Broadley and Taylor v Moreton Bay Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Broadley and Taylor v Moreton Bay Regional Council  [2020] QCAT 254

PARTIES:

JAMES LEIGH BROADLEY and AMY TAYLOR
(applicant)

v

MORETON BAY REGIONAL COUNCIL

 (respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR165-20

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review

DELIVERED ON:

9 July 2020

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member King-Scott

ORDERS:

The Tribunal directs

1.   Hayley Walker be joined as a party to proceeding GAR165-20.

2.   The application for an extension of time is allowed;

3.   The Destruction Order of the Moreton Bay Regional Council of 22 February 2020 is stayed until determination of the Application to Review or otherwise lifted;

4.   The Moreton Bay Regional Council serve Ms Walker by post or email with all relevant material relating to the Application to Review including these reasons and orders by 24 July 2020;

5. Ms Walker must file two (2) copies and give to the Council one (1) copy a detailed statement undertaking to care for Kesha and detailing her ability to meet the requirements of Schedule 1 of the AM Act including the provision of a compliant enclosure and where that enclosure will be situated (the undertaking) by 4.00 pm 14 August 2020:

6.   The Council must file two (2) copies and give to the Council one (1) copy of its response to the proposal by Ms Walker by 4.00 pm 28 August 2020:

7.    Should Ms Walker not be prepared to give the said undertaking then the stay will be lifted.

8.   The Application to Review be listed for a Compulsory Conference at a date after 28 August 2020.

CATCHWORDS:

ANIMALS – VARIOUS STATUTORY PROVISIONS REGULATION OF COMPANION ANIMALS – SEZIURE AND DESTRUCTION – where local government made destruction order pursuant to s.127 of the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 – where owner applied for external review of the decision – where absent co-owners offers to care for dog – where co-owner joined by the tribunal as a party.
PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – TIME EXTENSION AND ABRIDGMENT – application to review 5 weeks out of time – interests of justice

Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (Qld) ss. 5, 127, 184, 188, Schedule 1, Schedule 2 s.9
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) ss 20, 22, 32, 33 (3), 61 (1) and (3)
Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Regulations 2009.

Coppens v Water Wise Design Pty Ltd [2014] QCATA 309
Crime and Misconduct Commission v Chapman and Anor [2011] QCAT 229
Jensen v Queensland Building and Constructions Commission [2017] QCAT 232

APPEARANCES:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld).

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On 7 April 2019 the Moreton Bay Regional Council (“the Council”) declared the Applicant’s dog, a bitch named Kesha, a Regulated and Dangerous Dog (“the declaration”). The declaration was made relating to an incident that occurred on 16 April 2019. That declaration was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Broadley and Taylor v Moreton Bay Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCAT 254
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Broadley and Taylor sought a review of a decision by the Moreton Bay Regional Council to make a destruction order in respect of their dog, Kesha. The dispute arose from the Council's decision to declare Kesha as a Regulated and Dangerous Dog and subsequently order her destruction due to multiple incidents of aggressive behaviour and non-compliance with dangerous dog permit conditions. The Tribunal was tasked with deciding whether the destruction order should be reviewed and whether an extension of time should be granted for the application.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the destruction order should be reviewed and if so, whether an extension of time should be granted for the application to review. The Tribunal had to consider the interests of the parties, the public interest, and the specific circumstances of the case, including the co-owner's offer to care for Kesha and her compliance with the dangerous dog permit conditions.

The Tribunal allowed the application for an extension of time and granted the application for review. The Tribunal found that the interests of justice required the destruction order to be stayed until the review application was determined. The Tribunal also ordered that Hayley Walker, the co-owner who offered to care for Kesha, be joined as a party to the proceeding. The Tribunal directed that Walker must provide an undertaking to care for Kesha, including details of a compliant enclosure, by a specified date. If Walker did not provide the undertaking, the stay would be lifted. The review application was listed for a compulsory conference after the specified date for Walker's undertaking.

The Tribunal made several orders, including allowing the application for an extension of time, staying the destruction order until the review application was determined, and requiring Walker to provide an undertaking to care for Kesha. The Tribunal also ordered that the Council must respond to Walker's proposal by a specified date and listed the review application for a compulsory conference after Walker's undertaking was due.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal directs

1. Hayley Walker be joined as a party to proceeding GAR165-20.

2. The application for an extension of time is allowed;

3. The Destruction Order of the Moreton Bay Regional Council of 22 February 2020 is stayed until determination of the Application to Review or otherwise lifted;

4. The Moreton Bay Regional Council serve Ms Walker by post or email with all relevant material relating to the Application to Review including these reasons and orders by 24 July 2020;

5. Ms Walker must file two (2) copies and give to the Council one (1) copy a detailed statement undertaking to care for Kesha and detailing her ability to meet the requirements of Schedule 1 of the AM Act including the provision of a compliant enclosure and where that enclosure will be situated (the undertaking) by 4.00 pm 14 August 2020:

6. The Council must file two (2) copies and give to the Council one (1) copy of its response to the proposal by Ms Walker by 4.00 pm 28 August 2020:

7. Should Ms Walker not be prepared to give the said undertaking then the stay will be lifted.

8. The Application to Review be listed for a Compulsory Conference at a date after 28 August 2020.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 22 of the QCAT Act provides that the Tribunal can make an order to stay a decision only if it considers it desirable after having regard to the interests of any person whose interests may be affected by the making of, or declining of, a stay order, having regard to any submissions made by the decision-maker and having regard to the public interest. Background According to the Council there had been multiple incidents involving Kesha that led to it making the declaration on 7 April 2019. Briefly, they were:(a)On 6 July 2017 she was reported as wandering at large;(b)On 22 August 2017 a report was received of Kesha biting a person;(c)On 25 October 2017 the Council received a report of Kesha menacing a person by barking, growling and advancing towards a person as they retreated to their home to avoid being bitten. Mr Broadley was fined.(d)On 15 May 2018 she was reported as wandering at large and menacing other dogs on several occasions. Mr Broadley was issued with a warning.(e)On 16 March 2019 the Council investigated a reported attack by Kesha and found that Kesha had attacked and killed another dog;(f)On 29 March 2019 Council officers found Kesha wandering at large:(g)On 7 April 2019 Kesha was declared a Regulated and Dangerous Dog relating to the incident on 16 April 2019. Subsequent to the making of the declaration further incidents occurred, namely:(a)On 14 April 2019 the Council received a report of Kesha rushing out of the property where she was to be detained and attacking a woman walking two dogs;(b)On 11 May 2019 Council received a report of Kesha wandering at large;(c)On 24 May 2019 Council received a report of Kesha wandering at large and stalking a person walking a dog. On 30 May 2019 Mr Broadley admitted that he had allowed Kesha to wander outside his property and was issued with a fine for not complying with the dangerous dog permit conditions of retention in a enclosure and muzzled; (d)On 2 September 2019 Council received a report of Kesha wandering at large;(e)On 16 December 2019 Council received a report of Kesha wandering at large;(f)On 17 January 2020 a Council officer sighted Kesha wandering at large and seized her;(g)On 20 January 2020 Council officers visited Mr Broadley’s property and found that the enclosure for Kesha was non-compliant. The decision by the Council’s authorised officer to issue the Order was based on the failure of the Applicant to abide the requirements for keeping a Regulated Dangerous Dog in accordance with the AM Act and the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Regulations 2009. Mr Broadley wants to dispute the facts relating to the declaration which are now irrelevant as he did not dispute them at the time and did not contest the making of the declaration. He has not sought a review of that decision. Indeed, it seems clear that he has not complied with the declaration. The crux of his case seems to be to rely upon the observations of the RSPCA carers who have cared for Kesha while she has been impounded. Those observations tend to show that in the early days that Kesha displayed some stress and anxiety requiring medication, however, she did not exhibit any aggressive behaviour.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established