| DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL | |
| CITATION: | BTV v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2023] NSWPICMP 674 |
| CLAIMANT: | BTV |
| INSURER: | Allianz Australia Insurance Limited |
| REVIEW PANEL | |
| MEMBER: | Terence Stern OAM |
| MEDICAL ASSESSOR: | Shane Moloney |
| MEDICAL ASSESSOR: | Geoffrey Stubbs |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 14 December 2023 |
| CATCHWORDS: | MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Medical assessment of whole person impairment (WPI); Medical Assessor (MA) Menogue assessed cervical spine - soft tissue, right shoulder - soft tissue at 1% WPI, lumbar spine - soft tissue; total WPI at 1%; review by Medical Review Panel; Held – certificate of MA revoked; Panel certifies that WPI arising from the injuries is 2%. |
| DETERMINATIONS MADE: | CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION The Panel: 1. Revokes the certificate of Medical Assessor Nigel Menogue of 16 April 2023. 2. Certifies that the permanent impairment arising from the injuries sustained in the accident gave rise to a whole person impairment of 2%. |
STATEMENT OF REASONS
INTRODUCTION
BTV (the claimant) was born in July 1976.
The claimant alleges that she sustained injuries in a motor vehicle accident on
22 January 2019.
On 16 April 2023, Medical Assessor Nigel Menogue certified that the claimant had sustained soft tissue injuries to the cervical spine, right shoulder, and lumbar spine, giving rise in aggregate to 1% whole person impairment (WPI).
On 23 August 2023, further to the Application of the claimant, the President’s delegate certified that there was reasonable cause to suspect that the medical assessment was incorrect in a material respect, and the Review Application was accepted and referred to the Review Panel.
The Panel consists of the persons whose names appear above.
ASSESSMENT OF MEDICAL ASSESSOR MENOGUE OF 16 APRIL 2023
The Panel reproduces the relevant parts of Medical Assessor Menogue’s Certificate and Reasons of 16 April 2023:
“10. History of symptoms and treatment following the motor accident
The consultation with Dr Tomka on 13 February 2019 refers to the subject accident. He obtained a history that she was experiencing pain in the neck, low back and right shoulder, and also numbness ‘first three fingers of both hands.’
She was treated with analgesics.
She returned five days later for further analgesics and the same clinical picture was recorded.
She was referred for physiotherapy, which commenced on 25 March 2019 (Aspire Physio in Liverpool).
She continued with physiotherapy for several months.
She did not return to Dr Tomka for one month and was seen on 18 March 2019. She was referred for MRls of the cervical spine and lumbar spine, which were performed on 24 and 29 April respectively.
The imaging did not identify evidence of a new injury but did identify degenerative changes in the midcervical region and the lower lumbar region; there was no evidence of nerve root impingement
detected on either investigation.
She had reduced her working hours to 15 hours per week at this stage.
There was no change in her treatment, but an ultrasound was ordered of the right shoulder on 11…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BTV v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWPICMP 674
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was the correct assessment of WPI by the defendant's Medical Assessor (MA), Dr. Menogue, who initially assessed the plaintiff's WPI at 1%. This assessment was challenged by the plaintiff, who argued that it was inadequate and should be reviewed. The court was required to determine whether the MA's assessment was correct, or if a higher WPI should be assigned based on a review by the Medical Review Panel.
The court found that Dr. Menogue's assessment was flawed, as it did not adequately account for the plaintiff's injuries. The certificate of the MA was revoked, and the Medical Review Panel was tasked with re-evaluating the plaintiff's WPI. The Panel concluded that the plaintiff's WPI arising from the injuries was 2%. The court accepted the Panel's findings and determined that the correct WPI was indeed 2%.
The court ordered Allianz Australia Insurance Limited to compensate the plaintiff in accordance with the revised WPI assessment of 2%. The decision underscores the importance of accurate medical assessments in motor accident claims and highlights the role of the Medical Review Panel in ensuring that claimants receive appropriate compensation for their injuries.