JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: BUILDING SERVICES (COMPLAINT RESOLUTION AND ADMINISTRATION) ACT 2011 (WA)
CITATION: BROOKS and GRANSDEN BUILDING COMPANY PTY LTD [No 2] [2021] WASAT 86
MEMBER: MS R PETRUCCI, MEMBER
MR R AFFLECK, SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER
HEARD: 8 MARCH 2021 AND 11 MARCH 2021 (LAST DOCUMENT FILED 23 MARCH 2021)
DELIVERED : 15 JUNE 2021
FILE NO/S: CC 1816 of 2019
CC 278 of 2020
BETWEEN: CRAIG BROOKS
First Applicant
MELISSA BROOKS
Second Applicant
AND
GRANSDEN BUILDING COMPANY PTY LTD
Respondent
Catchwords:
Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA) - Building dispute - Exercise of discretion in making a building remedy order - Costs of remedial work - Whether order to remedy or order to pay is appropriate - Monetary order - Application for costs - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA), s 36(1), s 36(1)(a), s 36(1)(b), s 36(1)(c), s 36(3), s 38, s 38(1), s 49 s 49(1), s 51
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 9, s 87, s 87(1), s 87(2) - s 87(6)
Result:
Application partly successful
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| First Applicant | : | In Person |
| Second Applicant | : | In Person |
| Respondent | : | In Person |
Solicitors:
| First Applicant | : | N/A |
| Second Applicant | : | N/A |
| Respondent | : | N/A |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Brodun Construction and Love & Anor [2008] WASAT 174
J & P Metals Pty Ltd and Shire of Dardanup [2006] WASAT 282 (S)
Marvelle Investments Pty Ltd and Argyle Holdings Pty Ltd [2010] WASAT 125 (S)
Medical Board of Western Australia and Kyi [2009] WASAT 22
Nelson v Mardesic (1998) 22 SR (WA) 42
Panegyres v Medical Board of Australia [2020] WASCA 58
Perth Central Holdings Pty Ltd and Doric Constructions Pty Ltd [No 2] [2008] WASAT 302 at [67]
Rae and Prima Homes Nominees Pty Ltd [2020] WASAT 24
Sanders and Gemmill Homes Pty Ltd [2017] WASAT 41
Trengove and Celebration Nominees Pty Ltd [2012] WASAT 65; (2012) 80 SR (WA) 77
Western Australian Planning Commission v Questdale Holdings Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 32
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
On 4 December 2020 the Tribunal delivered its written decision in Brooks and Gransden Building Company Pty Ltd [2020] WASAT 151 where the Tribunal determined that the building work, the basis of complaint items 1, 2, 4, 7, 13, 14, 15, 17, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 39, 42, 43, 45, 54, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63 and 64 was not carried out in a proper and proficient manner, or was faulty or unsatisfactory and is to be remedied.
Despite protestation by Gransden Building Company Pty Ltd[1] (builder or respondent), the Tribunal, in the above decision, concluded it was appropriate and necessary to specify for each complaint item the scope of the remedial work. Where Dr Craig Brooks and Mrs Melissa Brooks' (owners or applicants) experts and the builder's experts agreed…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Brooks and Gransden Building Company Pty Ltd [No 2] and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] WASAT 86
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Tribunal included determining the appropriate type of remedy order under the Act, considering whether the relationship between the parties had irretrievably broken down, and assessing the owners' loss of confidence in the builder's ability to perform satisfactory remedial work. The Tribunal examined factors such as the builder's willingness to remedy the defects, the owner's denial of access to the site, and the builder's competence and trustworthiness.
The Tribunal concluded that the relationship between the parties had indeed irretrievably broken down, primarily due to the owners' loss of confidence in the builder's ability to perform the remedial work satisfactorily. The Tribunal noted that the builder had previously indicated it had no intention of hiring another registered building supervisor and might be entering liquidation, which further eroded the owners' confidence. Additionally, the builder's attempts to remedy the defects were obstructed by the owners, who denied the builder access to the site. Based on these findings, the Tribunal decided that a monetary order was more appropriate than a works order, as ordering remedial work would likely not result in finality of the disputes.
The Tribunal further ordered that the builder pay the owners' costs of the proceedings, as the owners had sought a monetary order from the outset and had acted reasonably in doing so.
Background
Background to the litigation
The material facts begin with the engagement of Brooks and Gransden Building Company Pty Ltd by the owners to construct their residential property. During the construction, the owners raised concerns about defects and the builder's workmanship. Following the completion of the construction, the owners lodged a complaint under the Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA) against the builder, alleging various defects in the construction. The dispute escalated, leading to proceedings before the Building and Construction Commissioner (the "Tribunal").
Throughout the proceedings, the relationship between the parties deteriorated significantly. The owners asserted that they had lost confidence in the builder's ability to perform the remedial work required to address the defects. The builder, on the other hand, maintained that it had made continuous efforts to remedy the issues and that the owners had denied access to the site for the builder to assess and address the defects. The builder also claimed that the owner's interference with the construction site had made it difficult for the builder to perform the necessary work.
The owners sought a monetary order instead of a works order, citing the builder's lack of a registered building supervisor and the possibility of the builder entering liquidation. The builder argued that it had attempted to address the defects and that the owner's refusal to grant access to the site had hindered its efforts. The Tribunal was required to determine the appropriate remedy for the building dispute, taking into account the relationship between the parties and the circumstances surrounding the construction defects.
The case of Brooks and Gransden Building Company Pty Ltd [No 2] involves a building dispute under the Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA). The matter was brought before the Tribunal by the owners, seeking a building remedy order (BRO) due to dissatisfaction with the quality of building works carried out by the builder. The dispute escalated to the point where the owners sought to amend their claim from a 'works order' to a 'monetary order', citing the builder's inability to maintain a registered building supervisor and the loss of confidence in the builder's competence. The builder, on the other hand, argued that it had made continued efforts to address the defects and that the owners had denied access to the site for assessment and remediation.
The matter has progressed through several procedural stages, including initial hearings and subsequent interlocutory applications. Notably, the builder's legal representative indicated that pursuing the claim was pointless due to the builder's lack of a registered building supervisor, which later expired. The Tribunal had to consider these developments and the implications for the appropriateness of a works order versus a monetary order. The Tribunal's decision hinges on the relationship between the parties, the builder's willingness and ability to perform remedial works, and the owners' loss of confidence in the builder's competence. The Tribunal has applied principles from prior cases such as Trengove and Celebration Nominees Pty Ltd and Gemmill Homes Pty Ltd v Saunders, which emphasise the importance of ensuring finality in litigation and the factors influencing the choice between a works order and a monetary order.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the appropriate type of building remedy order (BRO) to make in circumstances where the relationship between the parties has irretrievably broken down?
2. Should the Tribunal order remedial work by the builder, or should it order the builder to pay a monetary amount instead?
3. What factors should the Tribunal consider in determining whether the relationship between the parties has irretrievably broken down?
4. Has the owner lost confidence in the builder's competence and trustworthiness, and if so, to what extent should this influence the type of BRO made?
5. Does the builder's history of attempting to address and remedy the defects claimed by the owner influence the type of BRO that should be made?
6. Should the Tribunal consider the builder's lack of a registered building supervisor and the subsequent expiration of the registration when determining the type of BRO to make?
7. What weight should the Tribunal give to the builder's evidence that the owner denied the builder access to the site to remedy the defects?
8. Does the owner's history of interference and adversarial conduct at the work site influence the type of BRO that should be made?
Held
1. The appropriate type of building remedy order (BRO) to make in circumstances where the relationship between the parties has irretrievably broken down is a monetary order. The court concluded that ordering remedial work by the builder would likely not result in finality of the disputes.
2. The Tribunal should order the builder to pay a monetary amount instead of ordering remedial work by the builder. The court concluded that there is no right or requirement on a party to a complaint to elect whether the builder undertakes the remedial works.
3. The factors the Tribunal should consider in determining whether the relationship between the parties has irretrievably broken down include the relationship between the parties, the owner's loss of confidence in the builder, the builder's willingness or otherwise to perform remedial works, whether the builder has performed remedial works which have been unsatisfactory, whether the builder has been refused access, and whether the extent of the remedial work itself evidences perhaps a lack of competence or ability on the part of the builder.
4. The owner has lost confidence in the builder's competence and trustworthiness, and this should influence the type of BRO made. The court concluded that ordering remedial work by the builder would likely not result in finality of the disputes.
5. The builder's history of attempting to address and remedy the defects claimed by the owner does not influence the type of BRO that should be made. The court concluded that ordering remedial work by the builder would likely not result in finality of the disputes.
6. The Tribunal should consider the builder's lack of a registered building supervisor and the subsequent expiration of the registration when determining the type of BRO to make. The court concluded that this was one of the factors that contributed to the owner's loss of confidence in the builder.
7. The Tribunal should give little weight to the builder's evidence that the owner denied the builder access to the site to remedy the defects. The court concluded that the builder's lack of a registered building supervisor and the subsequent expiration of the registration were more significant factors in the Tribunal's decision.
8. The owner's history of interference and adversarial conduct at the work site does not influence the type of BRO that should be made. The court concluded that ordering remedial work by the builder would likely not result in finality of the disputes.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In deciding to make a BRO we have taken in consideration the principles enunciated in Trengove and Celebration Nominees Pty Ltd [2012] WASAT 65; (2012) 80 SR (WA) 77 (Trengove) as set out in Gemmill Homes Pty Ltd –v- Saunders [2018] WASC 179 (Gemmill and Sanders) at [33] as follows:…(a)At the heart of the issue as to what order is appropriate is the question as to whether the relationship between the parties has irretrievably broken down. The fact that it is the builder asserting that the relationship has broken down does not matter. The principles equally apply whether it is a builder or an owner making the assertion. This is an important consideration for a number of obvious reasons, including the primary one, namely, to ensure some finality in litigation. If the Tribunal were to order remedial work in circumstances where the relationship between the parties has irretrievably broken down, it is likely not to result in finality of the disputes arising between those parties.(b)The Tribunal looks to the relationship between the parties and whether the owner has lost confidence in the builder, the willingness or otherwise of the builder to perform remedial works, whether it has performed remedial works which have been unsatisfactory, whether the builder has been refused access, and whether, for example, the extent of the remedial work itself evidences perhaps a lack of competence or ability on the part of the builder which justifies the owner losing confidence in the builder's ability. We also have taken into account that there is no right or requirement on a party to a complaint to elect whether the builder undertakes the remedial works: Gemmill and Sanders at [131] and [135] - [139]. The owners submit that as early as March 2020 they informed the builder (and its then legal representative) that they would be seeking to amend the orders sought from the Tribunal in these proceedings from a 'works order' to a 'monetary order' for the following reasons:(a)the builder's then legal representative indicated on 3 March 2020 (two days before the then hearing before the Tribunal) that it would be pointless for the owners to proceed with their claim because the builder no longer had a registered building supervisor, that they had no intention of hiring another one and it was possible they were going into liquidation;(b)whilst the builder did register another building supervisor, the registration expired on 1 September 2020 (two weeks prior to the then final hearing date); and(c)they have totally lost faith in the builder's competence and trustworthiness. The builder's position is that it has continued for the past three years to attempt to address and remedy the defects claimed by the owners. It is Mr Lorian's evidence that the owners denied the builder access to the site to remedy the defects. Mr Lorian states that the builder was never given unfettered access to the owners' property for the builder's expert, Mr Richard Machell of Prescient Consulting, to assess the owners' defect claims. Mr Lorian submits that 'trades are reluctant to attend given [the owners'] adversarial and dictatorial history of interference of the work site during construction'.