Built Environs WA Pty Ltd v Perth Airport Pty Ltd [No 3]

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   BUILT ENVIRONS WA PTY LTD -v- PERTH AIRPORT PTY LTD [No 3] [2019] WASC 399

CORAM:   KENNETH MARTIN J

HEARD:   7 OCTOBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   7 NOVEMBER 2019

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1513 of 2016

BETWEEN:   BUILT ENVIRONS WA PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

PERTH AIRPORT PTY LTD

Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Application for leave to replead previously struck out pleas - Pleading by reference to schedule - Schedule oppressively assembled but substantively insufficient detail of plaintiff's breach of contract case - Discrete pleas of breach - General drawing deficiencies - Insufficient pleas of material facts as to the alleged causative consequences of each drawing deficiency as regards a loss or detriment to plaintiff - Case management considerations of delay, expense and waste associated with this and former pleas - Leave to amend previously struck out pleas refused - No further repleading attempts allowed on this aspect of claim

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Application refused

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : Mr S Doyle QC and Mr T Porter
Defendant : Mr D Miller SC and Mr M R Collins

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Baker McKenzie - Brisbane
Defendant : King & Wood Mallesons

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Barclay Mowlem Construction Ltd v Dampier Port Authority [2006] WASC 281; (2006) 33 WAR 82

Built Environs WA Pty Ltd v Perth Airport Pty Ltd [No 2] [2019] WASC 76

DM Drainage & Constructions Pty Ltd as trustee for the DM Unit Trust t/as DM Civil v Karara Mining Ltd [2014] WASC 170

Ipex ITG Pty Ltd v Melbourne Water Corporation [No 3] [2006] VSC 83

JLW (Vic) Pty Ltd v Tsiloglou [1994] 1 VR 237

KENNETH MARTIN J:

  1. I am dealing with the plaintiff's amended chamber summons filed 4 October 2019, seeking leave to replead pars [14] and [15] of its further amended substituted statement of claim (FASSOC) by fresh pleas in the terms of a minute of proposed amended pleading, also dated 4 October 2019. 

  2. The latest proposed iterations of amendments to the FASSOC were marked in purple.  This iteration only emerged on the last working day prior to the hearing of the present application. 

Background

  1. The need to obtain leave to replead in respect of pars [14] and [15] of the FASSOC arises out of orders which I issued following my earlier decision in this action delivered on 12 March 2019, being Built Environs WA Pty Ltd v Perth Airport Pty Ltd [No 2] [2019] WASC 76 (Built Environs [No 2]).

  2. At the conclusion of those reasons I said:

    [52]The present application was advanced initially as a basis to relieve the defendant of further discovery obligations towards pars [11], [14] and [15] of the further amended SSOC. I would accede to the present application. But it is now apparent to me that the underlying cause of the problem is deeper and fundamentally structural. It now needs to be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Built Environs WA Pty Ltd v Perth Airport Pty Ltd [No 3] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASC 399
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia heard an application from Built Environs WA Pty Ltd against Perth Airport Pty Ltd regarding an application for leave to replead previously struck out pleas in a contract dispute. The plaintiff sought to amend its pleadings to address alleged breaches of contract, particularly in relation to general drawing deficiencies, which were claimed to have caused loss or detriment to the plaintiff. The defendants opposed the application on the basis that the proposed amendments were substantively insufficient, oppressively assembled, and would result in further delay, expense, and waste. The case management considerations of the court included the significant delay in bringing forward the amended pleas and the potential for further amendments in the future.

The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff's proposed repleadings sufficiently detailed the material facts as to the alleged causative consequences of each drawing deficiency, and whether the proposed amendments would be oppressive to the defendants and wasteful of court resources. The court had to consider the adequacy of the proposed pleadings, the potential for further amendments, and the overall fairness and efficiency of the litigation process. The court also had to assess whether the proposed amendments would provide sufficient clarity and detail to allow the defendants to properly respond to the allegations and whether the potential for further amendments indicated an ongoing failure to properly particularise the claims.

The court found that the proposed repleadings were still insufficient in detail and oppressive in assembly. The plaintiff had not provided discrete pleas of breach or sufficiently particularised the material facts concerning the alleged causative consequences of each drawing deficiency. The court noted that the proposed amendments still referenced a schedule that was incomplete and potentially subject to further additions. The court was concerned about the ongoing delay and the potential for further repleadings, which would continue to burden the defendants and waste court resources. The court concluded that the proposed amendments did not meet the necessary standard for leave to be granted and that it was in the interests of justice to refuse leave to amend the previously struck out pleas. The court also decided that no further repleading attempts would be allowed on this aspect of the claim.

The court ordered that leave to amend the previously struck out pleas be refused and that no further repleading attempts would be permitted on this aspect of the claim. This decision underscored the importance of proper particularisation of claims and the need for plaintiffs to provide sufficient detail in their pleadings to allow defendants to properly respond. The court's decision also highlighted the significant case management considerations involved in deciding whether to allow repleadings, particularly in cases where there is a history of insufficient pleadings and potential for ongoing amendments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

During the course of oral submissions by senior counsel for the defendants I was referred to a first instance decision of Byrne J in the Supreme Court of Victoria Commercial and Equity Division (Long Cases List) in the matter of Ipex ITG Pty Ltd v Melbourne Water Corporation [No 3] [2006] VSC 83. Although, of course, the facts are necessarily different, senior counsel relied on some observations by Byrne J within that decision in the context of what looked to be an hours claim, particularly his Honour's ultimate conclusion that the way that hours claim had been pleaded was inadequate and embarrassing, leading to pleading relief in that respect. I mention but do not cite his Honour's observations seen at [4], [6], [10], [16], [17], [21] and [23]. At [26] of his Honour's reasons he explained what he there identified as being more correctly described as a total time/cost claim. His Honour explained steps involved in establishing such a claim at [26] and added at [28]:But, even so, it is for the plaintiff to decide how it will quantify this loss but the Court will expect it to do so by showing, in a case such as the present, that the breach caused Ipex to perform certain extra work which is valued at a certain sum unless this evidence is not obtainable ...applying observations of Brooking J in JLW (Vic) Pty Ltd v Tsiloglou [1994] 1 VR 237, 241 and the cases there referred. Central to the attempted reconstitution of proposed pars [14] and [15] in respect of which leave is now sought are the pleas under altered particulars to par [11] which now make a direct reference to the content of the SFASSOC minute's Schedule V iteration. In particular, as regards alleged breach of contract, the key Schedule V column is headed 'IFC Drawing Reference'. As now seen, that 'IFC Drawing Reference' column within Schedule V remains a work in progress with further future augmentations foreshadowed. In other words, even further alleged breaches of contract as regards general drawing deficiencies are foreshadowed to emerge in future. That is said to be as a result of the review work still being undertaken, but which possibly might conclude within the next six weeks. In other words, almost three and a half years after this action was commenced (with the writ of summons being issued on 31 March 2016), possible contended breaches of contract alleged by the plaintiff, are still emerging. But these potential breaches of contract in reference to alleged general drawing deficiencies are only emerging in piecemeal fashion. Again, by way of illustration, by reference to Schedule V and item 2, it can be seen that two 'lack of coordination' grievances, between electrical design and architectural design and, moreover, as between electrical design and column design have recently arrived. But the new grievances as articulated within item 2 are still in the vaguest of terms. No real or tangible detail about a so called 'lack of coordination' has been forthcoming. Significantly, however, the Schedule V 'Correspondence Reference(s)' column, illustrated by reference again to item 2, therein, now makes reference to ten differently identified pieces of correspondence. Decoding that column is a confrontingly oppressive task. It would essentially leave the defendant (and the court) to find out for themselves, out of what a multifarious group of assembled documents might hold, once located, then to assess them and possibly derive some details therein from such a document (taking account of their prefixes as identified under par [14] particulars (c)(i) through to (viii)), as the source of such documents. Currently, I can gain no clues about what all those prefixed documents might contain, if I ever could locate and assemble them and know what I was looking for.