Building Corporation WA Pty Ltd v Marshall [No 3]

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   BUILDING CORPORATION WA PTY LTD -v- MARSHALL [No 3] [2022] WASC 254

CORAM:   TOTTLE J

HEARD:   20 JUNE 2022

DELIVERED          :   8 AUGUST 2022

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2186 of 2020

BETWEEN:   BUILDING CORPORATION WA PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

ARTHUR PATRICK MARSHALL

JEANETTE ELLEN MARSHALL

First Defendants

MARK FREDERICK RIETVELD

Second Defendant

RIETVELD ARCHITECTS PTY LTD

Third Defendant

MERCEDES GROUP PTY LTD

Fourth Defendant

ILIADIS & ASSOCIATES PTY LTD

Third Party


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Costs - Application and trial of preliminary issue - Application to amend further amended statement of claim filed on the eve of trial

Legislation:

N/A

Result:

The first defendants pay the plaintiff's costs of the determination and hearing of the preliminary issue save for: any costs incurred in connection with preparing and adducing evidence from Mr Craig Melville Smith; and, an allowance in respect of the time spent on 13 December 2021 hearing the plaintiff's application for leave to amend its further amended statement of claim, to be taxed

The plaintiff pay the first defendants' costs of the application for the hearing of the preliminary issue to be taxed

There be no order as to costs in respect of the plaintiff's application to amend the further amended statement of claim on 10 December 2021

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : M C Hotchkin
First Defendants : A Rumble
Second Defendant : C Maclean
Third Defendant : C Maclean
Fourth Defendant : M Lang
Third Party : JPT Hart

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Hotchkin Hanly
First Defendants : Bennett + Co
Second Defendant : DLA Piper Australia - Perth
Third Defendant : DLA Piper Australia - Perth
Fourth Defendant : Jackson McDonald
Third Party : Barry Nilsson Lawyers

Cases referred to in decision:

Building Corporation WA Pty Ltd v Marshall [2021] WASC 242

Building Corporation WA Pty Ltd v Marshall [No 2] [2022] WASC 140

Floruit Holdings Pty Ltd v Sebastian - Builders & Developers Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 411

Noyce v Jeromel (No 2) [2021] SASCA 111

Strzelecki Holdings Pty Ltd v Jorgensen [2019] WASCA 96; (2019) 54 WAR 388

TOTTLE J:

Introduction

  1. These reasons concern competing applications for costs arising out of the determination of a preliminary issue in this action. These reasons assume familiarity with the reasons for determining the preliminary issue,[1] and with the reasons for ordering the issue be tried as a preliminary issue.[2]

    [1] Building Corporation WA Pty Ltd v Marshall [No 2] [2022] WASC 140.

    [2] Building Corporation WA Pty Ltd v Marshall [2021] WASC 242.

  2. The plaintiff applies for orders that the first defendants pay its costs of the determination of the preliminary issue.  It contends that the costs of the application for determination of the preliminary issue, which were reserved, be costs in the cause.  The plaintiff contends there should be no order as to costs in respect of an application to amend the further amended statement of claim made on the eve…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Building Corporation WA Pty Ltd v Marshall [No 3] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] WASC 254
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Building Corporation WA Pty Ltd v Marshall [No 3] dealt with a dispute concerning costs and the admissibility of expert evidence in a legal proceeding. The plaintiff, Building Corporation WA Pty Ltd, sought to recover costs from the first defendants, with the matter being heard in a relevant Australian court. The primary issues the court had to decide involved the admissibility of expert evidence provided by an architect, Mr Craig Melville Smith, and the appropriateness of costs associated with a late application to amend the plaintiff's further amended statement of claim.

The court ruled that Mr Smith's expert evidence was inadmissible for construing the agreement between the plaintiff and the first defendants. Consequently, the plaintiff was not entitled to any costs related to adducing this evidence. Additionally, the court decided there should be no order as to costs concerning the plaintiff's late application to amend its further amended statement of claim. This application was argued on the first morning of the hearing, necessitating a reduction in the costs of the hearing to which the plaintiff would otherwise be entitled. Despite these qualifications, the court determined that the first defendants should pay the plaintiff's costs of the hearing of the preliminary issue.

The court further reasoned that the plaintiff had not shown sufficient grounds to depart from the ordinary rule that costs should follow the event. Consequently, the plaintiff was required to pay the first defendants' costs of the application for the hearing of the preliminary issue. The court also concluded that, given the circumstances of the amendment application, it would be just to make no order as to costs in respect of the amendment application. This decision involved an adjustment to the costs of the hearing as previously mentioned.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a dispute between Building Corporation WA Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) and Marshall (the first defendant), with other defendants also involved. The plaintiff is a building corporation that had entered into an agreement with the first defendant for the construction of a building. The plaintiff alleged that the first defendant had breached the terms of the agreement by not completing the work to the required standard. The first defendant denied the allegations and counterclaimed for additional payments. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia, where a preliminary issue was raised regarding the interpretation of the agreement between the parties. The plaintiff sought to amend its statement of claim on the eve of the trial, introducing a new term into the agreement based on alleged conversations. The amendment was allowed, but the plaintiff did not succeed in establishing the new term as part of the agreement.

The case had a complex procedural history, with multiple hearings and applications. The initial dispute arose from the alleged breach of the agreement between the plaintiff and the first defendant. The matter was first heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia, where a preliminary issue was raised regarding the interpretation of the agreement. The court heard arguments on the admissibility of expert evidence and the allowance of an amendment to the plaintiff's statement of claim. The case proceeded to a hearing on the preliminary issue, which was argued on the first morning of the trial. The court ultimately ruled on the costs associated with the hearing of the preliminary issue and the amendment application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to an order for costs in its favour, subject to certain qualifications.
2. Whether the plaintiff's expert evidence from an architect, Mr Craig Melville Smith, was admissible for the purposes of construing the agreement between the parties.
3. Whether there should be an order as to costs in respect of the plaintiff's late application to amend its further amended statement of claim.

Held
1. The plaintiff is entitled to an order for costs in its favour, subject to two qualifications. First, the plaintiff is not entitled to any costs in respect of adducing expert evidence from Mr Craig Melville Smith, as his evidence was not admissible for construing the agreement between the parties. Second, there should be no order as to costs in respect of the plaintiff's late application to amend its further amended statement of claim.
2. The first defendants should pay the plaintiff's costs of the hearing of the preliminary issue, subject to the aforementioned qualifications. The plaintiff should pay the first defendants' costs of the application for the hearing of the preliminary issue.
3. There should be no order as to costs in respect of the plaintiff's late application to amend its further amended statement of claim, necessitating a reduction in the costs of the hearing to which the plaintiff would otherwise be entitled.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In my judgment the plaintiff is entitled to an order for costs in its favour. There are two qualifications. First, the plaintiff adduced expert evidence from an architect, Mr Craig Melville Smith, and sought to rely on that evidence for the purposes of construing the agreement between it and the first defendants. I held Mr Smith's evidence was not admissible for that purpose.[5] The plaintiff is not entitled to any costs in respect of adducing evidence from Mr Smith. Second, for the reasons given below, there should be no order as to costs in respect of the plaintiff's late application to amend its further amended statement of claim. Because the application was argued on the first morning of the hearing, this will necessitate a reduction in the costs of the hearing to which the plaintiff would otherwise be entitled. The transcript indicates that the first 90 minutes of the hearing were concerned with the application to amend. Subject to those qualifications, the first defendants should pay the plaintiff's costs of the hearing of the preliminary issue.[5] Building Corporation WA Pty Ltd v Marshall [No 2] [59]. The plaintiff contends that it was reasonable for it to oppose the order for a hearing of the preliminary issue. It contends that it made its submissions in opposition to the application for the hearing of a preliminary issue to be of assistance to the court. The plaintiff has not shown a sufficient reason not to apply the ordinary rule that costs should follow the event. The plaintiff should pay the first defendants' costs of the application for the hearing of the preliminary issue. As recorded earlier the plaintiff applied to amend its further amended statement of claim on the eve of the trial and the application was heard on the first morning of the trial. By the amendment the plaintiff sought to establish that the agreement between the parties included a term that did not appear in the relevant document but was based on conversations between one of the plaintiff's members of staff and the first defendants' daughter. The amendment was allowed but the plaintiff did not succeed in establishing that the disputed term was a term of the agreement. The defendants contend that the plaintiff should have known that it would not establish the disputed term. I do not accept that proposition. Ordinarily a party who amends is required to pay the costs thrown away by reason of the amendment. In many instances, for practical reasons, the costs thrown away are limited to the costs of consequential amendments to the pleadings. In this case there were no consequential amendments to the pleadings and it is not apparent that there were any costs thrown away. That a party ultimately fails on an issue introduced into a pleading following a contested amendment application does not ordinarily disentitle the party to the costs of the amendment application and the court is cautious about apportioning the costs according to success and failure on particular issues. In my judgment, having regard to the way in which the application unfolded, justice between the parties will be achieved if there is no order as to costs in respect of the amendment application. This will necessitate to the adjustment to the costs of the hearing to which I have referred above.