Broken Hill Junction North Silver Mining Co v Broken Hill Junction Lead Mining Co

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read
17 CLR 335

. duces tecum; but it has been decided by the Court of Appeal in

Elder v. Carter 1, that wide as are the terms of Order XXXVII., rule 7, they were not intended to give litigants any new right to discovery against persons not parties to the proceedings. As against Mr. Pym, the solicitor, the appeal must be dismissed with costs." That judgment was concurred in by Bowen L.J., who sat with Lindley L.J. in Elder v. Carter (1), and it was agreed in also by Kay L.J.

That is the position of the authorities with regard to the rule which appears in the Rules of this Court as Order XXXIV., rule 2; and it will be quite apparent from what I have cited that the rule cannot possibly apply to a case like the present, in which discovery, or that which amounts to discovery, is sought against a person not a party to the suit. I think I ought to follow these decisions. This is not an application to secure the attendance of a person as a witness to produce documents. The petitioner is seeking an order to inspect, with leave to take extracts. This distinction was drawn in Straker Bros. v. Reynolds 2.

The result is that no section of the Commonwealth Electoral Act, nor any rule under that Act, has been discovered which can be held to give this Court of Disputed Returns the power to make such an order as is sought on behalf of the petitioner. It may be that such a power is highly necessary, and that the ends of justice are frustrated by its absence. It seems strange that in a proceeding which involves the question of the proper conduct of an election, when information is sought which exists only in the rolls and other documents in the custody of public officers, a petitioner is not entitled to the discovery that is here sought. But the remedy is in the hands of the legislature, not those of the Court.

I must therefore dismiss the application, and I think the sitting member is entitled to his costs of opposing it.

Application dismissed with costs. Solicitors, for petitioner, M. L. Moss &Dwyer, Perth. Solicitors, for respondent, Hudson &Walker, Perth.

125 Q.B.D., 194. 222 Q.B.D., 262.
17 CLR 336

[ ]

THE BROKEN HILL JUNCTION NORTH

SILVER MINING CO., NO LIABILITY,

AND OTHERS.

THE BROKEN HILL JUNCTION LEAD

RESPONDENTS.

MINING CO., NO LIABILITY

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Practice-High Court-Abandonment of defences-Raising new defence-Agree.

ment of parties-Remitter of case to Supreme Court-Order allowing further time-Interpretation.

The plaintiffs and the defendants were lessees from the Crown of adjoining mining leases in New South Wales, the mines on which communicated below 29, 30; Oct. the surface by means of certain adits. Through these adits air passed from the plaintiffs' mine into the defendants' mine. The plaintiffs brought a suit in the Supreme Court of New South Wales against the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Broken Hill Junction North Silver Mining Co v Broken Hill Ju... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1913] HCA 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties to this matter were the Broken Hill Junction North Silver Mining Co., No Liability (the plaintiffs) and the Broken Hill Junction Lead Mining Co., No Liability (the defendants). The dispute concerned the ventilation of adjoining mining leases, with the plaintiffs seeking a declaration and injunction regarding the free passage of air through adits connecting their mine to the defendants' mine. The defendants counterclaimed, seeking an injunction to prevent the plaintiffs from forcing impure air into their mine and interfering with natural ventilation, along with an inquiry as to damages. The case was heard on appeal before the High Court of Australia.

The legal issues before the High Court included the interpretation of an agreement between the parties that significantly altered the scope of the appeal. This agreement involved the plaintiffs abandoning their appeal against the dismissal of their claim and their defences to the counterclaim, while being permitted to raise a new defence of justification under their lease and the relevant Mining Acts. The Court also had to determine the consequences of this agreement on the existing decree, particularly concerning the counterclaim and the plaintiffs' liability for damages arising from a stay of the Supreme Court's judgment. A further issue was the plaintiffs' obligation to compensate the defendants for damages sustained due to the continued stay of the Supreme Court's injunction, a matter on which there was a divergence of judicial opinion.

The Court's reasoning was largely guided by the agreement reached between the parties. This agreement led to the remittal of the counterclaim to the Supreme Court for further determination, allowing the plaintiffs to pursue their new defence. Regarding the compensation for the stay of the injunction, a majority of the Court held that the plaintiffs should pay compensation if the appeal was ultimately unsuccessful, viewing the initial extension of time as a concession granted at a price. However, one judge dissented, arguing that the basis for the special compensation order had failed due to the abandonment of the original grounds for the injunction, and therefore the plaintiffs should not be compelled to pay. The Court also clarified that certain legal arguments regarding the interpretation of mining leases and restrictive covenants were not decided on their merits due to the procedural posture of the appeal and the parties' agreement.

The final orders reflected the parties' agreement. The appeal was partially dismissed, and the counterclaim was remitted to the Supreme Court for further proceedings. The plaintiffs were permitted to amend their defence to the counterclaim. A majority of the Court ordered that the plaintiffs pay compensation to the defendants for damages caused by the stay of the Supreme Court's judgment, should the appeal be unsuccessful, though the precise calculation and payment were subject to further determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.