Brisbane City Council v Davidson

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

[1998] QLAC 159

 
IN THE LAND APPEAL COURT BRISBANE

Re:An appeal from a decision of the Land Court Determination of Compensation

A97-39

BETWEEN:

Brisbane City Council

and

Sue Elizabeth Davidson

(Appellant)

(Respondent/Claimant)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

Judgment delivered this Eighth day of October 1998

Brisbane City Council has appealed from a decision of the Land Court delivered on 20 March 1998 in which the Court determined compensation at $286,330.00 for land resumed by the Council in August 1996 for environmental purposes.

The resumed land, Lot 2 on Plan No 890166, Parish of Tingalpa, has an area of

13.58 hectares.  At the date of resumption it was part of a parcel of land with an area of

25.37 hectares, Lot 4 on RP 209817, Parish of Tingalpa. The resumed land is an irregularly shaped block zoned Non-Urban. It is substantially timbered and has a frontage with land already owned by the Council, known as Brisbane Koala Bushlands (formerly Brisbane Koala Park). The resumed land was made part of Brisbane Koala Bushlands, which is a mosaic of about 800 hectares of bushland owned or controlled by the Council. These protected bushlands are linked by areas of privately owned land and land owned by other levels of government. The resumed land is part of a larger bushland unit in the south-east of the City of Brisbane which had a high-quality koala habitat.

The respondent, Mrs Davidson, has a dwelling house on the retention area, close to its western boundary. The land is mainly cleared and pastured. Access to the retention area is from Jenyns Court, Burbank.

The amount of compensation determined by the Court was calculated as follows:

Loss in value of land due to resumption $250,000.00
Compensation for injurious affection $  35,000.00
Legal and valuation fees, sundry expenses $    1,330.00

Total award of compensation

$286,330.00

to which was added an award of interest.

There were four main findings in support of that determination. First, the parent parcel was used for rural residential purposes and the land surrounding the resumed land was used in that way. Second, prior to the resumption, the parent parcel had potential to be subdivided into two allotments. Third, after resumption, the highest and best use of the retention land was as a single homesite. Fourth, the parent parcel had special value to the owner. It was the loss of amenity which flows to the retention land from use of the resumed land by the public which led the Member to make the award for injurious affection.

The Council takes issue only with the sum of $35,000.00 in respect of injurious affection.

The reasons for decision of the learned Member disclose the factual basis on which he determined that there should be an award for injurious affection and the evidence on which he relied to determine the amount awarded.

Whether an award for injurious affection should be made: The Member accepted Mrs Davidson’s evidence about the privacy and amenity of the parent parcel before the resumption. Mrs Davidson informed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brisbane City Council v Davidson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] QLAC 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Brisbane City Council sought to appeal a decision by the Land Court that determined the compensation payable to Sue Elizabeth Davidson for land resumed by the Council for environmental purposes. The Land Court determined compensation for loss of land at $250,000.00, compensation for injurious affection at $35,000.00, and other expenses at $1,330.00. The Council took issue with the sum awarded for injurious affection. The appeal was heard by the Land Appeal Court. The sole issue before the Court was whether the Member of the Land Court erred in making a separate award for injurious affection, and if so, whether the error was material. The Court found that the Member had not erred in making a separate award for injurious affection. The Court concluded that the Member was entitled to find that the retained land would suffer from injurious affection because it adjoined a bushland park to which the public had unfettered access, rather than a large residential allotment. The effects of public access which the evidence identified and on which the Member relied were effects that would not apply if the land was subdivided into two residential home sites. Although some factual matters were agreed, the resolution of the appeal involved an element of speculation. However, it was apparent that Mrs Davidson could expect to suffer less interference, and would have more control over the nature and extent of the interference, if the resumed land was privately owned than in the present circumstances. The quantum of the award to be made for injurious affection was not in issue in the appeal. As noted earlier, the Member considered the amount to be "rather nominal" when weighed against Mr Peterson’s valuation of the retention area property, he awarded that sum. There is no suggestion of any evidence on which the Court could vary that figure and the Court had no reason to do so. The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established