Broadbent and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 822

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No  N2000/891

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      FRANCIS BROADBENT  
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President           

Date25 August 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      For the reasons given orally, the matter is referred back to the Minister with a direction that while failing the character test the discretion be exercised not to cancel Mr Broadbent's visa.           
  (Dr D Chappell)
  ..............................................
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP – cancellation of permanent transitional visa – expedited hearing under provisions of Migration Reform Act – citizen of Zambia – citizen of the United Kingdom – consideration of validity of s501of the Act – section valid – substantial criminal record – fails to pass the character test – consideration of the discretion – arrived in Australia from Zambia aged seven – convicted as both a juvenile and an adult of a series of offences – consideration of the protection of the Australian Community – consideration of the seriousness and nature of the conduct – crimes serious - consideration of risk of recidivism – prospect that he will assume responsibilities - consideration of deterrence factor – little weight given to this factor - consideration of the expectations of the Australian community – applicant resided in Australia for over almost four decades - consideration of the best interests of the child – future relationship hypothetical and afforded little weight - other considerations – consideration of hardship to applicant – significant hardship - referred back to Minister – applicant's visa not to be cancelled
Migration Act 1958 s501
Msumba v Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs 2000 AATA 87
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Paul William Gunner [1998] FCA 831

REASONS FOR DECISION

25 August 2000       Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President   

BACKGROUND
Application and Hearing

  1. This is an application by Mr Francis Broadbent (the applicant) for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (the Minister) pursuant to s501 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act) to cancel his permanent transitional visa granted originally as a result of the Migration Reform Act on 1 September 1994 (SG3).  The refusal was based on a finding that Mr Broadbent was not a person of good character.  Section 500(1)(b) of the Act confers jurisdiction on the Tribunal to review this decision.  Mr Broadbent was notified of the Minister's decision to cancel his visa on 6 June 2000 (SG3).  Mr Broadbent sought review of this decision by the Tribunal in an application lodged on 8 June 2000 (SG4).

  2. Mr Jeffrey Loxton, of counsel, represented Mr Broadbent on a pro bono basis at the hearing.  Mr Broadbent gave personal testimony to the Tribunal.  The following witnesses also testified on behalf of the applicant:

    Ms Kelly Lee Lewis
    Mr Ian David Henderson
    Ms Nicole Freeman
    Mr William Broadbent
    Mr Davy Broadbent

  3. Mr Paul Hardman, solicitor, represented the respondent.  The following witnesses also…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Broadbent and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Aff... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 822
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves Mr. Broadbent, a citizen of Zambia, appealing the cancellation of his permanent transitional visa by the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs. The court was tasked with deciding whether the visa cancellation should be upheld, considering Mr. Broadbent's substantial criminal record and the relevant statutory provisions. The key legal issue was whether the Tribunal should exercise its discretion under section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 not to cancel Mr. Broadbent's visa despite his failure to pass the character test.

The court examined the validity of section 501 and Mr. Broadbent's substantial criminal record, which included multiple convictions and sentences totaling over two years. It was noted that Mr. Broadbent had been convicted as both a juvenile and an adult of serious crimes, leading to a finding that he did not meet the character test. The court then turned to the discretion under section 501(1), weighing the primary considerations of the protection of the Australian community, the expectations of the Australian community, and the best interests of any child involved. Mr. Broadbent had resided in Australia for almost four decades and had a son, Brian, who was an Australian citizen. The court also considered other factors such as the risk of recidivism, rehabilitation efforts, and the hardship to Mr. Broadbent if his visa were to be cancelled. Ultimately, the court found that the significant hardship to Mr. Broadbent and his long-term ties to Australia warranted a reconsideration of the visa cancellation.

The court concluded that while Mr. Broadbent's criminal history was serious, the Tribunal should exercise its discretion not to cancel his visa. The decision was influenced by the long-term residence in Australia, his efforts at rehabilitation, and the potential hardship to his family. The case was remitted back to the Minister for further consideration in light of the Tribunal's findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Reference will be made later in this decision to those provisions of the Policy Directions which are relevant to the Tribunal's consideration of the present matter. But first the Tribunal turns its attention to the evidence presented concerning Mr Broadbent and the application of the character test under s501.EVIDENCESubstantial Criminal Record Mr Broadbent did not dispute that he did not pass the character test by reason of having a "substantial criminal record", as defined under s501. Section 501(6)(a) of the Act provides that a person does not pass the character test if the person has a substantial criminal record as defined by s501(7)(a). That section relevantly provides that:For the purposes of the character test, the person has a substantial criminal record if:…(c)the person has been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of twelve months or more; or(d)the person has been sentenced to two or more terms of imprisonment (whether on one or more occasions), where the total of those terms is two years or more… The evidence showed that Mr Broadbent had a substantial criminal record, as defined under both ss501(7)(c) and (d), in that he had been sentenced to terms of imprisonment of 12 months or more for each of 11 separate crimes, as well as being sentenced to two or more terms of imprisonment where the total of those terms was two years or more. A summary of Mr Broadbent's criminal record is contained in Attachment 1. More will be said about that record shortly.EXERCISING THE DISCRETIONPolicy As Mr Broadbent has failed to pass the character test the principal issue which must be determined by the Tribunal is whether it should still exercise its discretion under s 501(1) of the Act not to cancel his visa. The Policy Direction refers to a number of factors to which decision makers should have regard when exercising this discretion. These include three primary considerations as well as a number of other considerations. The Policy Direction notes that:Decision makers should note that no individual considerations can be more important than a primary consideration, but that a primary consideration cannot be conclusive in itself in deciding whether to exercise the discretion to refuse or to cancel a visa. Decision-makers must have due regard to the important placed by the Government on the three primary considerations, but should also adopt a balancing process which takes into account all relevant considerations.(paragraph 2.2) The three primary considerations to which the Tribunal must have regard are:the protection of the Australia community, and members of the community;the expectations of the Australian community; andin all cases involving a parental relationship between a child or children and the person under consideration, the best interests of the child or children.(paragraph 2.3) In the present case each of these primary considerations require attention. However, before turning to the evidence presented to the Tribunal on these three primary considerations it is appropriate to provide some general background information about the circumstances which led to the cancellation of Mr Broadbent's visa.Circumstances Leading to Visa Cancellation

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having reached this conclusion the Tribunal will disregard entirely the additional oral evidence given by Mr Broadbent about any hardship he would experience if removed to the United Kingdom. In regard to the documentary and personal testimony provided by the British High Commission officials the Tribunal, having accepted this evidence, does not feel it can now treat it as being null and void because is it was obtained under what might be viewed as a tainted process. The evidence is clearly relevant and it would be inappropriate to ignore it, or to proceed as Mr Loxton submitted, on the basis that Mr Broadbent will be removed to Zambia if his visa is cancelled. Ultimately, it is for the respondent to determine where Mr Broadbent should be sent and that would clearly be affected by his citizenship. In the present case the Tribunal accepts that this is certainly British, and may also be Zambian. The respondent has already indicated that it is proceeding on the basis of a removal to the United Kingdom, should the decision under review be affirmed.CONCLUSION As the Policy Direction indicates:The government is mindful of the need to balance a number of important factors in reaching a decision whether or not to refuse or cancel a visa. … Decision makers must have due regard to the importance placed by the government on the three primary considerations, but should also adopt a balancing process which takes into account all relevant considerations.(Policy Direction: 2.2) The Tribunal has already expressed its views in regard to the nature and the seriousness of Mr Broadbent's criminal conduct. His pattern of offending has been both persistent and of escalating gravity. He seems to have been undeterred in the past by a series of custodial sentences and committed his most recent armed robbery and home invasion while enjoying the privileges of parole. He professed to have been addicted to cannabis at the time that he committed a number of offences, including his most recent, although his evidence on this point was somewhat conflicting. The fact that he has continued to commit serious crimes is of obvious relevance both to the framework set for decision makers by the Policy Direction, and to his general prospects of rehabilitation. In considering what are the risks of Mr Broadbent re-offending there are some more encouraging signs from the appraisals made of his performance while in prison since his conviction and sentence in 1994. This evidence does suggest that Mr Broadbent has, following years of apparent indifference to any rehabilitative programs, determined that he should obtain an understanding of his addictive behaviours and acquire work skills that would allow him to make a more positive contribution to the community. The Tribunal was impressed by the evidence of his successful completion of tertiary studies at Curtin University as well as the most positive appraisals provided by his correctional and educational supervisors regarding his study and work practices. Sufficient trust was placed in Mr Broadbent to allow him to be given a security classification which allowed him to work outside the prison walls in a nursery. He appears to have been able to maintain this employment and to gain the full confidence of his employers. He has also been able to obtain some work after his release to parole.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Loxton submitted, on Mr Broadbent's behalf, that the issue which had to be determined by the Tribunal was what was in Brian's best interests in the future, rather than his father's interests of being with his son. Brian was an Australian citizen who was already subject to care orders and who needed more than most children a steady and stable influence in his life. Mr Broadbent, his natural father, wished to accept that role once circumstances permitted.Other Considerations Paragraph 2.17 of the Policy Direction refers to a number of other matters which, although not primary considerations, may be relevant to the exercise of the discretion under the Act. The Policy Direction states, in part, that:2.17 It is the Government's view that where relevant, it is appropriate these matters be taken into account but that they be given less individual weight than that given to the primary considerations. These other considerations may include:(a)the extent of disruption to the non-citizen's family, business and other ties to the Australian community;(b)genuine marriage to, or de facto or interdependent relationship with, an Australian citizen, permanent resident or eligible New Zealand citizen:· in assessing the compassionate claims of the Australian partner (Australian citizen, resident or eligible New Zealand citizen), decision-makers must consider the circumstances under which the relationship was established and whether the Australian partner knew that the non-citizen was of character concern at the time of entering into or establishing the relationship.(c)the degree of hardship which would be caused to immediate family members lawfully resident in Australia (including Australian citizens), including whether the immediate family members are able to travel overseas to visit the non-citizen, the nature of the relationship between the non-citizen and the immediate family members, whether immediate family members are in some way dependant on the non-citizen for support which cannot be provided elsewhere;(d)family composition of the non-citizen's family, both in Australia and overseas;(e)the likelihood of the non-citizen seeking to evade any outstanding legal matter or on-going liability;(f)the likelihood of the non-citizen breaching any conditions attached to the outstanding legal or on-going matter, any cost or bilateral implications of such a breach (eg extradition);(g)the nature and seriousness of the offence(s) or alleged offence(s) (in the context of seeking to evade an outstanding legal matter);(h)any evidence of rehabilitation and any recent good conduct;(i)whether the application is for a temporary visa or permanent visa;(j)the purpose and intended duration of the entry to or stay in Australia, including any significant compassionate circumstances; and(k)the fact that a non-citizen has been formally advised in the past by an officer of the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs about conduct which brought him or her within the deportation provisions at section 200/201 of the Act or the visa refusal and cancellation provisions at section 501.(Policy Direction 2.17)