| CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER | |
| CITATION: | Buckley v Rivalea (Australia) Pty Ltd [2021] NSWPIC 62 |
| APPLICANT: | Douglas Buckley |
| RESPONDENT: | Rivalea (Australia) Pty Ltd |
| MEMBER: | Mr Paul Sweeney |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 6 April 2021 |
| CATCHWORDS: | WORKERS COMPENSATION- Worker employed by respondent for 28 years claims cost of proposed total hip replacement; where conflicting evidence as to nature of worker’s employment; where worker ceased to perform work, which could aggravate arthritis several years before his hip became symptomatic; where applicant’s medical case assumes an incorrect history; Held- finding that applicant had not established injury; award for the respondent. |
| DETERMINATIONS MADE: | 1. The applicant has not established that the need for right hip surgery proposed by Dr Kirwan results from employment injury. 2. Award for the Respondent |
STATEMENT OF REASONS
INTRODUCTION
Rivalea (Australia) Pty Ltd (the respondent) is an agri-business company engaged in the breeding and raising of pigs. It operates an abattoir at Corowa which processes pig carcasses. Douglas Buckley (the applicant) has worked for the respondent for 28 years. He has been promoted on several occasions. He commenced employment as a casual labourer at the abattoir in 1992. He is currently employed as the retail accounts manager.
For some time, the applicant has experienced pain in his right hip. In December 2019, Dr Kirwan, his treating orthopaedic surgeon, recommended that he undergo right total hip replacement.
The applicant alleges that the nature of his employment materially aggravated the osteoarthritic condition of his right hip and that his need for hip replacement surgery results from that injury. The respondent denies that the need for surgery results from employment injury. Its denial of liability is primarily based upon the opinion of Dr Richard Powell, an orthopaedic surgeon, who saw the applicant and provided reports dated 3 February 2020 and 11 August 2020.
PROCEDURE BEFORE THE COMMISSION
When this matter came on for conciliation and arbitration on 9 March 2021, Mr Alan Parker, of counsel, represented the applicant and Mr Robertson, of counsel, represented the respondent. I was informed by counsel that the parties were unable to reach agreement on the threshold question of whether the need for right hip replacement surgery resulted from employment injury. I am satisfied that the parties, who were represented by experienced counsel, had ample opportunity to consider settlement but were unable to reach a mutually satisfactory resolution. The arbitration hearing was heard over the telephone.
By these proceedings the applicant claims the cost of right hip replacement surgery proposed by Dr Kirwan pursuant to s 60(5) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act).
EVIDENCE
The following documents were admitted into evidence:
(a) Application to Resolve a Dispute and attached documents; and
(b) An Application to Admit Late Documents enclosing the respondent’s Reply and the documents attached.
There was no objection to any of the material referred to above. Neither side sought to adduce further written or oral evidence at the arbitration hearing. It was agreed, however, that Angela Webb, the current boning room supervisor at the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Buckley v Rivalea (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWPIC 62
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the evidence presented regarding Buckley's employment and its impact on his hip condition. Buckley's case relied on a specific employment history that the court found to be incorrect. The court also noted that Buckley had ceased working several years before his hip became symptomatic, which could have aggravated his arthritis. The court concluded that Buckley had not provided sufficient evidence to establish a causal link between his employment and his condition. As a result, the court dismissed Buckley's claim and ordered him to pay the respondent's costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The employer, Rivalea (Australia) Pty Ltd, disputes Buckley's claim, arguing that he did not establish that his employment caused or significantly contributed to his hip condition. The employer contends that Buckley's condition could have been caused by factors unrelated to his employment and that his ceasing to perform physically demanding work several years before his hip became symptomatic weakens his claim.
The case came before the court for determination of Buckley's claim for the cost of a proposed total hip replacement against his former employer, Rivalea (Australia) Pty Ltd. The matter was heard following Buckley's application for compensation under the workers' compensation laws. Prior to this hearing, there were no relevant prior decisions, tribunals, or courts involved in the dispute. Key procedural steps included the filing of Buckley's application for compensation, the exchange of evidence and medical reports, and the presentation of arguments by both parties. The court was required to assess the credibility of the conflicting evidence and determine whether Buckley had established that his employment caused or significantly contributed to his hip condition.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did Buckley establish that his employment with Rivalea (Australia) Pty Ltd caused or significantly contributed to his hip condition necessitating a total hip replacement?
2. Is Buckley's medical case based on an incorrect history of his employment, and how does this affect his claim?
3. Does Buckley's cessation of physically demanding work several years before his hip became symptomatic weaken his claim for compensation?
Held
1. Buckley did not establish that his employment with Rivalea (Australia) Pty Ltd caused or significantly contributed to his hip condition necessitating a total hip replacement.
2. Buckley's medical case is based on an incorrect history of his employment, which affects his claim negatively.
3. Buckley's cessation of physically demanding work several years before his hip became symptomatic weakens his claim for compensation.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court found that Buckley's employment did not cause or significantly contribute to his hip condition. There was conflicting evidence about the nature of Buckley's employment, with the respondent claiming that Buckley's role did not involve physical labour as suggested by Buckley. This conflict undermined Buckley's assertion that his employment was a significant contributing factor to his hip condition. Moreover, Buckley's medical case assumed an incorrect history of his employment, further weakening his claim. The court held that Buckley's cessation of physically demanding work several years before his hip became symptomatic meant that the link between his employment and his hip condition was tenuous. This cessation broke the chain of causation necessary for a successful compensation claim. The court followed established principles that cessation of employment can weaken a claim for work-related injuries, reinforcing its conclusion that Buckley had not established his case. The ratio decidendi of this case is that cessation of physically demanding work several years before symptoms appear can weaken a claim for work-related injury compensation, especially when there is conflicting evidence about the nature of the employment.