Buggy v Reinisch

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Buggy v Reinisch [2010] FCA 917

Citation: Buggy v Reinisch [2010] FCA 917
Parties: MICHAEL FRANCIS BUGGY v FRANK REINISCH AND ORS
File number: NSD 1229 of 2009
Judge: FLICK J
Date of judgment: 25 August 2010
Catchwords:

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading or deceptive conduct

EVIDENCE – onus of proof – Jones v Dunkel – Browne v Dunn

Legislation: Evidence Act1995 (Cth)
Fair Trading Act 1989 (Qld), ss 38, 99, 100
Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic), ss 9, 158, 159
Federal Court of Australia Act1976 (Cth)
Federal Court Rules
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 52, 82, 87
Cases cited:

Browne v Dunn (1894) 6 R 67, cited
Ghazal v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales (1992) 29 NSWLR 336, cited
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298, considered
Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2008] FCA 1436, 171 FCR 174, cited
Unsted v Unsted (1947) 47 SR (NSW) 495, cited

Mellinkoff, D, The Language of the Law (1963)
Silving, H, ‘The Oath’ (1959) 68 Yale L J 1329  

Dates of hearing: 30 June and 5 July 2010
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 81
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr E Hyde
Solicitor for the Applicant: Malcolm Johns & Company, Lawyers
Solicitor for the Respondents: Delaneys Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NSW DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1229 of 2009

BETWEEN:

MICHAEL FRANCIS BUGGY
Applicant

AND:

FRANK REINISCH
First Respondent

ADAM REINISCH
Second Respondent

CAROLYN BARBARA REINISCH
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

FLICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 AUGUST 2010

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Application as filed on 30 October 2009 is dismissed.

2.The Applicant is to pay the costs of the Respondents.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NSW DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1229 of 2009

BETWEEN:

MICHAEL FRANCIS BUGGY
Applicant

AND:

FRANK REINISCH
First Respondent

ADAM REINISCH
Second Respondent

CAROLYN BARBARA REINISCH
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

FLICK J

DATE:

25 AUGUST 2010

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 30 October 2009 an Application was filed in the New South Wales District Registry of this Court supported by an affidavit.

  2. The proceeding, in very summary form, involves a boat. It is described as a 1993 Norcat 1000 Flybridge Challenger charter game fishing boat known as “Blue Magic”. The registered owner of that boat was previously the First Respondent, Mr Frank Reinisch, but is presently the Third Respondent, Ms Carolyn Reinisch.

  3. The Application as filed asserts a number of claims, including that the boat is the Applicant’s or that Ms Reinisch holds her interest in the boat on trust for him. Declaratory relief is sought. Further or alternatively, the Applicant claims that the First and/or Second Respondents have engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Buggy v Reinisch and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 917
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Buggy v Reinisch, the primary issue before the court was whether the Applicant, Mr Buggy, had a claim for declaratory relief regarding the "Blue Magic" boat being held on trust for him. The court also needed to determine if there was misleading or deceptive conduct by the Respondents, and if the Applicant was entitled to damages and interest. The case arose from a financial arrangement in 2004 where Mr Buggy provided funds to the Respondents to prevent the repossession of a boat, with an expectation of receiving a service fee and the option to purchase the boat back at a later date.

The court examined the evidence and found that while it was clear that Mr Buggy had provided financial assistance to the Respondents, the nature of the agreement between the parties was not as the Applicant claimed. The Applicant had failed to discharge the onus of proof required under Jones v Dunkel and Browne v Dunn, and thus could not establish the existence of the alleged agreement. The court also found that the document referred to as the "Tax Invoice" was not a reliable standalone agreement and could not be construed in isolation from the overall context of the events.

The reasoning of the court was based on the lack of satisfactory evidence to support the Applicant’s claims. The oral testimony provided by Mr Adam Reinisch was deemed unconvincing, particularly regarding claims of duress and intimidation. Furthermore, the court concluded that no misrepresentation had been made that would justify the granting of any relief to the Applicant. Consequently, the court dismissed the Application and ordered that the Applicant pay the costs of the Respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Application as filed on 30 October 2009 is dismissed.

2. The Applicant is to pay the costs of the Respondents.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The claims for declaratory relief as to the “Blue Magic” being held on trust for the Applicant were abandoned during the course of final submissions.THE FACTS IN OUTLINE The present unhappy tale begins in 2004 and ends with the present litigation. Along the way there are probably only two events – if not one – that assume any relevance. In February 2004 the “Blue Magic” was registered in the name of Mr Frank Reinisch and was subject to a finance agreement with Capital Finance Australia Limited (“Capital Finance”). There was default in payment in December 2003 and the finance company sought to recover the amount outstanding by repossessing the boat with a view to selling it. The Respondents’ fear was that the boat would be sold for less than it was worth albeit at an amount that would satisfy the amount then owing to Capital Finance. Mr Buggy was approached with a view to providing funding. He was approached by Mr Steven Goodman of Allied Mortgage Pty Ltd. Mr Buggy has known Mr Goodman for approximately 20 years. Mr Goodman told him of the difficulties that Messrs Frank and Adam Reinisch were experiencing and Mr Buggy agreed to help. A company with which Mr Buggy was associated, Icehot Pty Limited, had some available moneys. As had been agreed, Mr Buggy contacted Capital Finance in February 2004 and Icehot Pty Limited paid out the amount owing ($138,058.49) in March 2004. Inquiries made by Mr Buggy revealed that on a quick sale the boat was worth about $210,000. In return for paying out the amount owing to Capital Finance, Mr Buggy was to receive $30,000 as a “service fee”. Messrs Adam and Frank Reinisch would benefit since the boat would not be sold for less than it was worth and their interest in the boat would be preserved. So much was not in dispute between the parties. The first of the two events that potentially assume relevance occurred in or around February 2004. Mr Buggy and Mr Adam Reinisch met. Mr Adam Reinisch was told by Mr Buggy that he could “only carry the deal for three months. The Company will need its dough then”. The account given by Mr Buggy – and not disputed – was that he said to Mr Adam Reinisch:Okay, well, just so that nobody gets any surprises, the deal is, if you don’t pay us out I will have no other option but to take the boat and sell it. I’m told that the best that I can get quickly for it will be Two Hundred and Ten Grand and if you aren’t able to buy it back at the end of the time I will have to get it sold quickly. My Company will be in as much trouble as you are now if it doesn’t get its dough back. So if you are going to run close to the deadline then I suggest that you look for a buyer at a good figure whilst you have the time. Remember I will give you whatever you get over what you owe Icehot at the time it is sold. The whole purpose of the exercise, as I understand it, is to protect your equity in the boat, otherwise the Finance Company will butcher it.It was then anticipated that Mr Goodman could arrange on behalf of Messrs Adam and/or Frank Reinisch re-financing in order to repay the $138,058.49 and to pay the $30,000 variously described as a “service fee”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Neither the individual parts of the edifice upon which Counsel for the Applicant sought to found an inference or an implication that the agreement was as set forth by Mr Buggy in his affidavit (or as set forth in the written submissions), nor those parts taken together, support the granting of relief to the Applicant. The onus of proof imposed upon him has not been discharged.THE EVIDENCE OF THE RESPONDENTS Perhaps in anticipation of difficulties that he may encounter in making out all elements of the agreement upon which he wished to rely, Counsel for the Applicant contended that he only bore the onus of making out that Mr Buggy purchased the “Blue Magic”. Thereafter, it was understood that he contended that the Respondents bore the onus of establishing that the moneys paid were anything other than rent. The Respondents, of course, maintained that the moneys paid were repayment of a loan. That submission of the Applicant has been rejected. Some brief observations should nevertheless be made as to the Respondents’ evidence. All Respondents were in Court on 30 June 2010. Only Mr Adam Reinisch swore an affidavit that was relied upon by the Respondents. Objection was rightly taken to much of that affidavit. Much of it was rejected. But leave was given for oral evidence to be adduced in an attempt to redress the deficiencies the affidavit exposed. The oral evidence of Mr Adam Reinisch was less than satisfactory. To a large extent Mr Adam Reinisch was more willing to explain his own case than to answer the questions being asked of him. But that may well have been due to his age and the stress occasioned by the courtroom environment and its procedures being an alien environment. Less able to be satisfactorily explained, however, was his eagerness to embellish his explanations. When confronted with his signature on the “Tax Invoice” he thus repeatedly explained that he signed it “under duress” or “extreme duress”. He said he had been “intimidated” into signing it. But no reference had previously been made to any “duress” that had been exerted upon him by Mr Buggy. Nor to any “intimidation”. An eagerness and a commitment to retain the boat may be accepted; but the explanation of “duress” was less than satisfactory and less than convincing. But the criticism directed by Mr Adam Reinisch to the “Tax Invoice” is not totally misplaced. It is a document which forms but part of the overall matrix of events from which the terms of an entire agreement between Mr Buggy and Mr Frank Reinisch are to be discerned. It is not a document which forms a discrete agreement unto itself between the parties. And there is reason to question the reliability of the document itself. There is, for example, little basis upon which it could be concluded that any deposit of $35,000 was in fact ever paid; yet that is part of what the “Tax Invoice” purports to record. So, too, is Mr Adam Reinisch’s evidence in respect to the 2 August 2004 facsimile forwarded by Mr Goodman open to criticism. He initially said:I haven’t seen this document, sorry, because it’s got my wrong fax number on it.A little later in the context of discussing how this document came to be in the possession of the Respondents’ solicitor the following exchange occurred:

Decision

Reasons for decision

No inference should be drawn by reason of the failure on the part of the Respondents to call Mr Frank Reinisch. The conversations upon which the events turned were relevantly conversations with Mr Adam Reinisch.CONCLUSIONS No case, it is considered, has been made out by the Applicant such as to found any of the relief which was ultimately claimed. Although it was common ground that Mr Buggy provided financial assistance to the Respondents in the form of Icehot Pty Limited paying moneys to Capital Finance, all that has relevantly been established is that, thereafter, moneys totalling $208,223.62 were paid to Mr Buggy by one or other of the Respondents. It is not concluded that those moneys were the payment of rent for the “Blue Magic”. The primary manner in which the case was advanced on behalf of the Applicant was to seek to establish an agreement in July 2004 for both the repayment of moneys and the payment of rent and the right to negotiate a price to re-purchase the “Blue Magic”. The Applicant has failed to make out that agreement. That failure also carries with it the failure to separately make out any case in relation to misleading and deceptive conduct by reason of the “Tax Invoice” and the failure of claims for damages and interest. The representation relied upon, namely that the title to the “Blue Magic” was to be transferred to Mr Buggy, may be accepted. What is not accepted is Mr Buggy’s characterisation of the moneys received by him from September 2004 as rent, rather than repayments, and his entitlement to relief once those moneys have been paid. What is also not accepted is that whatever representation may be distilled from that document, it is not a document which can be construed as a discrete document divorced from the context in which it emerged. There is no reason why costs should not follow the event. The Applicant is to pay the costs of the Respondents.ORDERS The Orders of the Court are: 1.The Application as filed on 30 October 2009 is dismissed.2.The Applicant is to pay the costs of the Respondents.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.