Brooymans v. Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

[2008] QDC 207

DISTRICT COURT

APPELLATE JURISDICTION

JUDGE EVERSON

BETINA LEE BROOYMANS Appellate

and

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS Respondent

CAIRNS

..DATE 25/08/2008

JUDGMENT

HIS HONOUR:  This is an appeal by Betina Lee Brooymans, arising out of her conviction and sentence in the Atherton Magistrates Court on 1 April 2008 for 3 counts of disqualified driving.  She received a sentence of 2 months' imprisonment with 2 years' probation in respect of each charge.  She was also disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver's licence for a period of 2 years.

Before me it is submitted by her barrister, Mr Murray, that the sentence is manifestly excessive.  Mr English, who appears on behalf of the respondent, supports this submission.

Relevant considerations appear in the decision of his Honour Judge Brabazon QC in Santillan v Queensland Police Force [2008] QDC 33. He notes, at paragraph 3, that punishments such as imprisonment and licence disqualification are separate punishments and can amount to a double punishment for the same offence. In that case he also sentenced someone for three counts of disqualified driving, but also one count of obtaining a false driver's licence, in the context of someone described at paragraph 5 as a 22 year old with "a very bad traffic history", extending to 5 and a-half pages. Whilst his Honour Judge Brabazon noted the appellant didn't drink, he summarised his behaviour in the following terms, "He speeds, he drives without his licence and he does things, such as, making a noise and creating smoke with his rear tyres". Significantly it is also observed at the same paragraph that the appellant used his car to earn his living as a painter. That can also be said of the appellant before me. Part of the reason for driving was to maintain her employment in a supermarket some distance from where she lived.

The circumstances before his Honour Judge Brabazon were summarised by him at paragraph 8 as including "calculated offences of driving whilst disqualified and...deception".  The circumstances before me reveal a more spontaneous approach by the appellant who drove in circumstances where she needed to get to work, or the designated driver at a party had consumed too much alcohol.

The disqualification arose when the appellant was convicted of drink driving, but to a very limited extent.  The amount of the blood alcohol level was .034 per cent, this was sufficient to qualify for drink driving because she was on a provisional licence.  The penalty she received in this regard on the 12th of February 2008, again, in the Atherton Magistrates Court, was a fine of $200 and a disqualification for 3 months.

In Santillan, as I have indicated, an appeal involving circumstances of much more serious offending, his Honour Judge Brabazon held an appropriate penalty was imprisonment for eight months with an immediate parole release date and a disqualification period of two years.

The facts before me make it clear that the penalty imposed upon the appellant was manifestly excessive. This is particularly…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brooymans v. Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QDC 207
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Brooymans v. Director of Public Prosecutions, Betina Lee Brooymans appealed against her conviction and sentence for three counts of disqualified driving, as determined by the Atherton Magistrates Court on April 1, 2008. Brooymans was sentenced to 2 months' imprisonment with 2 years' probation for each charge, and a 2-year disqualification from holding or obtaining a driver's licence. The appeal was heard in the District Court's appellate jurisdiction by Judge Everson, who was tasked with determining whether the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive.

The legal issue at the heart of this appeal was whether the sentence of imprisonment, along with the two-year licence disqualification, was excessively punitive for the offence of disqualified driving, particularly in light of the offender's age and the absence of any element of drink driving or dangerous driving. The appeal drew comparisons to the case of Santillan v Queensland Police Force, where a similar offence resulted in a different penalty, thereby providing a benchmark for evaluating the proportionality of the sentence in this case. The court had to consider whether the Magistrate's decision to impose immediate imprisonment, rather than a community-based sentence, was justified given the circumstances and the statutory guidance on sentencing young offenders.

Judge Everson found that the penalty imposed on Brooymans was indeed manifestly excessive. The court acknowledged that while driving while disqualified is a serious matter, particularly given that Brooymans had been caught on three occasions within a month, the circumstances of her offences were more spontaneous and driven by necessity rather than calculated deception. Furthermore, Brooymans had already served six weeks of her sentence by the time the appeal was heard, and the court deemed the two-year disqualification period to be sufficient punishment. Given the offender's age and the principles outlined in section 9 of the Penalties and Sentences Act, which advocate for imprisonment as a last resort and community-based sentences where possible, the court determined that the original sentence was disproportionate. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the original sentence was set aside, with a substituted sentence of six weeks' imprisonment being deemed appropriate given that the time already served. The two-year disqualification was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established