BRU15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BRU15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 453

Appeal from: BRU15 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017] FCCA 712
File number: NSD 617 of 2017
Judge: GLEESON J
Date of judgment: 12 April 2018
Catchwords: MIGRATION – whether to grant leave to amend notice of appeal – whether proposed amended ground of appeal meritless such that amendment futile – consideration of proper approach to corroborative evidence where provenance not established – appeal dismissed
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 r 36.10
Cases cited:

Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor [1996] HCA 25; (1996) 186 CLR 541

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao [2015] FCAFC 94; (2015) 236 FCR 322

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship vSZNSP [2010] FCAFC 50; (2010) 115 ALD 294

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex-parte ApplicantS20/2002 [2003] HCA 30; (2003) 198 ALR 59

Date of hearing: 2 March 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 35
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr PW Bodisco
Solicitor for the Appellant: Mr S Hodges of Hodges Legal
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms C Hillary
Solicitor for the Respondents: DLA Piper Australia

ORDERS

NSD 617 of 2017
BETWEEN:

BRU15

Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

GLEESON J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 APRIL 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Leave to amend the notice of appeal in accordance with the amended notice of appeal filed 26 February 2018 be refused.

2.The appeal be dismissed.

3.The appellant pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

GLEESON J:

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of a judge of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (“FCCA”) dismissing an application for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“AAT”): BRU15 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017] FCCA 712 (“FCCA judgment”). In its decision, the AAT affirmed a decision of a delegate of the first respondent (“Minister”) not to grant the appellant a protection visa.

  2. At the hearing of the appeal, the appellant sought leave to rely on an amended notice of appeal in substitution for the original notice of appeal, containing the following single ground of appeal:

    That her Honour erred by failing to find that there had not been a proper, genuine and realistic consideration of the evidence contained in a Human Rights Commission of Sri Lanka letter dated 25 February 2010 (“the HRC letter”) in circumstances where the [AAT] had made determinative and adverse credibility findings before assessing the corroborative evidence.

    Particulars

    a.Her Honour erred at [55] of the decision in holding that it was open to the [AAT] “to assess the credit of the applicant and then, in the light of that assessment, consider what weight should be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BRU15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 453
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In BRU15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the appellant, an irregular maritime arrival in Australia from Sri Lanka, sought leave to amend his notice of appeal against the refusal of his application for a protection visa. The appellant's application for a protection visa was based on claims of persecution due to his Tamil ethnicity, residence in the eastern province, illegal departure from Sri Lanka, and subsequent asylum application in Australia. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) found the appellant's evidence not credible and dismissed his appeal to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCCA). The FCCA judge upheld the AAT's decision, finding that the AAT had properly assessed the evidence and the weight to be given to the Human Rights Commission (HRC) letter provided by the appellant. The appellant now sought leave to amend his notice of appeal, arguing that the AAT did not adequately consider the HRC letter.

The primary legal issue was whether the proposed amendment to the grounds of appeal would be meritless and thus futile, warranting a refusal of leave to amend. The court had to determine if the AAT's assessment of the HRC letter was adequate and if the proposed amendment had any merit. The court considered the established principles regarding the assessment of documentary evidence, particularly in the context of corroborative evidence where the provenance is unproved, as in SZNSP. The court held that the AAT had properly exercised its discretion in giving no weight to the HRC letter due to the appellant's lack of credibility and the country information indicating that documents can be fabricated. The proposed amendment to the grounds of appeal was found to be meritless as the AAT had already considered the letter and the weight to be given to it.

The court concluded that the proposed amended ground of appeal was meritless and it would be futile to grant leave to amend the notice of appeal. The reasoning was that the AAT had adequately considered the HRC letter and decided to give it no weight based on the appellant's lack of credibility and the country information. The court found no error in the FCCA judge's conclusion that the AAT had considered the letter and what weight to give it. Therefore, the application for leave to amend the notice of appeal was refused, and the appeal was dismissed. The appellant was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to amend the notice of appeal in accordance with the amended notice of appeal filed 26 February 2018 be refused.

2. The appeal be dismissed.

3. The appellant pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

That leave was opposed by the Minister. Accordingly, it was convenient to hear the application for leave to amend the notice of appeal at the same time as the appeal.BACKGROUND TO APPEAL The appellant arrived in Australia as an irregular maritime arrival in July 2012 and lodged an application for a protection visa on 12 December 2012. A summary of the appellant’s claims for protection, prepared by his solicitor for the FCCA proceeding, is set out at [20] of the FCCA judge’s reasons. The summary concludes:The applicant claims to fear harm or persecution from the Sri Lankan authorities if he were to return to Sri Lanka, for the following reasons:10.1 He is of Tamil ethnicity.10.2 He lived in the eastern province.10.3 He departed Sri Lanka illegally.10.4 He applied for asylum in Australia. The protection visa application was accompanied by a letter dated 30 November 2012 which attached various documents including the HRC letter referred to in the proposed amended notice of appeal. The letter sets out a complaint number and states:This is to inform you that your complaint dated 25.02.2010 has been registered under the above number and is receiving attention of the commission. The letter is purportedly signed by the Regional Coordinator Human Rights Commission of Sri Lanka Regional Office Kalmunai. A handwritten annotation to the letter stated “Original sighted @ PV interview 14/6/13”.TRIBUNAL’S REASONS The written submissions filed on behalf of the appellant noted that the AAT dealt with his credibility under eleven headings commencing at para 25 of its decision record before ultimately concluding, at para 51, that the “Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant is a witness of truth”. Counsel for the appellant, Mr Bodisco, acknowledged that the appellant did not dispute that this conclusion was open to the Tribunal. At para 54 of the decision record, the AAT said:The Tribunal acknowledges that the applicant provided some consistent evidence throughout the process about the key events (for example, he claimed he feared unidentified people who had visited his family home wearing masks and had asked for his whereabouts). However, the Tribunal is not persuaded that these matters can overcome the difficulties with the applicant’s evidence as referred to above. At para 55 of the decision record, the AAT said:The applicant provided supporting documents. The Tribunal noted at hearing that there was country information indicating that documents can be fabricated, and it would have to weigh up that information together with credibility concerns. The documents provided included a letter from the HRC which acknowledged a complaint had been made. Having regard to the credibility concerns and the country information, the Tribunal is not prepared to accept that this is a genuine letter. The Tribunal does not give this letter any weight.FCCA DECISION The appellant argued two grounds in the FCCA proceeding. The first ground raised a complaint of denial of procedural fairness. The FCCA judge’s decision on the first ground is not the subject of the appeal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

At para 55 of the decision record, the AAT said:The applicant provided supporting documents. The Tribunal noted at hearing that there was country information indicating that documents can be fabricated, and it would have to weigh up that information together with credibility concerns. The documents provided included a letter from the HRC which acknowledged a complaint had been made. Having regard to the credibility concerns and the country information, the Tribunal is not prepared to accept that this is a genuine letter. The Tribunal does not give this letter any weight.FCCA DECISION The appellant argued two grounds in the FCCA proceeding. The first ground raised a complaint of denial of procedural fairness. The FCCA judge’s decision on the first ground is not the subject of the appeal. The second ground was that the AAT failed to assess and weigh five documents provided by the appellant. One of the documents was the HRC letter. The FCCA judge set out the HRC letter at [46] of her Honour’s reasons. At [48], her Honour set out para 55 of the AAT’s decision record. At [50], her Honour recorded the submission made on behalf of the appellant that the HRC letter was potentially corroborative of the appellant’s assertion of having received a death threat in 2010, and that his parents went to the Human Rights Commission in Sri Lanka following that event. After considering the AAT’s reasons, at [54] her Honour noted the AAT’s acknowledgment “that the applicant had provided some consistent evidence, but was not persuaded that it was sufficient to overcome the Tribunal’s overall difficulties with the applicant’s evidence detailed by it in its decision record”. At [55], her Honour concluded that it was open to the AAT to assess the credit of the appellant and then, in light of that assessment, consider what weight should be given to the HRC letter. Her Honour referred to Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex-parte ApplicantS20/2002 [2003] HCA 30; (2003) 198 ALR 59 (“S20/2002”) and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship vSZNSP [2010] FCAFC 50; (2010) 115 ALD 294 at [33] (“SZNSP”) in support of this proposition. In SZNSP at [33], North and Lander JJ (Katzmann J agreeing) said:[C]onsistently with Applicant S20/2002 198 ALR 59 it was open to the RRT to assess the credit of the first respondent and then, in the light of that assessment, consider what weight should be given to the witness statement. This was the process followed by the RRT which it described in the sentence “Given the adverse credibility finding, the Tribunal does not give weight to the document”. Although expressed in the most cryptic terms, this statement shows that the RRT made an assessment of the value of the witness statement and then considered its effect in the light of the view it had formed to that point about the credibility of the first respondent. At [56] to [58], the FCCA judge said:The Tribunal’s finding to put no weight on the HRC letter was made in the light of country information before it that documents can be fabricated and its adverse credibility findings in respect of the applicant. Moreover, the HRC letter itself gave no information whatsoever about the nature of the complaint, although it was dated early 2010.In the circumstances, the Tribunal considered the HRC letter and what weight to give it. Its conclusion that it gave it no weight was open to it on the evidence and material before it and for the reasons it gave.Accordingly, Ground 4 is not made out.LEAVE TO AMEND NOTICE OF APPEAL

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to [56] of the FCCA judge’s reasons, Mr Bodisco described the second part of the first sentence (that the AAT’s finding to put no weight on the letter was made in the light of its adverse credibility findings in respect of the appellant) as “questionable” and the second sentence (making findings about the letter) as a “merits-based assessment”. Mr Bodisco concluded by saying that the FCCA judge’s conclusion, at [57], that the AAT considered the HRC letter and what weight to give it “simply did not occur”, in that it was not considered “against the backdrop of a presumptive conclusion as the other matters were”. I understood the criticism to be that the AAT did not consider whether the letter could redress or displace its “credibility concerns”.CONSIDERATION I do not accept Mr Bodisco’s argument. The HRC letter is materially different from the corroborative evidence that was the subject of S20/2002, in that its provenance was not established. It is documentary evidence of the kind considered in SZNSP, the provenance of which was unproved. As the Full Court concluded in SZNSP, there is nothing irrational in rejecting a document by giving it no weight where there is no evidence other than the applicant’s to say that it is a genuine document. I respectfully agree with their Honours’ observation, towards the end of [36] of their Honours’ reasons:In circumstances where the provenance of the document is unproved, but it is proffered by a witness whose credibility has been destroyed, the document has no more credit than the person proffering it. Thus, there was no requirement for the AAT to assess the HRC letter against “the backdrop of a presumptive conclusion”. As set out above, at para 55 of the decision record, the AAT considered the HRC letter and decided to give it no weight in light of the country information and its credibility concerns. It follows that the FCCA judge was correct to find that the AAT considered the HRC letter and what weight to give it. Accordingly, the proposed amended ground of appeal has no merit and it would be futile to grant leave to amend.CONCLUSION Leave to amend the notice of appeal is refused. The appeal must therefore be dismissed. Costs should follow the event.