Budage Pty Ltd ATF Tonclay Services Trust v Melhopt

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL PANEL
CITATION: Budage Pty Ltd ATF Tonclay Services Trust v Melhopt [2024] NSWPICMP 567
APPELLANT: Budage Pty Limited ATF Tonclay Services Trust
RESPONDENT: Noel Melhopt
APPEAL PANEL
MEMBER: John Wynyard
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Michael Hong
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Douglas Andrews
DATE OF DECISION: 14 August 2024
CATCHWORDS: 

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Appeal by employer from 19% whole person impairment (WPI) for psychiatric injury: whether Medical Assessor (MA) gave adequate reasons regarding the psychiatric impairment rating scale (PIRS) categories of social and recreational activities, travel, concentration persistence and pace and employability; Held – reasons contradictory and not adequately explained as to social and recreational activities; MA considered motivation rather than behavioural consequences; MA failed to consider the volunteer work by claimant; rating in employability contradicted by the amount of volunteer work being performed by the claimant; factual errors are not explained adequately; Medical Assessment Certificate revoked.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION TO APPEAL

  1. On 28 March 2024, the appellant, Budage Pty Limited ATF Tonclay Services Trust, the appellant employer, lodged an Application to Appeal Against the Decision of a Medical Assessor. The medical dispute was assessed by Dr Gerard Walsh, a Medical Assessor, who issued a Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) on 1 March 2024.

  2. The appellant relies on the following grounds of appeal under s 327(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (the 1998 Act):

    ·        the assessment was made on the basis of incorrect criteria, and

    ·        the MAC contains a demonstrable error.

  3. The delegate is satisfied that, on the face of the application, at least one ground of appeal has been made out. The Appeal Panel has conducted a review of the original medical assessment but limited to the ground(s) of appeal on which the appeal is made.

  4. Rule 128 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 (the PIC Rules) and Procedural Direction PIC7 - Appeals, reviews, reconsiderations and correction of obvious errors in medical disputes set out the practice and procedure in relation to the medical appeal process under s 328 of the 1998 Act. An Appeal Panel determines its own procedures in accordance with r 128(1) of the PIC Rules.

  5. The assessment of permanent impairment is conducted in accordance with the SIRA NSW Workers Compensation Guidelines for the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 4th ed
    1 March 2021 (the Guides) and the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 5th ed (AMA 5). “WPI” is reference to whole person impairment.

RELEVANT FACTUAL BACKGROUND

  1. On 24 January 2024 this matter was referred for an assessment of WPI caused by psychiatric and psychological injury which were deemed to have occurred on
    13 December 2022.  

  2. Mr Melhopt was employed as a Senior Technical Specialist with the respondent when he was injured by the bullying and harassment of his employer’s management and colleagues.

  3. The Medical Assessor found 19% WPI.

PRELIMINARY REVIEW

  1. The Appeal Panel conducted a preliminary review of the original medical assessment in the absence of the parties and in accordance with the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Budage Pty Ltd ATF Tonclay Services Trust v Melhopt and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPICMP 567
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Budage Pty Ltd ATF Tonclay Services Trust v Melhopt involved a dispute concerning the assessment of a 19% whole person impairment (WPI) for psychiatric injury by a Medical Assessor (MA). The dispute was brought to the court by the employer, who was seeking clarification and a review of the MA's assessment. The legal issues at the heart of this case revolved around whether the MA provided sufficient and coherent reasons for the ratings assigned under the psychiatric impairment rating scale (PIRS), particularly in relation to the categories of social and recreational activities, travel, concentration persistence and pace, and employability.

The court was tasked with examining whether the MA's reasons were adequately explained, whether the MA had correctly considered the impact of the psychiatric injury on the claimant's life, and whether there were factual errors in the assessment that were not properly addressed. The court found that the MA's reasons were contradictory and not sufficiently explained, particularly in relation to social and recreational activities and employability. The court identified that the MA had considered the claimant's motivation rather than the behavioural consequences of the psychiatric injury, which is not in line with the requirements of the PIRS. Furthermore, the MA failed to consider the claimant's volunteer work, which was substantial and relevant to the employability assessment. The court also found that the employability rating contradicted the amount of volunteer work being performed by the claimant.

In light of these findings, the court revoked the Medical Assessment Certificate. The decision underscored the necessity for Medical Assessors to provide clear, consistent, and comprehensive reasons that align with the criteria set out in the psychiatric impairment rating scale. The revocation of the certificate highlights the importance of ensuring that psychiatric injury assessments are conducted with due diligence and in accordance with the relevant guidelines. The final orders of the court were that the Medical Assessment Certificate be revoked and the matter be referred back for reassessment, ensuring that all relevant factors are properly considered and explained.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established