BUG15 v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BUG15 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2017] FCCA 3059
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Application for judicial review of decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) affirming decision not to grant applicant protection visa – whether Tribunal considered claims – whether the Tribunal conducted hearing fairly – no jurisdictional error.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s.36(2)(aa)

Applicant: BUG15
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 2436 of 2015
Judgment of: Judge Manousaridis
Hearing date: 18 November 2016
Date of Last Submission: 18 November 2016
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 8 December 2017

REPRESENTATION

Applicant in person assisted by an interpreter.
Solicitor for the First Respondent:

Mr T Hillyard of

Sparke Helmore Lawyers

ORDERS

  1. The application is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 2436 of 2015

BUG15

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The applicant, who is a young child and a citizen of the People’s Republic of China (China), seeks judicial review of a decision of the second respondent (Tribunal) affirming the decision of a delegate of the first respondent (Minister) not to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa (Protection visa).

  2. Before I turn to the grounds stated in the application, I will set out the claims for protection advanced on the applicant’s behalf by his mother, and the Tribunal’s reasons for not accepting those claims.

Claims for Protection

  1. The applicant’s claims for protection were recorded in a statement written by the applicant’s mother that formed part of the applicant’s application for a Protection visa.[1] According to that statement, the applicant was born in Australia and will be persecuted if he returns to China because of his parent’s Christianity, and because he was born in contravention of China’s birth-control policy. The applicant’s parents, who are both from Fujian province, arrived in Australia as the holders of student visas. The applicant claims that both his parents are Christians and have attended the Local Church.

    [1] CB27-29

  2. While in Australia the applicants were legally married, but their families rejected their union. The applicant claims his parents are unable to register their marriage in China because they hold an Australian marriage certificate. The applicant claims that his parents would have to show their residency status (Hukou) by law and the “reality is that my parents’ families will definitely not agree to deliver a Huko [sic] to them for marriage registration”.[2] As a result, if they return to China the applicant’s parents will be fined for being in breach of the family planning policy which they are unable to pay. The applicant’s parent’s inability to pay any imposed fine will prohibit the applicant from receiving his residence permit and as a consequence, he will become a “black baby” without legal status and will be discriminated against in “

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BUG15 v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCCA 3059
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, BUG15, sought judicial review of a decision made by the Minister for Immigration. The dispute concerned the Minister's decision to refuse to grant BUG15 a protection visa. The matter was heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the Minister's decision to refuse the protection visa was affected by jurisdictional error. Specifically, the Court was required to consider whether the delegate of the Minister, in assessing BUG15's claims, had failed to properly consider relevant evidence or had applied the wrong legal test in relation to the assessment of risk of harm.

Judge Manousaridis found that the delegate had failed to adequately consider crucial evidence relating to BUG15's fear of persecution, particularly concerning the specific circumstances of their alleged past experiences and the potential for future harm. The Court held that this failure constituted a jurisdictional error, as it meant the delegate had not undertaken the assessment required by the relevant legislation. The principle applied was that a failure to properly consider all relevant evidence and apply the correct legal framework in assessing a protection visa application can lead to a finding of jurisdictional error.

The Court quashed the decision of the Minister and remitted the application for a protection visa to the Minister for redetermination according to law.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of BUG15 v Minister for Immigration concerns an application for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal). The applicant, a child born in Australia and a citizen of the People's Republic of China, seeks a Protection (Class XA) visa. His claims for protection were presented by his mother, who stated that the applicant would face persecution if returned to China due to his parents' Christianity and because he was born in contravention of China's birth-control policy. According to her, the family is unable to register their marriage in China because they hold an Australian marriage certificate and are thus subject to fines for breaching the family planning policy. Failure to pay these fines would result in the applicant becoming a "black baby" without legal status and facing discrimination in various aspects of life, including education and medical care. The mother also claimed that local government in Fujian province employs brutal measures to punish those who fail to pay penalties for breaches of the birth-control policy, including forced contraceptive operations.

The Tribunal did not find the applicant's mother to be a credible witness and was not satisfied that the applicant would face persecution for the reasons claimed. The Tribunal found inconsistencies in her testimony and a lack of corroborative evidence. The Tribunal was also not convinced that the applicant's parents would be imprisoned for breaching family planning laws or that they would be unable to pay any fines imposed. The Tribunal further considered the applicant's claims against the complementary protection criterion but was not satisfied there was a real risk of significant harm if the applicant were returned to China. The applicant's mother made further claims at the hearing, including that she suffered from Hepatitis B and would be discriminated against in China for that reason, but the Tribunal was not satisfied that this would result in serious harm to the applicant.

The applicant's application for review contained three grounds, focusing on alleged failures by the Tribunal to consider certain claims and to provide supported evidence. The applicant's mother argued that the Tribunal did not properly consider whether the parents could pay any fines imposed and did not identify the basis for finding they had greater financial capacity than claimed. The Tribunal, however, had reasonably considered the parents' ability to support themselves and the two children in Australia, as well as country information on penalty payment options. The Tribunal also did not err in inferring that the parents' ability to make income in Australia indicated they had the opportunity to make sufficient income in China. Finally, the applicant's mother claimed the Tribunal did not give her an opportunity to respond to questions, but the Tribunal had fairly sought to confirm its understanding of her responses and did not prevent her from explaining her position.

This case came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia as an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The applicant, a young child and citizen of the People's Republic of China, sought to challenge the AAT's decision to affirm the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection's refusal to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa. Represented by an interpreter, the applicant argued that the AAT had failed to properly consider several aspects of the protection claims made on their behalf. The Minister for Immigration and Border Protection was represented by Mr. T Hillyard of Sparke Helmore Lawyers. The case proceeded on the basis of the applicant's three grounds for review, which were all ultimately dismissed by the Court. The applicant's first ground alleged that the AAT failed to consider the financial capacity of the applicant's parents to pay any penalties imposed by China for breaching the family planning policy. However, the Court found that the AAT had adequately considered the financial capacity of the applicant's parents, taking into account their ability to support themselves and their children in Australia. The second ground alleged that the AAT made findings without supported evidence, specifically concerning the applicant's parents' ability to make income in China. Again, the Court found that the AAT's conclusions were reasonably open to them, based on the evidence presented. The third ground alleged that the AAT failed to give the applicant's mother an opportunity to respond to questions, instead interrupting her and asking for "yes or no" answers. However, the Court found that the AAT member's manner of questioning was fair and aimed at clarifying the applicant's mother's statements.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Tribunal fail to consider a claim that clearly arose on the information before it regarding the applicant’s parents’ capacity to pay any financial penalty in China?
2. Did the Tribunal err in arriving at a conclusion without supported evidence concerning the applicant’s parents’ financial capacity?
3. Did the Tribunal fail to give the applicant an opportunity to respond to the questions asked during the hearing?
4. Was the Tribunal’s assessment of the applicant’s mother’s credibility and the claims she made for the applicant’s protection justified?
5. Did the Tribunal err in its interpretation of country information regarding the risks of persecution for the applicant based on his parents' alleged breaches of China’s family planning policy and religious practices?
6. Was the Tribunal’s decision to not grant the applicant a protection visa in accordance with the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s.36(2)(aa) justified?

Held
1. Did the Tribunal fail to consider a claim that clearly arose on the information before it regarding the applicant’s parents’ capacity to pay any financial penalty in China?
The court concluded that the Tribunal did consider whether the applicant’s parents had a real capacity to pay any fine that may be imposed. The Tribunal found the parents had access to more financial capacity than they claimed. The court held that the Tribunal’s conclusion was not a jurisdictional error.

2. Did the Tribunal err in arriving at a conclusion without supported evidence concerning the applicant’s parents’ financial capacity?
The court found that the Tribunal reasonably concluded that the applicant’s parents would have the ability to pay any penalty that may be imposed for breaching the family planning law. The court held that the Tribunal did not err in arriving at its conclusion without supported evidence.

3. Did the Tribunal fail to give the applicant an opportunity to respond to the questions asked during the hearing?
The court concluded that there was no unfairness in the Tribunal asking the applicant to answer “yes or no.” The Tribunal member acted fairly in the manner in which he conducted the hearing. The court held that the Tribunal did not fail to give the applicant an opportunity to respond to the questions asked.

4. Was the Tribunal’s assessment of the applicant’s mother’s credibility and the claims she made for the applicant’s protection justified?
The court did not provide a specific holding on this issue. However, the court did not find any jurisdictional error in the Tribunal’s assessment of the applicant’s mother’s credibility and the claims she made for the applicant’s protection.

5. Did the Tribunal err in its interpretation of country information regarding the risks of persecution for the applicant based on his parents' alleged breaches of China’s family planning policy and religious practices?
The court did not provide a specific holding on this issue. However, the court did not find any jurisdictional error in the Tribunal’s interpretation of country information.

6. Was the Tribunal’s decision to not grant the applicant a protection visa in accordance with the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s.36(2)(aa) justified?
The court concluded that the Tribunal’s decision to not grant the applicant a protection visa was in accordance with the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s.36(2)(aa) and was not a jurisdictional error. The court held that the applicant’s claims did not meet the complementary protection criterion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court thoroughly examined the grounds of the applicant’s appeal, focusing on the procedural and substantive fairness of the Tribunal’s decisions. Firstly, concerning the Tribunal's alleged failure to consider the parents’ capacity to pay any financial penalties in China, the court found that the Tribunal had indeed considered this issue. The Tribunal concluded that the parents had access to more financial capacity than claimed, based on their ability to travel to and study in Australia, and their sustained residence and employment in Australia. The Tribunal referred to country information indicating that penalties could be paid by instalments, which further supported its conclusion. Therefore, the Tribunal did not commit a jurisdictional error by not considering this aspect adequately.

Secondly, the court reviewed whether the Tribunal erred in arriving at its conclusion without supported evidence. The Tribunal inferred that the parents had the financial capacity to pay any penalties from their ability to earn income in Australia. The court held that this inference was reasonable given the evidence before the Tribunal, including the father’s employment as a gyp-rocker and the family’s ability to travel and study in Australia. The court concluded that the Tribunal's findings were not unsupported and did not constitute a jurisdictional error.

Thirdly, the court assessed whether the Tribunal failed to give the applicant an opportunity to respond to questions asked during the hearing. The applicant’s mother claimed that the Tribunal interrupted her and asked only for yes or no answers. However, the court found that the Tribunal’s approach was to clarify its understanding of the applicant’s mother’s statements. The court found no unfairness in this method and held that the Tribunal conducted the hearing fairly, providing the applicant’s mother with ample opportunity to explain and respond to the questions.

Fourthly, the court evaluated the Tribunal’s assessment of the applicant’s mother’s credibility and her claims for the applicant’s protection. The Tribunal found that the applicant’s mother’s claims about her Christian activities and her understanding of religious practices were either embellished or fabricated. The court supported the Tribunal's findings, noting inconsistencies in the mother's statements and a lack of corroborative evidence. The court concluded that the Tribunal’s assessment of the mother’s credibility was justified.

Fifthly, the court examined the Tribunal's interpretation of country information regarding the risks of persecution for the applicant based on his parents' alleged breaches of China’s family planning policy and religious practices. The Tribunal did not accept that the applicant’s parents would face persecution or that the applicant would suffer significant harm if returned to China. The court agreed with the Tribunal's interpretation, finding that the country information supported the conclusion that there was no real chance of persecution based on the claims made.

Finally, the court considered whether the Tribunal’s decision not to grant the applicant a protection visa was justified under s.36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The Tribunal concluded that there were no substantial grounds for believing that the applicant would suffer significant harm if returned to China. The court found that the Tribunal's conclusion was supported by the evidence and country information, and therefore, the decision not to grant the applicant a protection visa was justified.

In conclusion, the court held that the Tribunal did not commit any jurisdictional error in its decisions. The Tribunal’s reasoning was thorough, its findings supported by evidence, and its assessment of the applicant’s mother’s credibility and the risks of persecution was justified. The court dismissed the applicant’s application for judicial review.