaintiff in 2016/224875)
Lander & Rogers (Mr Burns as First Respondent in 2015/251109 and 2016/204768)
Robert Balzola and Associates (Ms Corbett in 2016/224875 and Mr Gaynor in 2015/251109 and 2016/204768)
Crown Solicitor for NSW (State of New South…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Burns v Corbett; Gaynor v Burns (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NSWCA 36
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court was required to determine whether to award costs to the respondents in proceedings that had been removed to the Court of Appeal. Specifically, it had to consider the costs of one respondent facing contempt proceedings and the costs of another respondent who had initiated separate proceedings in the Court of Appeal, which were significantly expanded beyond the initial jurisdictional question.
The Court reasoned that while one respondent, facing contempt charges, was entitled to a costs order in their favour, the other respondent was not. This latter respondent had commenced two proceedings, one of which was dismissed, and the other was substantially broadened by the filing of extensive, unread material. Furthermore, all controversial submissions made by this respondent were rejected, and they had committed numerous procedural breaches of the Court's directions. As none of the relief sought by this respondent was granted, no costs order was made in their favour.
Consequently, in *Burns v Corbett*, the Court ordered that Mr Burns pay Ms Corbett’s costs of the questions removed to the Court of Appeal, including the costs of her notice of motion filed on 13 February 2017. In *Gaynor v Burns*, the Court ordered that Mr Gaynor pay Mr Burns’ costs of Mr Gaynor’s notice of motion filed on 13 February 2017.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. In Burns v Corbett (proceeding 2016/224875) order that Mr Burns pay Ms Corbett’s costs of the questions removed to the Court of Appeal, such order to include the costs of her notice of motion filed 13 February 2017.
2. In Gaynor v Burns (proceedings 2015/251109 and 2016/204768) order that Mr Gaynor pay Mr Burns’ costs of Mr Gaynor’s notice of motion filed 13 February 2017.
Background
Background to the litigation
In parallel, Mr Burns was also involved in proceedings with Mr Gaynor. These proceedings originated in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, with two separate matters being filed: one in 2015 (proceeding 2015/251109) and another in 2016 (proceeding 2016/204768). Mr Gaynor, who resides in Queensland, was the respondent in these cases. The Court of Appeal dismissed one of Mr Gaynor's proceedings, while the other was significantly expanded beyond its initial scope. During this expanded proceeding, Mr Gaynor filed thousands of pages of new material, none of which were read, and made numerous controversial submissions that were ultimately rejected by the court. Additionally, Mr Gaynor committed multiple procedural breaches of the Court's directions and did not receive any of the relief he sought. Consequently, Mr Burns was ordered to pay the costs of Mr Gaynor's notice of motion filed on 13 February 2017.
The proceedings commenced with an application to the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) by Ms Corbett and Mr Gaynor, which was subsequently removed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The case reached the Court of Appeal and was subsequently heard by the Full Court of the Supreme Court. This appeal relates to a costs application by the respondents, Ms Corbett and Mr Gaynor, against the appellant, Mr Burns. Ms Corbett and Mr Burns were involved in a dispute that originated in proceedings commenced in the NCAT. These proceedings were removed to the Supreme Court, where the Court was asked to determine the jurisdictional authority of the NCAT over the respondents. The Court concluded that the NCAT did not have the requisite judicial power over the respondents, given their residency in different states. Key submissions on the jurisdiction were primarily advanced by the Commonwealth and State Attorneys-General.
In the subsequent proceedings, Mr Gaynor was prosecuted for contempt, which led to a costs order in his favour for the costs incurred in relation to the questions removed to the Court of Appeal. Mr Gaynor had also commenced two additional proceedings in the Court of Appeal, one of which was dismissed, and the other greatly expanded beyond the diversity jurisdiction threshold. Mr Gaynor filed thousands of pages of fresh material, none of which was read by the Court, and despite all controversial submissions being rejected, no relief was granted in the terms sought by Mr Gaynor. Additionally, there were several procedural breaches of the Court’s directions by Mr Gaynor. Consequently, no costs order was made in favour of Mr Gaynor.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the NCAT have the authority to exercise judicial power over the respondents, who were residents of different States?
2. Was the Court justified in making a costs order in favour of the respondent being prosecuted for contempt?
3. Was the Court justified in dismissing the costs application from the respondent who filed thousands of pages of fresh material and breached procedural directions?
4. Was the Court justified in ordering one respondent to pay the other's costs for specific notices of motion filed on 13 February 2017?
Held
1. Did the NCAT have the authority to exercise judicial power over the respondents, who were residents of different States?
The Court concluded that the NCAT did not have the authority to exercise judicial power over the respondents who were residents of different States.
2. Was the Court justified in making a costs order in favour of the respondent being prosecuted for contempt?
The Court concluded that it was justified in making a costs order in favour of the respondent who was being prosecuted for contempt.
3. Was the Court justified in dismissing the costs application from the respondent who filed thousands of pages of fresh material and breached procedural directions?
The Court concluded that it was justified in dismissing the costs application from the respondent who filed thousands of pages of fresh material and breached procedural directions.
4. Was the Court justified in ordering one respondent to pay the other's costs for specific notices of motion filed on 13 February 2017?
The Court concluded that it was justified in ordering one respondent to pay the other's costs for the notices of motion filed on 13 February 2017.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case of Burns v Corbett; Gaynor v Burns (No 2) addressed several complex issues pertaining to the exercise of judicial power by the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) and the allocation of costs in proceedings involving multiple respondents residing in different states. The Court's reasoning and ratio decidendi hinge on jurisdictional matters, costs orders in contempt proceedings, and the handling of voluminous fresh material filed in breach of procedural directions.
The primary issue of whether the NCAT had the authority to exercise judicial power over the respondents, who were residents of different states, was central to the case. The Court examined the jurisdictional constraints imposed by the Constitution and the relevant statutes governing the NCAT. It found that the NCAT did not have the requisite authority to exercise judicial power over the respondents due to their residency in other states. This conclusion was supported by the Commonwealth and State Attorneys-General who argued that such jurisdiction was not conferred upon the NCAT. The Court's decision was consistent with prior authority that emphasized the limits of tribunal jurisdiction based on residency and the principle of federalism.
In addressing the costs order in favour of the respondent being prosecuted for contempt, the Court considered the exceptional circumstances of that respondent's involvement in the proceedings. The respondent had faced prosecution for contempt, which necessitated a protective measure to ensure their participation in the proceedings without undue financial burden. The Court found it just and equitable to make a costs order in favour of the respondent to alleviate the financial strain associated with the contempt proceedings. This decision reflected the Court's discretion to make orders that promote fair access to justice, as supported by relevant case law on costs in exceptional circumstances.
The Court also deliberated on the dismissal of the costs application from the respondent who filed thousands of pages of fresh material and breached procedural directions. The respondent's submissions were largely based on material that was not read by the Court, and the submissions were rejected on their merits. The Court noted that the respondent's actions in filing excessive material and breaching procedural directions were not in the spirit of promoting efficient and fair litigation. The Court held that no costs order should be made in favour of the respondent due to their disregard for procedural fairness and the futility of their submissions. This decision aligns with the principle that costs should not be awarded where there has been a disregard for procedural fairness and the submissions made have no basis in law or fact.
Finally, the Court considered the order for one respondent to pay the other's costs for specific notices of motion filed on 13 February 2017. The Court found that the respondent who filed the notices of motion had not succeeded in any of the relief sought and had breached procedural directions. The Court held that the other respondent was entitled to costs for the notices of motion, reflecting the principle that costs follow the event. This decision underscores the importance of adhering to procedural directions and the consequences of failing to do so in litigation.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the NCAT lacks the authority to exercise judicial power over respondents residing in other states, costs may be awarded in exceptional circumstances such as contempt proceedings, costs should not be awarded where there is a disregard for procedural fairness and futile submissions, and costs follow the event, particularly where procedural breaches occur. The Court followed established principles of jurisdictional limits, exceptional costs orders, and the consequences of procedural breaches, while distinguishing the circumstances of each respondent to arrive at its decisions.