Brokenshire v Equity Trustees Executors & Agency Company Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

CAUSES JURISDICTION

Not Restricted

No.4 of 1998

IN THE MATTER OF THE WILL AND ESTATE OF

JEANETTE VERA BROKENSHIRE

THE EQUITY TRUSTEES EXECUTORS Propounder
& AGENCY COMPANY LTD.
v
ALAN REGINALD WORTS Caveator

---

JUDGE: Smith, J.
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 8, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 19, 20 & 21 October 1998
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 17 December 1998
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: Jeanette Vera Brokenshire v. The Equity Trustees
Executors & Agency Company Ltd
MEDIA NEUTRAL CITATION: [1998] VSC 183

Probate - testamentary capacity - dementia - undue influence.

--

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Propounder  Mr R. T. A. Waddell Hunt & Hunt
For the Caveator  Mr B. R. S. Kendall N. A. Young & Co
and Mr J. Mattin

HIS HONOUR:

The Proceedings

  1. By originating motion filed 15 January 1997 the plaintiff, the Equity Trustees Executors and Agency Company Limited ("the Executor"), seeks a grant of probate of a will dated 16 March 1990 made by Jeannette Vera Brokenshire ("the Testatrix"). Mrs Brokenshire died on 1 July 1996 at the Harcourt Nursing Home, 29 Shierlaw Avenue, Canterbury, Melbourne.

  2. On 31 July 1996, a caveat was lodged on behalf of Alan Reginald Worts (“the caveator”). Subsequently, the caveator identified two grounds upon which he sought to oppose the grant of probate of the 1990 will:

    1)          lack of testamentary capacity.

    2)          undue influence.

    The Wills

  3. By an earlier will dated 14 September 1987, the testatrix appointed her nephew Alan Reginald Worts (the caveator) as executor and trustee of her will. She gave a cutlery cabinet and its contents to her sister, Irene Mavis Worts. She gave a legacy of $50 to two of her nephews, the caveator and his brother Robert Sydney Worts. They were the children of her sister Irene Mavis Worts. Finally, she devised the rest of her estate to her brother, Alan Stuart Manley, and further provided that if he should predecease her the balance of the estate was to be paid and transferred to her nephews, the caveator and Robert Sydney Worts, in equal shares if both living at her death.

  4. In the challenged will of 16 March 1990, she repeated the dispositions to her sister and brother. She changed the residuary gift, however, so that, in the event that her brother predeceased her, her estate, other than the cutlery cabinet and contents, would go to the Eaglehawk Uniting Church not to her nephews. She also did not maintain the two legacies of $50 to her nephews. Finally, the 1990 will differed in that the executors named were her brother, Alan Stuart Manley, and the plaintiff, not her nephew, the caveator.

    The deceased's estate

  5. At her death, the assets held by the testatrix comprised the sum of $30,805.69 held in two accounts with the Commonwealth Bank of Australia and furniture and household effects valued at $950. She also owned her home at 17 Barloa Road, Mont Albert valued for the executor at $200,000. She…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brokenshire v Equity Trustees Executors & Agency Company Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] VSC 183
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Equity Trustees Executors and Agency Company Limited, sought a grant of probate of a will dated 16 March 1990 made by Jeannette Vera Brokenshire. The caveator, Alan Reginald Worts, opposed the grant of probate, arguing that the testatrix lacked testamentary capacity and that undue influence was exercised over her by her brother, Alan Stuart Manley. The Supreme Court of Victoria heard the case over several days in October 1998 and delivered its judgment on 17 December 1998. The court found that the testatrix had testamentary capacity at the time she executed the will and that there was no undue influence exerted on her. As a result, the court granted the plaintiff's application for a grant of probate. The caveator's arguments regarding the testatrix's lack of testamentary capacity were based on her age, dementia, and alleged paranoid ideation. However, the court found that the evidence presented did not support the conclusion that the testatrix lacked the necessary mental capacity to execute the will. The court also rejected the caveator's argument that undue influence was exerted on the testatrix by her brother, finding that the relationship between the testatrix and her brother was one of equal power, with the testatrix ultimately exercising control over the disposition of her estate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established