BSF17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BSF17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 1308

Appeal from: BSF17 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2020] FCCA 348
File number: NSD 266 of 2020
Judgment of: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 4 November 2022
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appeal from Federal Circuit Court (FCC) dismissing application for judicial review of a decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) affirming the decision of the Minister’s delegate – where interests of justice favoured grant of leave to raise a new issue not raised before the FCC – where sole ground of appeal challenges IAA’s finding as to whether the appellant’s fear of harm from Tamil paramilitary groups was well-founded – where no error established in the IAA’s finding having regard to the content of, and manner in which, the IAA considered the country evidence – where alleged error by IAA would not have been material in any event – where no jurisdictional error therefore established – appeal dismissed
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 473CB
Cases cited:

BHD18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 151; (2020) 280 FCR 26

Han v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 331

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 158 CLR at 272; [1996] HCA 6

SZKMS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 499

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 29
Date of hearing: 17 October 2022
Counsel for the Appellant Mr G Foster
Solicitor for the Appellant  Sentil Solicitor
Solicitor for the First Respondent  Mr G Pasas of Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Second Respondent The second respondent filed a submitting notice

ORDERS

NSD 266 of 2020
BETWEEN:

BSF17

Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

PERRY J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 NOVEMBER 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application for leave to raise ground 1 of the amended notice of appeal is granted.

2.The appeal is dismissed.

3.The appellant is to pay the first respondent’s costs as agreed or taxed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

PERRY J:

1.               INTRODUCTION        

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of the then Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCC) dismissing the appellant’s application for judicial review of a decision of the second respondent, the Immigration Assessment Authority (the IAA), made on 28 March 2017.  By its decision, the IAA affirmed a decision made on 28 September 2016 by a delegate of the first respondent, then known as the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, refusing to grant the appellant a Safe Haven Enterprise (subclass 790) Visa (SHEV) (the IAA decision).

  2. The amended notice of appeal, filed with leave after the appellant had obtained legal representation, raises one ground of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BSF17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1308
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of BSF17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs involved an appeal by the appellant, a Tamil from Sri Lanka, against a decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) affirming the decision of the Minister’s delegate. The appellant sought judicial review of the IAA's decision which found that his fear of harm from Tamil paramilitary groups was not well-founded. The Federal Circuit Court (FCC) dismissed the application for judicial review, and the appellant now appealed to the Federal Court.

The primary legal issue in the appeal was whether the IAA erred in finding that the appellant's fear of harm from paramilitary groups was not well-founded. The appellant contended that the IAA did not properly consider the country evidence or failed to address specific reports of ongoing harassment and violence by paramilitary groups. The Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs argued that the appellant should not be permitted to raise this new issue for the first time on appeal, as it would subvert the purpose of the judicial review process and potentially transform the appeal into a de facto trial on new grounds.

The Federal Court considered the interests of justice in granting leave to raise the new issue. The Court noted that the issue was discrete, being the sole ground of appeal, and the consequences for the appellant of an adverse decision were significant. The Court acknowledged the caution required in permitting new grounds of appeal but found that the interests of justice favoured allowing the new issue to be raised. The Court found no error in the IAA's consideration of the country evidence and concluded that even if there had been an error, it would not have been material. The IAA had reasonably found that the appellant's fear of harm from paramilitary groups was not well-founded, considering the overall security situation in Sri Lanka and the diminishing power of the relevant groups.

The Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the IAA's decision that the appellant's fear of harm from paramilitary groups was not well-founded. The Court ordered that the appellant pay the costs of the first respondent as agreed or taxed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for leave to raise ground 1 of the amended notice of appeal is granted.

2. The appeal is dismissed.

3. The appellant is to pay the first respondent’s costs as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Notwithstanding the caution which must be exercised before permitting an appellant to raise a new ground for the first time on appeal, on balance I consider that the interests of justice weigh in favour of the grant of leave in this case. In addition to the considerations identified by the appellant’s counsel, the issue sought to be raised is a discrete one and is indeed the only ground of appeal on which the appellant now seeks to rely. I have also taken into account the seriousness of the consequences for the appellant flowing from an adverse decision on the appeal.3. BACKGROUND The relevant background was non-contentious and may be summarised as follows.3.1 The appellant’s claims to fear harm The appellant is a Tamil from Sri Lanka who grew up in an area controlled by the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE). His brother was conscripted by the LTTE in 2002 and escaped on a number of occasions. The appellant claimed to fear harm:(1)as a Tamil from a former LTTE-controlled area in Sri Lanka;(2)from paramilitary groups who harassed his brother in 2012 and threatened the appellant because of his brother's prior involvement with, and defection from, the LTTE (the paramilitary claim); and(3)as a failed asylum seeker who departed Sri Lanka illegally. Only the paramilitary claim is relevant to the present appeal. There is no challenge to the findings by the IAA that it was not satisfied that there was a real chance that the appellant would face any harm as a Tamil or by reason of the fact that he was from an area formerly controlled by the LTTE (IAAR at [21]). Nor is there any challenge to the IAA’s finding that the consequences which may flow from the appellant having left Sri Lanka illegally and returning as a failed asylum seeker would not amount to serious harm (IAAR at [31]).3.2 The decision of the IAA The IAA received submissions from the appellant on 15 October 2016 and expressly took those submissions into account in making its decision. The IAA accepted significant aspects of the appellant’s claims, including (relevantly) that:(1)the appellant’s brother was forcibly recruited by the LTTE in 2002, made attempts to leave or escape the LTTE, and was imprisoned by them (IAAR at [11]);(2)the appellant's family was threatened by the LTTE, his father was detained by the LTTE for two days, and the appellant’s brother went into hiding until the LTTE vacated the local area (IAAR at [11]);(3)it was plausible that, in 2005 or 2006, the appellant’s brother was assisted by an International Organization for Migration (IOM) program to re-establish himself and as a result was not charged for his prior LTTE involvement (IAAR at [12]); and(4)it was plausible that a paramilitary group had harassed the appellant's brother and the appellant in 2012 (at [13]). With respect to the appellant’s paramilitary claim to fear harm, the IAA also found that the appellant had specifically mentioned two paramilitary groups, Karuna and Pillayan, as causing trouble for his brother. On the basis of country information, the IAA found that these were among a number of splinter groups which had developed from disputes within the LTTE into paramilitary organisations and “had close connections with the security agencies during the civil war and in the period immediately after the war” (IAAR at [13]). While accepting that the appellant had a subjective fear of harm from paramilitary groups and that there were reports of ongoing kidnappings and “white van” abductions, the IAA was not satisfied that the country information supported his fear of harm as being (objectively) well-founded (IAAR at [14]). In reaching this conclusion the IAA reasoned as follows.(1)While there were indications that the power of the paramilitary groups may have lessened after the war, other agencies continued to report activity by these groups in the aftermath of the war (referring to a report by the Danish Immigration Service, “Human Rights and Security Issues concerning Tamils in Sri Lanka”, dated 1 October 2010, a report dated 11 February 2015 by the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada on the treatment of suspected members or supporters of the LTTE in Sri Lanka, and a report by the US Department of State, “Human Rights Report 2014 Sri Lanka”, dated 25 June 2015 (IAAR at [15]-[17]).(2)In a critical passage on which the appellant relied, the IAA found that:I accept that the paramilitary groups were closely linked to the security agencies during the war and under the repressive Rajapaksa government; however I take account of information before the delegate that Tamil paramilitary groups have renounced paramilitary activities [footnoting the 2015 DFAT report] and that the power of the Karuna and Pillayan groups specifically has diminished. The security situation in Sri Lanka has improved since the change of government in January 2015 and the Sirisena government has made advances to work toward greater reconciliation with the Tamils.(IAAR at [18]; emphasis added.)(3)In support of this view, the IAA referred among other things to a number of reforms enacted by the new government of Sri Lanka regarding reconciliation with Tamils and to address human rights issues at the regional level, and the advances made by that government towards reconciliation in 2015 as reported by the US Department of State (IAAR at [18]-[19]).(4)The IAA then found in a further passage also relied upon by the appellant, that:I accept that there are credible reports of arrests of people with LTTE links and those involved in Tamil separatist activities, but the widespread arbitrary harassment of Tamils during the Civil War and post war years has eased. While the applicant’s brother was an LTTE member this did not attract adverse attention from the authorities during the war, nor afterward and I am not satisfied that the applicant would be imputed as an LTTE/Tamil separatist supporter now on the basis of his brother’s history. Cited in the post-interview submission are reports from TamilNet of the arrests and detention in March 2016 of 23 Tamils, some of whom were possibly linked to a person alleged to have possessed explosives, though others arrested were not aware why they had been detained, and the International Crisis Group May 2016 report that notes the continued reporting of abuse of Tamils suspected of LTTE links. Reporting on the 2015 year the US State Department noted cases of deaths and detention by the security forces with the assistance of paramilitary groups and, while stating these included ordinary civilians, noted the particular targets were Tamil politicians, humanitarian workers, and journalists. I am satisfied that overall country information indicates that while the security agencies harassed and abused the civilian population this has eased since the cessation of hostilities and the move to greater political cooperation under the Sirisena government. The paramilitary groups operated with impunity as associates of the security agencies during the war and immediately afterwards, and the US State Department reported “that EPDP and Karuna group members supported security force intelligence gathering that included the torture and physical and sexual abuse of Tamils accused of LTTE connections in the five years since the end of the war”. However, noting the curbing of the excesses of the security agencies since that time, and the indications that the power base of the Karuna and Pillayan groups has diminished, I am not satisfied that the applicant’s fear of harm from paramilitary groups is well founded. Nor am I … satisfied that they would harm the applicant in retribution for his brother’s escape from them in 2012.(IAAR at [20]; emphasis added; citations omitted.)3.3 The decision of the FCC

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Only the paramilitary claim is relevant to the present appeal. There is no challenge to the findings by the IAA that it was not satisfied that there was a real chance that the appellant would face any harm as a Tamil or by reason of the fact that he was from an area formerly controlled by the LTTE (IAAR at [21]). Nor is there any challenge to the IAA’s finding that the consequences which may flow from the appellant having left Sri Lanka illegally and returning as a failed asylum seeker would not amount to serious harm (IAAR at [31]).3.2 The decision of the IAA The IAA received submissions from the appellant on 15 October 2016 and expressly took those submissions into account in making its decision. The IAA accepted significant aspects of the appellant’s claims, including (relevantly) that:(1)the appellant’s brother was forcibly recruited by the LTTE in 2002, made attempts to leave or escape the LTTE, and was imprisoned by them (IAAR at [11]);(2)the appellant's family was threatened by the LTTE, his father was detained by the LTTE for two days, and the appellant’s brother went into hiding until the LTTE vacated the local area (IAAR at [11]);(3)it was plausible that, in 2005 or 2006, the appellant’s brother was assisted by an International Organization for Migration (IOM) program to re-establish himself and as a result was not charged for his prior LTTE involvement (IAAR at [12]); and(4)it was plausible that a paramilitary group had harassed the appellant's brother and the appellant in 2012 (at [13]). With respect to the appellant’s paramilitary claim to fear harm, the IAA also found that the appellant had specifically mentioned two paramilitary groups, Karuna and Pillayan, as causing trouble for his brother. On the basis of country information, the IAA found that these were among a number of splinter groups which had developed from disputes within the LTTE into paramilitary organisations and “had close connections with the security agencies during the civil war and in the period immediately after the war” (IAAR at [13]). While accepting that the appellant had a subjective fear of harm from paramilitary groups and that there were reports of ongoing kidnappings and “white van” abductions, the IAA was not satisfied that the country information supported his fear of harm as being (objectively) well-founded (IAAR at [14]). In reaching this conclusion the IAA reasoned as follows.(1)While there were indications that the power of the paramilitary groups may have lessened after the war, other agencies continued to report activity by these groups in the aftermath of the war (referring to a report by the Danish Immigration Service, “Human Rights and Security Issues concerning Tamils in Sri Lanka”, dated 1 October 2010, a report dated 11 February 2015 by the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada on the treatment of suspected members or supporters of the LTTE in Sri Lanka, and a report by the US Department of State, “Human Rights Report 2014 Sri Lanka”, dated 25 June 2015 (IAAR at [15]-[17]).(2)In a critical passage on which the appellant relied, the IAA found that:I accept that the paramilitary groups were closely linked to the security agencies during the war and under the repressive Rajapaksa government; however I take account of information before the delegate that Tamil paramilitary groups have renounced paramilitary activities [footnoting the 2015 DFAT report] and that the power of the Karuna and Pillayan groups specifically has diminished. The security situation in Sri Lanka has improved since the change of government in January 2015 and the Sirisena government has made advances to work toward greater reconciliation with the Tamils.(IAAR at [18]; emphasis added.)(3)In support of this view, the IAA referred among other things to a number of reforms enacted by the new government of Sri Lanka regarding reconciliation with Tamils and to address human rights issues at the regional level, and the advances made by that government towards reconciliation in 2015 as reported by the US Department of State (IAAR at [18]-[19]).(4)The IAA then found in a further passage also relied upon by the appellant, that:I accept that there are credible reports of arrests of people with LTTE links and those involved in Tamil separatist activities, but the widespread arbitrary harassment of Tamils during the Civil War and post war years has eased. While the applicant’s brother was an LTTE member this did not attract adverse attention from the authorities during the war, nor afterward and I am not satisfied that the applicant would be imputed as an LTTE/Tamil separatist supporter now on the basis of his brother’s history. Cited in the post-interview submission are reports from TamilNet of the arrests and detention in March 2016 of 23 Tamils, some of whom were possibly linked to a person alleged to have possessed explosives, though others arrested were not aware why they had been detained, and the International Crisis Group May 2016 report that notes the continued reporting of abuse of Tamils suspected of LTTE links. Reporting on the 2015 year the US State Department noted cases of deaths and detention by the security forces with the assistance of paramilitary groups and, while stating these included ordinary civilians, noted the particular targets were Tamil politicians, humanitarian workers, and journalists. I am satisfied that overall country information indicates that while the security agencies harassed and abused the civilian population this has eased since the cessation of hostilities and the move to greater political cooperation under the Sirisena government. The paramilitary groups operated with impunity as associates of the security agencies during the war and immediately afterwards, and the US State Department reported “that EPDP and Karuna group members supported security force intelligence gathering that included the torture and physical and sexual abuse of Tamils accused of LTTE connections in the five years since the end of the war”. However, noting the curbing of the excesses of the security agencies since that time, and the indications that the power base of the Karuna and Pillayan groups has diminished, I am not satisfied that the applicant’s fear of harm from paramilitary groups is well founded. Nor am I … satisfied that they would harm the applicant in retribution for his brother’s escape from them in 2012.(IAAR at [20]; emphasis added; citations omitted.)3.3 The decision of the FCC

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Furthermore, the Minister did not oppose the tender of the 2015 DFAT report on the basis that the report was before the IAA. I also note in this regard that material which is considered to be relevant to the review must be provided to the IAA in accordance with s 473CB(1)(c) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Migration Act). The Minister, however, rightly pointed to decisions of this Court warning against the transformation of appeals into de facto trials on new grounds because:(a)that approach subverts the evident purpose of s 476A of the [Migration Act], which is to preclude this Court from having original jurisdiction to review the IAA’s decision; and(b) it denies the Minister any practical right of appeal, given that any subsequent appeal faces the hurdle of obtaining special leave from the High Court.(First respondent’s submissions (RS) at [6].)(See, eg, the discussion in Han v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 331 at [8]-[20] (Bromwich J) and the authorities referred to therein.) At the hearing, the Minister also correctly submitted that the fact that the appellant was unrepresented at first instance is not of itself sufficient to allow a new ground to be raised on appeal, referring to SZKMS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 499 at [20] (Lander J). The Minister further invited the Court to infer that, while the appellant was ultimately not represented at the hearing in the FCC, his originating application for judicial review was prepared with legal assistance. However, no proper foundation has been established for the drawing of such an inference. The evidence rose no higher than speculation. Notwithstanding the caution which must be exercised before permitting an appellant to raise a new ground for the first time on appeal, on balance I consider that the interests of justice weigh in favour of the grant of leave in this case. In addition to the considerations identified by the appellant’s counsel, the issue sought to be raised is a discrete one and is indeed the only ground of appeal on which the appellant now seeks to rely. I have also taken into account the seriousness of the consequences for the appellant flowing from an adverse decision on the appeal.3. BACKGROUND The relevant background was non-contentious and may be summarised as follows.3.1 The appellant’s claims to fear harm The appellant is a Tamil from Sri Lanka who grew up in an area controlled by the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE). His brother was conscripted by the LTTE in 2002 and escaped on a number of occasions. The appellant claimed to fear harm:(1)as a Tamil from a former LTTE-controlled area in Sri Lanka;(2)from paramilitary groups who harassed his brother in 2012 and threatened the appellant because of his brother's prior involvement with, and defection from, the LTTE (the paramilitary claim); and(3)as a failed asylum seeker who departed Sri Lanka illegally. Only the paramilitary claim is relevant to the present appeal. There is no challenge to the findings by the IAA that it was not satisfied that there was a real chance that the appellant would face any harm as a Tamil or by reason of the fact that he was from an area formerly controlled by the LTTE (IAAR at [21]). Nor is there any challenge to the IAA’s finding that the consequences which may flow from the appellant having left Sri Lanka illegally and returning as a failed asylum seeker would not amount to serious harm (IAAR at [31]).3.2 The decision of the IAA