Burnham v Carroll Musgrove Theatres Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read
41 CLR 540

CARROLL MUSGROVE THEATRES LIMITED

RESPONDENTS.

AND ANOTHER

DEFENDANTS, Landlord and Tenant-EstoppelAction of ejectment-Issue-Effect of judgment-

Res judicata-Weekly tenancy-Tenant holding over after expiration of term- Acceptance of weekly rent-Terms implied by law-Fair rents-Restriction on SYDNEY,

landlord's right to recover possession-Shop reasonably required for purpose of Aug. 1, 2, 3,

reconstruction to substantial extent-Greater hardship caused by refusing than by 7, 8.

granting order-Conveyancing Act 1919 (N.S.W.) (No. 6 of 1919), sec. 127*___ Fair Rents Act 1915 (N.S.W.) (No. 66 of 1915), sec. 21A (1) (f)-Fair Rents MELBOURNE,

(Amendment) Act 1926 (No. 2 of 1926), sec. 11.*

The judgment in an action of ejectment is only an estoppel between the parties on the statutory issue as to whether or not the claimant was entitled to possession on the day named in the writ, and not as to any facts decided by the jury in such action. * The Conveyancing Act 1919

implication before the commencement (N.S.W.), sec. 127, provides (1) No tenancy from year to year shall,

of any such tenancy in respect of which after the commencement of this Act, be implied by payment of rent; if

the lessor or the lessee, as the case may there is a tenancy, and no agreement as

be, who is seeking to determine the to its duration, then such tenancy shall

same, such tenancy shall, subject to be deemed to be a tenancy determin-

any express agreement to the contrary, able at the will of either of the parties

be determinable by six months' notice by one month's notice in writing expiring at any time. (2) This section

The Fair Rents Act 1915 (N.S.W.), shall not apply where there is a tenancy

sec. 21A, inserted by sec. 11 of the Fair from year to year which has arisen by

Rents (Amendment) Act 1926 (N.S.W.),

41 CLR 541

A weekly tenant who, after the termination of his tenancy, holds over, with the consent of his landlord, without any agreement other than that implied by law from the continuance in possession and acceptance of a weekly rent, continues to hold as a weekly tenant, and is not entitled to one month's notice under the provisions of sec. 127 of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (N.S.W.) for the determination of such tenancy that section has no application to cases where before the Act no implication of a tenancy from year to year

A landlord required possession of a shop in order that he might effect some external alterations and also remove a partition from between the shop and an adjoining shop, which had been empty for a long time, and from the resultant combined shop he would receive a weekly rent of a sum considerably greater than the sum of the rents of the two shops if let separately.

Held, by Knox C.J., Higgins, Gavan Duffy and Powers JJ. (Isaacs J. dis- senting), that the shop was reasonably required for the purpose of reconstruc- tion to a substantial extent, and that greater hardship would…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burnham v Carroll Musgrove Theatres Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1928] HCA 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The dispute involved a landlord, Carroll Musgrove Theatres Ltd. (and later Victoria Arcade Ltd.), seeking possession of a shop from its tenant, Arthur Burnham. Burnham had occupied the premises since December 1920, initially at a weekly rent of £5. A significant point of contention throughout the proceedings was the nature of Burnham's tenancy, with the landlord asserting it was a weekly tenancy and Burnham claiming an agreement for a longer lease. The landlord had made multiple attempts to recover possession of the shop.

The legal issues before the High Court included whether previous judgments in ejectment actions created an estoppel preventing the landlord from asserting a weekly tenancy, whether Burnham was a weekly tenant at the relevant time, and if not, whether his tenancy fell under section 127 of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW). Furthermore, the court had to determine if the landlord had satisfied the conditions of section 21A of the Fair Rents Act 1915 (NSW), as amended, which required the premises to be reasonably required for substantial reconstruction and that greater hardship would be caused by refusing possession than by granting it.

A majority of the High Court, comprising Knox C.J., Higgins, Gavan Duffy, and Powers JJ., affirmed the decision of the Supreme Court. They found that the shop was reasonably required for reconstruction to a substantial extent and that greater hardship would result from refusing possession. Isaacs J., dissenting, addressed several points, including the effect of a prior judgment on the alleged agreement for a lease, finding it to be res judicata. He also considered the nature of the tenancy, concluding that earlier notices to quit had terminated any weekly tenancy, and that subsequent occupation, due to ongoing disputes about the terms, did not create a new weekly tenancy but rather a tenancy at will, which then fell under section 127 of the Conveyancing Act. However, the majority ultimately upheld the landlord's claim for possession based on the grounds of reasonable requirement for reconstruction and greater hardship.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.