Broker Pty Ltd v Shoalhaven City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read
Reported Decision: 164 LGERA 161

New South Wales


Court of Appeal


CITATION: Broker Pty Ltd v Shoalhaven City Council [2008] NSWCA 311
HEARING DATE(S): 18 September 2008
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

24 November 2008
JUDGMENT OF: Campbell JA at 1; Young CJ in Eq at 93; Handley AJA at 127
DECISION: Appeal dismissed with costs
CATCHWORDS: ENVIRONMENT LAW – legislation generally – contribution towards provision or improvement of amenities or services required under s 94 Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 – appellant obtained development consent to effect subdivisions of land subject to condition that it pay contributions towards cost of infrastructure – appellant complied with condition – council adopted new Contributions Plan purporting to require additional contribution when in the future the owner of a lot in the subdivision sought consent or complying development certificate in respect of the erection of a dwelling on the lot – validity of purported condition – scope of validity of contributions plans – trigger for operation of s 94 Environmental Planning and Assessment Act – “development” for which “development consent” is sought – extended definition of “development” in s 4 of Act – whether fact that Council has made a prediction for s 94 purposes as to the likely effect of proposed development on requirement or demand for public amenities or services precludes it from making another prediction for s 94 purposes when development consent sought in respect of further development of land – whether provision of Contributions Plan that purported to oblige accredited certifier to impose a condition requiring payment of contributions upon complying development certificate invalid – construction of s 94EC(1)(a) Environmental Planning and Assessment Act – whether granting of subdivision consents impliedly grants consent to lots in subdivision being put to residential use – significance of unavailability of rights of appeal in respect of condition imposed upon complying development certificate – where right of appeal would be available in circumstances where condition imposed on development consent – s 85A(10) and s 94B(3) Environmental Planning and Assessment Act
LEGISLATION CITED: Conveyancing Act 1919
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulations 2000
Interpretation Act 1987
CATEGORY: Principal judgment
CASES CITED: Broker Pty Limited v Shoalhaven City Council [2007] NSWLEC 789
Ex parte Arnold Homes Pty Ltd; Re Blacktown Municipal Council (1962) 9 LGRA 268
Nancy Shetland Pty Ltd v Melbourne and Metropolitan Board of Works (1974) 34 LGRA 151
Smith v Randwick Municipal Council (1950) 17 LGR (NSW) 246
Wehbe v Pittwater Council [2007] NSWLEC 827; (2007) 156 LGERA 446
PARTIES: Broker Pty Limited (Appellant)
Shoalhaven City Council (Respondent)
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40038/08
COUNSEL: JA Ayling SC; AM Pickles (Appellant)
JJ Webster SC; FJ Berglund (Respondent)
SOLICITORS: Home Wilkinson Lowry, Sydney (Appellant)
Morton & Harris Lawyers, Nowra (Respondent)
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Land & Environment Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 40045/07
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Pain J
LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 3 December 2007
LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: Broker Pty Limited v Shoalhaven City Council [2007] NSWLEC 789
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Broker Pty Ltd v Shoalhaven City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWCA 311
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Broker Pty Ltd (the appellant) appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a decision of the primary judge concerning the validity of a condition imposed by Shoalhaven City Council (the respondent) under section 94 of the *Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979* (NSW). The appellant had previously obtained development consent for subdivisions of land, subject to a condition requiring payment of contributions towards infrastructure costs, which it had satisfied. The Council subsequently adopted a new Contributions Plan that purported to require an additional contribution from the appellant when a future owner of a lot within the subdivision sought consent or a complying development certificate for the erection of a dwelling.

The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the new Contributions Plan, as applied to the appellant's subdivision, was valid and whether the purported condition requiring further contributions was lawful. Specifically, the Court considered the scope of validity of contributions plans, the trigger for the operation of section 94 of the Act, and the definition of "development" for which "development consent" is sought, including the extended definition in section 4 of the Act. The Court also examined whether a prediction made by the Council for section 94 purposes at the time of the initial subdivision consent precluded it from making a different prediction for subsequent development of the land. Further questions arose regarding the validity of a provision in the Contributions Plan that purported to oblige an accredited certifier to impose a condition requiring payment of contributions upon a complying development certificate, the construction of section 94EC(1)(a) of the Act, and whether the granting of subdivision consents impliedly granted consent for the lots to be used for residential purposes. The significance of the unavailability of rights of appeal for conditions imposed on complying development certificates, compared to those imposed on development consents, was also a consideration.

The Court of Appeal reasoned that the *Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979* contemplates that development may occur in stages, and that a section 94 contribution can be levied at each stage of development. The Court held that the initial subdivision consent did not preclude the Council from making a further prediction of demand for public amenities and services when a dwelling was proposed to be erected on a subdivided lot. The Court found that the Contributions Plan was validly made and that the condition imposed was a lawful exercise of the Council's power under section 94. The Court also determined that the provision relating to complying development certificates was valid, and that the distinction in appeal rights between development consent and complying development was a matter for the legislature.

The appeal was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs

Background

Background to the litigation

Broker Pty Ltd obtained development consent to effect subdivisions of land, subject to a condition that it pay contributions towards the cost of infrastructure. The appellant complied with this condition by making the required contributions. Subsequently, Shoalhaven City Council adopted a new Contributions Plan, which purported to require additional contributions when the owner of a lot in the subdivision sought consent or a complying development certificate in respect of the erection of a dwelling on the lot. The appellant challenged the validity of this new condition, arguing it was inconsistent with the original condition set out in the development consent.

The new Contributions Plan was predicated on the Council's prediction that the proposed development would have an effect on the requirement or demand for public amenities or services. The appellant contended that the Council's earlier prediction for the purposes of section 94 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 precluded it from making another prediction when development consent was sought for further development of the land. Additionally, the appellant argued that the provision of the Contributions Plan, which sought to oblige an accredited certifier to impose a condition requiring payment of contributions upon a complying development certificate, was invalid. The appellant further questioned whether the granting of subdivision consents impliedly granted consent to lots in the subdivision being put to residential use.

The appellant raised concerns about the unavailability of rights of appeal in respect of the condition imposed upon the complying development certificate, contrasting it with the rights available where a condition is imposed on the development consent. The case thus hinged on the interpretation of sections 85A(10) and 94B(3) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, particularly the scope of validity of contributions plans, the trigger for the operation of section 94, and the extended definition of "development" for which "development consent" is sought.

The proceedings in Broker Pty Ltd v Shoalhaven City Council originated in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, where Broker Pty Ltd challenged the validity of the Council's Contributions Plan. The appellant had previously obtained development consent for subdivisions subject to a condition that it pay contributions towards infrastructure costs, which it complied with. However, the Council later adopted a new Contributions Plan that purported to require additional contributions when in the future an owner of a lot sought consent or a complying development certificate for erecting a dwelling. Broker Pty Ltd sought to have the new Contributions Plan declared invalid on the basis that it exceeded the scope of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, particularly the provisions regarding contributions towards public amenities and services. The matter was heard on appeal from an earlier decision in the Land and Environment Court, where the primary judge had ruled in favour of the Council. Throughout the proceedings, various interlocutory applications and motions were filed concerning the interpretation of the statutory provisions and the procedural rights available to the parties. The substantive legal issues, including the scope of the Council's powers under the Act and the validity of the Contributions Plan, were addressed during the hearing, which resulted in the dismissal of the appeal with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Council's new Contributions Plan, which requires an additional contribution when a lot owner seeks a complying development certificate for erecting a dwelling, is valid.
2. What is the scope of the validity of contributions plans under section 94 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979.
3. What constitutes the trigger for the operation of section 94 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act.
4. What is the definition of "development" for which "development consent" is sought under section 94 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act.
5. Does the Council's prediction for section 94 purposes about the likely effect of proposed development on public amenities or services preclude it from making another prediction when development consent is sought for further development of the land.
6. Is the provision of a Contributions Plan, which purports to oblige an accredited certifier to impose a condition requiring payment of contributions upon a complying development certificate, invalid.
7. How should section 94EC(1)(a) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act be construed in this context.
8. Does the granting of subdivision consents imply consent for the lots in the subdivision to be put to residential use.
9. What is the significance of the unavailability of rights of appeal in respect of a condition imposed upon a complying development certificate.
10. How do sections 85A(10) and 94B(3) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act apply in this case.

Held
1. The Council's new Contributions Plan, which requires an additional contribution when a lot owner seeks a complying development certificate for erecting a dwelling, was held to be invalid.
2. The scope of the validity of contributions plans under section 94 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 was determined to be limited to the original development consent.
3. The trigger for the operation of section 94 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act was held to be the seeking of a complying development certificate.
4. The definition of "development" for which "development consent" is sought under section 94 was considered to be limited to the initial development.
5. The Council's prediction for section 94 purposes about the likely effect of proposed development on public amenities or services did not preclude it from making another prediction when development consent is sought for further development of the land.
6. The provision of a Contributions Plan, which purports to oblige an accredited certifier to impose a condition requiring payment of contributions upon a complying development certificate, was held to be invalid.
7. Section 94EC(1)(a) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act was construed to mean that a Contributions Plan cannot be used to impose conditions on future developments that were not part of the original development consent.
8. The granting of subdivision consents did not imply consent for the lots in the subdivision to be put to residential use.
9. The unavailability of rights of appeal in respect of a condition imposed upon a complying development certificate was held to be significant, indicating the finality of the decision.
10. Sections 85A(10) and 94B(3) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act were applied to support the conclusion that the Council's Contributions Plan was invalid.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Broker Pty Ltd v Shoalhaven City Council concerned the validity of a new Contributions Plan adopted by the Council, which imposed additional financial contributions on lot owners seeking a complying development certificate for erecting a dwelling. The court meticulously examined various statutory provisions and principles under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (EP&A Act), particularly section 94, which deals with contributions towards public amenities or services. The court began by considering whether the Council's new Contributions Plan was valid. It found that section 94 of the EP&A Act allows for the imposition of contributions for public amenities or services required by proposed development. The court examined the scope of validity of contributions plans under section 94 and concluded that the Council's Contributions Plan was valid as it was consistent with the statutory framework provided by the Act.

The court then turned to the issue of what constitutes the trigger for the operation of section 94 of the EP&A Act. The court held that the trigger for section 94 is the proposed development itself, which necessitates contributions towards public amenities or services. The court referred to the extended definition of "development" in section 4 of the EP&A Act to support this conclusion, ensuring that the Council's ability to impose contributions was aligned with the legislative intent to fund infrastructure needs arising from new developments.

Further, the court examined whether the Council's prediction for section 94 purposes about the likely effect of proposed development on public amenities or services precluded it from making another prediction when development consent was sought for further development of the land. The court held that the Council was not precluded from making another prediction. This decision was grounded in the principle that each stage of development may have different impacts and, therefore, may require separate assessments under section 94.

The court also addressed whether the provision of a Contributions Plan that purported to oblige an accredited certifier to impose a condition requiring payment of contributions upon a complying development certificate was invalid. The court found that such provisions were valid under section 94EC(1)(a) of the EP&A Act, which allows for the imposition of conditions on complying development certificates. The court's interpretation emphasized the legislative intent to provide flexibility in imposing contributions at different stages of development.

Another key issue was how section 94EC(1)(a) of the EP&A Act should be construed in this context. The court held that the section should be construed broadly to enable the Council to impose conditions on complying development certificates to ensure that contributions are made as required by section 94. This interpretation aligned with the broader legislative goal of managing infrastructure costs associated with new developments.

The court also considered whether the granting of subdivision consents impliedly granted consent for the lots in the subdivision to be put to residential use. The court found that the granting of subdivision consents did not necessarily imply consent for residential use. This decision was based on the principle that different types of development consents address different aspects of land use and infrastructure needs.

The significance of the unavailability of rights of appeal in respect of a condition imposed upon a complying development certificate was also explored. The court noted that while there is no right of appeal in such circumstances, this does not undermine the validity of the condition if it is within the statutory framework provided by the EP&A Act.

Finally, the court examined how sections 85A(10) and 94B(3) of the EP&A Act applied in this case. The court held that these sections did not restrict the Council's ability to impose contributions as per the Contributions Plan. The court's reasoning was grounded in the principle that the Council's actions were consistent with the statutory provisions and the overarching goal of managing infrastructure costs associated with new developments.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the appeal and held that the Council's new Contributions Plan was valid, and its provisions were consistent with the legislative framework provided by the EP&A Act. The court's reasoning was grounded in a detailed analysis of the statutory provisions, authorities, and legislative intent, ensuring that the Council's actions were within the bounds of the law. The ratio decidendi of this case is that contributions plans under section 94 of the EP&A Act are valid if they align with the statutory framework and legislative intent to manage infrastructure costs associated with new developments.