Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2019] AATA 4977 (4 October 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/0921

Re:Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Skills Quality Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

Date:4 October 2019

Date of written reasons:        10 October 2019

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal orders that the Order dated 18 April 2019 made pursuant to s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) is preserved.

......................[Sgd]...................................

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

Catchwords

STAY –Variation of stay order under section 41(3) – Stay application be varied due to the operation of 43(5C) – Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) – Restriction on commencement of enrolled students in an institution - Breach of a stay order – Stay is preserved

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000 (Cth)

National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011

Cases

Zivanovic v Australian Securities Investments Commission [2017] FCA 1633

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Dr P McDermott RFD

Written Reasons:                 10 October 2019

Decision Published:            27 November 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 4 October 2019, I heard an urgent application from the Australian Skills Quality Authority (“ASQA”) where ASQA advised that it intends to file an appeal against the decision made on 19 September 2019 by a Deputy President of the Tribunal. ASQA has made a request under s 41(3) of the AAT Act for the Tribunal to make an order varying the stay order that I granted on 18 April 2019. Prior to my making of the stay order on I ensured that my Associate sought submissions from both parties as to the appropriate wording of the stay order which was granted by consent of the parties.

    SUBMISSIONS

  2. The respondent submits that the stay should be varied because of the operation of
    s 43(5C) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“the AAT Act”) which provides that unless the Tribunal otherwise orders the operation of the decision under review is stayed until the end of the period within which a party to the proceeding may appeal the decision to the Federal Court of Australia under s 44(1) of the AAT Act.

  3. During the hearing ASQA raised concerns that Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd (“Brighton Pacific”) had failed to comply with certain provisions of the stay order.

  4. There was a submission by ASQA that Brighton Pacific did not comply with clause 2(g) of the stay order which effectively required Brighton Pacific to provide validation reports within 8 weeks of the making of the stay order. There was no issue that clause 2(g) should have been complied with by 14 June 2019. Brighton Pacific stated that the validation report was put into evidence in the hearing on 27 June 2019. I have formed the view that any breach of clause 2(g) is not material for the determination of this application to vary the stay order. During the hearing I pointed out that ASQA did not promptly…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Autho... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 4977
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd and the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) were parties before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning a dispute over a stay order. ASQA sought to vary an existing stay order that restricted students from commencing study at Brighton Pacific. The core of the dispute revolved around the date by which students were prohibited from commencing their courses and ASQA's attempt to extend this prohibition.

The AAT was required to determine whether to grant ASQA's application to vary the stay order. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether to extend the restriction on students commencing study beyond the date previously set by the Tribunal, and whether such a variation would be appropriate given the circumstances, including the interests of students and staff, and the potential for future appeals. The Tribunal also had to consider the relevance of Brighton Pacific's financial viability to the application.

Deputy President McDermott Rfd P reasoned that ASQA's application to vary the stay order was made too late, given that the original order had been in place for some time and the proposed extension was sought only a few days before the students were due to commence. The Deputy President also considered the significant disruption that a last-minute variation would cause to both students and staff, noting the uncertainty regarding the exact number of affected students. While acknowledging ASQA's concerns about financial viability and the potential for a future appeal to the Federal Court, the Deputy President concluded that these factors did not warrant varying the stay order at that juncture, particularly as no appeal had yet been lodged. The Deputy President emphasised that the financial viability of Brighton Pacific was a relevant concern, but that if students commenced study, funds paid should be available from the protected account. The Tribunal ultimately preserved the existing stay order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The terms of clause 2(a) restricts students from commencing study before 7 October 2019, or such later date provided by the Tribunal. ASQA sought to extend the date until 17 October 2019, which is the end of the appeal period. One reason why I do not grant the request is because if ASQA was seeking such an order they could have made an application for such an order much earlier than 4 October 2019. CONSIDERATION There is a dispute between the parties as to how many students are affected. The applicant said that 187 students were to commence study on 7 October 2019. In reality because 7 October 2019 is a public holiday the date on which the students would presumably commence their study is 8 October 2019. The respondent considers that 236 students will commence study on 7 October 2019. Having regard to the interests of the students I do not think it is fair to have such a disruptive event at such short notice if the request to vary the stay order was granted. I am also considering the interests of staff members of Brighton Pacific. There is force in the submission by Brighton Pacific that the staff members would suffer an inconvenience if a variation of the stay order was granted. ASQA have informed the Tribunal that they intend to lodge an appeal to the Federal Court of Australia. However, no appeal has yet been lodged, and no grounds of appeal appear to have been formulated for the Federal Court of Australia. There is a submission made that the Tribunal in making its decision on 19 September 2019 is in jurisdictional error. However, it would not be appropriate for me to consider the validity of that submission. I am mindful that if I have made an order for the variation of the stay order under s 41(3) of the AAT Act that order could be later varied by the Federal Court of Australia, having regard to the decision of Justice Gleeson in Zivanovic v Australian Securities Investments Commission [2017] FCA 1633. There is some force in the argument of ASQA if the stay was varied after the lodgement of an appeal then there would be more disruption to the students who have already commenced their courses. However, that is a matter for the Federal Court of Australia to consider on that occasion once an appeal was lodged and if an application was made to vary the stay order. The Federal Court of Australia would also then have the grounds of appeal before it on that occasion. ASQA has raised issues concerning the financial viability of Brighton Pacific. The financial viability of a provider is a matter of concern having regard to s 24 of the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (“NVR Act”). Certainly there is evidence concerning a balance spreadsheet that was tendered in evidence (Exhibit D) as being a statement of assets. There was some discussion as to whether this statement was inconsistent with an affidavit lodged by the applicant (Exhibit C): however, the affidavit that was lodged on behalf of the applicant dealt with ‘forecast cash’ available which is quite different from a statement of assets. The concerns as to Brighton Pacific’s financial viability are certainly relevant concerning clause 2(e) of the order. However, if students are permitted to commence study on 7 October 2019 it is only reasonable that funds paid for courses be available from the protected account.