PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for stay of decision – banning order – applicant banned from providing any financial services – applicant banned from controlling an entity that carries on a financial services business – applicant banned from performing any function involved in the carrying on of a financial services business – whether discretion of the Tribunal is enlivened to grant a stay – whether a stay is desirable for the purpose of securing the effectiveness of the hearing and determination of the application for review – prospects of success – reputational damage and financial hardship – whether hearing rendered nugatory – public interest considerations – anticipated delay in hearing of the application for review – application for stay refused
Australian Securities and Investments Commission, Regulatory Guide 105: AFS Licensing: Organisational Competence
REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member G Lazanas
19 October 2022
Introduction
Mr Mark Bringans has applied to the Tribunal for review of a decision of a Delegate of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) made on 28 June 2022 under ss 920A and 920B of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act). The decision banned Mr Bringans from providing any financial services, controlling an entity that carries on a financial services business, and performing any function involved in the carrying on of a financial services business for a period of 8 years (Banning Order).
Mr Bringans has also requested, pursuant to s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act1975 (Cth) (AAT Act), a stay of the implementation of the Banning Order. An interim stay was granted by Deputy President McCabe on 26 July 2022 pending the outcome of this interlocutory application. Accordingly, the sole issue for determination by me is whether a stay should be granted…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bringans and Australian Securities and Investments Commissio... and more:
This matter concerned an application by Mr Bringans for a stay of a banning order made by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). The banning order prohibited Mr Bringans from providing any financial services, controlling an entity that carries on a financial services business, or performing any function involved in the carrying on of a financial services business. The application was heard by G Lazanas SM in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.
The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether its discretion to grant a stay was enlivened, and if so, whether it was desirable to grant a stay for the purpose of securing the effectiveness of the hearing and determination of Mr Bringans' application for review. In considering these issues, the Tribunal was required to assess Mr Bringans' prospects of success on review, the potential for reputational damage and financial hardship, whether the hearing could be rendered nugatory without a stay, and relevant public interest considerations, including the anticipated delay in the hearing.
The Tribunal reasoned that a stay is not automatically granted and requires a demonstration that it is necessary to secure the effectiveness of the review. While acknowledging the potential for significant financial hardship and reputational damage to Mr Bringans, the Tribunal found his prospects of success on review to be weak. Furthermore, the Tribunal considered that public interest considerations, particularly the general deterrence effect of banning orders, weighed heavily against granting a stay. The Tribunal concluded that even if its discretion was engaged, it was not desirable to grant a stay in the circumstances.
Consequently, the Tribunal refused Mr Bringans' application for a stay of the ASIC banning order.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
I have decided that it is not desirable to make an order under the AAT Act staying the operation of the Banning Order for the reasons set out below.Factual Background It is important to first set out the relevant factual matrix including the activities that are the subject of the alleged contraventions of the Corporations Act before turning to the evidence of Mr Bringans in support of the stay application. This is followed by an outline of the relevant legal principles and their application to Mr Bringans. An entity then known as FIBO Australia Pty Ltd (FIBO) applied for an AFSL in September 2013. The AFSL covered authorisations to deal in, amongst other things, derivatives and to provide general financial product advice to consumers. Mr Bringans was one of two initial RMs for the AFSL and entered into a RM agreement with FIBO which, relevantly, provided for him to be paid a fee of $4,000 per month. In March 2014, Mr Bringans became a full-time employee and director of AMFEX, an entity unrelated to FIBO. In May 2014, he was appointed CEO of AMFEX. In June 2014, he was approved as RM and KP for AMFEX, being one of two RMs and KPs. In around January 2018, there was a sale of FIBO, the AFSL holder entity, to Cardiff Global Management Pty Ltd. The AFSL holder entity then changed its name to Cardiff Global Markets Pty Ltd (CGM). In March 2018, Mr Bringans entered into a new RM agreement with CGM which provided for him to be paid $4,000 per month for services as RM and KP for the AFSL. Relevantly, the agreement specified that he was required to perform his services for a minimum of 3 days per week. This was while Mr Bringans was already working full-time at AMFEX. The RM Agreement listed, at Schedule 1, the following as the required services:(a)have direct responsibility for significant day-to-day decisions about the Company’s financial services;(b)decide how the Company’s financial services are provided and supervise the provision of those services;(c)have weekly oversight and will review and monitor the market exposure and financial position of the Company to ensure compliance with the Applicable Law;(d)use their best endeavours to maintain the Company's authorisations under the AFSL in accordance with the Applicable Law;(e)collaborate with, and where necessary, supervise other responsible managers and provide supervision and assistance for other personnel of the Company as directed by the Company;(f)undertake and continue to undertake training and professional development and maintain their competence, knowledge and skills as required under the Applicable Law;(g)attend meetings and report to the Company Board or Board committees on any complaints, incidents, breaches, as directed by the Company;(h)be available on an as needs basis to provide advice and supervision relating to the provision of financial services;(i)provide or assist in the provision of any information required to be provided to regulatory authorities;(j)assist in the preparation, implementation and audit of compliance programmes relating to the AFSL conditions including liaising with external service providers who report on compliance and related matters;(k)assist in the preparation, review and implementation of dispute resolution and complaints handling procedures and policies;(l)use their best endeavours to ensure that the Company complies with the conditions of the AFSL and any Applicable Law;(m)assist in the establishment and maintenance of the Company's breach reporting principles (including the establishment and maintenance of the breach reporting register) as required by the Applicable Laws;(n)review the Company's policies, procedures and document templates and update those policies, procedures and templates as directed by the Company (including assisting with the review of AML/CTF procedures and policies);(o)provide advice in relation to the review, preparation, verification and implementation of any disclosure documents to be issued by the Company and any marketing or promotional materials issued by the Company (including the Company's website);(p)assist in the training and preparation of training programmes, for the Company employees who provide financial services under the AFSL including continuing professional development training;(q)maintain and provide the Company with records of their continuing development activities during the Term of this Agreement;(r)notify the Company of any complaints against him or a company with which they are involved even if not associated with the Services;(s)advise the Company as soon as possible but in any event at least within two (2) business days of any changes that would affect the Company’s organisational competence, including any change in good fame and character, qualifications, and experience under the Applicable Law; and(t)perform other duties, activities and functions of the Position required and advised to the Manager by the Company as part of the Services as the Responsible Manager.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
ASIC stated that it may also allege that the power to ban was enlivened under s 920(1)(g), on the basis Mr Bringans has been involved in the contravention of financial services laws by Sirius because of his omission to act in his role, particularly given he was aware of the issues detailed in the compliance reports: see also s 79 of the Corporations Act. THE EVIDENCE Mr Bringans relied on his affidavit affirmed on 25 July 2022 in support of his application for a stay. Mr Bringans was not cross-examined for the purposes of the application and his evidence was mostly accepted by ASIC except for the circumstances as to his resignation from Sirius, to which I will come shortly. Counsel for ASIC also contended that some of Mr Bringans’ evidence fell short of establishing certain aspects of his submissions in support of a stay, for example, as to his financial hardship claims.Mr Bringans as CEO of AMFEX In his affidavit, Mr Bringans focused on his role and duties performed at AMFEX, emphasising that it differed substantially to the duties and functions in his role at Sirius. Mr Bringans was employed in a full-time capacity as a director of AMFEX on 4 March 2014 and became AMFEX’s CEO on 1 May 2014. In June 2014, he was approved as a RM and a KP of AMFEX. He was one of two RMs and KPs and he was responsible for the derivatives activity of AMFEX while the other RM and KP was responsible for the securities activity. Mr Bringans stated that a typical day at AMFEX for him commenced at around 7am and finished at around midnight (Sydney time) as he would start by attending meetings after the close of the New York trading session. He would review information in various reports to determine the financial impacts on AMFEX and subsequently determine the exposure around AMFEX’s cashflow and implement appropriate actions. He would then attend to any Australian regulatory matters. Mr Bringans stated that a key part of his duties as CEO is managing the launch of a new platform with the global IT team based overseas. During his working day, he would also liaise with numerous people, including the Asian client service team in Tokyo and brokers, the Indian client service team in Delhi and brokers, as well as various people in the Sydney office. Mr Bringans had numerous other regular commitments as CEO of AMFEX. For example, at 9pm on Monday and Wednesday of each week he would also typically attend global meetings focused on the direction and goals of AMFEX’s owner. These meetings also had heavy input from the IT management team with which Mr Bringans was also involved in various projects. Prejudice to Mr Bringans and AMFEX Mr Bringans stated that if the Banning Order is not stayed, he will suffer financial hardship and lasting reputational harm. Specifically, he said he feared he would lose and not be able to regain his current employment as CEO at AMFEX. At the time of his affidavit, Mr Bringans was 58 years old. He has been employed in the financial services industry since leaving university and does not have any experience, qualifications, or training outside the financial services industry such that he considers he is unlikely to find alternative employment in another field, especially at a comparable salary.
Decision
Reasons for decision
That factor weighs in favour of granting a stay as the impact on Mr Bringans is unlikely to be contained to a short duration. This is because the joinder of matters will likely involve some delay in corralling all the parties and any representatives for the hearing by the Tribunal. In all the circumstances, however, this factor does not weigh heavily in favour of staying the Banning Order.CONCLUSION I was not persuaded that a stay is required “for the purpose of securing the effectiveness of the hearing and determination of the application for review” under s 41(2) of the AAT Act. I was also not persuaded, even if the discretion to make a stay order was engaged, that it is desirable in all the circumstances to exercise the discretion to grant a stay order. The consideration of the abovementioned factors weigh against ordering a stay of the Banning Order. In particular, the prospects of success and the public interest considerations do not support a stay being granted in respect of the Banning Order, even on conditions. On the evidence before me, Mr Bringans’ prospects are weak. The public interest considerations, particularly the general deterrence effect of banning orders, also weigh heavily against the grant of a stay. In all the circumstances, I consider the application for a stay should be refused.