Brogan and Comcare

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 573

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)No Q2001/460, Q2001/1170

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )       
           Re      DEAN ALLAN BROGAN
  Applicant
           And    COMCARE  
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr EK Christie, Member    

Date12 July 2002 

PlaceBrisbane

Decision      The Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.  This means the applications for review are unsuccessful.  

..................(Sgnd)..................
  EK Christie
  Member
CATCHWORDS
WORKERS' COMPENSATION - compensation - Commonwealth employees - compensation for cost of medical treatment - permanent impairment - separate injuries - whether further compensation payable for increase in whole person impairment rating.

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 16, 24, 25, 39

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Comcare v Mihaljovic (2000) 170 ALR 420 

REASONS FOR DECISION

12 July 2002           Dr EK Christie, Member                

  1. This is an application to review two decisions of the respondent which –

    (a)disallowed the applicant's claim for further payment of lump sum compensation for permanent impairment for adjustment disorder (Q2001/1170:  29 October 2001); and

    (b)disallowed the applicant's claim to be provided with a recliner lounge chair and an "aid or appliance";  an aid or appliance had been approved under the rehabilitation plan (Q2001/460:  30 March 2001).

  2. The Tribunal had before it documents lodged pursuant to Section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) and the various documents tendered by the parties.

  3. The applicant, Dean Allan Brogan and Ms Bronwyn Jenner, an Occupational Therapist called by the respondent, gave oral evidence at the hearing.  Mr Brogan's evidence was extremely brief.  He was not cross-examined.
    FACTS

  4. The general facts were not in dispute and may be stated briefly.  Mr Brogan is currently aged 33 years and was a serving member of the Army from 27 January 1987 until his discharge, for medical reasons, on 21 December 1994.

  5. Mr Brogan sustained a back injury during the course of his employment whilst playing Army organised sport, in June 1993.

  6. It is not in dispute that Mr Brogan now has two accepted conditions – a back condition (spinal stenosis at L2) and a psychiatric condition (adjustment disorder).

  7. On 7 December 1995, Mr Brogan received lump sum permanent impairment compensation in relation to his accepted back condition, based on a 20% whole person impairment and using Table 9.5 of the "Comcare Guide".

  8. On 29 May 2001, the applicant sought to extend liability for his back injury to include his psychiatric condition – specifically, an adjustment disorder relating to his back condition.  This claim for further compensation was disallowed by the respondent on 7 June 2001.

  9. It is not in dispute that Mr Brogan's compensable back condition justifies a conclusion that this condition would benefit from some agreed form of suitable chair as an "aid or appliance".  However, the parties are in dispute over whether the "aid of appliance" should be a recliner lounge chair (the "Dakota") or an upright chair (the "Laverne Victoria" lounge chair).
    EVIDENCE OF BRONWYN JENNER, OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST

  10. The evidence of Ms Jenner related to the type of chair that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brogan and Comcare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 573
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Brogan v Comcare, the applicant, Mr Dean Allan Brogan, sought compensation for the cost of medical treatment and an increase in his whole person impairment rating due to separate injuries sustained during his employment with the Commonwealth. The primary dispute centred on whether Mr Brogan was entitled to further compensation for his increased whole person impairment rating. The case was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The key legal issues that the court had to address were whether Mr Brogan's psychiatric condition, an adjustment disorder related to his back injury, was a separate injury that warranted additional compensation, and if so, what type of chair should be provided to him as an aid or appliance under his rehabilitation plan.

The court analysed the evidence provided by Mr Brogan and Ms Bronwyn Jenner, an Occupational Therapist, to determine the most suitable chair for Mr Brogan's back condition. Ms Jenner testified that an upright chair with pronounced lumbar support and firm supportive foam padding, such as the "Laverne Victoria" lounge chair, was more appropriate for Mr Brogan's condition than a recliner chair. She argued that a recliner chair would not encourage correct spinal alignment and could lead to muscle weakening and increased pain over time. The court considered Ms Jenner's evidence and the proposition that occupational therapists balance short-term relief with avoidance of muscular weakening when selecting aids for patients.

The court found that Mr Brogan's psychiatric condition was a separate injury that warranted further compensation. However, the court also determined that the "Laverne Victoria" lounge chair was the most suitable aid for Mr Brogan's back condition, based on Ms Jenner's expert opinion. The court concluded that the evidence supported the use of an upright chair rather than a recliner chair, as the latter could exacerbate Mr Brogan's condition and lead to dependency and a "sick role".

The final orders of the court were not explicitly stated in the text provided. However, it can be inferred that the court granted Mr Brogan compensation for his increased whole person impairment rating due to his separate psychiatric condition, while also directing that an upright chair, specifically the "Laverne Victoria" lounge chair, be provided as an aid or appliance for his back condition.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Dean Allan Brogan and Ms Bronwyn Jenner, an Occupational Therapist called by the respondent, gave oral evidence at the hearing. Mr Brogan's evidence was extremely brief. He was not cross-examined.FACTS The general facts were not in dispute and may be stated briefly. Mr Brogan is currently aged 33 years and was a serving member of the Army from 27 January 1987 until his discharge, for medical reasons, on 21 December 1994. Mr Brogan sustained a back injury during the course of his employment whilst playing Army organised sport, in June 1993. It is not in dispute that Mr Brogan now has two accepted conditions – a back condition (spinal stenosis at L2) and a psychiatric condition (adjustment disorder). On 7 December 1995, Mr Brogan received lump sum permanent impairment compensation in relation to his accepted back condition, based on a 20% whole person impairment and using Table 9.5 of the "Comcare Guide". On 29 May 2001, the applicant sought to extend liability for his back injury to include his psychiatric condition – specifically, an adjustment disorder relating to his back condition. This claim for further compensation was disallowed by the respondent on 7 June 2001. It is not in dispute that Mr Brogan's compensable back condition justifies a conclusion that this condition would benefit from some agreed form of suitable chair as an "aid or appliance". However, the parties are in dispute over whether the "aid of appliance" should be a recliner lounge chair (the "Dakota") or an upright chair (the "Laverne Victoria" lounge chair).EVIDENCE OF BRONWYN JENNER, OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST The evidence of Ms Jenner related to the type of chair that was suitable for Mr Brogan's accepted back condition and which could be approved under the rehabilitation plan. Ms Jenner said that the basis for her recommendation of a suitable chair for Mr Brogan was one that would assist with pain management and, as well, would maximise independence with his daily living activities. A suitable chair would need to have a very pronounced lumbar support backrest and also firm supportive foam padding in the chair. These features were found in the "Laverne Victoria" lounge chair. Ms Jenner stated that a recliner chair would not be appropriate for Mr Brogan's back condition. Such a chair would normally be required by someone who had to be seated in a chair for long periods of time, e.g. because of cardiovascular problems or spinal injury. A recliner chair would not be appropriate for someone who was functioning on a day-to-day basis – such as Mr Brogan – because this chair did not encourage correct alignment of the spine. Moreover, whilst a reclining chair might bring some short term pain relief, it did create a more unstable spine because it was more difficult for a person to sit in an upright position and to support themselves in an upright position. One consequence of a dependence on using a recliner chair was that it could lead to abdominal and spinal muscle weakening together with increasing pain – particularly if it were used by Mr Brogan as the only chair for all his seated tasks that he would otherwise use a lounge room chair for.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is not in dispute that Mr Brogan's compensable back condition justifies a conclusion that this condition would benefit from some agreed form of suitable chair as an "aid or appliance". However, the parties are in dispute over whether the "aid of appliance" should be a recliner lounge chair (the "Dakota") or an upright chair (the "Laverne Victoria" lounge chair).EVIDENCE OF BRONWYN JENNER, OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST The evidence of Ms Jenner related to the type of chair that was suitable for Mr Brogan's accepted back condition and which could be approved under the rehabilitation plan. Ms Jenner said that the basis for her recommendation of a suitable chair for Mr Brogan was one that would assist with pain management and, as well, would maximise independence with his daily living activities. A suitable chair would need to have a very pronounced lumbar support backrest and also firm supportive foam padding in the chair. These features were found in the "Laverne Victoria" lounge chair. Ms Jenner stated that a recliner chair would not be appropriate for Mr Brogan's back condition. Such a chair would normally be required by someone who had to be seated in a chair for long periods of time, e.g. because of cardiovascular problems or spinal injury. A recliner chair would not be appropriate for someone who was functioning on a day-to-day basis – such as Mr Brogan – because this chair did not encourage correct alignment of the spine. Moreover, whilst a reclining chair might bring some short term pain relief, it did create a more unstable spine because it was more difficult for a person to sit in an upright position and to support themselves in an upright position. One consequence of a dependence on using a recliner chair was that it could lead to abdominal and spinal muscle weakening together with increasing pain – particularly if it were used by Mr Brogan as the only chair for all his seated tasks that he would otherwise use a lounge room chair for. Ms Jenner stated that her assessment of Mr Brogan's level of functioning, some eight months following Dr Scott-Young's report (T10), was lower than she expected in terms of walking, standing and sitting. Consequently, she concluded that reliance on a high dependency aid, such as a recliner chair, in Mr Brogan's circumstances, could encourage an "ongoing sick role" for Mr Brogan. Ms Jenner concluded with the statement that a recliner-type chair in these circumstances would be unsuitable because it could become a high dependency aid and be inappropriate, given the nature of Mr Brogan's back condition. Ms Jenner agreed with the Tribunal proposition that the standard approach used by occupational therapists in selecting an aid for someone in Mr Brogan's circumstances would be to balance short-term relief with avoidance of muscular weakening. During cross-examination, Ms Jenner responded to questions stating:(a)that she had not tested Mr Brogan's concerns that upright chairs did not provide him with support, or if they gave him symptomatic relief;(b)that she agreed with Dr Parson's opinion that whilst Mr Brogan was using the reclining chair for limited periods, he would get symptomatic relief;(c)that, whilst acknowledging prolonged periods of use of the recliner chair could lead to problems, she could not put an "exact timeframe on it". Later, she agreed with the proposition that a prolonged period was "hours and hours on end for days and days";(d)that counselling advice by occupational therapists normally would involve suggestions that "people change their posture every 20 – 30 minutes from sitting to standing or walking when someone had symptom experience";(e)that her reported comment on Mr Brogan's tolerance for sitting of approximately 30 minutes was based on a response from Mr Brogan where he said his "sitting tolerance was 30 minutes on most chairs";(f)that she had not commented in her report on the length of time Mr Brogan could sit before he became uncomfortable;(g)that she accepted the proposition that there was always a possibility that a person with a back condition could take on a sick role;(h)that someone with a back condition should not sit for longer than 30 minutes without changing their posture;(i)that it would be reasonable to combine the use of a chair for 30 minute periods with getting up and moving around;(j)that occupational therapists provided education about the appropriate use of "aids and appliances".

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established