DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 641
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No V01/880
VETERANS APPEALS DIVISION )
Re MERVYN THOMAS BROWN
Applicant
And REPATRIATION COMMISSION
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Mr J. Handley, Senior Member
Date26 July 2002
PlaceMelbourne
Decision The decision under review is affirmed.
.............Sgd. Mr J. Handley ................
Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
Veterans' Entitlements - applicant fell in 1944 - whether clinical onset within 25 years of accident whether definition of trauma of (affected) joint satisfied - decision affirmed.
Statement of Principle Instrument No. 82 of 2001
REASONS FOR DECISION
26 July 2002 Mr J. Handley, Senior Member
The applicant applies to review a decision of the Veteran's Review Board ("VRB") made on 23 May 2001. The VRB then decided to affirm a decision made by the Repatriation Commission on 7 July 2000, which refused his claim for acceptance of localised osteoarthrosis of the left knee.
The applicant presently has sensori neural hearing loss of the left ear and bilateral tinnitus, which is accepted as war-caused. The rejected disabilities are osteoarthrosis of both hips and both knees and ischaemic heart disease.
This application only concerns a decision made with respect to the rejection of the claim for localised osteoarthrosis of the left knee.
Mr Brown is presently 76 years of age, born on 6 January 1926. At all relevant times, Mr Brown was a member of the Royal Australian Air Force and served within Australia only. Accordingly, his application is to be determined upon the balance of probabilities.
The application for acceptance of localised osteoarthrosis of the left knee was made on 1 June 2000. At that date, Statement of Principle No. 42 of 1998 was in force. It was subsequently amended by Instrument No. 20 of 1999, only with respect (relevantly) to the definition of "trauma to a joint". Instrument No. 82 of 2001 was issued on 9 October 2001 and it revoked both of the above instruments.
Having regard to the circumstances of the applicants alleged injury (refer later), the applicable factor in Instrument No. 42 of 1998 is 5(h) namely-
"suffering a trauma to a joint within the 25 years immediately before the clinical onset of osteoarthrosis in that joint; or …….."
"Trauma to a joint" is defined at paragraph 8 of that Instrument and it reads-
""trauma to a joint" means a discrete joint injury that causes the development within 24 hours of the injury being sustained, of acute symptoms and signs of pain, swelling, tenderness, and altered mobility or range of movement of that joint. These acute symptoms and signs must last for a period of at least 10 days immediately after the injury occurs;".
Instrument No. 20 of 1999 amended the above definition of "trauma to a joint" by deleting the words "acute" & "swelling" as it previously appeared. In lieu of the words "immediately after the injury occurs", as those words appear after the words "10 days", the words "following their onset" appears. Additionally, the latter definition refers…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Brown and Repatriation Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] AATA 641
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine if Mr Brown's knee injury could be classified as "trauma" under the definitions provided and if the injury occurred within the requisite timeframe of 25 years prior to the clinical onset of osteoarthrosis. This involved examining the evidence presented by Mr Brown, including his recollection of the incident, his subsequent medical history, and the testimonies of medical experts, particularly Dr Houghton.
The court concluded that while Mr Brown did suffer a knee injury in 1944 and currently exhibits osteoarthrosis in his left knee, the evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate that the symptoms of the injury lasted for the minimum required period of 10 days post-injury. Additionally, the court found that the clinical onset of osteoarthrosis occurred outside the stipulated 25-year window, thus failing to meet the criteria set forth in the relevant Statement of Principles. As a result, the decision to deny Mr Brown's claim was affirmed.
The court's decision was final, affirming the respondent's ruling that Mr Brown's claim did not meet the necessary criteria for a service-connected injury under the relevant legislation and principles.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi