In the Matter of the Patents Act 1952 - and - In the Matter of Application No. 526329 for a Patent by BRISTOL-MYERS COMPANY - and - In the Matter of Opposition thereto under Section 59 by L'OREAL.
DECISION OF A SUPERVISING EXAMINER OF PATENTS
Background
Patent application No. 526329, which is entitled "Hair Conditioning Composition and Method", was lodged on 2 July, 1980. The earliest priority date of this application which is based on three United States patent applications is 2 July 1979. Advertisement of acceptance appeared in the official Journal of 6 January 1983.
L'OREAL lodged notice of opposition under sub-section 59(1) on 6 April 1983 and service of evidence was completed on 11 November 1986. On 13 May 1985 and 11 December 1985 the applicant lodged requests to amend the complete specification under section 77 and neither req4est was opposed. Allowance of these requests was advertised in the Official Journals of 19 December 1985 and 26 June 1986 respectively. A further request to amend the complete specification under section 77 was lodged on 5 February 1988.
The opposition under section 59 was set down for hearing in Melbourne on 8 February 1988. The notice of opposition specified paragraphs (a) to (i) inclusive of sub-section (1) of section 59 as the grounds of opposition; however at the hearing argument was restricted to those grounds specified in paragraphs (e), (g), (h) and (i), i.e. anticipation, obviousness and compliance with section 40. At the hearing Mr P.W. Jones, patent attorney of Phillips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick, Melbourne, represented the applicant (BRISTOL-MYERS) and Mr J. Murray, Patent attorney of Edward Waters & Sons, Melbourne, represented L'OREAL.
The Specification
The specification, as amended by the requests under section 77 lodged on 13 May 1985 and 11 December 1985 relates to compositions that are useful in conditioning hair and to processes for conditioning hair by employing such compositions.
It is known in the prior art to treat hair with certain quaternary amine compounds for the purpose of conditioning hair i.e. to improve its compatibility, manageability and softness. Although such prior art compositions have proven to be effective in varying degrees, one of the chief drawbacks has been the fact that the effect has not been long-lasting i.e. it does not survive repeated shampooings.
Accordingly it is an object of the present invention to provide a hair conditioning composition that retains its conditioning effect through repeated hair shampooings.
The invention is then described in similar terms to those found in claim 1 which reads as follows:
"1. A composition for conditioning hair which has been previously treated with a treating agent having an alkaline pH, said composition comprising:
(a) from 0.4% to 20% of at least one cationic polymer which produces a durable conditioning effect;
(b) from 0.2% to 20% of an amphoteric surfactant; and
(c) sufficient acid to give the composition a pH in the range of from 1 to 6; the ratio
=(polymer (mer)]
[detergent (mol)]
being from 0.2 to 5; in
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BRISTOL-MYERS Company v L'OREAL and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1988] APO 36
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court analyzed various prior art references and arguments presented by both parties. L'OREAL argued that the claims were anticipated by prior art and that they lacked clarity and precision. BRISTOL-MYERS countered these arguments by asserting that the prior art did not disclose the specific combination of ingredients and conditions that produced the claimed durable conditioning effect. The court meticulously examined each cited prior art reference, including patents and technical publications, to determine if they anticipated or made obvious the claims in the patent application. The court also scrutinized the definition and scope of terms used in the claims, such as "cationic polymer" and "amphoteric surfactant," to ensure they were properly defined in the specification.
The court concluded that none of the cited prior art references anticipated the specific composition and method claimed by BRISTOL-MYERS. The prior art either lacked certain critical elements or failed to achieve the specific conditioning effect described in the patent application. Additionally, the court found that the claims were not obvious to one skilled in the art based on the prior art. The court also determined that the patent specification did not comply with statutory requirements, particularly regarding the clarity and precision of the claims and the description of the invention.
As a result, the court ruled that the patent application did not meet the statutory requirements and granted BRISTOL-MYERS 60 days to propose amendments to address these deficiencies. The court awarded costs of the opposition to L'OREAL. The decision underscores the importance of specificity and clarity in patent claims to ensure they are both novel and non-obvious while complying with statutory requirements.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi