Supreme Court
New South Wales
Case Title: Brown v Hodgkinson; Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd v Abadeen Group Pty Ltd; Medium Neutral Citation: [2012] NSWSC 1627 Hearing Date(s): 17 December 2012 Decision Date: 17 December 2012 Jurisdiction: Equity Division - Corporations List Before: Brereton J Decision: Order that caveators consent to registration of mortgage to permit finance to be raised to pay debt to caveators
Cases Cited: Brown & Ors v Hodgkinson & Ors [2009] NSWSC 262
Brown & Ors v Hodgkinson & Ors (No 3) [2009] NSWSC 436
In the Matter of First Equilibrium Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 1624Category: Interlocutory applications Parties: 2008/277880:
Justin John Brown - First Plaintiff
Sharlotte Pty Ltd - Second Plaintiff
Abadeen Group Pty Ltd - Third Plaintiff
Lighter Quay Investments Ltd - Fourth Plaintiff
Greenberg Investments Development Ltd - Fifth Plaintiff
Lance Hodgkinson - First Defendant
Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd - Second Defendant
230 Palmer Street Pty Ltd - Third Defendant
Daniel Hausman - Fourth Defendant
Crown Street Developments Pty Ltd - Fifth Defendant
519 St Kilda Road Developments Pty Ltd - Sixth Defendant
Gorcha Pty Ltd - Seventh Defendant
2008/279957:
Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd - First Plaintiff
Namsauh Holdings Pty Ltd - Second Plaintiff
519 St Kilda Road Developments Pty Ltd - Third Plaintiff
Abadeen Group Pty - First Defendant
Brooke Brown - Second DefendantRepresentation - Counsel: Counsel:
J Baird - Plaintiff
P Newton - Defendant- Solicitors: Solicitors:
ERA Legal - First & Second Plaintiffs
Levitt Robinson Solicitors - First and Second DefendantsFile Number(s): 2008/277880
2008/279957
JUDGMENT (EX TEMPORE)
HIS HONOUR: On 8 April 2009, Palmer J gave judgment for Bluestone Property Services against Abadeen Group Pty Ltd, now First Equilibrium, for $600,000 [proceedings 2008/277880], and for two other companies against Abadeen and Brooke Brown, respectively, for $200,000 and $150,000 [proceedings 2008/279957] [Brown & Ors v Hodgkinson & Ors [2009] NSWSC 262].
On 19 May 2009, his Honour made orders staying the judgment pending appeal, upon two conditions: first, that the Brown parties file a notice of appeal within seven days; and secondly, that the Brown parties provide mortgages in a form acceptable to the Hodgkinsons' parties solicitors within 14 days [Brown & Ors v Hodgkinson & Ors (No 3) [2009] NSWSC 436].
In due course, such mortgages were provided, including a mortgage the subject of the present application by Justin John Brown as registered proprietor over land described as Lot 7 XXXXX . The mortgage contains provisions that it is a second ranking equitable mortgage, subject only to any prior mortgage, there being a prior mortgage to the Trust Company Australia Limited in respect of the properties comprised in SPXXXX, and to AMP Bank Limited in respect of the properties comprised in SPXXXX.
The mortgage contains, in clause 12.38, a provision in these terms:
The mortgagee will only be under an obligation to grant a release of the mortgaged property from this mortgage upon an order of the court in the proceedings.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Brown v Hodgkinson; Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd v Ab... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NSWSC 1656
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the judgment creditor, Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd, could be compelled to consent to the registration of a mortgage on property to secure a loan from Fixx Commercial Pty Limited, which would be used to pay off a portion of the debt owed to Bluestone. The court needed to consider whether such an order would be appropriate, particularly in light of the existing equitable mortgage and the potential impact on the priority of the mortgages.
In delivering the judgment, the court noted that the existing mortgage was a second-ranking equitable mortgage, subject only to any prior mortgage. The court acknowledged that Bluestone had chosen to pursue its debt through a creditors' statutory demand rather than enforcing its mortgages directly. The court concluded that it would not be appropriate to restrain the judgment debtor from mortgaging property to raise funds to pay the judgment creditor. The court found that it was reasonable for Bluestone to consent to the registration of the mortgage to Fixx Commercial Pty Limited, as it would enable Bluestone to receive payment of the debt owed to it, albeit with a reduced priority. The court ordered that the caveators consent to the registration of the mortgage, subject to certain undertakings and conditions.
The final orders of the court were that upon the tender of a bank cheque in the sum of $294,689.67 to Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd, the caveators under Caveat AF221988H would deliver to Mr Brown a consent to the registration of the mortgage to Fixx Commercial Pty Limited, with priority over the existing mortgage to Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd. This consent was contingent on the provision of an undertaking by the relevant parties that they would not further encumber the properties and that the mortgage would secure only the obligations of the borrower as outlined in the loan agreement.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case originated with judgments entered on 8 April 2009 by Palmer J in proceedings 2008/277880 and 2008/279957. Palmer J stayed the judgment pending appeal on 19 May 2009, subject to certain conditions including the provision of mortgages. The Brown parties complied with the conditions, and the stay remained in effect until the appeals were unsuccessful. Bluestone served a creditor's statutory demand on First Equilibrium on 18 September 2012, which was varied to $294,689.67 on 10 December 2012. On 13 December 2012, Justin John Brown filed a Notice of Motion seeking an order to permit the registration of a mortgage to Fixx Commercial Pty Limited to secure the payment of $294,689.67 to Bluestone and to allow the consent of the caveators to the registration of the mortgage with priority over Bluestone's existing mortgage.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court should vary the terms of the security ordered by Palmer J on 19 May 2009 to allow the registration of a mortgage to Fixx Commercial Pty Limited for the payment of $294,689.67 to Bluestone and to permit the consent of the caveators to the registration of the mortgage with priority over Bluestone's existing mortgage.
2. Whether Bluestone should be permitted to oppose the application despite having chosen to proceed by creditors' statutory demand and having had ample opportunity to enforce its mortgages by other means.
Held
1. The Court granted the application to vary the terms of the security ordered by Palmer J on 19 May 2009 to allow the registration of a mortgage to Fixx Commercial Pty Limited for the payment of $294,689.67 to Bluestone and to permit the consent of the caveators to the registration of the mortgage with priority over Bluestone's existing mortgage.
2. The Court dismissed Bluestone's opposition to the application, despite Bluestone having chosen to proceed by creditors' statutory demand and having had ample opportunity to enforce its mortgages by other means.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court addressed the application under the authority of the Corporations Act 2001 and the equitable principle that a court is unlikely to restrain a judgment debtor from mortgaging or charging their property for the purpose of raising funds to pay the judgment creditor. The court found that the application sought to free enough of the judgment debtor's assets to enable the satisfaction of Bluestone's demand, and that Bluestone's choice to proceed by creditors' statutory demand precluded it from opposing the application. The court ordered that the caveators consent to the registration of the mortgage to Fixx Commercial Pty Limited, provided the applicants undertook not to further encumber the properties and that the mortgage secured only the obligations of the borrower. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a judgment creditor who has chosen to proceed by creditors' statutory demand cannot oppose an application to allow the judgment debtor to raise funds to satisfy the debt, even if it results in the judgment creditor losing priority over other creditors. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by emphasising the importance of the judgment debtor's ability to raise funds to pay the judgment creditor and the judgment creditor's choice of enforcement method.