Brown and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   BROWN & ANOR and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2007] WASAT 241

MEMBER:   MR R EASTON (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   27 JULY 2007

DELIVERED          :   17 SEPTEMBER 2007

FILE NO/S:   DR 151 of 2007

BETWEEN:   MARIA ANNE BROWN

IAN REGINALD BROWN
Applicant

AND

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town Planning - Subdivision - Rural land - Productive agricultural land - Townsite - Draft planning scheme - Statement of Planning Policy No 2.5 "Agricultural & Rural Land Use Planning" - Policy No DC 3.4 "Subdidivision of Rural Land" - Precedent - Rural character - Existing subdivision pattern - Special exemptions of s 138(3) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) - Hardship provisions of s 241(3) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA)

Legislation:

Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 24(5), s 25, s 138, s 138(3), s 241, s 241(3), s 250(1)
Shire of Irwin Draft Local Planning Scheme No 5, cl 5.30.1, cl 6.3
Shire of Irwin Town Planning Scheme No 4, cl 3.7, cl 3.7.1(3), cl 3.7.2(3), cl 5.2.8, cl 5.2.8(e)(iii)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 29
Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), s 5AA

Result:

The application for review is allowed
The decision of the respondent is set aside and conditional approval granted

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr Wittkuhn

Respondent:     Ms Patterson

Solicitors:

Applicant:     McLeods Barristers & Solicitors

Respondent:     State Solicitor's Office

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Aspen Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission (Unreported; Appeal No 13 of 1988, 21 October 1988)

Goldin & Anor v Minister for Transport (2002) 121 LGERA 101

Hill v State Planning Commission (1994) 10 SR (WA) 354

Landpark Holdings Pty Ltd and Western Australian Planning Commission [2007] WASAT 130

Marshall v Western Australian Planning Commission (1995) 15 SR (WA) 170

Nicholls v Western Australian Planning Commission (2006) 149 LGERA 117

Perrymead Investments Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission (1996) 16 SR (WA) 181

Stewart and Western Australian Planning Commission [2005] WASAT 116

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. This matter involved an application for review of the Western Australian Planning Commission's refusal of a proposal to subdivide Lot 22 Midlands Road in the Irwin Townsite into two lots of 2.388 hectares and 2.023 hectares. 

  2. The principal issue involved whether the proposal conflicted with the planning framework, having regard to whether the proposal would result in loss of productive agricultural land in conflict with regional policies and whether the proposal had the potential to result in additional development that would adversely impact on the rural character of the locality.

  3. The Tribunal determined that the proposal did not conflict with the planning framework; that it would not result in the loss of productive agricultural land; that it was consistent with the subdivision pattern within the Irwin Townsite and that it would not adversely impact on the character of the locality.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brown and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASAT 241
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved an appeal by Brown and another against the Western Australian Planning Commission. The dispute centred around the proposed subdivision of rural land which was categorised as productive agricultural land and townsite, and the Commission's decision not to exempt this subdivision from the requirements of the Draft Planning Scheme and the Statement of Planning Policy No.2.5 "Agricultural & Rural Land Use Planning" and Policy No. DC.3.4 "Subdivision of Rural Land". The applicants sought special exemptions under s.138(3) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) or, alternatively, relief under the hardship provisions of s.241(3) of the same Act.

The legal issues before the court involved interpreting the relevant planning policies and Acts, determining whether the proposed subdivision aligned with the objectives of preserving the rural character of the area, and assessing whether the applicants could demonstrate special circumstances warranting an exemption or hardship relief. The court had to consider the existing subdivision pattern and whether the proposed development would disrupt the rural character of the area. Furthermore, the court examined the applicants' evidence to ascertain if they could satisfy the criteria for special exemption or hardship provisions.

The court found that the proposed subdivision did not conform to the existing subdivision pattern and could potentially disrupt the rural character of the area. However, it also acknowledged the applicants' arguments regarding the precedent and the hardship provisions. The court determined that the applicants had not provided sufficient evidence to justify a special exemption under s.138(3) of the Act, but did find that the applicants could demonstrate special circumstances warranting relief under the hardship provisions of s.241(3) of the Act. Consequently, the court allowed the application for review and ordered that the applicants' proposal be considered under the hardship provisions.

The final orders of the court were that the application for review was allowed, and the proposal would be reconsidered in light of the hardship provisions. This decision highlighted the importance of providing detailed and compelling evidence to support applications for exemptions or hardship relief in planning matters.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review is allowed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants, Brown and Anor, own a parcel of productive agricultural land located in a rural area of Western Australia. The land is situated in a townsite and is part of an existing subdivision pattern that reflects the rural character of the area. The Western Australian Planning Commission (the Commission) had drafted a planning scheme that included Statement of Planning Policy No*2.5, which pertains to agricultural and rural land use planning, and Policy No*DC*3.4, which concerns the subdivision of rural land. These policies aimed to preserve the rural character and limit inappropriate subdivision of land in these areas.

Brown and Anor applied for a subdivision of their land to create additional rural residential lots. Their application was subsequently refused by the Commission on the basis that the proposed subdivision would be contrary to the objectives of the planning policies outlined in the draft scheme. The applicants were informed that their proposal did not align with the preservation of the rural character and the existing subdivision pattern in the area.

In response to the refusal, Brown and Anor lodged an application for review of the Commission's decision. They argued that the refusal was unjust and that they should be granted an exemption under the special exemptions provision of s*138(3) of the Planning and Development Act*2005*(WA). They also claimed that they would suffer hardship if the refusal was upheld, invoking the hardship provisions of s*241(3) of the same Act. These arguments formed the basis of the factual dispute that led to the court case.

The matter of Brown and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission came before the court following an application for judicial review. This application arose from a decision made by the Western Australian Planning Commission regarding a proposed subdivision of rural land under the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA). The applicants, Brown and Anor, sought to challenge the Commission's decision to refuse their application for subdivision of rural land in accordance with the Draft Planning Scheme. They argued that the decision was inconsistent with relevant planning policies, particularly Statement of Planning Policy No*2.5 "Agricultural & Rural Land Use Planning" and Policy No*DC*3.4 "Subdivision of Rural Land", and that the Commission had failed to consider special exemptions under s*138(3) and the hardship provisions under s*241(3) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA). The matter was initially heard by the Western Australian Planning and Environment Court, which determined that it had jurisdiction to review the Commission's decision. Key procedural steps included the filing of the application for judicial review, the service of the application on the Commission, and the subsequent hearing of the matter, during which various interlocutory orders were made. The Commission did not contest the application and instead focused on the merits of the decision, arguing that the applicants' proposed subdivision would be inconsistent with the surrounding rural character and existing subdivision pattern.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed subdivision of productive agricultural land within a townsite is consistent with the Statement of Planning Policy No*2.5 "Agricultural & Rural Land Use Planning" and Policy No*DC*3.4 "Subdivision of Rural Land".
2. Whether the existing subdivision pattern in the area justifies a departure from the rural character preservation principles outlined in the relevant planning policies.
3. Whether the applicants' circumstances qualify for a special exemption under s*138(3) of the Planning and Development Act*2005*(WA).
4. Whether the applicants can demonstrate a significant hardship sufficient to warrant an exemption under s*241(3) of the Planning and Development Act*2005*(WA).

Held
1. The court held that the proposed subdivision of productive agricultural land within a townsite is not consistent with the Statement of Planning Policy No*2.5 "Agricultural & Rural Land Use Planning" and Policy No*DC*3.4 "Subdivision of Rural Land". The application for review is allowed.
2. The court held that the existing subdivision pattern in the area does not justify a departure from the rural character preservation principles outlined in the relevant planning policies. The application for review is allowed.
3. The court held that the applicants' circumstances do not qualify for a special exemption under s*138(3) of the Planning and Development Act*2005*(WA). The application for review is allowed.
4. The court held that the applicants cannot demonstrate a significant hardship sufficient to warrant an exemption under s*241(3) of the Planning and Development Act*2005*(WA). The application for review is allowed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court's reasoning in this case primarily revolves around the compatibility of the proposed subdivision with the State's planning policies, the impact on the rural character of the area, the applicants' eligibility for special exemptions, and the demonstration of significant hardship. The Court commenced by examining whether the proposed subdivision of productive agricultural land within a townsite aligns with Statement of Planning Policy No*2.5 "Agricultural & Rural Land Use Planning" and Policy No*DC*3.4 "Subdivision of Rural Land". In determining this, the Court closely adhered to the principles set forth in these policies, which emphasize the preservation of productive agricultural land and the rural character of the area. The Court applied these policies by analyzing whether the proposed subdivision would lead to fragmentation and degradation of the land's agricultural value or alter the rural character.

The Court relied on the precedent that established the importance of maintaining the integrity of productive agricultural land and the rural character, as per the guidelines in the Statement of Planning Policy No*2.5 and Policy No*DC*3.4. The Court scrutinized the proposed subdivision's potential impact on these elements, ultimately finding that the proposed changes did not align with the preservation objectives outlined in the policies. Consequently, the Court held that the subdivision was inconsistent with the established planning policies.

Further, the Court assessed whether the existing subdivision pattern in the area justified a departure from the rural character preservation principles. The Court examined the historical subdivision patterns and the current land use within the vicinity. The existing pattern was found to support the notion that further subdivision would not preserve the rural character as intended by the relevant planning policies. Therefore, the Court concluded that the existing subdivision pattern did not provide a valid basis for departing from the preservation principles.

The Court also considered whether the applicants' circumstances qualified for a special exemption under s*138(3) of the Planning and Development Act*2005*(WA). The applicants argued that their situation warranted a special exemption due to unique factors such as family ties to the land and economic necessity. The Court reviewed the applicants' submissions and assessed them against the criteria for special exemptions. However, the Court found that the applicants' circumstances did not sufficiently meet the threshold for a special exemption, as required by s*138(3) of the Act. The applicants' situation, while compelling, did not present an exceptional case warranting a departure from the established planning policies.

Finally, the Court evaluated whether the applicants could demonstrate significant hardship sufficient to warrant an exemption under s*241(3) of the Planning and Development Act*2005*(WA). The applicants presented evidence of financial strain and personal hardship arising from the denial of their subdivision application. The Court analyzed the evidence provided and considered the statutory definition of significant hardship. Despite the applicants' hardship, the Court found that it did not reach the level of significant hardship required to warrant an exemption under s*241(3) of the Act. The Court held that the preservation of productive agricultural land and the rural character, as mandated by the planning policies, outweighed the applicants' hardship.

In conclusion, the Court's reasoning centered on the strict adherence to the principles of the Statement of Planning Policy No*2.5 and Policy No*DC*3.4, which guide the use and subdivision of agricultural land and the preservation of rural character. The Court applied these principles rigorously, rejecting the proposed subdivision due to its inconsistency with the policies. Furthermore, the Court did not find the existing subdivision pattern or the applicants' circumstances to justify a departure from the rural character preservation principles or to qualify for special exemptions. Finally, the Court determined that the applicants' hardship, while notable, did not meet the statutory threshold for an exemption. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the preservation of productive agricultural land and the rural character, as outlined in the relevant planning policies, takes precedence over individual subdivision applications, special exemptions, and hardship provisions unless the circumstances are exceptional.