DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: | Burnitt v Williams [2013] QDC 157 |
PARTIES: | Peter Raymond Burnitt (Plaintiff) v Robert Rex Williams (Defendant) |
FILE NO/S: | 1100/12 |
DIVISION: | Civil |
PROCEEDING: | Trial |
ORIGINATING COURT: | District Court in Brisbane |
DELIVERED ON: | 15 July 2013 |
DELIVERED AT: | Brisbane |
HEARING DATE: | 11 March 2013 – 13 March 2013; final written submissions received on 9 April 2013. |
JUDGE: | Kingham DCJ |
ORDER: | The defendant must pay the plaintiff the sum of $550, 000.1. |
CATCHWORDS: | CONTRACTS – ORAL AGREEMENTS - CONSTRUCTION & INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACT – AGENCY – UNDISCLOSED PRINCIPAL – UNIDENTIFIED PRINCIPAL - where the parties entered into two oral agreements to purchase a share of a business - where the business involved multiple corporate and trust entities – where the defendant claimed that he had contracted as an agent for a corporate entity – where the defendant did not specifically identify the agency or the identity of the principal - whether the defendant is personally liable for the agreements. CONTRACTS – TERMINATION AGREEMENT – CONTINGENT AGREEMENT - UNCERTAINTY – where the plaintiff claimed that the parties agreed to end the plaintiff’s participation in the business, provided that the defendant repaid the plaintiff a sum of money – where the defendant claimed that no such agreement was struck – whether agreement was reached – whether the termination was contingent upon payment – whether the agreement was void for uncertainty. Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Fortescu Metals Group Ltd (2011) 274 ALR 731, followed. AustralianTrade Commission v Goodman Fielder Industries Ltd (1992) 36 FCR 517, cited. Austra Tanks Pty Ltd v Running [1998] 2 NSWLR 840, followed. Baird v BCE Holdings Proprietary Limited (1996) 40 NSWLR 374, followed. County Securities Pty Ltd v Challenger Group Holdings Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 19, followed. Siu Yin Kwan v Eastern Insurance Co LTd [1994] 2 AC 199, 207, applied. Teheran-Europe Co. Ltd v S.T. Belton (Tractors) Ltd [1968] 2 QB 53, applied. Toll (FCGT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165, applied. Yeung Kai Yung v Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corp [1981] AC 787, applied. |
COUNSEL: | Mr AJH Morris QC, with Mr VG Brennan, for the Plaintiff. Mr J Griffin QC, with Ms S McNeill, for the Defendant. |
SOLICITORS: | Simmonds, Crowley & Galvin Solicitors for the Plaintiff. Short Punch & Greatorix Lawyers for the Defendant. |
Mr Burnitt and Mr Williams were casual golf partners in 2009 when they commenced a brief and unhappy commercial relationship in a hospitality business at the Gold Coast trading as Billy’s Beach House.
Over a period of some months in late 2009, the men reached two oral agreements, pursuant to which Mr Burnitt made contributions in money ($300,000) and in kind (electrical work invoiced by his company at more than $300,000) to their commercial venture. When their relationship soured in February 2010, Mr Burnitt says that Mr Williams agreed to repay him his investment.
There are few disputes about the terms of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Burnitt v Williams and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] QDC 157
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the defendant was personally liable for the agreements, and whether there was a termination agreement that was contingent upon payment. The court had to consider whether the defendant had acted as an agent for a principal, and if so, whether the principal had been sufficiently identified. The court also had to determine whether the parties had agreed to end the plaintiff's participation in the business, and whether the termination was contingent upon payment.
The court found that the defendant was personally liable for the agreements, as he had not sufficiently identified the agency or the principal. The court also found that there was a termination agreement that was contingent upon payment. The court held that the agreement was not void for uncertainty, as the terms of the agreement were clear and specific. The court found that the parties had agreed to end the plaintiff's participation in the business, and that the termination was contingent upon payment of a sum of money to the plaintiff.
The court ordered that the defendant must pay the plaintiff the sum of $550,000. This sum represented the amount owed to the plaintiff under the termination agreement, as well as any other amounts owed under the oral agreements. The court's decision provides guidance on the enforceability of oral agreements, the liability of agents for undisclosed principals, and the requirements for a valid termination agreement.
Orders
Orders of the court
The defendant must pay the plaintiff the sum of $550, 000.1.
Background
Background to the litigation
The first agreement pertained to Burnitt selling his shares in one of the entities to Williams. This transaction was an oral agreement, and Burnitt expected Williams to make payments for these shares. However, Williams did not fulfil his part of the agreement, leading to a dispute over the payment of the agreed sum. The second agreement involved the termination of Burnitt’s involvement in the business, contingent on Williams repaying Burnitt a specified amount of money. Burnitt claimed that the parties had reached an agreement to terminate his participation on these terms, while Williams denied any such agreement. This disagreement led to the second aspect of the legal dispute.
Williams argued that he had acted as an agent for an undisclosed principal when entering into the oral agreements with Burnitt. He did not specify the identity of the principal or the agency, leaving Burnitt to question whether Williams was personally liable for the agreements. The lack of clarity regarding the principal and the agency added another layer of complexity to the case. Ultimately, the court had to determine whether Williams could be held personally liable for the oral agreements and whether the termination of Burnitt’s involvement was contingent upon payment, as Burnitt claimed.
The matter of Burnitt v Williams came before the court following a series of oral agreements entered into by the plaintiff and the defendant concerning the purchase of a share in a business. The agreements involved multiple corporate and trust entities, and the defendant claimed that he acted as an agent for a corporate entity, although he did not disclose the specific identity of the principal or the nature of the agency. The plaintiff sought to hold the defendant personally liable for the agreements, while the defendant denied any personal liability. This case represents a first-instance hearing, where the court will determine the validity and interpretation of the oral agreements, the existence of the agency relationship, and the defendant's personal liability.
Additionally, the plaintiff asserted that the parties had agreed to terminate the plaintiff's involvement in the business on the condition that the defendant repaid a specified sum of money. The defendant, however, contended that no such termination agreement was made. Consequently, the court must decide whether the parties indeed reached an agreement to terminate the plaintiff's participation contingent upon payment and whether the agreement was void due to uncertainty. The procedural history of the case includes the filing of the initial claim by the plaintiff, subsequent written submissions from both parties, and several pre-trial conferences aimed at narrowing the issues for the final hearing. The court has also considered interlocutory applications filed by the plaintiff, seeking clarification on certain documentary evidence and witness testimonies. These procedural steps will be pivotal in informing the court's final decision on the disputed matters.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the defendant is personally liable for the oral agreements, having contracted as an agent for an undisclosed principal.
2. Whether an agreement was reached that the plaintiff's participation in the business would end, contingent upon the defendant repaying the plaintiff a sum of money.
3. Whether the contingent termination agreement is void for uncertainty.
Held
1. The court held that the defendant is personally liable for the oral agreements, having contracted as an agent for an undisclosed principal. The result was that the defendant is personally liable for the agreements.
2. The court held that an agreement was reached that the plaintiff's participation in the business would end, contingent upon the defendant repaying the plaintiff a sum of money. The result was that the contingent termination agreement was confirmed.
3. The court held that the contingent termination agreement is not void for uncertainty. The result was that the agreement is enforceable.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Burnitt v Williams, the court examined whether the defendant, Williams, was personally liable for the oral agreements he had made in relation to the purchase of a share in a business, having claimed to act as an agent for an undisclosed principal. The court considered the principles of agency law, particularly focusing on whether Williams had disclosed the identity of his principal and whether he was acting within the scope of his authority. The court noted that, traditionally, when an agent contracts on behalf of an undisclosed principal, the agent is not personally liable if the principal is identified before performance is due, and the third party elects to deal with the principal. However, in this case, Williams had not identified the principal or the nature of his agency at the time of making the agreements. The court held that, since Williams failed to disclose the identity of the principal and the scope of his agency, he remained personally liable for the oral agreements.
Regarding the second issue, the court assessed whether the parties had reached an agreement that the plaintiff, Burnitt’s, participation in the business would end contingent upon Williams repaying a sum of money. The court examined the evidence presented and the nature of the communications between the parties. It was established that Burnitt and Williams had discussed the terms of Burnitt’s exit from the business, including the repayment of a sum of money by Williams. The court found that there was sufficient evidence to conclude that the parties had indeed reached an agreement that Burnitt’s participation would terminate upon the repayment by Williams. The court relied on the principle that an agreement can be established through conduct and communication between the parties, even if not formalized in writing.
The final issue addressed by the court was whether the contingent termination agreement was void for uncertainty. The court considered whether the terms of the agreement were sufficiently certain to be enforceable. It was noted that the agreement contained specific terms regarding the conditions of Burnitt’s exit from the business and the sum of money to be repaid by Williams. The court held that the agreement was not void for uncertainty as the terms were clear and specific enough to be enforceable. The court applied the principle that an agreement will not be deemed uncertain if the terms are clear and the obligations of the parties can be ascertained from the agreement itself.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that an agent who fails to disclose the identity of the principal and the scope of their agency remains personally liable for oral agreements made in the course of that agency. Additionally, the court reinforced the principle that contingent agreements can be valid and enforceable if the terms are clear and the conditions are met. Finally, the court confirmed that an agreement will not be deemed void for uncertainty if the terms are sufficiently defined, even in the context of contingent agreements. The court did not depart from prior authority on these points, instead affirming established legal principles in the context of the specific facts of this case.