BUDARICK & ANOR v DISTRICT COUNCIL OF ELLISTON & ANOR
[2001] SASC 184Land and Valuation Division
DEBELLE J. This is an application for judicial review of a decision of a Council granting development approval to the erection of a dwelling which involved the placing of a substantial amount of filling on land. The application was heard on 14 May 2001. At the completion of the hearing I stated my decision save for the question of costs. I said I would publish reasons. These are the reasons.
The plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Budarick (“the Budaricks”), own a holiday house at Venus Bay on Eyre Peninsula. Venus Bay is a township within the area of the District Council of Elliston (“the Council”). It is zoned Country Township by the Development Plan which applies to the Council area. The Budaricks’ house is about 150 to 200 metres from the coastline and until February 2000 enjoyed sweeping views over Venus Bay.
The second defendants, Mr and Mrs Lamkin (“the Lamkins”), own a block of land adjacent to the Budaricks’ house at Venus Bay. The land owned by the Lamkins is a larger allotment than the land owned by the Budaricks. Both parcels have a frontage to Sandham Street, Venus Bay. The level of the allotments falls towards the sea from the frontage to Sandham Street.
An Application to Fill Land and Erect a Dwelling
On 6 December 1999 the Lamkins lodged an application with the Council to construct on their land what the application described as a “private dwelling”. The plans lodged with the application showed the application was, not only to erect a dwelling but also, to introduce a substantial amount of filling on to the land. The filling was intended to level almost the whole of the Lamkins’ land to the same level as the level at the front of the land. In other words, instead of the land sloping down to the rear, it was to be filled to about the same level as the front of the land. On the hearing of this application, it was common ground that in excess of 600 cubic metres of filling was to be used. The dwelling was to be a transportable dwelling.
Council Grants Development Approval
The Council dealt with the application on the footing that it was for a Category 1 development. It, therefore, did not give notice of the intended development to any person. The minutes of the Council disclose that the Council was aware of the intended filling. It approved both the erection of the dwelling and the filling at its meeting on 22 December 1999. It orally informed the Lamkins of the decision on either 22 or 23 December. By notice dated 14 January 2000, the Council gave the Lamkins written notice that development approval had been granted. The nature of the development was described as “Transportable Dwelling”. The Budaricks were entirely unaware either that the development was intended or that it had been approved.
On 7 February…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Budarick v District Council of Elliston and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] SASC 184
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the introduction of filling on the Lamkins' land constituted development under the Act and required approval. The classification of the development as a Category 3, necessitating public notice, was correct as the filling was not of minor nature and likely to face objections. The Council's failure to classify the development correctly and provide notice led to the grant of approval being liable to be set aside. However, exercising its discretion, the Court declined to quash the approval due to the Lamkins' substantial investment in the project and the Budaricks' delay in taking action. Instead, the Court made declarations regarding the correct classification of the development and ordered the Council to pay the Lamkins' costs.
The final orders included declarations that the development was a Category 3 development and that the Council should have given notice of it to the Budaricks. The application was otherwise dismissed, and the Council was ordered to pay the Lamkins' costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case before the South Australian Supreme Court is an application for judicial review of a decision made by the District Council of Elliston to grant development approval for the construction of a dwelling, which involved the placement of a substantial amount of filling on adjacent land. The application was brought by Mr and Mrs Budarick who own a holiday house at Venus Bay, which is in the area of the District Council of Elliston. The Budaricks sought judicial review of the Council's decision to approve the development without providing them notice, as required under the Development Act 1993. The case was heard on 14 May 2001, and the court delivered its decision on the same day, reserving the matter of costs for later determination. The Budaricks argued that the Council failed to classify the development correctly, resulting in the need for public notice which was not given, thus rendering the approval process unlawful. The court found that the development was indeed a Category 3 development, requiring public notice, and that the Council's failure to provide such notice meant the approval could be set aside. However, the court exercised its discretion not to quash the approval due to the significant prejudice it would cause to the respondents, the Lamkins, who had already constructed the dwelling and made significant improvements to the site. The court did, however, grant the Budaricks declaratory relief, confirming the classification of the development and the requirement for notice. The court also addressed the issue of costs, determining that the Council should bear the Lamkins' costs due to their role in initiating the litigation.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the introduction of filling on to the land, as part of the Lamkins' development application, properly classified as a Category 3 development requiring public notice?
2. Did the Council err in not giving public notice of the Lamkins' development to the Budaricks as adjoining property owners?
3. Does the delay in the Budaricks instituting legal proceedings affect their entitlement to the relief they seek?
4. Does the court have the discretion to quash the Council's grant of development approval despite the Lamkins having already erected the dwelling and placed the fill on their land?
5. If the court chooses not to quash the development approval, what declarations can be made to address the Budaricks' grievances without unduly prejudicing the Lamkins?
6. Should the Council be liable to pay the costs of the Lamkins, or should the Budaricks bear their own costs as unsuccessful applicants?
7. Are there broader implications for planning authorities in correctly classifying developments involving excavation or filling?
Held
1. The introduction of filling on to the land, as part of the Lamkins' development application, was properly classified as a Category 3 development requiring public notice.
2. The Council erred in not giving public notice of the Lamkins' development to the Budaricks as adjoining property owners.
3. The delay in the Budaricks instituting legal proceedings affects their entitlement to the relief they seek.
4. The court does not have the discretion to quash the Council's grant of development approval despite the Lamkins having already erected the dwelling and placed the fill on their land.
5. The court can make declarations to address the Budaricks' grievances without unduly prejudicing the Lamkins, such as declaring the development as a Category 3 development and that the Council should have given public notice.
6. The Council should be liable to pay the costs of the Lamkins as their conduct caused this litigation.
7. Planning authorities need to correctly classify developments involving excavation or filling, as incorrect classification can result in legal liability.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: DEBELLE J
The first issue before the court was whether the introduction of filling onto the Lamkins' land as part of their development application was properly classified as a Category 3 development requiring public notice. The court held that the filling was development, as defined in section 4 of the Development Act, because it was incidental to the construction of a building. Since the construction of a dwelling in a Country Township Zone is a complying development, the court considered whether the filling should be regarded as a separate development. The court concluded that the filling was a Category 3 development, as it did not fall within the prescribed Category 1 or Category 2 developments in Schedule 9 of the Development Regulations 1993. The court also noted that the filling was not of a minor nature and was likely to be the subject of reasonable objection from adjoining property owners, as required for a Category 1 development.
The second issue was whether the Council erred in not giving public notice of the Lamkins' development to the Budaricks as adjoining property owners. The court found that the Council was required to classify the development as a Category 3 development and give public notice to the Budaricks, as it did not do so, the development approval granted to the Lamkins is liable to be set aside.
The third issue was whether the delay in the Budaricks instituting legal proceedings affects their entitlement to the relief they seek. The court held that the Budaricks were out of time in instituting this application but found it appropriate to extend the time within which to commence the proceedings to 1 October 2000. The court considered the delay in instituting proceedings relevant to the question of whether the Budaricks were entitled to the relief they sought.
The fourth issue was whether the court has the discretion to quash the Council's grant of development approval despite the Lamkins having already erected the dwelling and placed the fill on their land. The court held that while it was possible to frame declarations to address the Budaricks' grievances without unduly prejudiscing the Lamkins, it would not be appropriate to make any order which invalidates the development approval provided to the Lamkins. The court considered the prejudice to both parties and the Budaricks' delay in instituting legal proceedings.
The fifth issue was if the court chooses not to quash the development approval, what declarations can be made to address the Budaricks' grievances without unduly prejudicing the Lamkins. The court made declarations stating that the development was a Category 3 development and that the Council should have classified the development as such.
The sixth issue was whether the Council should be liable to pay the costs of the Lamkins, or whether the Budaricks should bear their own costs as unsuccessful applicants. The court held that the Council should bear the Lamkins' costs of the application as the Council's conduct directly caused the litigation, and it was not entitled to an order for costs as it failed in defending its action.
The seventh issue was whether there are broader implications for planning authorities in correctly classifying developments involving excavation or filling. The court highlighted the need for planning authorities to give closer attention to the question of excavation and filling when considering applications for development consent. It noted that both excavation and filling are a form of development and require development consent or approval. Planning authorities must consider whether they constitute a Category 1 or a Category 3 development and consider the further controls in Schedule 2 of the Development Regulations. If a planning authority negligently fails to assign the correct classification to a development with adverse consequences to a party, the planning authority may be liable to a party who suffers loss in consequence.