QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CITATION:
Brown v AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy [2024] QCATA 14
PARTIES:
CAMERON JAMES BROWN (appellant)
v
AGY GLOBAL WEALTH PTY LTD T/AS SKYLIGHT ENERGY (respondent)
APPLICATION NO/S:
APL053-22
ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:
MCDO60397/21 (Brisbane)
MATTER TYPE:
Appeals
DELIVERED ON:
13 February 2024
HEARING DATE:
On the papers
HEARD AT:
Brisbane
DECISION OF:
Member Gordon
ORDERS:
1. Leave to appeal is granted and the appeal is allowed.
2. The order made in MCDO60397/21 (Brisbane) on 23 February 2022 is set aside.
3. If AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy wishes to proceed with application MCDO60397/21 (Brisbane) in the building list then a payment of the additional filing fee of $226.60 must be made to the tribunal registry in Brisbane by 4pm on 28 March 2024.
4. AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy is asked to inform the tribunal under reference APL053-22 and Cameron James Brown upon making the payment and provide the payment receipt.
5. If the payment is not made by 4pm on 28 March 2024 then AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy will have lost the opportunity to make the payment and MCDO60397/21 (Brisbane) is stayed and shall be recorded as finalised without further order.
6. If the payment is made by 4pm on 28 March 2024 then the following orders shall take effect:
(a) MCDO60397/21 (Brisbane) is transferred to the building list and will proceed as a domestic building dispute.
(b) MCDO228/22 (Brisbane) is also transferred to the building list and will proceed as a domestic building dispute travelling with MCDO60397/21.
(c) AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy must by 4pm on 19 April 2024 file in the tribunal under the correct BDL case number, and give to Cameron James Brown, evidence showing whether prior to 18 June 2021, the QBCC offered a dispute resolution process for a dispute about a solar panel installation to a dwelling.
(d) If the QBCC did offer a dispute resolution process for a dispute about a solar panel installation to a dwelling prior to 18 June 2021 then AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy must by 4pm on 19 April 2024 file in the tribunal, and give to Cameron James Brown, evidence showing that it complied with that process prior to filing the application in MCDO60397/21.
(e) Cameron James Brown must by 4pm on 19 April 2024 file in the tribunal under the correct BDL case number, and give to AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy, evidence showing whether prior to 4 March 2022, the QBCC offered a dispute resolution process for a dispute about a solar panel installation to a dwelling.
(f) If the QBCC did offer a dispute resolution process for a dispute about a solar panel installation to a dwelling prior to 4 March 2022 then Cameron James Brown must by 4pm on 19 April 2024 file in the tribunal, and give to AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Brown v Agy Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] QCATA 14
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the solar panel installation constituted an improvement to the property, thereby making the dispute a building dispute, and if so, whether QCAT had jurisdiction to hear the claim as a minor civil dispute. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the claim should be transferred to the building list and whether the tribunal had the authority to impose conditions for such a transfer, including the payment of an additional filing fee.
The court found that the solar panel installation constituted an improvement to the property and that the dispute was indeed a building dispute. Consequently, QCAT did not have jurisdiction to hear the claim as a minor civil dispute. The tribunal concluded that the appeal tribunal could impose conditions for transferring the application to the building list, including the payment of an additional filing fee. If the fee was not paid by the specified deadline, the application would be stayed and recorded as finalised without further order. If the fee was paid, the application would be transferred to the building list, and the parties would be required to exchange evidence related to the contract and any dispute resolution processes offered by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC).
The tribunal granted leave to appeal and allowed the appeal, setting aside the previous order. Agy Global Wealth Pty Ltd was given the opportunity to proceed with the application in the building list by paying the additional filing fee by 28 March 2024. If the payment was made, the application would be transferred to the building list, and a series of evidentiary exchanges between the parties were mandated. A building list directions hearing was scheduled to be fixed after 19 April 2024.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Leave to appeal is granted and the appeal is allowed.
2. The order made in MCDO60397/21 (Brisbane) on 23 February 2022 is set aside.
3. If AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy wishes to proceed with application MCDO60397/21 (Brisbane) in the building list then a payment of the additional filing fee of $226.60 must be made to the tribunal registry in Brisbane by 4pm on 28 March 2024.
4. AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy is asked to inform the tribunal under reference APL053-22 and Cameron James Brown upon making the payment and provide the payment receipt.
5. If the payment is not made by 4pm on 28 March 2024 then AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy will have lost the opportunity to make the payment and MCDO60397/21 (Brisbane) is stayed and shall be recorded as finalised without further order.
6. If the payment is made by 4pm on 28 March 2024 then the following orders shall take effect:
(a) MCDO60397/21 (Brisbane) is transferred to the building list and will proceed as a domestic building dispute.
(b) MCDO228/22 (Brisbane) is also transferred to the building list and will proceed as a domestic building dispute travelling with MCDO60397/21.
(c) AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy must by 4pm on 19 April 2024 file in the tribunal under the correct BDL case number, and give to Cameron James Brown, evidence showing whether prior to 18 June 2021, the QBCC offered a dispute resolution process for a dispute about a solar panel installation to a dwelling.
(d) If the QBCC did offer a dispute resolution process for a dispute about a solar panel installation to a dwelling prior to 18 June 2021 then AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy must by 4pm on 19 April 2024 file in the tribunal, and give to Cameron James Brown, evidence showing that it complied with that process prior to filing the application in MCDO60397/21.
(e) Cameron James Brown must by 4pm on 19 April 2024 file in the tribunal under the correct BDL case number, and give to AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy, evidence showing whether prior to 4 March 2022, the QBCC offered a dispute resolution process for a dispute about a solar panel installation to a dwelling.
(f) If the QBCC did offer a dispute resolution process for a dispute about a solar panel installation to a dwelling prior to 4 March 2022 then Cameron James Brown must by 4pm on 19 April 2024 file in the tribunal, and give to AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy, evidence showing that he complied with that process prior to filing the application in MCDO228/22 (Brisbane).
(g) AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy and Cameron James Brown must by 4pm on 19 April 2024 file in the tribunal under the correct BDL case number, and give to each other, evidence showing how the contract between them to install the solar panel system came about, exhibiting all emails texts and messages and all quotations specifications plans drawings and draft contracts in full.
(h) AGY Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy and Cameron James Brown must by 4pm on 19 April 2024 file in the tribunal under the correct BDL case number, and give to each other, any further evidence on which they wish to rely in this matter.
(i) There shall be a building list directions hearing for the matters transferred on a date to be fixed after 19 April 2024.
Background
Background to the litigation
Agy Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy filed an application in the minor civil dispute jurisdiction of the tribunal seeking payment of the remaining balance of its invoice for the solar panel installation. The Adjudicator determined in favour of Agy Global Wealth Pty Ltd t/as Skylight Energy. Mr Brown appealed the Adjudicator's decision to the Appeal Tribunal. The Appeal Tribunal heard the appeal and decided to allow the appeal and set aside the Adjudicator's decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the tribunal had jurisdiction to hear and determine the claim as a minor civil dispute.
2. Whether there should be an oral hearing of the appeal.
3. Whether leave to appeal should be given and the decision set aside.
4. Whether the Appeal Tribunal can itself transfer the application to the building list on payment of the additional filing fee.
5. Whether the Appeal Tribunal can stay the application indefinitely if the additional filing fee is not paid.
Held
1. The tribunal did not have jurisdiction to hear and determine the claim as a minor civil dispute because the claim was a building dispute.
2. An oral hearing of the appeal should not be held because the appeal did not raise significant questions of law or mixed law and fact.
3. Leave to appeal should be granted and the decision should be set aside because the tribunal incorrectly exercised its jurisdiction.
4. The Appeal Tribunal can transfer the application to the building list on payment of the additional filing fee.
5. The Appeal Tribunal can stay the application indefinitely if the additional filing fee is not paid.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined whether the tribunal had jurisdiction to hear the claim as a minor civil dispute. The tribunal exercised its jurisdiction under the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 but the claim was a building dispute, not a minor civil dispute. The tribunal's jurisdiction was limited to minor civil disputes and did not extend to building disputes. This was a significant error of law. The court allowed the appeal on this basis.
The court considered whether there should be an oral hearing of the appeal. It was found that the appeal did not raise significant questions of law or mixed law and fact, thus an oral hearing was not necessary.
The court then addressed whether leave to appeal should be granted and the decision set aside. Given that the tribunal exercised its jurisdiction incorrectly, the court granted leave to appeal and set aside the decision. The tribunal's error of law was substantial enough to justify setting aside the original decision.
The court also ruled on whether the Appeal Tribunal could transfer the application to the building list on payment of the additional filing fee. It found that the tribunal had the authority to transfer the application under the relevant legislation, provided the additional filing fee was paid.
Lastly, the court determined that the Appeal Tribunal could stay the application indefinitely if the additional filing fee was not paid. This power was necessary to ensure that the tribunal's processes were adhered to and to manage the tribunal's resources effectively. The court's decision was grounded in the tribunal's statutory authority and the need to maintain orderly proceedings.