Buckley and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Buckley and Comcare (Compensation) [2016] AATA 151 (15 March 2016)

Division

 GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2015/0139

Re

William Buckley

APPLICANT

And

Comcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

Date 15 March 2016
Place Brisbane

I affirm the decision under review.

.......................[sgd].............................

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – compensation for injuries resulting in permanent impairment – compensation for non-economic loss – accepted condition – date of permanent impairment considered – decision affirmed under review

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 24, 27, 45

Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971 (Cth)

Cases

Department of Defence v West (1998) 85 FCR 491

Re Johnston and Military Rehabilitation v Compensation Commission (2011) 123 ALD 113

Canute v Comcare [2006] HCA 47

Re Russell and Comcare (2000) 63 ALD 734

Secondary Materials

Sutherland P, Ballard J and Anforth A, Annotated Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (10th ed, The Federation Press, 2014)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

15 March 2016

INTRODUCTION

  1. I have to determine whether the applicant is entitled to compensation under ss 24 and 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“the Act”) for permanent impairment and non-economic loss resulting from his accepted condition of ‘pain over central lumbar spine’.[1]

    [1] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T30.

    BACKGROUND

  2. On 12 August 1982, Mr William Buckley (“the applicant”) was lifting a box of twelve reams of paper in the course of his employment with the Department of Defence when his back made a cracking sound and he could not get up for a while. In a statutory declaration dated 29 August 1983 he stated that he reported the incident to his supervisor.[2] On 23 June 1983 the applicant made a claim for compensation for what he referred to as ‘slipped discs’.[3] The claim form contains a statement that the date of injury was 12 May 1982; it appears that the applicant intended to refer to the incident of 12 August 1982. On 31 October 1983 a determination was made to accept, liability for ‘pain over the central lumbar spine’ with a date of injury of 12 August 1982.[4]

    [2] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T7.

    [3] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T3.

    [4] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T9.

  3. In July 1988 the applicant was referred to a rehabilitation unit for rehabilitation assistance. The applicant was monitored by an occupational therapist during the program which was focused on back care. His capabilities as a registry clerk were assessed for a month in a real work situation in a Government Department where he was assessed as capable of heavy lifting and prolonged standing. The applicant was granted a clearance by his specialist and in December 1988 he was granted a probationary placement with the Department of Defence. He retired from that position on 16 October 1989.[5]

    [5] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T18.

    CLAIMS HISTORY

  4. On 20 June 1989 made an election under s 45 of the Act to claim damages against the Commonwealth for non-economic loss…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Buckley and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr William Buckley, the applicant, brought a claim for compensation under sections 24 and 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) for permanent impairment and non-economic loss resulting from his accepted condition of ‘pain over the central lumbar spine’. The application was reviewed and subsequently denied by the delegate. The applicant sought judicial review of the decision in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The central issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant was entitled to compensation for his permanent impairment and non-economic loss under sections 24 and 27 of the SRC Act.

The Tribunal considered the medical evidence provided and found that there was no cogent evidence of deterioration of the permanent impairment since the date of the last medical assessment. The most recent medical report indicated that the applicant was managing his pain without medication and that the condition appeared to have improved compared to earlier assessments. The Tribunal concluded that there was no need to consider whether there was a change in the underlying patho-physiological condition of the back, as there was insufficient evidence of deterioration. Therefore, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review.

The Tribunal noted that the decision in Canute v Comcare cast doubt on the extent to which an election under section 45 of the Act would prevent a further claim for impairment. However, in this case, there was no evidence of deterioration, and thus the Tribunal did not need to consider whether the applicant had irrevocably lost the entitlement to pursue a claim under sections 24 and 27 of the Act.

ORDERS:
The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

I affirm the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

I have to determine whether the applicant is entitled to compensation under ss 24 and 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“the Act”) for permanent impairment and non-economic loss resulting from his accepted condition of ‘pain over central lumbar spine’.[1][1] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T30.BACKGROUND On 12 August 1982, Mr William Buckley (“the applicant”) was lifting a box of twelve reams of paper in the course of his employment with the Department of Defence when his back made a cracking sound and he could not get up for a while. In a statutory declaration dated 29 August 1983 he stated that he reported the incident to his supervisor.[2] On 23 June 1983 the applicant made a claim for compensation for what he referred to as ‘slipped discs’.[3] The claim form contains a statement that the date of injury was 12 May 1982; it appears that the applicant intended to refer to the incident of 12 August 1982. On 31 October 1983 a determination was made to accept, liability for ‘pain over the central lumbar spine’ with a date of injury of 12 August 1982.[4][2] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T7.[3] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T3.[4] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T9. In July 1988 the applicant was referred to a rehabilitation unit for rehabilitation assistance. The applicant was monitored by an occupational therapist during the program which was focused on back care. His capabilities as a registry clerk were assessed for a month in a real work situation in a Government Department where he was assessed as capable of heavy lifting and prolonged standing. The applicant was granted a clearance by his specialist and in December 1988 he was granted a probationary placement with the Department of Defence. He retired from that position on 16 October 1989.[5][5] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T18.CLAIMS HISTORY On 20 June 1989 made an election under s 45 of the Act to claim damages against the Commonwealth for non-economic loss arising out of his injury.[6][6] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T19. On 25 March 1991 the applicant made a claim for permanent impairment compensation.[7] On 7 August 1991 a determination was made that the applicant was not entitled to lump sum compensation because his condition had become permanent prior to the commencement of the Act on 1 December 1988.[8] [7] Exhibit A: T-Documents. 20.[8] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T21. On 30 September 2014, the applicant made another claim for compensation for a permanent impairment.[9] In this claim form, his general practitioner Dr Catton has given his opinion that the degree of permanent impairment of the low back is 20%.[10][9] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T30.[10] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T30. On 27 October 2014 a determination was made to deny liability to compensation for permanent impairment and non-economic loss for the accepted condition of the applicant under ss 24 and 27 of the Act. The delegate gave as the reason for the determination that the condition of the applicant became permanent prior to the commencement of the Act because he had laminectomy surgery in March 1988.[11] On 31 October 2014 the applicant made a request for reconsideration of the determination.[12] [11] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T32.[12] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T33.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I note that some commentators have observed that the decision of the High Court in Canute v Comcare [2006] HCA 47 casted doubt on the extent to which an election would prevent a further claim for impairment resulting from an injury.[27] Where there is no cogent residual evidence that there is a deterioration of the permanent impairment it is unnecessary to consider the submission of the respondent that the applicant has irrevocably lost the entitlement to pursue a claim under ss 24 and 27 of the Act, because of the operation of s 45(3) of the Act.[28] [27] Sutherland P, Ballard J and Anforth A, Annotated Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (10th ed, The Federation Press, 2014), p. 421.[28] See Re Russell and Comcare (2000) 63 ALD 734.DECISION I affirm the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The most recent medical report concerning the accepted condition is the treating practitioner’s assessment on 30 September 2014 in the claim form. Whilst the applicant comments that ‘backpain is so severe I get sick of taking pills’,[22] Dr Catton, general practitioner, comments:[23]Analgesia rarely prescribed. He copes with any pain without medication except for occasional Panadeine Forte… Low back discomfort requires major changes of position every 30 minutes: eg standing to sitting or lying or walking. Able to use most forms of transport up to 20-30 minutes. [22] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T30.[23] Exhibit A: T-Documents. T30.CONSIDERATION The issue before the Tribunal is whether the Applicant is entitled to compensation for permanent impairment and non-economic loss resulting from his accepted condition of ‘pain over central lumbar spine’ under ss 24 and 27 of the SRC Act. The applicant was injured when the 1971 Act was in force. That Act did not confer any entitlement to lump-sum compensation for a back injury. Compensation is payable under the Act in respect of an injury, loss or damage suffered before the commencing day of the Act, if compensation was or would have been payable in respect of that injury, loss or damage under the 1971 Act.[24] [24] See s 124(1A). In Department of Defence v West (1998) 85 FCR 491 Merkel J (at 512) identified that I should consider ‘whether, in a particular case, the permanent impairment existing as at 1 December 1988 has deteriorated to an extent that that it is properly to be characterised as a further or different impairment to that which existed at the commencement date’.[25] [25] See also, Re Johnston and Military Rehabilitation v Compensation Commission (2011) 123 ALD 113. There is no medical evidence before the Tribunal which shows that the accepted condition can be characterised as a further or different impairment to that which existed at the commencement date. Reports from Dr Catton, general practitioner, on 1 September 2003 and Dr Morris, orthopaedic surgeon, on 18 March 2003 indicate that the back condition was then stable. Dr Haynes in 2008 reported that the applicant had advised that there was sustainable benefit as a result of the discectomy surgery. A recent CT scan shows that the nerve roots of the lumbar spine remain unencumbered.[26] [26] Exhibit B: CT Scan dated 6 July 2015. I do not accept the self-report of the applicant concerning his current pain levels. The most recent medical report from the treating doctor indicates that the applicant ‘copes with any pain without medication except for occasional Panadeine Forte’. In that report there is an indication that ‘Low back discomfort requires major changes of position every 30 minutes’. If anything the back position appears to have improved because in 2002 Dr Catton indicated that then applicant could not sit or stand still for more than 10 minutes. I do not accept that there is any cogent medical evidence of the deterioration of the permanent impairment which is the accepted condition. That is why I consider that there is no need to give consideration to whether there is any change to the underlying patho-physiological condition of the back. If there was evidence of deterioration of the accepted condition I would have remitted the application to the respondent to obtain an up-to-date assessment from a specialist who is an orthopaedic surgeon or occupational physician.