Brown v Havenfoot Pty Ltd trading as Ibis Pools

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Brown v Havenfoot Pty Ltd trading as Ibis Pools & Anor [2019] QCAT 1

PARTIES:

PAUL DAVID BROWN
(applicant)

v

HAVENFOOT PTY LTD trading as IBIS POOLS

(first respondent)

TAYLOR ASSOCIATES PTY LTD
(second respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

BDL077-15

MATTER TYPE:

Building matters

DELIVERED ON:

2 January 2019

HEARING DATE:

17 November, 2016, 18 November 2016, 26 April 2017 and on the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Burke

ORDERS:

1.   The First Respondent and the Second Respondent make payment to the Applicant the sum of $52,120.00.

2.   The First Respondent make payment to the Applicant the sum of $7,000.00 as damages for breach of contract.

3.   The First Respondent and the Second Respondent are to deliver submissions to the tribunal in relation to each of their contribution to the said sum referred to in Order 1 on or before 18 January 2019.

4.   The Applicant is to deliver submissions in reply regarding the proportion of contribution of each of the First Respondent and Second Respondent  the sum referred to in Order 1 on or before 1 February 2019.

5.    Submissions on costs to be delivered by all parties on or before 1 February 2019.

CATCHWORDS: 

CONTRACTS – BUILDING AND ENGINEERING CONTRACTS – PERFORMANCE OF WORK – REMEDIES FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT – whether measure of damages replacement or rectification costs – whether rectification works necessary and reasonable course to adopt – joint experts

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – ENGINEERS – NEGLIGENCE – negligence of engineer – joint and several liability – contribution to damages

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 77, s 168(1)
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), Schedule 2, Schedule 1B section 4

Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613, applied
Kirby & Anor v Coote & Anor [2006] QCA 61
Robinson v Harman [1848] Eng R 135; (1848) 1 Exch. 850
Ruxley Electronics & Construction Co Ltd v Forsyth [1996] AC 344, considered
Tabcorp Holdings Pty Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 8
Tranquility Pools & Spas Pty Limited v Huntsman Chemical Co Pty Limited [2011] NSWSC 75
Wheeler & Anor v Ecroplot Pty Ltd [2010] NSWCA 61

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

C L Ray, solicitor of McKay Solicitors

First Respondent:

Self-represented

Second Respondent:

P Chandra, Meridian Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This application is to be determined by me as directed by the President of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal pursuant to s 168(1) of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (‘the QCAT Act’) having regard to the decisions and records of proceedings of the Tribunal as previously constituted and delivered to me on 3 November 2018.

  2. These proceedings involve a domestic building dispute as defined in Schedule 2 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) (‘the QBCC Act’) between the applicant, as a building owner, and the First Respondent, as a building contractor, relating to the performance of reviewable domestic work or a contract for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brown v Havenfoot Pty Ltd trading as Ibis Pools and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Brown v Havenfoot Pty Ltd trading as Ibis Pools involved a dispute over the construction of a pool at a property in Tinbeerwah, Queensland. The applicant, Paul Brown, had engaged Ibis Pools to construct a reinforced concrete in-ground swimming pool. However, after the completion of the construction, Brown noticed that the pool was not level, leading to the commencement of this legal action. The primary legal issues in this case were the measure of damages for breach of contract and negligence, specifically whether the costs of replacement or rectification were appropriate, and if the proposed rectification works were necessary and reasonable. Additionally, the court had to determine the extent of the engineer’s liability and the potential for joint and several liability between the builder and the engineer.

The court found that both Ibis Pools and Taylor & Associates Pty Ltd were responsible for the necessary rectification work due to their respective breaches of contract and negligence. The court directed that the rectification costs be shared between the builder and the engineer, inviting the parties to submit their contributions to these costs. The tribunal held that Ibis Pools was liable for additional damages due to a breach of contract concerning the lighting cables. The court ordered that both respondents pay a total of $52,120.00 to the applicant for breach of contract and/or negligence, with Ibis Pools also ordered to pay an additional $7,000.00 for the lighting cable defect.

The final orders of the tribunal included payment of the rectification costs by both respondents, with further submissions required to determine the specific contributions of each party. The parties were also required to submit on the costs of the proceedings by a specified date. This decision underscores the importance of adherence to contractual obligations and professional standards in construction projects, highlighting the shared responsibility of both builders and engineers in ensuring the quality and safety of construction works.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The First Respondent and the Second Respondent make payment to the Applicant the sum of $52,120.00.

2. The First Respondent make payment to the Applicant the sum of $7,000.00 as damages for breach of contract.

3. The First Respondent and the Second Respondent are to deliver submissions to the tribunal in relation to each of their contribution to the said sum referred to in Order 1 on or before 18 January 2019.

4. The Applicant is to deliver submissions in reply regarding the proportion of contribution of each of the First Respondent and Second Respondent the sum referred to in Order 1 on or before 1 February 2019.

5. Submissions on costs to be delivered by all parties on or before 1 February 2019.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Second Respondent filed a defence on 29 June 2015 resisting the Applicant’s claim and requesting dismissal of the Applicant’s claim on the following bases:(a)neither the first or second orders sought by the Applicant are relevant to the Second Respondent; and(b)if the Second Respondent owed a duty of care to the Applicant, which is denied, the Second Respondent relies upon the scope of retainer with the First Respondent, the geotechnical report provided to the Second Respondent and the class M classification of the site by Soils Test Australia to assert that it did not breach its duty in the provision of engineering services as the Second Respondent acted in a way that (at the time the service was provided) was widely accepted by peer professional opinion by a significant number of respected practitioners in the field as competent professional practice.Background The Applicant, Paul Brown (‘Brown’) is the owner of a home located at 547 Sunrise Road, Tinbeerwah which is a semi-rural area west of Noosa in Queensland (‘the property’). The property was purchased in 2011 by Brown and his wife, with the expectation of constructing a pool and outdoor area to take advantage of the views from the home across the valley. The property is situated on the top of a hill with expansive views to the valley and beyond. The pool is said to be a focal feature of the property in that it can be seen from every vantage point of the living areas of the house.[2][2]Photographs attached as Annexure D to Exhibit 1. It is common ground that:(a)on 14 September 2011, Brown entered into a contract with Mr Crane (‘Crane’), on behalf of the First Respondent, Havenfoot Pty Ltd trading as Ibis Pools (‘Ibis Pools’), whereby Ibis Pools was to construct a reinforced concrete in-ground swimming pool at the property (‘the contract’);[3](b)the contract price for the contract works was $66,760.00;(c)the special conditions of the contract stated:Geotech and 6 piers includedStart ASAPFinish 10 weeks to be advised;[4](d)the Second Respondent, Taylor & Associates Pty Ltd (‘Taylor’), provided design drawings numbers 697/9-1 and 697/9-2;[5](e)Taylor issued a Form 15 Compliance Certificate for Building Design or Specification dated 23 September 2011 in respect of the construction of the pool at the property which provided:Site inspection to confirm design criteria as detailed on drawings No’s 697/9 – 1 and 2 provided 450 dia mass concrete bored piers at not more than 2.0m centres are placed under the downslope wall to found into competent natural material;[6](f)the pool was constructed by Ibis Pools between 20 September 2011 and 12 December 2011. [3]Annexure A to Exhibit 1.[4]Annexure A to Exhibit 1.[5]Annexure B to Exhibit 1.[6]Annexure C to Exhibit 1. On 16 December 2011, Shaun Stuart of Stuart Building Certification Service, issued a Form 17 Final Inspection Certificate. In January 2014, Brown noticed that the pool was not level as a result of movement and tilting of the pool and thus he began to monitor the water levels of the pool.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Since 2014, a number of experts have been engaged to consider the cause of the movement of the pool and have given advice on rectification methods.Evidence of the Applicant Mr Brown Brown and his wife first met Crane, on behalf of Ibis Pools, in early September 2011. At an initial inspection of the property, Brown says that he discussed with Crane the slope of the steep gradient of the downhill slope where the pool was to be located and other issues including the soakage pits which run the length of one side of the home and extend to within five metres of the proposed site of the pool. The problem with roots and trees in the area was also discussed. On 5 September 2011, Ibis Pools provided to Brown a quotation for the construction of the pool.[7][7]Exhibit 24. On 14 September 2011, Mr and Mrs Brown and Crane, on behalf of Ibis Pools, executed a contract for the construction of the pool in accordance with design drawings attached to the contract.[8][8]Annexure A to Exhibit 1. Brown always considered that any geotechnical reports required for the construction would be obtained by Ibis Pools. Brown resided in Gladstone during construction so their monitoring of the construction was limited. Brown was not aware of the engagement of the engineer by Ibis Pools and basically left any necessary applications or compliance with Council requirements to Ibis Pools. Brown did however receive the Form 15 Compliance Certificate from Ibis Pools on 23 September 2011. Whilst the pool was being constructed between September 2011 and December 2011, Mr and Mrs Brown were happy with the construction except for an issue with the tiles used by Ibis Pools. In the year after construction of the pool, Brown carried out works near the pool including the removal of a 20 to 30 metre tall gum tree which was situated about 2.5m from the end of the pool.[9] Brown also installed a timber deck.[9]Annexure E to Exhibit 1. In about January 2014, Brown noticed that the pool was out of level and the tiles between the coping and the concourse had separated with the expansion joint increasing from 5mm to 14mm. Brown measured the pool level which was out of level by 34mm. On about 8 March 2014, Brown contacted Crane to advise him of the problem with the level of the pool and the tiling of the pool. Brown gave evidence that on contacting Crane he was advised by Crane that it was his view and that of Mr Taylor, the engineer, that it was the timber deck which was pulling the pool down the slope. Crane advised Brown to prop the deck to alleviate the load of the deck from the pool. Brown engaged a structural engineer, Mr Cox from COJE Consulting Engineers, to inspect the pool and to prepare a report regarding the cause of the movement. Mr Cox advised Brown in a report dated 14 April 2014 (‘the COJO report’) that the timber deck was not contributing to the problem and that the design provided by Taylor had in fact accommodated the weight of a cantilevered walkway on the downside slope of the pool with a much heavier weight than the deck.[10][10]Report of COJO Consulting Engineers dated 14 April 2014 referred to at paragraph 7 Exhibit 16

Decision

Reasons for decision

No evidence was produced to support Brown’s claim in relation to the alleged damaged lighting cables. Accordingly, I am unable to assess if there is any further costs involved for this defect.Conclusions and Orders Based on my findings above, I have concluded that both the builder, Ibis Pools, and the engineer, Taylor, are culpable for the rectification work required to remedy the tilting pool. Given that the parties have not addressed the contribution of each to the damage which has been caused, I invite the parties to make submissions regarding their contribution to the rectification costs. Accordingly, I make the following orders:(a)the First Respondent and Second Respondent are to make payment to the Applicant the sum of $52,120.00 as damages for breach of contract and/or negligence;(b)the First Respondent is to make payment to the Applicant the sum of $7,000.00 as damages for breach of contract;(c)the First Respondent and Second Respondent are to deliver submissions to the tribunal on or before 14 January 2019 addressing the proportion of each of their contribution to the sum referred to in (a) above;(d)by way of reply, the Applicant is to deliver submissions regarding the proportion of contribution by each of the First Respondent and Second Respondent to the sum referred to in (a) above on or before 28 January 2019;(e)Submissions as to costs of the proceedings are to be delivered on or before 28 January 2019 with the application for costs to be determined on the papers without an oral hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.