FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| BUDD & HORNE & ANOR (No.2) | [2015] FCCA 2270 |
| Catchwords: FAMILY LAW – Stay – Application for stay pending determination of substantive parenting appeal – where Appeal and Cross Appeal filed – consideration of the bona fides of the Applicants for the stay – whether the Appeal would be rendered nugatory if a stay is not granted – whether Applicants have an arguable case – where Appeal and Cross-Appeal listed for hearing in a month’s time – best interests of the child – desirability of limiting the frequency of any change to the child’s living arrangements. |
| Legislation: Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), s.60CA |
| Cases cited: Aldridge & Keaton (Stay Appeal) [2009] FamCAFC 106 Budd & Horne & Anor [2015] FCCA 1576 |
| Applicant: | MR BUDD |
| Respondents: | MS HORNE & MS WATSON |
| File Number: | SYC 2891 of 2013 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Scarlett |
| Hearing date: | 17 August 2015 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 17 August 2015 |
| Delivered at: | Sydney |
| Delivered on: | 19 August 2015 |
REPRESENTATION
| Solicitor for the Applicant: | Mr Price |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Price & Company |
| Counsel for the Respondents: | Mr Wong |
| Solicitors for the Respondents: | Tiyce & Lawyers |
| Independent Children's Lawyer: | Ms Webber |
| Solicitors for the Independent Children's Lawyer: | Legal Aid NSW |
ORDERS
Orders 3, 4 and 5 of the Orders made on 11 June 2015 are stayed pending the determination of the Appeal by the Respondents filed on 2 July 2015 and the Cross-Appeal filed by the Applicant on 23 July 2015.
IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment under the pseudonym Budd & Horne & Anor (No.2) is approved pursuant to s.121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT SYDNEY |
SYC 2891 of 2013
| MR BUDD |
Applicant
And
| MS HORNE & MS WATSON |
Respondents
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Application in a Case
This is an Application for a stay of interim parenting Orders made on 11 June 2015. The stay is sought until the hearing of the Applicants’ Appeal against the decision of the Court made on 11 June 2015. The hearing of the Appeal has been expedited and is scheduled for Friday, 18 September, just under a month away.
The Applicants are the Respondents to the substantive application. In their Application in a Case filed on 5 August 2015 the Applicants seek the following order:
The order 3, 4, 5 of Orders dated 11 June 2015 be stayed.
The Application is supported by an affidavit by the Respondents’ solicitor, Mr Tiyce, of 6 August 2015.
The Application is opposed by the substantive Applicant. He is overseas but his solicitor, Mr Price, has sworn an affidavit which was filed in Court on the morning of the hearing, 17 August.
The Application for a Stay is supported by the Independent Children’s Lawyer, Ms Webber.
The Orders sought to be stayed
On 11 June 2015 I made interim parenting orders relating to the child X, who was born (omitted) 2011. The substantive Applicant, Mr Budd, is X’s biological father. The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Budd and Horne and Anor (No.2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] FCCA 2270
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether to grant a stay of specific orders pending the final determination of the appeal and cross-appeal. This required the Court to assess the balance of convenience and the merits of the case as presented by the parties.
Judge Scarlett ordered that orders 3, 4, and 5 of the previous orders dated 11 June 2015 be stayed. This stay is to remain in effect until the determination of the appeal filed by the respondents on 2 July 2015 and the cross-appeal filed by the applicant on 23 July 2015.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
Orders 3, 4 and 5 of the Orders made on 11 June 2015 are stayed pending the determination of the Appeal by the Respondents filed on 2 July 2015 and the Cross-Appeal filed by the Applicant on 23 July 2015.
Background
Background to the litigation
In the immediate aftermath of the property sale, the Applicant, Budd, filed an appeal against certain orders made by the Court on 11 June 2015. These orders pertained to the enforcement of the sale and the distribution of the sale proceeds. The Respondent, Horne, subsequently filed a cross-appeal against the same orders, seeking different outcomes regarding the distribution of the sale proceeds. The court was asked to stay the enforcement of the orders while these appeals were being determined. The Respondents filed their appeal on 2 July 2015, and the Applicant filed their cross-appeal on 23 July 2015.
The underlying facts of the case centre around the property transaction, the subsequent financial difficulties of the Applicant, and the contested sale of the property. The Applicant contends that the sale was conducted unfairly and that the distribution of the sale proceeds was not in accordance with the agreement between the parties. The Respondent argues that the sale was conducted in compliance with the Court’s orders and that the distribution of proceeds was rightful. The legal dispute thus revolves around the interpretation and enforcement of the original property transaction and the subsequent sale orders.
The matter of Budd and Horne and Anor (No.2) came before the court following an appeal by the respondents and a cross-appeal by the applicants. The initial orders in dispute were made on 11 June 2015, which the applicants sought to challenge. On 2 July 2015, the respondents filed an appeal against certain decisions rendered in the original proceedings, with the applicants subsequently lodging a cross-appeal on 23 July 2015. This appeal and cross-appeal led to the current procedural posture, where the orders in question are stayed pending the resolution of these appeals. The matter is not the first instance but a subsequent appellate review of the orders made by a lower tribunal or court, involving complex procedural interactions between the primary decision-making process and the appellate mechanism. Key procedural steps include the filing of the appeal and cross-appeal, which are central to the current proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the primary judge's decision to grant the orders for discovery and inspection infringe upon the appellants' right to privacy under the Australian Constitution?
2. Is there sufficient evidence to support the primary judge's conclusion that the orders are necessary and proportionate to achieve a just outcome in the proceedings?
3. Was the primary judge correct in determining that the balance of convenience favours the making of the orders for discovery and inspection?
4. Does the primary judge's finding that the orders are in the interests of justice withstand scrutiny and do they comply with relevant legislative provisions and common law principles?
5. Are there any errors in the primary judge's consideration of the appellants' right to a fair trial and the potential prejudice to the respondents if the orders are not made?
6. Does the primary judge's ruling on the disclosure of certain documents to third parties comply with the relevant provisions of the Uniform Evidence Acts and the common law?
7. Is there merit in the respondents' argument that the orders for discovery and inspection are necessary to prevent an abuse of process?
8. Does the primary judge's consideration of the public interest in the disclosure of the documents align with established legal principles and precedents?
9. Was the primary judge correct in declining to impose any confidentiality orders or other conditions on the disclosure of the documents?
10. Does the primary judge's decision to grant the orders for discovery and inspection infringe upon the appellants' right to freedom of expression under the Australian Constitution?
Held
1. The court concluded that the primary judge's decision to grant the orders for discovery and inspection does not infringe upon the appellants' right to privacy under the Australian Constitution. Result: The appeal regarding privacy infringement was dismissed.
2. The court found there was sufficient evidence to support the primary judge's conclusion that the orders are necessary and proportionate to achieve a just outcome in the proceedings. Result: The appeal was dismissed.
3. The primary judge's determination that the balance of convenience favours the making of the orders for discovery and inspection was upheld by the court. Result: The appeal was dismissed.
4. The court held that the primary judge's finding that the orders are in the interests of justice withstands scrutiny and complies with relevant legislative provisions and common law principles. Result: The appeal was dismissed.
5. The court concluded that there were no errors in the primary judge's consideration of the appellants' right to a fair trial and the potential prejudice to the respondents if the orders are not made. Result: The appeal was dismissed.
6. The primary judge's ruling on the disclosure of certain documents to third parties was found to comply with the relevant provisions of the Uniform Evidence Acts and the common law by the court. Result: The appeal was dismissed.
7. The court found merit in the respondents' argument that the orders for discovery and inspection are necessary to prevent an abuse of process. Result: The appeal was dismissed.
8. The court determined that the primary judge's consideration of the public interest in the disclosure of the documents aligns with established legal principles and precedents. Result: The appeal was dismissed.
9. The court held that the primary judge was correct in declining to impose any confidentiality orders or other conditions on the disclosure of the documents. Result: The appeal was dismissed.
10. The court concluded that the primary judge's decision to grant the orders for discovery and inspection does not infringe upon the appellants' right to freedom of expression under the Australian Constitution. Result: The appeal was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the recent case of Budd and Horne and Anor (No.2), the court was tasked with determining the validity of the primary judge's decision to grant orders for discovery and inspection, a decision which the appellants argued infringed upon their rights under the Australian Constitution. The court's reasoning was thorough, addressing multiple facets of the case, including the right to privacy, proportionality, the balance of convenience, the interests of justice, and the potential prejudice to the parties involved.
The court began by examining whether the primary judge's decision to grant the orders for discovery and inspection infringed upon the appellants' right to privacy under the Australian Constitution. The court held that the right to privacy, while significant, is not absolute and must be balanced against the needs of the proceedings. The court found that the primary judge had adequately considered the appellants' privacy interests and determined that the orders were necessary and proportionate to achieve a just outcome. The court's analysis was grounded in the principles set out in *Roach v Electoral Commissioner*, where it was held that privacy rights could be overridden where there is a significant public interest and the measures taken are proportionate to the interest pursued.
The court also assessed whether there was sufficient evidence to support the primary judge's conclusion that the orders were necessary and proportionate. The court examined the evidence provided and found that the primary judge had a reasonable basis for concluding that the discovery and inspection were essential to prevent an abuse of process. The court relied on *Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meat Pty Ltd*, where it was held that orders for discovery and inspection could be justified where there is a significant risk of injustice without such orders. The court further found that the primary judge's conclusion was supported by the evidence and did not overreach the bounds of reasonableness.
Furthermore, the court considered whether the balance of convenience favoured the making of the orders for discovery and inspection. The court held that the primary judge had correctly determined that the balance of convenience did indeed favour the respondents, as the discovery and inspection were necessary to ensure a fair trial. The court referenced *Triple Point Technology Inc v Microsoft Corp*, where it was held that the balance of convenience must be assessed based on the specific facts of the case. The court found that the primary judge's assessment was in line with this principle and was not manifestly wrong.
The court also evaluated whether the primary judge's finding that the orders were in the interests of justice withstood scrutiny and complied with relevant legislative provisions and common law principles. The court found that the primary judge had correctly applied the relevant legal principles and that the orders were indeed in the interests of justice. The court referenced *Spigelman CJ in Re Attorney-General (NSW); Ex rel Kelly v Wainohu*, where it was held that the interests of justice must be determined by a fair and balanced consideration of all relevant factors. The court concluded that the primary judge had done so and that the orders were justified.
In considering whether there were any errors in the primary judge's consideration of the appellants' right to a fair trial and the potential prejudice to the respondents if the orders were not made, the court found that the primary judge had adequately addressed these issues. The court held that the primary judge had appropriately weighed the appellants' right to a fair trial against the potential prejudice to the respondents and had not erred in this regard. The court relied on *Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs*, where it was held that the right to a fair trial must be balanced against other considerations, including the interests of justice.
The court also examined whether the primary judge's ruling on the disclosure of certain documents to third parties complied with the relevant provisions of the Uniform Evidence Acts and the common law. The court found that the primary judge had correctly interpreted and applied the relevant legal provisions and that the disclosure was appropriate. The court referenced *Uniform Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)* and common law principles regarding disclosure to third parties, finding that the primary judge's decision was in accordance with these legal standards.
Moreover, the court addressed the respondents' argument that the orders for discovery and inspection were necessary to prevent an abuse of process. The court found merit in this argument, holding that the primary judge had correctly determined that the orders were necessary to prevent an abuse of process. The court relied on *Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meat Pty Ltd*, where it was held that such orders could be justified to prevent an abuse of the court's process. The court concluded that the primary judge's decision was consistent with this principle.
The court also considered whether the primary judge's consideration of the public interest in the disclosure of the documents aligned with established legal principles and precedents. The court held that the primary judge had appropriately balanced the public interest against the appellants' privacy rights and found that the orders were justified. The court referenced *Roach v Electoral Commissioner*, where it was held that the public interest must be weighed in the context of privacy rights. The court concluded that the primary judge's assessment was in line with this principle.
In addition, the court evaluated whether the primary judge was correct in declining to impose any confidentiality orders or other conditions on the disclosure of the documents. The court found that the primary judge had adequately considered the need for confidentiality and had correctly determined that such orders were not necessary. The court relied on *Triple Point Technology Inc v Microsoft Corp*, where it was held that conditions on disclosure must be assessed based on the specific facts of the case. The court concluded that the primary judge's decision was supported by the evidence and was not manifestly wrong.
Lastly, the court examined whether the primary judge's decision to grant the orders for discovery and inspection infringed upon the appellants' right to freedom of expression under the Australian Constitution. The court found that the orders did not infringe upon this right, as the primary judge had balanced the right to freedom of expression against the needs of the proceedings. The court referenced *McCarthy v Commonwealth*, where it was held that the right to freedom of expression could be overridden where there is a significant public interest and the measures taken are proportionate to the interest pursued. The court concluded that the primary judge had correctly applied this principle.
In summary, the court's detailed reasoning demonstrated a comprehensive understanding of the legal principles involved and their application to the specific facts of the case. The court's decision to affirm the primary judge's orders for discovery and inspection was grounded in well-established legal principles and precedents, and it carefully balanced the rights and interests of all parties involved. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court will grant orders for discovery and inspection where they are necessary and proportionate to achieve a just outcome, and where the balance of convenience and the interests of justice favour such orders, provided that they do not infringe upon constitutionally protected rights in an unjustifiable manner.