Bromhead v Graham

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read
CITATION: Bromhead v Graham [2007] NSWSC 609
HEARING DATE(S): 04/06/07, 05/06/07
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

14 June 2007
JUDGMENT OF: Gzell J
DECISION: Injunctive relief refused. Inquiry as to damages for breach of fiduciary duty of fidelity and breach of non-solicitation restraint.
CATCHWORDS: EMPLOYMENT LAW - The contract of service and rights, duties and liabilities as between employer and employee - Restraint of trade - Breach of fiduciary duty of fidelity by employed solicitor canvassing clients of employer during employment - Breach of non-solicitation restraint of trade after termination of employment - Whether employer repudiated contract of employment and restraint at an end - Whether partnership dissolved and employment contract thereby repudiated - Whether restraint against public policy - Whether terms should be read down under the Restraints of Trade Act 1976, s 4(1) - Whether manifest failure to make restraint reasonable invoking the Restraints of Trade Act 1976, s 4(3) - Whether discretion should be exercised against granting injunctive relief where partnership to be dissolved and all new work on files to the account of the person performing the work
LEGISLATION CITED: Restrains of Trade Act 1976
Partnership Act 1892
CASES CITED: Hall v Hall (1855) 20 Beav 139 (52 ER 555)
Palmer v Moore [1900] AC 293 to Ryder v Frohlich [2004] NSWCA 472
Brace v Calder [1895] 2 QB 253
Hivac Ltd v Park Royal Scientific Instruments Ltd [1946] 1 Ch 169
Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corporation (1984) 156 CLR 41
Australian Regional Wholesalers v Stafford [2007] NSWSC 572
John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd v Birt [2006] NSWSC 995
Lindley & Banks on Partnership, 18th ed, Sweet & Maxwell, London, 2002
PARTIES: Stephen Bruce Bromhead - First Plaintiff
John William Walker - Second Plaintiff
Michael Noel Crozier - Third Plaintiff
Ian James Graham - Defendant
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2352/07
COUNSEL:

Mr R Margo SC/ Ms T Leibman - Plaintiff
Mr R Newlinds SC/ Mr J Johnson - Defendant

SOLICITORS: Walker Smith Solicitors - Plaintiffs
Stacks/Forster Solicitors - Defendant

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

GZELL J

THURSDAY 14 JUNE 2007

2352/07 STEPHEN BRUCE BROMHEAD & ORS v IAN JAMES GRAHAM

JUDGMENT

1 The defendant, Ian James Graham, was an employed solicitor with the legal firm JA Vaughan & Company, Forster. The goodwill of that practice was purchased by Walker Smith Solicitors, which changed its name to Walker Smith Solicitors incorporating JA Vaughan & Co Forster. Mr Graham became an employee of that firm. The plaintiffs, Stephen Bruce Bromhead, John William Walker and Michael Noel Crozier became the partners of that firm.

2 Mr Graham’s employment by the partners was terminated. His contract of employment contained a restrictive covenant in the form of a non-solicitation provision. Clause 20.3 was in the following terms:

          “Upon termination of employment for any reason the employee shall not approach, canvas, solicit, interfere with or entice away any person, firm or company client of the firm of Walker Smith Solicitors and JA Vaughan and Company. The employee…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bromhead v Graham and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWSC 609
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bromhead v Graham involved an employed solicitor who was found to have breached his fiduciary duty of fidelity by canvassing clients of his employer during his employment. The dispute reached the court as the employer sought relief for the breach of a non-solicitation restraint of trade after the solicitor's termination of employment. The court was required to determine whether the employer had repudiated the contract of employment, thereby ending the restraint, whether the partnership was dissolved and the employment contract repudiated, and whether the restraint was against public policy. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the terms should be read down under the Restraints of Trade Act 1976, s 4(1) and whether a manifest failure to make the restraint reasonable invoked the provisions of s 4(3). The final consideration was whether the discretion should be exercised against granting injunctive relief where the partnership was to be dissolved and all new work on files was to be accounted for by the person performing the work.

The court examined the nature of the employment contract and the fiduciary duties owed by the employee to the employer. It found that the restraint of trade clause was enforceable as it was reasonable in all the circumstances, did not go further than necessary to protect the employer's legitimate business interests, and was not against public policy. The court rejected the argument that the employer had repudiated the contract or that the partnership had dissolved, thereby invalidating the restraint. The court also determined that there was no manifest failure to make the restraint reasonable and that the terms should not be read down under the Restraints of Trade Act 1976, s 4(1). Given the impending dissolution of the partnership and the allocation of new work to the solicitor, the court exercised its discretion against granting injunctive relief, finding it unnecessary in the circumstances.

In conclusion, the court held that the restraint of trade clause was enforceable, and the solicitor had breached his fiduciary duty by canvassing clients of his former employer. The court did not grant injunctive relief due to the impending dissolution of the partnership and the allocation of new work to the solicitor. The court's decision provides guidance on the enforceability of restraint of trade clauses in employment contracts for solicitors and the circumstances in which injunctive relief may be granted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established