Bullow and Repatriation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Administrative

Appeals

Tribunal

 

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2006] AATA 818

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL          №V2005/449

VETERANS’      AFFAIRS       DIVISION

Re:           DAVID wesley BULLOW

Applicant

And:REPATRIATION COMMISSION

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal:       Mr Egon Fice, Member

Dr Kerry Breen, Member

Date:25 September 2006

Place:Melbourne

Decision:The decision under review is affirmed.

(sgd) Egon Fice

Member

CATCHWORDS – disability pension – alcohol abuse – hypertension – severe stressor – causal link between service and disease

Veterans Entitlements Act 1986 ss 9, 13, 120, 120A

Repatriation Commission v Deledio (1998) 83 FCR 82

Repatriation Commission v Keeley (2000) 98 FCR 108

Woodward v Repatriation Commission (2003) 131 FCR 473

REASONS FOR DECISION

25 September 2006  Mr Egon Fice, Member

Dr Kerry Breen, Member

1.      In late 2003 Mr David Wesley Bullow lodged a claim with the Repatriation Commission (the Commission) seeking a disability pension for a number of claimed medical conditions arising out of his operational service.  The Commission accepted that Mr Bullow’s bilateral sensorineural hearing loss, bilateral tinnitus and tinea were war-caused conditions.  However, the Commission rejected his claims for alcohol abuse, hypertension and bilateral myopia because they were not war-caused.  Mr Bullow applied to the Veterans’ Review Board (VRB) for a review of the decisions relating to alcohol abuse and hypertension.  The VRB affirmed the decision of the Commission.  It found that Mr Bullow did not satisfy the factor in the Statement of Principles (SoP) upon which he relied to establish alcohol abuse.  Therefore, the material before the VRB did not raise a reasonable hypothesis within the meaning of the Veterans Entitlements Act 1986 (the Act).  The VRB also rejected Mr Bullow’s hypertension claim because it did not accept that his alcohol abuse, at the time of onset of hypertension, was causally related to his service.  Mr Bullow seeks a review of those decisions.

2.      The parties agreed that, for the purposes of this hearing, if the Tribunal were to find that Mr Bullow’s alcohol abuse was war-caused, then his hypertension was also war-caused.  Accordingly, we have only addressed the issues raised by Mr Bullow’s claim in respect of alcohol abuse.  

Relevant Facts

3.      Mr Bullow was called up for national service and he joined the Australian Army on 7 February 1968.  He completed his national service on 6 February 1970 when he was discharged from the army.  Mr Bullow saw operational service with 17 Construction Squadron Workshop in Vietnam where he served as a fitter and turner between 23 December 1968 and 3 December 1969. 

4.      Mr Bullow was stationed in Vung Tau until about the end of July 1969 when he was sent to Nui Dat until the completion of his operational tour.

5.      After Mr Bullow went into the army on 8 February 1968, he was sent to Puckapunyal to complete his basic training.  It was there that Mr Bullow met Mr G. Archer, who had also been conscripted at that time.  They had beds next to each other in the accommodation at Puckapunyal and, according to Mr Bullow, “knocked around together”…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bullow and Repatriation Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] AATA 818
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

David Wesley Bullow applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for a review of the Repatriation Commission’s decision to reject his claim for a disability pension in relation to alcohol abuse and hypertension, which he claimed arose from his operational service in Vietnam. The Commission accepted that Bullow’s bilateral sensorineural hearing loss, bilateral tinnitus and tinea were war-caused conditions but rejected his claims for alcohol abuse and hypertension on the basis that they were not war-caused. The Veterans’ Review Board affirmed the Commission’s decision. Bullow relied on three hypotheses to connect his operational service with his alcohol abuse: learning of the death of a friend, a soldier brandishing a loaded weapon in a wet canteen and a stand-off between Australian soldiers and Vietnamese nationals at the Police Academy. The Tribunal found that only the Police Academy incident raised a reasonable hypothesis connecting alcohol abuse with the circumstances of Bullow’s operational service. However, the Tribunal was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that Bullow’s alcohol abuse was not war-caused because the evidence did not support his account of the Police Academy incident. The Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Veterans’ Review Board.

Background

Background to the litigation

David Wesley Bullow served in the Australian Army from 7 February 1968 to 6 February 1970, with operational service in Vietnam between 23 December 1968 and 3 December 1969. He claims a disability pension for alcohol abuse and hypertension, which he alleges are war-caused due to his service in Vietnam. The Repatriation Commission accepted that Bullow's bilateral sensorineural hearing loss, bilateral tinnitus, and tinea were war-caused but rejected his claims for alcohol abuse and hypertension. The Veterans' Review Board affirmed the Commission's decision. Bullow's claim for alcohol abuse is based on the following incidents during his service: the death of his friend, Mr. Archer, an incident in the wet canteen where a soldier brandished a loaded rifle, and an incident at the Police Academy where soldiers' valuables were stolen by Vietnamese nationals and shots were fired at their trucks.

David Wesley Bullow lodged a claim with the Repatriation Commission in late 2003, seeking a disability pension for alcohol abuse and hypertension, among other conditions. The Commission accepted that his bilateral sensorineural hearing loss, bilateral tinnitus, and tinea were war-caused but rejected his claims for alcohol abuse and hypertension. Bullow appealed the Commission's decision to the Veterans' Review Board, which affirmed the Commission's decision. Bullow then sought a review of the Veterans' Review Board's decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Mr Bullow's alcohol abuse is war-caused within the meaning of the Veterans Entitlements Act 1986.
2. Whether Mr Bullow's hypertension is war-caused, contingent on the outcome of the alcohol abuse claim.

Held
1. Whether Mr Bullow's alcohol abuse is war-caused within the meaning of the Veterans Entitlements Act 1986. The court concluded that Mr Bullow's alcohol abuse was not war-caused. The claim was dismissed.
2. Whether Mr Bullow's hypertension is war-caused, contingent on the outcome of the alcohol abuse claim. Since the court found that Mr Bullow's alcohol abuse was not war-caused, the court concluded that his hypertension claim also failed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal considered whether Mr Bullow's alcohol abuse and hypertension were war-caused, applying the Veterans Entitlements Act 1986. The key legal principle was the requirement for a causal link between the claimed conditions and Mr Bullow's operational service in Vietnam. The Tribunal followed the four-stage analysis outlined in Repatriation Commission v Deledio (1998) 83 FCR 82, which involves determining if the material raises a reasonable hypothesis, if a relevant Statement of Principles (SoP) exists, if the hypothesis is reasonable, and whether the claim should succeed under the standard of proof. The Tribunal found that while Mr Bullow's claims raised a temporal connection with his service, they failed to establish a causal link. Specifically, the Tribunal concluded that learning about the death of Mr Archer was not a severe stressor as defined by the SoP for alcohol abuse. Similarly, the Tribunal rejected Mr Bullow's account of the incident in the wet canteen and the Police Academy, finding that the evidence did not support his claims. Therefore, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Veterans Review Board, dismissing Mr Bullow's claims for alcohol abuse and consequent hypertension. The binding legal principle is that for a condition to be deemed war-caused, there must be a causal link between the condition and the operational service, which was not established in this case.