Bristile Holdings Ltd v Giacci Brothers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

CITATION:   BRISTILE HOLDINGS LTD & ORS -v- GIACCI BROTHERS PTY LTD [2000] WASCA 48

CORAM:   OWEN J

STEYTLER J

HEARD:   3 SEPTEMBER 1999

DELIVERED          :   7 MARCH 2000

FILE NO/S:   FUL 50 of 1999

BETWEEN:   BRISTILE HOLDINGS LTD

First Applicant

WILLIAM JAMES EMMETT
LAWRENCE JOHN CLARK
Second Applicants

AND

GIACCI BROTHERS PTY LTD
Respondent

Catchwords:

Evidence - Matters relating to proof - Order made under O 29 r 2(1)(c) and (d) concerning cartage dockets - Dockets to stand as evidence of tonnages carted without authors being called - Whether tonnages peripheral or central issue in action - Extent of discretion under O 29

Legislation:

Supreme Court Rules, O 29 r 2

Supreme Court Act 1935, s 167(1)(g)
Corporations Law, s 592

Evidence Act 1906, s 79C

Result:

Appeal allowed

Representation:

Counsel:

First Applicant               :     Mr M L Bennett

Second Applicants        :     Mr M L Bennett

Respondent:     Mr J C Curthoys

Solicitors:

First Applicant               :     Bennett & Co

Second Applicants        :     Bennett & Co

Respondent:     Slee Anderson & Pidgeon

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Downs Irrigation Co‑operative Association Ltd v The National Bank of Australasia Ltd (No 2) [1983] 1 Qd R 475

H v Schering Chemicals Ltd [1983] 1 WLR 143

Murine Eye Remedy Co v Eldred [1926] VLR 425

Pearce v Button (1986) 8 FCR 408

Case(s) also cited:

Nil

  1. JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: This is an application for leave to appeal against an interlocutory order of a Master made under O 29 r 2 that when the action comes to trial copies of certain nominated documents be treated as evidence of certain stipulated facts. The substantive appeal against the decision was heard at the same time.

Background

  1. The first applicant  ("Bristile") is a company that carries on business under the name "Metro Bricks".  The second applicants ("Emmett" and "Clark" respectively) are the principal executive officer and the company secretary, respectively, of Bristile.  A company called International Brick & Tile Pty Ltd ("IBT") carried on business as a brick manufacturer.  Bristile holds some of the issued capital of IBT and had entered into a management agreement with, and was the manager of, the business activities of IBT.  Emmett and Clark were also the directors of IBT.

  2. The respondent is a company engaged in cartage contracting.  In the period 1988 to 1992 it had business dealings with IBT which, it alleges, were conducted with Bristile as manager of IBT's business activities.  The respondent entered into a contract with IBT to cart clay from various sites to IBT's plant.  There was a separate contract for the respondent to extract and stockpile clay for IBT at various sites.

  3. On 6 May 1992 a receiver and manager was appointed to the property and business of IBT.  At the time the respondent was owed approximately $254,000 under the cartage and stockpiling contracts.  At some time in 1993 IBT entered into a scheme of arrangement with its creditors as a result of which the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bristile Holdings Ltd v Giacci Brothers Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] WASCA 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bristile Holdings Ltd v Giacci Brothers Pty Ltd involved an application for leave to appeal an interlocutory order made by a Master of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The order, pursuant to Order 29 rule 2, mandated that copies of certain documents be treated as evidence of specified facts during the trial. The substantive appeal against this decision was heard concurrently. The first applicant, Bristile, is a company trading as Metro Bricks, with Emmett and Clark serving as the principal executive officer and company secretary, respectively. They were also directors of International Brick & Tile Pty Ltd (IBT), a brick manufacturing company managed by Bristile. The respondent, Giacci Brothers, was engaged in cartage contracting with IBT, claiming it was owed approximately $254,000 for services rendered between 1988 and 1992. Giacci Brothers alleged that Bristile and its directors were responsible for IBT's debts due to alleged insolvent trading under the Corporations Law.

The central legal issue before the court was the extent of the discretion available under Order 29 rule 2 concerning the admission of documentary evidence. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the cartage dockets could be admitted as evidence of the tonnages carted without the authors of the dockets being called to testify. The applicants argued that the tonnages were a peripheral issue and that the documents should not be admitted without the authors' testimony. The respondent contended that the tonnages were a central issue and that the documents should be admitted without the need for the authors to appear in court.

The court examined the nature of the tonnages in the context of the case, determining whether they were central or peripheral to the action. It was concluded that the tonnages were not a peripheral matter but rather a central issue, as they were integral to the respondent's claim. The court held that the discretion under Order 29 rule 2 allowed for the admission of the documents as evidence without the authors being called, provided that their admission did not unfairly prejudice the applicants. The court found that the applicants would not be unfairly prejudiced if the documents were admitted as evidence. Consequently, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed, and the substantive appeal was also dismissed.

In conclusion, the court ruled that the cartage dockets could be admitted as evidence of the tonnages carted, without the authors being called to testify. This decision was based on the finding that the tonnages were a central issue in the action and that the admission of the documents would not unfairly prejudice the applicants. The application for leave to appeal and the substantive appeal were both dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: This is an application for leave to appeal against an interlocutory order of a Master made under O 29 r 2 that when the action comes to trial copies of certain nominated documents be treated as evidence of certain stipulated facts. The substantive appeal against the decision was heard at the same time. The first applicant ("Bristile") is a company that carries on business under the name "Metro Bricks". The second applicants ("Emmett" and "Clark" respectively) are the principal executive officer and the company secretary, respectively, of Bristile. A company called International Brick & Tile Pty Ltd ("IBT") carried on business as a brick manufacturer. Bristile holds some of the issued capital of IBT and had entered into a management agreement with, and was the manager of, the business activities of IBT. Emmett and Clark were also the directors of IBT. The respondent is a company engaged in cartage contracting. In the period 1988 to 1992 it had business dealings with IBT which, it alleges, were conducted with Bristile as manager of IBT's business activities. The respondent entered into a contract with IBT to cart clay from various sites to IBT's plant. There was a separate contract for the respondent to extract and stockpile clay for IBT at various sites. On 6 May 1992 a receiver and manager was appointed to the property and business of IBT. At the time the respondent was owed approximately $254,000 under the cartage and stockpiling contracts. At some time in 1993 IBT entered into a scheme of arrangement with its creditors as a result of which the respondent received approximately $52,000 against the debt owed to it by IBT. Initially, the respondent had declined to accept the cheque sent to it by the Scheme Administrator. However, it seems from the pleadings (par 13 of the statement of claim) that the respondent altered its position in that respect and accepted the cheque. The Scheme document is not before the Court but assuming it takes the conventional form the payment would have been in full satisfaction of the respondent's claim against IBT. This leaves a shortfall of around $202,000, which is the subject of the claim made by the respondent against the applicants in the action. It is common ground that, because of the receivership, IBT is a company to which s 592 of the Corporations Law applies. This brings into play the insolvent trading provisions of the Law. The respondent alleges that Emmett and Clark (as directors of IBT) and Bristile (because it took part in the management of IBT) are responsible for the debts incurred by IBT to the respondent. Specifically, it is alleged that at the time the debts were incurred there were reasonable grounds to believe that IBT would not be able to pay all its debts as and when they fell due. The applicants have denied that at any material time there were reasonable grounds to expect that IBT would be unable to pay all its debts as they became due. But they have gone further and have either denied or not admitted that the debts were incurred by IBT at all, or on the dates alleged.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established