Brunswick and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

Brunswick and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2018] AATA 2564 (26 July 2018)

Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number:2017/0457           

Re:David Brunswick

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Brigadier A G Warner

Date:26 July 2018

Place:Perth

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

........[sgd]................................................................

Brigadier A G Warner

CATCHWORDS

VETERANS’ AFFAIRS – overpayment of service pension – date from which Applicant’s service pension should be calculated at partnered rate – date on which Applicant entered into de facto relationship – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975(Cth) – s 43(1)

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) – s 5E(2) – s 5E(3) – s 5E(5) – s 11A – Schedule 6 – Schedule 6-B1

CASES

Hafza v Director-General of Social Security (1985) 60 ALR 674

Pelka v Secretary, Department of Family & Community Services [2006] FCA 735; 43 AAR 220

REASONS FOR DECISION

BRIGADIER A G WARNER

26 July 2018

NATURE OF APPLICATION

  1. Mr Brunswick seeks review of a reviewable decision dated 17 November 2016 which affirmed the Respondent’s determination dated 19 May 2016 which found that Mr Brunswick entered into a de facto relationship on 19 December 2015 (T17). As a result of this determination Mr Brunswick was found to have been overpaid service pension from 19 December 2015 and that the overpayment constituted a debt that should be recovered.

  2. Mr Brunswick attended the hearing and was represented by Reverend Dr Alan Stubbs, a veterans’ advocate. The Respondent was represented by Mr Ashley Burgess of Sparke Helmore Lawyers.

    ISSUES

  3. The issue for the Tribunal’s consideration is the date from which Mr Brunswick’s entitlement to a service pension should be calculated at the partnered rate. That requires consideration of the date on which Mr Brunswick entered into a de facto relationship with Mrs Linda Terry.

    BACKGROUND

  4. Mr Brunswick was born in 1939 and is covered by the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (VEA).He was granted a service pension in 2001 and receives a Department of Veterans’ Affairs (DVA) 10% disability pension.

  5. Mr Brunswick lived in Collie with his wife in their own home until her death.  Mr Brunswick subsequently placed the home on the market in 2013 and it was finally sold on 19 April 2016 (Exhibit A4, paragraph 3.7).

  6. Mr Brunswick met Mrs Terry in 2014 (Exhibit A4, paragraph 3.5).

  7. Mr Brunswick and Mrs Terry exchanged cohabitation agreements on 17 March 2016 (Exhibits A2 and A3).

  8. On 27 April 2016, Mrs Terry lodged a Claim for Service Pension by a Partner (Part A in T8/22-36, Part B in T9/37-49) and that claim form was signed by Mr Brunswick.  The claim form includes a response to question 17 that Mrs Terry and Mr Brunswick are in a de facto relationship and that they commenced living together on 19 December 2015 (T8/25).  The claim form also indicates, at question 42, that Mr Brunswick and Mrs Terry held a joint bank account (T8/33).

  9. In response to question 14 at Part…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brunswick and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlement... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 2564
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the case of Mr Brunswick and the Repatriation Commission concerning the correct date for calculating Mr Brunswick's service pension at the partnered rate. The dispute arose from an overpayment of his service pension, which was attributed to the date on which he was deemed to have entered into a de facto relationship with Mrs Linda Terry.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the commencement date of Mr Brunswick's de facto relationship with Mrs Terry, as this date dictated when his service pension should be reassessed at the partnered rate. This determination required an examination of the evidence presented regarding the nature and progression of their relationship, particularly in light of the provisions of section 11A of the *Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986* (Cth), which outlines the factors to be considered when assessing whether two people are living in a de facto relationship.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the conflicting accounts provided by Mr Brunswick and Mrs Terry regarding the commencement of their de facto relationship. While an initial claim form indicated a commencement date of 19 December 2015, both parties later asserted this was a mistake. Evidence suggested that Mr Brunswick continued to reside primarily in his own home in Collie until its sale in April 2016, making regular weekend visits to Mrs Terry's residence. The Tribunal considered various aspects of their relationship, including financial arrangements, living arrangements, social activities, and their commitment to each other, as outlined in section 11A of the VEA. Ultimately, the Tribunal found that the evidence supported the initial claim that the de facto relationship commenced on 19 December 2015, and therefore the service pension was correctly calculated at the partnered rate from that date.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue for the Tribunal’s consideration is the date from which Mr Brunswick’s entitlement to a service pension should be calculated at the partnered rate. That requires consideration of the date on which Mr Brunswick entered into a de facto relationship with Mrs Linda Terry.BACKGROUND Mr Brunswick was born in 1939 and is covered by the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (VEA).He was granted a service pension in 2001 and receives a Department of Veterans’ Affairs (DVA) 10% disability pension. Mr Brunswick lived in Collie with his wife in their own home until her death. Mr Brunswick subsequently placed the home on the market in 2013 and it was finally sold on 19 April 2016 (Exhibit A4, paragraph 3.7). Mr Brunswick met Mrs Terry in 2014 (Exhibit A4, paragraph 3.5). Mr Brunswick and Mrs Terry exchanged cohabitation agreements on 17 March 2016 (Exhibits A2 and A3). On 27 April 2016, Mrs Terry lodged a Claim for Service Pension by a Partner (Part A in T8/22-36, Part B in T9/37-49) and that claim form was signed by Mr Brunswick. The claim form includes a response to question 17 that Mrs Terry and Mr Brunswick are in a de facto relationship and that they commenced living together on 19 December 2015 (T8/25). The claim form also indicates, at question 42, that Mr Brunswick and Mrs Terry held a joint bank account (T8/33). In response to question 14 at Part B of the claim form, Mrs Terry advised that she had ceased working on 13 March 2016 (T9/43). In a telephone call on 19 May 2016, the delegate spoke with both Mrs Terry and Mr Brunswick in order to confirm the date upon which the de facto relationship commenced (T10/50). Mrs Terry advised that she had been in a relationship with Mr Brunswick for two years and that he had moved into her house before Christmas 2015. Mrs Terry noted that Mr Brunswick was “living with her from then on” and confirmed that 19 December 2015 was the date upon which Mr Brunswick moved into her house. In that same telephone call, Mr Brunswick also confirmed the start date of the de facto relationship as 19 December 2015 (T10/50). Mr Brunswick acknowledged he had not notified the DVA of his change of circumstances within 14 days as required. On being advised of a likely overpayment as a result of this, Mr Brunswick then claimed that he only spent Thursday to Monday at Mrs Terry’s house and that he spent the remainder of the time at his house in Collie. By determination dated 19 May 2016, Mr Brunswick was notified that his service pension had been “retrospectively reassessed at the partnered rate from the 19th December 2015” (T13/60). By email dated 21 May 2016, Mrs Terry stated that she and Mr Brunswick had “made mistakes” in completing the claim form and in indicating that they commenced living together on 19 December 2015. Mrs Terry noted that “we both thought if we put december (sic) down, that you could see we had a serious relationship” (T14/66). By letter received 26 May 2016, Mr Brunswick requested a review of the delegate’s decision (T16/68). Mr Brunswick noted that he “commenced an in depth relationship” with Mrs Terry in mid-December 2015 and had been in a platonic relationship for about 12 months prior to this. Mr Brunswick claimed that as a result of medical treatment he was obtaining (which meant he couldn’t drive), he stayed with Mrs Terry some nights a week from December 2015 but did not start living full time with her until March 2016 when he sold his house in Collie.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 11A of the VEA provides that:In forming an opinion for the purposes of this Act whether 2 people are living together in a de facto relationship, regard is to be had to all the circumstances of the relationship including, in particular, the following matters:(a)the financial aspects of the relationship, including:(i)any joint ownership of real estate or other major assets and any joint liabilities; and(ii)any significant pooling of financial resources especially in relation to major financial commitments; and(iii)any legal obligations owed by one person in respect of the other person; and(iv)the basis of any sharing of day-to-day household expenses;(b)the nature of the household, including:(i)any joint responsibility for providing care or support of children; and(ii)the living arrangements of the people; and(iii)the basis on which responsibility for housework is distributed;(c)the social aspects of the relationship, including:(i)whether the people hold themselves out as being in a de facto relationship with each other; and(ii)the assessment of friends and regular associates of the people about the nature of their relationship; and(iii)the basis on which the people make plans for, or engage in, joint social activities;(d)any sexual relationship between the people;(e)the nature of the people's commitment to each other, including:(i)the length of the relationship; and(ii)the nature of any companionship and emotional support that the people provide to each other; and(iii)whether the people consider that the relationship is likely to continue indefinitely; and(iv)whether the people see their relationship as a de facto relationship.EVIDENCE The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1-T20, pp1-84);·Statement of Linda Terry dated 24 January 2017 (Exhibit A1);·Cohabitation Agreement received by the Tribunal on 17 May 2017 (Exhibit A2);·Cohabitation Agreement received by the Tribunal on 17 May 2017 (Exhibit A3);·Applicant’s Replacement Statement dated 10 December 2017 (Applicant’s Statement) (Exhibit A4);·Respondent’s Statement of Issues, Facts and Contentions dated 24 November 2017 (Respondent’s SIFC) (Exhibit R1);·the oral evidence of Mrs Linda Terry; and·the oral evidence of the Applicant.Oral evidence of Mrs Terry Mrs Terry read a prepared statement: I’d like to say that I’m responsible for this situation and not David. When I filled the form for the application of the DV pension I said to David, “Shall we put that our de facto relationship started in December?” which it did. I thought that de facto relationship meant that you had an intimate relationship. I did not think that it would cause all this problem. So let’s say I was lying, which was not my intention, I thought it sounded like we had a secure relationship. Yes, I should have told [the delegate] this when I spoke to her. David did not move into my house till the end of March, beginning of April. On [19 March 2016] I told my children that he was moving in, they knew about the relationship and I felt I needed their approval for him to move in. All the important things that happened at this time shows that he was not living with me, opening a joint bank account, selling his house, still playing golf in Collie and doing his radio show. We also did a de facto agreement, which a JP signed in March. David did stay at my house for some weekends, as he lived in Collie, so it was not a 10 minute drive for him to get home. David had an operation in December so was unable to drive for quite some time and had appointments in Bunbury, so I would go down there, when I was not working, and drive him to the doctor’s. Some weekends David did not come up as he was playing golf all weekend. In March I lost my job so my mind was on other things, David moving in with me was a hectic time. At no time between December and March did we share expenses. He had his bills and I had mine. So I’m admitting that I lied to [the delegate] on my written application that I lied. David should not be held responsible for this.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that the rate of service pension payable to Mr Brunswick was correctly calculated at the partnered rate with effect from 19 December 2015.DECISION For the reasons given above, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

During the hearing, Mr Brunswick:·told the Tribunal that he chose 19 December 2015 as the commencement date of his cohabitation with Mrs Terry (see paragraphs 8 and 10 above) because it was the first day that they had intimate relations, and they “…figured that that was virtually becoming a de facto relationship, not understanding fully what a de facto relationship was”;·told the Tribunal that he did not move into Mrs Terry’s house until the end of March, beginning of April 2016 and that in the period December 2015 to April 2016 he journeyed backwards and forwards between his house in Collie and Mrs Terry’s house in Cooloongup. He described the pattern of this journeying as:I’d come up, maybe once a month, on the Thursday, but it was usually Friday. If she was not working for that weekend I’d come up on the Friday evening and I would be going back Sunday morning, Sunday afternoon, because I had the radio show on the Monday.·agreed that it was reasonable to conclude that his de facto relationship commenced on 19 March 2016 which was also the day on which Mrs Terry spoke with her family and it was confirmed that he would move into her home;·explained that he entered his address as Mrs Terry’s address on the cohabitation agreements signed on 17 March 2016 (Exhibits A2 and A3) on the advice of the Justice of the Peace who witnessed the documents; and·told the Tribunal that he underwent surgery on his thumb on or about 17 December 2015, and Mrs Terry stayed overnight at his house in Collie on 18 and 19 December 2015. He said that in the period between then and 19 March 2016, he and Mrs Terry shared a bedroom and bed when he stayed at her house, and during those stays he helped make the bed, helped wash the dishes and they occasionally socialised with others. Mr Brunswick said that Mrs Terry provided him with emotional support, and after he had injured his thumb, physical support.CONSIDERATION The Respondent submits, and the Tribunal agrees that Mr Brunswick is not married and therefore does not fall within s 5E(2)(a) of the VEA (Exhibit R1, paragraph 4.3). The Applicant’s Statement submits that there are two conflicting accounts of the relationship between Mr Brunswick and Mrs Terry:…The first is accepted by the Respondent. This version relies on written dates as well as Ms. Terry’s Application responses to two brief telephone conversations with the Assessor. Apart from this there is no evidence to support this point of view and the types of actions that would normally have been associated (sic) the establishment of a de-factor (sic) relationship (ie. determining financial arrangements, transference of household goods, co-habitation agreements etc.) did not occur. Apart from Mr Brunswick’s weekend visits to Cooloongup, nothing changed. Mr Brunswick continued his established routine of golf and radio presentations in Collie and visiting Ms. Terry at the weekend. The other account put forward by both Ms. Terry and M. (sic) Brunswick asserts that the inclusion of the December dates is a mistake and provides a different sequence of dates and activities. This sequence of events is outlined above. (cf 3.7ff) This account centres around the sale of Mr. Brunswick’s house. All the things that one would expect to happen when a mature couple decide to enter a de-factor (sic) relationship happened and Mr Brunswick moved to Cooloongup. It should be noted that these arrangements were all concluded well before any questions about dates were raised by the Repatriation Commission (Exhibit A4, paragraph 4.6).